G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 High Field Magnet Fresca 2 Introduction Existing strand designs, PIT and OST’s RRP are being used in the conceptual designs for two.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Superconducting Magnet Program S. Gourlay CERN March 11-12, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory IR Quad R&D Program LHC IR Upgrade Stephen A.
Advertisements

E. Todesco DIPOLES FOR HIGH ENERGY LHC E. Todesco CERN, Geneva Switzerland Acknowledgements: B. Bordini, L. Bottura, G. De Rijk, L. Evans, P. Fessia, J.
SC Magnets at Fermilab New Collaring and Coil Pre-stress Limit for a Nb3Sn Magnet Alexander Zlobin Technical Division Fermilab.
Twin Solenoid Twin Solenoid - conceptual design for FCC-hh detector magnet - Matthias GT Mentink Alexey Dudarev Helder Pais Da Silva Leonardo Erik Gerritse.
Superconducting Large Bore Sextupole for ILC
E. Todesco PROPOSAL OF APERTURE FOR THE INNER TRIPLET E. Todesco CERN, Geneva Switzerland With relevant inputs from colleagues F. Cerutti, S. Fartoukh,
CARE08, Dec , G. de Rijk, The NED Conductor Review 1 The NED Conductor Review: Experience gained and outlook for future development Gijs de Rijk.
Magnets for muon collider ring and interaction regions V.V. Kashikhin, FNAL December 03, 2009.
LQ Goals and Design Study Summary – G. Ambrosio 1 LARP Collab Mtg – SLAC, Oct , 2007 BNL - FNAL - LBNL - SLAC LQ Goals & Design Summary Giorgio Ambrosio.
Development of the EuCARD Nb 3 Sn Dipole Magnet FRESCA2 P. Ferracin, M. Devaux, M. Durante, P. Fazilleau, P. Fessia, P. Manil, A. Milanese, J. E. Munoz.
CERN/CEA Collaboration agreement No. KE2275/TE WP4 – Nb 3 Sn technology development Pré-Kick-off meeting 03/07/2014.
CERN Accelerator School, Erice 2013 Tiepida-2 case-study 3: High field – large aperture magnet for a cable facility TiEpIdA2 design team: I. Mondino: Project.
11 T Nb3Sn Demonstrator Dipole R&D Strategy and Status
ASC 2014Nb 3 Sn Block Coil Dipoles for a 100 TeV Hadron Collider – G. Sabbi 1 Performance characteristics of Nb 3 Sn block-coil dipoles for a 100 TeV hadron.
S. Caspi, LBNL HQ Progress and Schedule Shlomo Caspi LBNL LARP Collaboration Meeting – CM13 Port Jefferson November 4-6, 2009.
Review of Quench Limits FermilabAccelerator Physics Center Nikolai Mokhov Fermilab 1 st HiLumi LHC / LARP Collaboration Meeting CERN November 16-18, 2011.
MQXF Design and Conductor Requirements P. Ferracin MQXF Conductor Review November 5-6, 2014 CERN.
R. Bonomi R. Kleindienst J. Munilla Lopez M. Chaibi E. Rogez CERN Accelerator School, Erice 2013 CASE STUDY 1: Group 1C Nb 3 Sn Quadrupole Magnet.
MQXF support structure An extension of LARP experience Helene Felice MQXF Design Review December 10 th to 12 th, 2014 CERN.
CERN Accelerator School Superconductivity for Accelerators Case study 1 Paolo Ferracin ( ) European Organization for Nuclear Research.
CERN Accelerator School Superconductivity for Accelerators Case study introduction Paolo Ferracin CERN, Geneva Claire Antoine
Outline: Main characteristics of the FRESCA2 cable Main characteristics of the strand Strand stability, an issue to avoid magnet quench at low field Procurement.
Superconducting Magnet Group Superconducting magnet development for ex-situ NMR LDRD 2003 Paolo Ferracin, Scott Bartlett 03/31/2003.
Subscale quadrupole (SQ) series Paolo Ferracin LARP DoE Review FNAL June 12-14, 2006.
GROUP C – Case study no.4 Dr. Nadezda BAGRETS (Karlsruhe Institute of Technology) Dr. Andrea CORNACCHINI (CERN EN Dept.) Mr. Miguel FERNANDES (CERN BE.
WAMSDO-2013, New Techniques, GdR WAMSDO, January 2013 Gijs de Rijk CERN 1 NEW TECHNIQUES.
Magnet design, final parameters Paolo Ferracin and Attilio Milanese EuCARD ESAC review for the FRESCA2 dipole CERN March, 2012.
Dipole design at the 16 T frontier - Magnet R&D for a Future Circular Collider (FCC) at Fermilab Alexander Zlobin Fermilab.
BNL High Field and HTS Magnet Program Ramesh Gupta BNL, NY USA H T.
CERN Accelerator School Superconductivity for Accelerators Case study 3 Paolo Ferracin ( ) European Organization for Nuclear Research.
Update on Q4 DSM/IRFU/SACM The HiLumi LHC Design Study (a sub-system of HL-LHC) is partly funded by the European Commission within the Framework Programme.
16 T Dipole Design Options: Input Parameters and Evaluation Criteria F. Toral - CIEMAT CIEMAT-VC, Sept. 4th, 2015.
E. Todesco OUTPUT OF THE CABLE REVIEW E. Todesco and the QXF team CERN, Geneva Switzerland CERN, 10 th December 2014 QXF design review, CERN.
Outline: Strand R&D and strand procurement and inventory. Main parameters of the cable without a core. Results obtained during the cable development without.
ECC Clément Lorin – Maria Durante Acknowledgements: Fresca2 team.
E. Todesco, Milano Bicocca January-February 2016 Appendix C: A digression on costs and applications in superconductivity Ezio Todesco European Organization.
E. Todesco INTERACTION REGION MAGNETS E. Todesco On behalf of the WP3 collaboration CERN, Geneva, Switzerland CERN, 27 th October 2015.
1 BNL -FNAL - LBNL - SLAC P. Wanderer IR’07 - Frascati 7 November 2007 U.S. LARP Magnet Programme.
DESIGN STUDIES IR Magnet Design P. Wanderer LARP Collaboration Meeting April 27, 2006.
Report from Session 2 Main Dipoles. P. McIntyre 2005 – 24T ss Tripler, a lot of Bi-2212, Je = 800 A/mm2 E. Todesco T, 80% ss 30% NbTi 55 %NbSn.
29 th September 2009 EuCARD-WP7 HFM Conductor specification and procurement Luc OBERLI CERN, TE-MSC-SCD.
MQXFS1 Test Results G. Chlachidze, J. DiMarco, S. Izquierdo-Bermudez, E. Ravaioli, S. Stoynev, T. Strauss et al. Joint LARP CM26/Hi-Lumi Meeting SLAC May.
Answers to the review committee G. Ambrosio, B.Bordini, P. Ferracin MQXF Conductor Review November 5-6, 2014 CERN.
The most likely cause of death for a superconducting magnet Input data for thermal modeling of Nb 3 Sn Superconducting Magnets by Andrew Davies Find the.
CERN QXF Conductor Procurement and Cable R&D A.Ballarino, B. Bordini and L. Oberli CERN, TE-MSC-SCD LARP Meeting, Napa, 9 April 2013.
CERN Cabling Experience FRESCA 2, 11 T Dipole and MQXF A. Ballarino
MQXC Nb-Ti 120mm 120T/m 2m models
Model magnet test results at FNAL
HQ Mirror Assembly R. Bossert
11 T cable development and procurement strategy at CERN
MQXF Goals & Plans G. Ambrosio MQXF Conductor Review
CERN Conductor and Cable Development for the 11T Dipole
Q0 magnet, cooling, support ideas
EuroCirCol: 16T dipole based on common coils
Glyn Kirby Magnet AssemblyTechniques.
HTS Magnet R&D at BNL Ramesh Gupta November 17, 2017.
To be presented at Nb3Al R&D Review,
MBHSP02 test STATUS and first results
DESIGN OPTIONS IN THE T RANGE
11T Dipole for the LHC Collimation upgrade
MQXF coil cross-section status
CERN Accelerator School Superconductivity for Accelerators Case study 2 Paolo Ferracin European Organization for Nuclear Research.
P.Fabbricatore & S.Farinon
Flux jumps in HQ Hugo BAJAS
Hilumi WP3 meeting, 1 October 2014
PROPOSAL OF APERTURE FOR THE INNER TRIPLET
Design of Nb3Sn IR quadrupoles with apertures larger than 120 mm
Design of Nb3Sn IR quadrupoles with apertures larger than 120 mm
Daniel Chávez A NbTi Cable-in-Conduit conductor for the
Cross-section of the 150 mm aperture case
Presentation transcript:

G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 High Field Magnet Fresca 2 Introduction Existing strand designs, PIT and OST’s RRP are being used in the conceptual designs for two types of magnet, classical Cos  and a hybrid block design. Which eventually will lead to building a high field 100mm clear aperture accelerator quality model magnet. This work is still ongoing however we present some initial ideas and observations related to the strand design and operating conditions for the strand. Glyn A. Kirby & Bernardo Bordini, Franck Borgnolutti, Jens Erik Bruer, Ezio Todesco, Gijs De Rijk, Stephan Russenschuck.

G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 Talk outline Comparing the available materials. Magnet quench protection. Mechanical protection of the Nb3Sn in the strand some ideas. Compare to magnet designs, Cos  & Hybrid-block Closing comments.

G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 Comparing the available materials OST 0.8 Jc 3000 T & 4.5K PIT 1.25 Jc T & 4.5K

G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 Quench simulations Accelerator magnets are designed to absorb their energy by spreading heat through the coils. However this heating must be limited so not to damage the cables performance. Nb3Sn has a high temperature margin ~15K in low field volumes at the operating point, this makes quenching the cables very difficult.

G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 Strand design in relation to quench performance -If we can quench all the coil volumes the existing strand copper volume is sufficient. However the recent magnet tests have only manages to quench the high field volumes, about 15% of the coils. We need to develop a working quench heater, or put more copper in the strand. We could also use Nb-Ti in the low field volumes where we have a working quench heater design. -If we use a energy extraction dump resistor the existing strand is ok. But this would imply that every magnet would have its own set of current leads and dump resistor. For development magnet and special one off magnets we can use dumps. However this is not practical for long strings of magnets. (we could develop a cold dump?) For a dump resistor can be used.

G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 Mechanical protection of the Nb 3 Sn in the strand At 150 MPa the strand starts to degrade. What can be done? : –Don’t let the strand see that stress! –Make larger coils/magnets with low stresses. –Protect the filaments with a tough collar and or, more copper around the filaments (this may be needed for quench). –Change the strand geometry? –Put Nb-Ti in low field volumes. –Arrange to put the low fields in high stress areas. Then degradation may not be seen in the magnet performance? Cu Tough collar High stress Low field Use Nb-Ti

G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 Stresses in Conductors Stress Magnet coil pushing against its support Stress uniform Collaring forces Magnetic forces Coil bonded to fix its external surface Classical magnet with surfaces that are free to slide above any friction forces Stress redistributes as magnet is energized however the final maximum stress much the same as a totally free coil. Compression stresses A bonded coil could have lower stress compared to an identical classic design. Tensile stresses Bonded coil Classic coil Try to support the turns by bonding and adding new features. Put Nb-Ti in low field volumes < 8 Tesla

G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 Avoiding the high stresses with a Hybrid design A hybrid design that uses Nb-Ti material in low field volumes also has the advantages that it is not limited by the same stress limits as the Nb3Sn. This also helps with the quench protection. There is also a cost saving using Nb-Ti instead of Nb3Sn. The block design lends itself better to a hybrid design than the Cos . 138 Conductors 74 conductors

G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 Hybrid Nb3Sn and Nb-Ti Nb-Ti Nb3Sn Nb-Ti Nb 3 Sn Nb-Ti Although the Nb-Ti is not damaged at 150MPa we still need to take care with the insulation.

G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 Low field, high current instabilities Data from Bernardo Bordini This should not be a problem for high field (15 to 17 T) magnets as the current in the strand is under 400A

G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 Cos  Magnet design using HD2 cable 51 stand 150 MPa 13 T Sliding coil TField in 13 T

G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 Magnet Designs OST RRP mm dia. Strands Tesla Central field at 99% short sample Tesla maximum in the coil Sliding 15.5T 1.9K Bonded 15.5T 1.9K 173 MPa 223 MPa 150 MPa

G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 Stress comparison at 15.5T PIT 40 strands 1.25mm diameter block design V HD2 cable RRP 51 strand 0.8 diameter block design 173 MPa 223 MPa HD2 51 strand 20.8mm wide cable PIT 40 strand 25mm wide cable 177 MPa 150 MPa 15.5T

G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 Iron Yoke diameter is large at High fields 16.5T 13 T 750mm diameter Stray fields m Stray fields <5 surface of Iron 1600mm diameter

G.A.Kirby 4th Nov.08 Closing Remarks Lots of development work is needed! Quench heaters that work in Nb3Sn at 1.9K low field volumes! Some problems can be avoided by design! –Use Nb-Ti in low fields, then we have a quench heater that work. –Use Nb-Ti in low fields, high stress not a problem for Nb-Ti. –Change the strand design so that it can withstand the high stress. Internal protection for the filaments, What temperature to use 4.5K or 1.9K?(at 1.9K many magnets show damage!) Small Strands in Wide Cables using block design hybrid magnets. –Smaller strands are more stable! For the “Fresca” replacement high field, large aperture magnet planed at CERN an operating current of under 17KA.