Climategate Also known as the Climate Research Unit e-mail controversy Internet leak of thousands of emails and other documents from the University of.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Formulation and Presentation of a Statement on Climate Change for Oklahoma Gary McManus Assistant State Climatologist.
Advertisements

1 Presentation to the Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations of the House Energy and Commerce Committee. Stephen McIntyre Toronto Ontario Washington.
De staat van het klimaat. The blogosphere, a small poll Who read my book or is reading it? Who frequently (at least once a week) reads RealClimate.org?
EXAMINING THE STATE OF CLIMATE SCIENCE, THE PROPOSED SOLUTIONS TO GLOBAL WARMING, AND THE CLAIMS OF CLIMATE CHANGE SKEPTICS Climate Change.
Human Caused Climate Change? A Real Look At The Physics And Evidence Chuck F. Wiese Meteorologist.
Elizabeth Machado.  The Medieval Warm Period (MWP) is the name given to the warm period observed in many parts of the world between 900 and 1200 AD.
Climategate Is this a conspiracy of the sceptics or the end of the global warming hype? Marcel Crok, science writer Wageningen, 9 December 2009.
1. Review- What is a scientific theory Compare and Contrast- How does use of the word theory differ in science and in daily life 2. Review- What is peer.
Keith Briffa Phil Jones Tim Osborn Climatic Research Unit staff.
Principal Component Analysis (PCA) Principal component analysis (PCA) creates new variables (components) that consist of uncorrelated, linear combinations.
School of Computing and Mathematical Sciences
CofC POLS 405 Spring 2011 P. Brian Fisher.  1,372 climate researchers and their publication and citation data  Results:  (i) 97–98% of the climate.
Web Searching. Web Search Engine A web search engine is designed to search for information on the World Wide Web and FTP servers The search results are.
Communicating climate change: Some lessons from climategate Kevin E Trenberth NCAR In Honor of Stephen Schneider Kevin E Trenberth NCAR In Honor of Stephen.
Global Warming: The Debate Objectives: Define the uncertainties Describe the scientific process Analyze available data Explore solutions.
Scientific Methods I. Hypothetical – Deductive Method many hypothesis (ideas), eliminate those without data to support them II. Correlation Method multi.
By Reaz Uddin, Ph. D. Dr. Panjwani Center for Molecular Medicine and Drug Research, International Center for Chemical and Biological Sciences, University.
Next step-beyond Kyoto Meeting in Copenhagen in December 2009 The Copenhagen Accord was drafted by the US, China, India, Brazil and South Africa on December.
Science & Technology: Chapter 1 Section 2
11/16/11ESPP /16/11ESPP Does it matter that they are inanimate, lack voice, have no subjectivity, could not place a value on themselves,
Scientific Inquiry & Skills
1 General Structure of a System Dealing with Research Misconduct - General Remarks on its diversity - Makoto Misono National Institute of Technology and.
Challenges for FOI researchers Ben Worthy Constitution Unit University College London.
 “In a democratic society, you can't control people by force. Therefore, you've got to control what they think.”  -Noam Chomsky, author of Manufacturing.
31,487 American scientists have signed this petition. Nearly 1 in every 3 people who signed this has a Ph.D degree.
FINAL PROJECT (CE3216) The Literature Review Dr Deepak T.J. SCHOOL OF CIVIL ENGINEERING.
Media Construction of Global Warming PowerPoint Slide Show, Lesson 2 Global warming: Fact of Myth.
MRS. STOREY / MRS. TAKTAK THE SCIENTIFIC METHOD. THE STEPS OF THE SCIENTIFIC METHOD 1.Ask a question or problem. Examples) Why am I in a hitting slump?
The Hockey Stick Model Daniela Domeisen, Josh Gellers, and Heather Raven W4400 December 5, 2006.
Topic 5: Basic Security.
Natural Events The Scientific Method The scientific method is a process of investigating natural events through a series of detailed steps. The scientific.
What Do Scientists Do? Quiz 1C.
SCIENCE THE STUDY OF LIVING THINGS!. GROWTH VS DEVELOPMENT Growth is the process by which an organism becomes larger. Development is the process of change.
Weart “In the IPCC reports, scientists gave their best answer. Now the main questions is what people will choose to do.”
The Scientific Method. Objectives Explain how science is different from other forms of human endeavor. Identify the steps that make up scientific methods.
Scientific investigations.  Question/problem –What do you want to know  Hypothesis- logical prediction for the question or problem  Variables- Factors.
I.What is Science? A.Thinking Like a Scientist 1.Scientists use the following skills to learn more about the world: Observing Inferring Predicting Classifying.
The Reliability of Tree Rings as a Temperature Proxy Liz Wiggins.
The Scientific Method aka: Scientific Inquiry. What is Science? The goal of science is to investigate and understand the natural world, to explain events.
NASA annual surface temperature anomaly relative to mean, based on surface air measurements at meteorological stations and ship and satellite.
Plagiarism What It Is, What Are The Consequences, And How To Avoid It.
Unit 5 Seminar Climate and Pollution. Climate Debate Climate Debate: What's Warming Us Up? Human Activity or Mother Nature? ScienceDaily (Dec. 21, 2009)
How to write an effective conclusion
CO2: Friend or Foe? PPPL Colloquium April 7, 2010 by William Happer.
Spring 2012 Writing 20:Ocean Acidification February 21, 2011 researching & developing a claim for MP2 Much of this material is compiled from:
A Farewell to Arms Small Group Seminar You need your reading journals, “What Your Friends Are Saying,” a copy of A Farewell to Arms, pen/pencil, and a.
RECORDS MANAGEMENT TRAINING. WHAT HAS RECORDS MANAGEMENT GOT TO DO WITH ME? Records management is everyone’s responsibility. The three examples which.
A Clear and Present Danger to the Caribbean: Climate Change or Climate Alarmism? Reynold J. Stone Department of Food Production.
Investigating the Hockey Stick Climate Model EAS Dr. Wang 4/22/08Robert Binion.
Comments by Hans von Storch Director of Institute for Coastal Research, GKSS Research Center, Germany, and Professor at the Meteorological Institute, University.
BIOLOGY: Chapter 1 The Science of Biology. 1.1 The Science of Biology “ Science” is basically two things: – A body of knowledge… an accumulation of things.
(Click to advance the presentation.). The best source for locating these articles is the collection of research databases at the Online Library. While.
Climate Change Spring 2016 Kyle Imhoff. Let’s start with the big picture (climate forcings)…
Greenhouse Gasses –in order of importance water vapor carbon dioxide methane nitrous oxide ozone CFCs.
The Goal: Add New Information To The Scientific Knowledge Base
Scientific Investigations
Chapter 1 The Science of Biology.
Scientific Methods Not 1 specific formula 
Experimental Psychology
Introduction to Biology
Climate Change Myths and Realities
Evaluating Sources.
Global Climate Change: Past and Future
Doing the Research Sylvia A Nita A Fifi A.
The Starting Point: Asking Questions
Life Science Chapter 1 Review
Logical problem solving sequence
Introduction to Science
PALEOCLIMATE IMPLICATIONS FOR RECENT HUMAN INFLUENCE ON CLIMATE
Presentation transcript:

Climategate Also known as the Climate Research Unit controversy Internet leak of thousands of s and other documents from the University of East Anglia's Climatic Research Unit (CRU). s and documents were obtained through the hacking of a server. hacker had filtered them using keywords, including "Yamal", "tree rings", and "Phil Jones", so that these names appear in many of the documents

Climategate-what was stolen more than 1,000 s, 2,000 documents, as well as commented source code, pertaining to climate change research covering a period from 1996 until The vast majority of the s related to four climatologists: Phil Jones, the head of the CRU; Michael E. Mann of Pennsylvania State University (PSU), one of the originators of the graph of temperature trends dubbed the "hockey stick graph”; Tim Osborn, a climate model developer; and Mike Hulme, director of the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research. The four were either recipients or senders of all but 66 of the 1,073 s,

Climategate-allegations Allegations that the hacked s showed evidence that climate scientists manipulated data. A few other commentators said that the evidence supported claims that dissenting scientific papers had been suppressed. The Wall Street Journal reported the s revealed apparent efforts to ensure the IPCC include their own views and exclude others and to withhold scientific data. It was reported that the CRU evidently plotted to remove journal editors with whom they disagreed and suppress the publication of articles that they disliked. The ICO made a statement that the s revealed that freedom of information requests were 'not dealt with as they should have been under the legislation' but that they could not prosecute due to statue of limitations. Academics and climate change researchers said that nothing in the s proved wrongdoing, and dismissed the allegations. Independent reviews by FactCheck and the Associated Press said that the s did not affect evidence that man made global warming is a real threat, and said that s were being misrepresented to support unfounded claims of scientific misconduct. They also concluded that there were disturbing suggestions that scientists had avoided sharing scientific data with skeptical critics.

Climategate-understanding the trick Many commentators quoted one referring to a "trick" used in Mann's graph to deal with the well-known tree ring divergence problem to "hide the decline" that particular proxy showed for modern temperatures after 1950, when measured temperatures were rising. These two phrases were taken out of context by climate change skeptics including Senator Jim Inhofe and former Governor of Alaska Sarah Palin as though they referred to a decline in measured global temperatures, even though they were written when temperatures were at a record high. In their inquiry into allegations of research misconduct, Penn State reviewers found ”the so-called 'trick' was nothing more than a statistical method used to bring two or more different kinds of data sets together in a legitimate fashion by a technique that has been reviewed by a broad array of peers in the field. The Parliament of the United Kingdom select committee inquiry concluded that "[Trick] appears to be a colloquialism for a "neat" method of handling data," and "[hide the decline] was a shorthand for the practice of discarding data known to be erroneous”.