C RITERIA FOR E VALUATION Design exploration capabilities Visualization capabilities “Scoreboard” for performance measures and scenario evaluation Usability.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Slide 1 What is the Student Score Report? This individualized report details scores received on the assessment and the career plans and needs indicated.
Advertisements

Chapter 3 Program Management and Project Evaluation Professor Hossein Saiedian McGraw-Hill Education ISBN
 Not Just a Collection of “Fill in the Blanks” Templates  Organized by Business Process  User Needs Assessment  Request for Proposal (RFP)  Vendor.
S CENARIO A ND V ISUALIZATION (SAV I ) T OOLS Todd Graham, Project Manager 651/
1 California State University, Fullerton Chapter 13 Developing and Managing Information Systems.
Chapter 6 Prototyping, RAD, and Extreme Programming
Scientific workflow systems are problem-solving environments designed to allow researchers to perform complex tasks simply by piecing together individual.
The Land Management Paradigm
© 2005 Prentice Hall, Decision Support Systems and Intelligent Systems, 7th Edition, Turban, Aronson, and Liang 4-1 Chapter 4 Modeling and Analysis Turban,
Iterative development and The Unified process
Table Lens Introduction to the Table Lens concept Table Lens Implementation Projected Usage Scenarios Usage Comparison with Splus Critical Analysis.
Lead Black Slide. © 2001 Business & Information Systems 2/e2 Chapter 13 Developing and Managing Information Systems.
Desktop Publishing Unit 7. Unit Layout Five Assessment Objectives Unit Completion end of January – Allowing 2-3 Months contingency work.
Strategic Information Systems Planning
Chapter 14: Redesigning the Organization with Information Systems Instructor: Kevin Brabazon.
Harnessing the Power of Environmental Data for Decision-Making IABIN Phase II.
THE OFFSHORE SITUATION IN GREECE Municipality of Corfu.
Introduction to RUP Spring Sharif Univ. of Tech.2 Outlines What is RUP? RUP Phases –Inception –Elaboration –Construction –Transition.
State Smart Transportation Initiative October 9, 2014 Matthew Garrett Oregon DOT Director Erik Havig Oregon DOT Planning Section Manager.
Project: May Project Team Members: Edward McDowell, EE Richard Mott, EE / Econ Faculty Advisors: Dr. John.
ENVISION TOMORROW UPDATES AND INDICATORS. What is Envision Tomorrow?  Suite of planning tools:  GIS Analysis Tools  Prototype Builder  Return on Investment.
Enhancing Local Land Use Decisions through the Evaluation and Use of Web-based Tools Enhancing Local Land Use Decisions through the Evaluation and Use.
© 2001 Business & Information Systems 2/e1 Chapter 13 Developing and Managing Information Systems.
Land Use Scenarios Status. Encompass 2040 Scenarios Scenario 1: Continues similar development patterns of the past with no new zoning initiatives Scenario.
CS 360 Lecture 3.  The software process is a structured set of activities required to develop a software system.  Fundamental Assumption:  Good software.
The Implementation of Land and Ecosystem Accounts in Europe Towards integrated land and ecosystem accounting Roy Haines-Young, University of Nottingham.
Chapter 11 Analysis Concepts and Principles
Enhancing Local Land Use Decisions through the Evaluation and Use of Web-based Tools Enhancing Local Land Use Decisions through the Evaluation and Use.
12.1 Introduction Checklists are used as a technique to give status information in a formalized manner about all aspects of the test process. This chapter.
IS Methodologies. Systems Development Life Cycle - SDLC Planning Planning define the system to be developed define the system to be developed Set the.
Training Resource Manual on Integrated Assessment Session UNEP-UNCTAD CBTF Contents and Methods of Integrated Assessment Session 3.
Handbook on Residential Property Price Indices Chapter 5: Methods Jan de Haan UNECE/ILO Meeting, May 2010.
Fifth Lecture Hour 9:30 – 10:20 am, September 9, 2001 Framework for a Software Management Process – Life Cycle Phases (Part II, Chapter 5 of Royce’ book)
Optimizing NASA IV&V Benefits Using Simulation Grant Number: NAG David M. Raffo, Ph.D College of Engineering and Computer Science School of Business.
EPA’s Development, Community and Environment Division: T ools for Evaluating Smart Growth and Climate Change February 28, 2002 Ilana Preuss.
Planning schemes Statutory documents under s.20(2) of LUPAA –outline policies and objectives –regulate or prohibit use or development of land –reserve.
Prototyping What prototyping is The benefits of prototyping Low-fidelity and high-fidelity prototypes, and the advantages of each How to build paper prototypes.
Chapter 6 Prototyping, RAD, and Extreme Programming Systems Analysis and Design Kendall & Kendall Sixth Edition.
Creating A Worksheet and Embedded Chart Chapter 1.
Software Architecture Evaluation Methodologies Presented By: Anthony Register.
SEAMLESS: Demo Version 1.4 “Presenting current developments and welcoming your feedback” For contact:
Diploma in Procurement & Supply Business needs in Procurement & Supply Session 1 Business Needs and Procurement Decisions.
WISE User Workshops Three user workshops held in 2012 Introduction and context Hands on exploring the tool Quantifying scenarios and exploring results.
Prototyping life cycle Important steps 1. Does prototyping suit the system 2. Abbreviated representation of requirements 3. Abbreviated design specification.
Topic 4 - Database Design Unit 1 – Database Analysis and Design Advanced Higher Information Systems St Kentigern’s Academy.
Rob Verheem The Netherlands EIA Commission
Assessing The Underworld An Integrated Performance Model of City Infrastructures Sustainability Costing Model for Streetworks.
Process Asad Ur Rehman Chief Technology Officer Feditec Enterprise.
Sistemas de Información Agosto-Diciembre 2007 Sesión # 9.
C A L I F O R N I A E N E R G Y C O M M I S S I O N Integrated Energy Policy Report Workshop Landscape-Scale Environmental Evaluations for Energy Infrastructure.
A Comparative Tool for Evaluating Campus Sustainability Sustainability Tracking, Assessment & Rating System (STARS)
Software Development Process CS 360 Lecture 3. Software Process The software process is a structured set of activities required to develop a software.
Healing Hospital North Shore, IL Vendor Selection for an Adverse Events Information System Imran Khan Project Manager Steven Stanford Chief Information.
Modern Approaches of Systems Development By: Hanouf AL-Monawer Sara Mohammed.
Evaluating GIS for Disaster Management Bruce Kinner GEOG 596A.
A framework that describes the activities performed at each stage of a software development project. A life-cycle or a software process is the organisational.
FESTIVAL SPREADSHEET ACTIVITY 2 Key stage – Music Festival.
10-1 McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2007 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Data Infrastructure Building Blocks (DIBBS) NSF Solicitation Webinar -- March 3, 2016 Amy Walton, Program Director Advanced Cyberinfrastructure.
Software Design and Development Development Methodoligies Computing Science.
Page 1 / DI Martin Moesl, M.A. Univ. Prof. DI Dr. Arnold Tautschnig Determining and controlling of the Life-Cycle-Yield in an early planning.
Public Service Announcement Movies made with the Alice Programming Language.
Diploma in Procurement & Supply
Introduction and Overview
SOFTWARE LIFE-CYCLES Beyond the Waterfall.
Rapid Prototyping.
Demonstration of the tool
Introduction and Overview
Assessing The Underworld
Presentation transcript:

C RITERIA FOR E VALUATION Design exploration capabilities Visualization capabilities “Scoreboard” for performance measures and scenario evaluation Usability and viability for the technician Usefulness and benefit for broad audience

1. D ESIGN E XPLORATION C APABILITIES Iterative scenario development: design or plan alternatives can be added, modified. The tested software uses different design approaches, CityCAD is liner, CommunityVIZ is iterative Scenario 1 To Scenario 2t

1. D ESIGN E XPLORATION C APABILITIES Compare scenario alternatives to existing landscape, environment CommunityVIZ uses existing spatial data to create 3D representations of existing conditions allowing side by side comparison between existing conditions and new scenario/proposals

1. D ESIGN E XPLORATION C APABILITIES Applicable to context of neighborhood-level design and planning. All programs use 3D modeling software to augment detailed site-level scenario visualization. Google SketchUp succeeded at providing sufficient detail to demonstrate the character of station and neighborhood level design scenarios while CityCAD creates scenarios with acceptable detail for early sketch planning.

1. D ESIGN E XPLORATION C APABILITIES Fast performance creating and exploring design or plan scenarios. CityCAD is a rapid sketch-planning tool

2. V ISUALIZATION C APABILITIES Generate 3-D visualization for land use and development. Powerful modeling programs have a clear advantage.

2. V ISUALIZATION C APABILITIES Able to show phased development, change over time CC

2. V ISUALIZATION C APABILITIES Adequate realism and detail in representing the landscape.

2. V ISUALIZATION C APABILITIES Demonstrates spatial arrangement, proximity to amenities. CityCAD’s proximity measurement

3. “S COREBOARD ” FOR PERFORMANCE MEASURES AND SCENARIO EVALUATION Composite scoring of indicators, determined by users’ goals Envision Tomorrow, although extremely data hungry, provides nearly limitless impact measures. Environmental Economic Infrastructure Resources Planning Measures By land use or building type CityCAD & CommunityVIZ are also customizable and comprehensive in impact measures.

3. “S COREBOARD ” FOR PERFORMANCE MEASURES AND SCENARIO EVALUATION Measures and scoring enable comparison of plan scenarios Envision Tomorrow and CommunityVIZ allow for side by side comparison of five scenarios simultaneously. CityCAD works in a more linear, step-by-step modification process were you see impacts only to what has just been modified or created. It is possible to create scenarios independently of one another and compare that way.

3. “S COREBOARD ” FOR PERFORMANCE MEASURES AND SCENARIO EVALUATION Tool can model land use and produce indicators of outcomes All can perform this function at some level, but Envision Tomorrow’s flexibility, level of detail, and easy of use make it the clear front runner in this category. CityCAD is the most ‘black box’ in this category, with the calculations based on information about local conditions and internalized formulas, resulting in limited capacity for modification.

3. “S COREBOARD ” FOR PERFORMANCE MEASURES AND SCENARIO EVALUATION Tool can model fiscal and infrastructure impacts and outcomes. Infrastructure: Envision and works on assumptions about infrastructure based on land use. CommunityVIZ and CityCAD can calculate construction and maintenance costs as they relate directly to the street/road type. Fiscal: Envision tomorrow has the finest level of detail in this category, assessing fiscal impacts down to the building level.