Personal Identity Ronald F. White, Ph.D. Professor of Philosophy College of Mount St. Joseph
Introduction What is “identity?” What is “personal identity?”
The Puzzle Personal identity – Bodies – Minds – Sociality Immortality
Historical – Plato Aristotle Hippocrates- Judeo-Christian Descartes
Personal Identity Theory Empiricist – Idealist Bundle Theory: “I am a bundle of ideas.” Memory, Dreams, Hallucinations Idealism: – Subjectivism – Transcenentalism – Materialist Bundle Theory: “I am a bundle of bodily functions.”
Personal Immortality? Survival of what? – Individual Body – Individual body Soul – Individual soul Ideas – Individual ideas (memories) Collectives – Civilizations – Institutions
Arguments for and Against Immortality Bodily Immortality – For: Genetic Immortality – Against: Thermodynamics Mental (spiritual) Immortality – For: – Against? Is it rational to fear death?