Results – Based Financing (RBF) in Health Presentation by Gaston Sorgho, HD Sector Leader – Central Africa World Bank AFRICA - HNP.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Monitoring and measuring UHC. 2 Policy and planning Monitoring and Measuring UHC Key Messages Equity is fundamental to UHC – all people get services they.
Advertisements

April 7, 2011 Alex Ergo, PhD Broad Branch Associates Using Performance- Based Incentives to Enhance the Quality of MNCH Interventions in Developing Countries.
Scaling up Family Planning through Performance-Based Financing in Rwanda Dr. Louis Rusa, Director PBF support Cell Ministry of Health, Rwanda.
Performance management System
The Adamawa Primary Health Care System
Canada’s birth & death rate have dropped steadily over the past 30 years Canada’s population is getting older In 2020, 1/5 Canadians will be above 65 years.
How did Rwanda Operationalize Performance-based Financing ? Results Based Financing Workshop October 20-24, 2008 Gisenyi, Rwanda.
Project Title. Project Title: to improve the care of people who are infected with both TB and HIV, through training and collaborative care initiatives.
Result Based Financing in Ethiopia Program for Result 1.
WHAT FACTORS INFLUENCE THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT OF COUNTRIES? OBJ: TO DETERMINE THE HOW WEALTH, HEALTH & EDUCATION CONTRIBUTE TO A NATION’S ECONOMIC STATUS.
General people’s Committee for Health & Environement
Performance Based Financing at Hospital - Liberia Health Systems Strengthening Project (HSSP) July 8, 2013 Harry Neufville Shun Mabuchi.
Information Cycle Data Handling in Information Cycle: Collection and Collation University of Oslo Department of Informatics Oslo Facilitator: Gertrudes.
Reaching the Poor Conference, February 23, Data: Types and Sources Abdo Yazbeck Lead Health Economist World Bank Institute.
Paying Health Care Providers for Performance: Evidence from Rwanda Paul Gertler UC Berkeley January 2009.
Prioritizing Performance Problems and Choosing Recipients Benjamin Loevinsohn Lead Public Health Specialist The World Bank June 2008.
Building an Evidence base for Primary Eye Care Improving health worldwide Professor Clare Gilbert International Centre.
Learning from RBF Implementation Dinesh Nair Sr Health Specialist.
RWANDA PERFORMANCE BASED SYSTEM: PUBLIC REFORMS Claude SEKABARAGA, MD, MPH Director policy, planning and capacity building Ministry of Health October 2008.
1 Influence of PBF Indicators on Health Coverage Kathy Kantengwa M.D, MPA; PBF advisor, MSH Montreux, November 2010 Rwanda IHSS Project.
February 2010 Petra Vergeer, Health Specialist RBF Team, World Bank At a glance… Verification of performance linked to financial incentives by Joe Naimoli.
The Reaching Every District (RED) strategy.  Re-establish outreach services  Conduct supportive supervision  Establish community links with service.
April 19, 2010 Regional Workshop Asian Development Bank Headquarters April Manila Philippines Dr Amanullah Senior Director Health & Nutrition Strengthening.
RBF through the Public Health Sector in Low-Income Countries Essential Design Elements for a Health Center RBF model György Fritsche HDNHE RBF Seminar.
What is RBF? A paradigm shift for health systems in low-income countries Cape Town – 30 th September 2014 Bruno Meessen, Institute of Tropicale Medicine,
1 What are Monitoring and Evaluation? How do we think about M&E in the context of the LAM Project?
Agenda  Motivation and Overview (using Education as an example)  Discussion by Selected Intervention Area  Energy Services.
Performances Based Financing scheme in Rwanda INVESTING MORE STRATEGICALLY 1.
Primer on Monitoring and Evaluation. The 3 Pillars of Monitoring and Evaluation  Identifying the Performance Indicators  Collecting information using.
Mothers unwilling to go to clinics Low staff skills Inadequate number of clinics Shortage of drugs High infant mortality rates Commercial pressure for.
Helping Nigeria make Rapid Progress Through Performance-Based Financing World Bank June 5, 2014 Health Center Storage Room Before and After Introduction.
Community Health Development Project in Long Reap Hoi 1 Members 1.Mr.Nalong Bouchaleune (Lao PDR) 2.Ms.Win Pa Pa Soe (Myanmar) 3.Mr.Kirati pong Punyaruang.
2015 EAST AFRICA EVIDENCE SUMMIT JULY 8-9, 2015 | NAIROBI, KENYA COMMUNITY PERFORMANCE-BASED FINANCING IMPACT EVALUATION DISSEMINATION MEETING JEANINE.
Primary Healthcare Is seen as the first point of contact within an organised health care system.
Choice of indicator and amount in the Performance Based Financing Rwanda IHSS Project First Global Symposium on Health Systems Research Montreux, November.
Results-based financing Why? What? How?. Jagaman district just erected a new health center and the health workers have started work. What are health workers.
Paulin Basinga Rwanda School of Public Health A collaboration between the Rwanda Ministry of Health, CNLS, SPH, INSP Mexico, UC Berkeley and the World.
21/4/2008 Evaluation of control measures 1. 21/4/2008 Evaluation of control measures 2 Family and Community Medicine Department.
PERFORMANCE BASED FINANCING FOR HEALTH IN RWANDA Dr RUSA U. Louis Ministry of Health Kigali-Rwanda Montreux 16th- 19th.
Creating an Enabling Environment for PE/E Interventions 23 February 2011 Addis Ababa, Ethiopia Lindsay Morgan 1 Interventions for Impact in Essential Obstetric.
Nigeria, January 2010 Petra Vergeer Health Specialist, RBF Team.
What PBF can achieve; Example from Rwanda Claude SEKABARAGA, MD, MPH World Bank, Nairobi Hub. January 2010.
Fiscal Planning (Budgeting). Fiscal Planning Fiscal planning is not intuitive; it is a learned skill that improves with practice. Fiscal planning requires.
Gaston Sorgho Harvard School of Public Health
National Community Health Performance-based Financing: design and implementation of supply-side model PBF workshop Bujumbura February 16 th, 2011 Ludwig.
Rwandan Performance-Based Financing Process and Tools Gisenyi Results-Based Financing Workshop October 21, 2008 Dr Gyuri FRITSCHE Management Sciences for.
UNDP Zatona Adil CNE/ PNLT FNM ICVSM CNES Centros Saúde HAM ASCPS 4% 6% 26% 2% 1% 2% 8% 28% 20% 34% 1% 5% 3% 4% 14% 0% 3% The Global Fund 100% flow of.
Preliminary Proposal Equity Factor for FY13. Context Wide variation in the distribution of resources across districts in Tanzania and in the effective.
Overview of Steps to Design and Implement Results Based Financing Schemes Susna De, MSc, MPH Results Based Financing to Reduce Maternal, Newborn, and Child.
Vaccination data collection from health facilities: Albania.
Data Collection. Data and information Data –observations and measurements Processed data (information) –facts extracted from a set of data (interpreted.
CONSTRAINTS TO PRIMARY HEALTH CARE DELIVERY THE GOVERNMENT OBJECTIVES FOR DELIVERING PHC SERVICES To increase accessibility to quality health care services.
SPECIAL SESSION COUNTDOWN TO 2015 IN ETHIOPIA SIX BUILDING BLOCKS OF THE HEALTH SYSTEM: PROGRESS TOWARDS THE INTEGRATION IN ETHIOPIA Dereje Mamo Tsegaye.
Endris Mohammed Seid 1,2, Arjanne Rietsema 1 1: CORDAID-Zimbabwe 2: Ministry of Health and Child Care- Zimbabwe Improving Maternal, Neonatal and Child.
Gender, Health and Poverty: Critical Factors Beyond the Health Sector Arlette Campbell White World Bank Institute.
Table © The Author(s) Published by Science and Education Publishing. Abebe Demewoz Mengesha et al. The Impact of Culture on the Nutritional Status.
Definition of indicators Facilitators’ Workshop on District Health Performance Improvement Lilongwe, 25 th – 27 th March 2015.
NASARAWA STATE GOVERNMENT NIGERIA STATE HEALTH INVESTMENT PROJECT (NSHIP) PROJECT PERFORMANCE REVIEW JANUARY TO JUNE 2015.
NIGERIA STATE HEALTH INVESTMENT PROJECT (NSHIP) IN NASARAWA STATE – 2015 HALF YEAR R.
Afghanistan Now: On the Path to Better Health
Results-based financing
NIGERIA STATE HEALTH INVESTMENT PROJECT IN NASARAWA STATE – Update on NSHIP activities Presented: December, 2016.
15th November 2016 HSR 2016 Symposium
NIGERIA STATE HEALTH INVESTMENT PROJECT IN NASARAWA STATE – NSHIP PROGRESS REPORT PRESENTATION Presented: March, 2017.
Descriptive Analysis of Performance-Based Financing Education Project in Burundi Victoria Ryan World Bank Group May 16, 2017.
1.03 Healthcare Trends.
Achieving the SPF Guarantees: Recommendations from group discussions
LECTURE 5.
Nigeria State Health Investment Project (NSHIP) Nasarawa State
Ambulances, Project Kiramama – June 2014
Presentation transcript:

Results – Based Financing (RBF) in Health Presentation by Gaston Sorgho, HD Sector Leader – Central Africa World Bank AFRICA - HNP

Inputs Outputs Activities Traditional Financing Results Based Financing World Bank - AFR Health Nutrition Population

Paying for results: Taking quality into account Measuring the quantity of services produced by the health facility; Quarterly measurement of the quality of services the facility delivers; Quantity * Unit price per service * Quality Index = Payment Adjustment made for remoteness or other difficulty. World Bank - AFR Health Nutrition Population

ServiceNumber Provided Unit price Total Earned Child fully vaccinated100$5$500 Skilled birth attendance20$10$200 Curative care <5 years1,000$0.5$500 TOTAL$1,200 Remoteness Bonus+50%$1,800 Quality Correction60%$1,080 Example of Results Based Financing (RBF) in a Health Facility World Bank - AFR Health Nutrition Population

ServiceNumber Provided Unit price Total Earned Child fully vaccinated100$5$500 Skilled birth attendance20$10$200 Curative care <5 years1,000$0.5$500 TOTAL$1,200 Remoteness Bonus+50%$1,800 Quality Correction60%$1,080 Deciding on which services to include, i.e., which are the priorities

World Bank - AFR Health Nutrition Population ServiceNumber Provided Unit price Total Earned Child fully vaccinated100$5$500 Skilled birth attendance20$10$200 Curative care <5 years1,000$0.5$500 TOTAL$1,200 Remoteness Bonus+50%$1,800 Quality Correction60%$1,080 Setting the unit price for each service is complicated but prices can be adjusted

World Bank - AFR Health Nutrition Population ServiceNumber Provided Unit price Total Earned Child fully vaccinated100$5$500 Skilled birth attendance20$10$200 Curative care <5 years1,000$0.5$500 TOTAL$1,200 Remoteness Bonus+50%$1,800 Quality Correction60%$1,080 Verifying that the claimed quantity of services were actually delivered requires care & a few approaches

World Bank - AFR Health Nutrition Population ServiceNumber Provided Unit price Total Earned Child fully vaccinated100$5$500 Skilled birth attendance20$10$200 Curative care <5 years1,000$0.5$500 TOTAL$1,200 Remoteness Bonus+50%$1,800 Quality Correction60%$1,080 Measuring quality of care is an important challenge

Example of a Quantitative Checklist to determine Quality of Care Score Date of Visit MaiAoutNovFev. Availability of Drugs (0-10)77810 Presence of staff (0-10)5689 SNIS implementation (0-10)3355 TB Case Detection Rate (0-10)58910 Cleanliness of Health Center67810 Quality of delivery care (0-10)6778 Outreach activities (0-10)2568 TOTAL SCORE (out of 70) TOTAL PERCENT

World Bank - AFR Health Nutrition Population ServiceNumber Provided Unit price Total Earned Child fully vaccinated100$5$500 Skilled birth attendance20$10$200 Curative care <5 years1,000$0.5$500 TOTAL$1,200 Remoteness Bonus+50%$1,800 Quality Correction60%$1,080 Remoteness bonus reflects the fact that some facilities will face bigger challenges in attracting patients

ServiceNumber Provided Unit price Total Earned Child fully vaccinated100$5$500 Skilled birth attendance20$10$200 Curative care <5 years1,000$0.5$500 TOTAL$1,200 Remoteness Bonus+50%$1,800 Quality Correction60%$1,080 Example of Results Based Financing (RBF) in a Health Facility World Bank - AFR Health Nutrition Population

Example of what can the facility do with the $1,080 Health facility operation costs(about 40%): -Maintenance and repair -Consumables -Drugs -Outreach -Other elements related to improving quality Performance bonus to health workers (about 60%) –criteria are defined World Bank - AFR Health Nutrition Population