On the Failure to Detect Changes in Scenes Across Brief Interruptions Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

The Role of Competition in Repetition Blindness Mary L. Still Alison L. MorrisIowa State University The Role of Competition in Repetition Blindness Mary.

Advertisements

Applying Analytical Writing Patterns to Essay #2.

One of these images doesn’t fit – which one is it and why? There are two connected pairs of images – what are they and what is the connection?

Detail to attention: Exploiting Visual Tasks for Selective Rendering Kirsten Cater 1, Alan Chalmers 1 and Greg Ward 2 1 University of Bristol, UK 2 Anyhere.

Chapter 6: Visual Attention. Overview of Questions Why do we pay attention to some parts of a scene but not to others? Do we have to pay attention to.

Eye Movements of Younger and Older Drivers Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

LOGO The role of attentional breadth in perceptual change detection Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

Change blindness examples are from: Spot the change in the following images.

Chapter 6: Visual Attention. Scanning a Scene Visual scanning – looking from place to place –Fixation –Saccadic eye movement Overt attention involves.

LOGO Effects of scene inversion on change detection of targets matched for visual salience Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

Visual attention reveals changing color in moving objects James E. Hoffman and Scott McLean University of Delaware.

Features and Objects in Visual Processing

Representation of statistical properties 作者： Sang Chul Chong, Anne Treisman 報告者：李正彥日期： 2006/3/23.

Visual search: Who cares?

Attention I failures to select information

Attention II Selective Attention & Visual Search.

Designing Pages and Screens Comm Arts II Mr. Wreford.

Verbal Rehearsal, Semantic Elaboration, and Imagery.

Attention I failures to select information. What is attention? How is the word used? Examples: –something bright caught my attention –I didn’t see you,

Status of conjunctive neurons Read from p. 88. Are higher-order conjunctive neurons amodal symbols? What determines what they activate and how the results.

Whole Report “report” (remember and write down) as many letters from a brief display as possible Average in laboratory is 4.5 out of nine Class average.

LOGO Current Approaches to Change Blindness Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

Change blindness: Past, present, and future Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

Verification of the Change Blindness Phenomenon While Managing Critical Events on a Combat Information Display 作者： Joseph DiVita et al. 報告者：李正彥日期： 2006/4/27.

Design Principles 3.02 Understand business publications Slide 1.

Effects of Warning Validity and Proximity on Responses to Warnings Joachim Meyer, Israel HUMAN FACTORS, Vol. 43, No. 4 (2001)

Studying Visual Attention with the Visual Search Paradigm Marc Pomplun Department of Computer Science University of Massachusetts at Boston

The Effect of Object Size and Speed on Time to Collision Estimation in the Horizontal Plane Douna Montazer, Valdeep Saini, Nicole Simone, Danielle Thorpe.

Information Extraction from Cricket Videos Syed Ahsan Ishtiaque Kumar Srijan.

Change blindness and time to consciousness Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

Lecture 8 – Visual Memory 1 Through associations between new material and familiar material. But how do we develop associations? In particular, do we.

Sensation & Perception

Capstone Presentation Guideline February 2010 Middletown High School Middletown Public Schools.

1 Perception and VR MONT 104S, Fall 2008 Session 13 Visual Attention.

Change detection and occlusion modes in road-traffic scenarios Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

Psych 435 Attention. Issues Capacity –We can’t respond to everything in the environment –Too many pieces of information –we can only actively respond.

CB during flicker (Rensink, O’Regan & Clark, 1997; 2000)

1 Computational Vision CSCI 363, Fall 2012 Lecture 36 Attention and Change Blindness (why you shouldn't text while driving)

Cornell System of Note-Taking The Cornell Method of note making is a 3 part system of making notes. Making notes, as distinguished from taking notes, is.

Effect of a concurrent auditory task on visual search performance in a driving-related image-flicker task Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

Assessment and Testing

Visual Search Deficits in Williams Buren Syndrome Montfoort, I., Frens, M.A., Lagers- Van Haselen, G.C., & van der Geest, J.N.

Design Concept Display. Emphasis The dictionary contains emphasis in the form of bolded words. The words in bold are given importance to differentiate.

Change Blind Information Display for Ubiquitous Computing Environments Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

Chapter 9—Basic Components of Memory. Basic Terms Memory = ability to recall information that has previously been learned Storage = putting new information.

Psych 335 Attention. Issues Capacity –We can’t respond to everything in the environment –Too many pieces of information –we can only actively respond.

Older Driver Failures of Attention at Intersections: Using Change Blindness Methods to Assess Turn Decision Accuracy Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

LOGO Change blindness in the absence of a visual disruption Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

RIGHT PARIETAL CORTEX PLAYS A CRITICAL ROLE IN CHANGE BLINDNESS by Naser Aljundi.

 Example: seeing a bird that is singing in a tree or miss a road sign in plain sight  Cell phone use while driving reduces attention and memory for.

Intelligent Robotics Today: Vision & Time & Space Complexity.

Picture change during blinks: looking without seeing and seeing without looking Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

Design Principles 5.01 Understand business publications Slide 1.

LOGO Conversation Disrupts Change Detection in Complex Traffic Scenes Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

Traffic scene related change blindness in older drivers Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

“There is nothing so practical as a good theory” - Kurt Lewin What is Social Psychology? Chapter 1.

Stimuli were presented on a 17 inch monitor (in a dimly lit room), operating at 60 Hz with a resolution of 1280 x Two objects of the same type (teapot.

LOGO Visual Attention in Driving: The Effects of Cognitive Load and Visual Disruption Professor: Liu Student: Ruby.

Assist. Prof. Dr. Ilmiye Seçer Fall

CHAPTER 4 Designing Studies

Eye Movements & Change Blindness: What do they tell us?

Perception Unit How can we so easily perceive the world? Objects may be moving, partially hidden, varying in orientation, and projected as a 2D image.

Illusory Jitter Perceived at the Frequency of Alpha Oscillations

Perceptual Echoes at 10 Hz in the Human Brain

Chapter V, Printing Digital Images: Lesson III Using Software to Adjust the Image

Karl R Gegenfurtner, Jochem Rieger Current Biology

Consequences of the Oculomotor Cycle for the Dynamics of Perception

Chapter 7 - Visual Attention

For this test you will be asked to remember the colors of words that are briefly presented on the computer screen. After several have been presented you.

Consequences of the Oculomotor Cycle for the Dynamics of Perception

Presentation transcript:

On the Failure to Detect Changes in Scenes Across Brief Interruptions Professor: Liu Student: Ruby

Motive & purpose Motive –The authors think that the past papers didn’t have a same detailed representation. Purpose –To test how the lack of consistency comes about.

References YearAuthors Result Bridgeman, Hendry, & Stark Grimes McConkie & Zola The observers find it hard to discover changes in pix made during a saccade ,1996 Hayhoe, & Whitehead Henderson Irwin It can be carried across a saccade are a few characteristics of a few previously fixated items. 1997Simons & Levin In the test, observers are poor at detecting change when the displays are separated by an interstimulus interval (ISI) of more than msec and the presentation time range from 250msec to 2sec.

References YearAuthors Result 1997Rensink Coherence theory which is the early level structures simple doesn’t have much coherence in the absence of focused attention. 1997Rensink Some people think the representation is too fast, they have to descript what they discover when the incoming stimuli at the same retinal location Kahneman, Treisman, & Gibbs The focused attention is required to provide the coherence which the early level structures into large scale objects and allows these objects to keep an identity over time.

General method Pix were displayed for 240msed and blanks for 80msec. The blank fields being medium gray. 48 color pix. 27wide and 18 high. Change the presence, color, or location. Central interests (CIs) were objects or areas mentioned by most observers. Marginal interests (MIs) were objects or areas mentioned by none.

General method Ten observers in each test. Observers were required to press the keyboard when they discover the change then say what the different in these two pix. Using computer presented the pix and controlled and collected the data. 6 trials for practice.

The procedure of the change blindness

Experiment 1 - Extended preview Giving observers an 8 sec preview for the original image before the test. They were asked to remember as much of the image as possible in order to improve the ability to notice change.

Result for Experiment 1 There is no significant in detection time (all Ps >.2). No effect of extended preview, F(1,10) = 0.6, P >.4. The change blindness is not caused by non-enough time to construct a serial pix, or by some flicker- induced interference with its consolidation in memory.

Experiment 2 – Different blank durations Change the blank field duration of 40msec, 160msec, and 320msec. Results here were combined with those obtained for the standard durations of 80msec.

Result of Experiment 2

No significant interactions between duration and interest,F(3,30) = 2.8, p >.05. No significant interactions between duration and change type, F(6,60) = 0.87, p >.5. No significant interactions between all three together, F(6,60) = 0.98, p >.4. However, a significant effect of duration was detected, F(3,30) = 3.66, p <.03.

Result of Experiment 2 Blanks of 320msec are slower than for 80msec blanks, this slowdown was significant only for marginal interests; CI: p >.1;MI: p <.05. This slowdown perhaps because some kind of memory are reduce.

Experiment 3 – Different blank colors Three different colors of the blank field: black, white, and red. The red field was isoluminant with the standard gray.

Result of Experiment 3 No interactions between luminance and interest, F(2,20) = 0.55, p >.5. No interactions between luminance and change type, F(4,36) = 0.44, p >.7. No interactions between all three factors, F(4,36) = 0.047, p >.9. No overall effect of luminance was found, F(2,20) = 1.03, p >.3.

Result of Experiment 3 Performance was not significantly affected for changes in central interests (all ps >.2). Color changes in marginal interests were significantly more difficult to detect (p <.05),

Experiment 4 – Reduced coverage of the interruption Using a brief, localized non-color “splats” that did not cover the areas of the image that were changed. Splats were rectangles having a structure of black and white checks, each check being approximately 20 arc minutes in size.

Result of Experiment 4 There was no effect of change type, F(2,18) = 2.70, p >.05 There was an interaction between change type and interest, F(2,18) = 9.83, p <.002. No significant difference between CIs and MIs (p >.6). There was a strong effect of interest, F(1,9) = , p < 10-6, with detection slower for MIs

Discussion 8 sec should to be enough to discover the change more easily. If change blindness were caused by disruption, performance might worse (or improve) with increasing duration.

Discussion A detailed representation does exist at each moment that our eyes are open, we are easily able to see that part of the scene being fixated. Although we have representations that large amounts of detailed information, and representations that provide coherence over time and space, we do not have representations to do both.