The Pliocene Warm Interval: Is It An Analogue For Future Warming? The Pliocene Epoch (5.3 to 2.6 Ma) is the last “great global warming” before the beginning.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
VEGETATION FEEDBACK AND DROUGHTS Russell Bird – 3 rd Year Atmospheric Science.
Advertisements

Comparing hypotheses for Pliocene tropical warmth Chris Brierley & Alexey Fedorov Yale University.
Locations on a Globe (GLEs 1,2) Today’s Agenda: Warm – Up
The Perfect Ocean for Drought, Martin Hoerling & Arun Kumar On the Cause of the 1930s Dust Bowl, Siegfried D. Schubert, Max J. Suarez, Philip J. Pegion,
It all begins with the sun……
Climatology Climatology is the study of Earth’s climate and the factors that affect past, present, and future climatic changes. Climate describes the long-term.
The Role of Internally Generated Megadroughts and External Solar Forcing in Long Term Pacific Climate Fluctuations Gerald A. Meehl NCAR.
Delayed onset of the South American Monsoon during the Last Glacial Maximum Kerry H. Cook and Edward K. Vizy, Cornell University I. INTRODUCTION Climate.
Oceans, Currents, and Weather Dynamics
Explaining the Evidence Activity 2: Clearing the Air.
Chapter 25.1 “Factors that Affect Climate”
Consolidated Seasonal Rainfall Guidance for Africa Dec 2012 Initial Conditions Summary Forecast maps Forecast Background – ENSO update – Current State.
Rising Temperatures. Various Temperature Reconstructions from
Lesson 11: El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) Physical Oceanography
5. Future climate predictions Global average temperature and sea-level are projected to rise under all IPCC scenarios Temperature: +1.8°C (B1) to +4.0°C.
Earth Science 17.3 Temperature Controls
Prentice Hall EARTH SCIENCE
Climate.
Climate and Climate Change
Are Exceptionally Cold Vermont Winters Returning? Dr. Jay Shafer July 1, 2015 Lyndon State College 1.
This postcard shows a warm coastal climate.
“Where America’s Climate, Weather Ocean and Space Weather Services Begin” Michelle L’Heureux NOAA Climate Prediction Center December 3, 2009 El Niño: What.
6-2 Climate and Biomes. Where is the water and life at?
Climate Lesson What factors contribute to a region’s climate?
Instructions: 1.Click on a box under the category you want. 2.Read the question and try to answer to yourself. 3.Click one time for the answer to appear.
Chapter 18 – Climate and Climate Change
CDC Cover. NOAA Lab roles in CCSP Strategic Plan for the U.S. Climate Change Science Program: Research Elements Element 3. Atmospheric Composition Aeronomy.
Global warming is increasing the average temperature of the global ocean and the atmosphere of the Earth, which is observed from the 1950s onwards. [1]
The Climate Chapter 25.
CLIMATE CHANGE DIFFERENT DATA DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES.
Lecture 5 The Climate System and the Biosphere. One significant way the ocean can influence climate is through formation of sea ice. Sea ice is much more.
Dan Cayan Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UC San Diego USGS Water Resources Discipline much support from David Pierce, Mary Tyree, and other colleagues.
Review Chapter 6: Climatic Changes. What’s Your Favorite Thing About Thanksgiving? Turkey 2.Vegetables.
Sponsors: National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) NASA Goddard Space Flight Center (GSFC) NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies (GISS)
The ability to accurately predict climate in the New York metropolitan area has tremendous significance in terms of minimizing potential economic loss.
Projection of Global Climate Change. Review of last lecture Rapid increase of greenhouse gases (CO 2, CH 4, N 2 O) since 1750: far exceed pre-industrial.
Climate. Climate Average weather conditions at a location over a long period of time. Average weather conditions at a location over a long period of time.
 In the mid-Pleistocene, the period of glacial cycles changed from 41kyr to 100kyr.  The zonal SST gradient increased during MPT due to the cooling in.
The European Heat Wave of 2003: A Modeling Study Using the NSIPP-1 AGCM. Global Modeling and Assimilation Office, NASA/GSFC Philip Pegion (1), Siegfried.
Mechanisms of drought in present and future climate Gerald A. Meehl and Aixue Hu.
Dr Mark Cresswell Statistical Forecasting [Part 2] 69EG6517 – Impacts & Models of Climate Change.
Global Climates. Global Distribution Of Climate Climate describes the temperature, precipitation, and other weather conditions of a certain area. The.
Monitoring and Modeling Climate Change Are oceans getting warmer? Are sea levels rising? To answer questions such as these, scientists need to collect.
Consolidated Seasonal Rainfall Guidance for Global Tropics, December 2015 Initial Conditions Issued 14 December 2015 Forecast Background – ENSO update.
Indo-Pacific Sea Surface Temperature Influences on Failed Consecutive Rainy Seasons over Eastern Africa** Andy Hoell 1 and Chris Funk 1,2 Contact:
Ahira Sánchez-Lugo October 20, 2015 NOAA’s National Centers for Environmental Information.
Anomalous Behavior Unit 3 Climate of Change InTeGrate Module Cynthia M. Fadem Earlham College Russian River Valley, CA, USA.
Chapter: Climate Section 3: Climatic Changes.
Art or Science?. Explain the thermal transfers of energy within oceans and the importance of oceanic conveyor belts.
“CLIMATE IS WHAT WE EXPECT, AND WEATHER IS WHAT WE GET” ~ MARK TWAIN.
Impacts of Climate Change and Variability on Agriculture: Using NASA Models for Regional Applications Radley Horton 1, Cynthia Rosenzweig 2, and David.
 On a climograph, what data are represented with bars? ◦ What data are represented with a line graph?  How can you determine the climate classification.
Section Climate Change According to NASA’s Goddard Institute for Space Studies, 2009 tied for second warmest year on record, just behind The.
Earth-Sun Relationships Climate & Weather. Earth-Sun Relationships Climate and Weather Weather is the condition of the atmosphere at a specific time.
Climates can change suddenly or slowly.  ICE AGE: Period in which huge sheets of ice spread out beyond the polar regions.  El NINO: A disturbance of.
CHAPTER 4 CLIMATE AND CLIMATE CHANGE. 4.1 CLIMATE IS A LONG TERM WEATHER PATTERN CLIMATE IS THE CHARACTERISTIC WEATHER CONDITIONS IN A PLACE OVER A LONG.
El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO): What is it?
Ch 20 Global Warming Part one.
Earth Science Notes Climate.
Bigger Hurricanes: Bigger Hurricanes: A Consequence A Consequence of
Climate Changes.
DO NOW Turn in Review #22. Pick up notes and Review #23.
Climate- Abiotic factor
EL NINO Figure (a) Average sea surface temperature departures from normal as measured by satellite. During El Niño conditions upwelling is greatly.
EQ: How can I differentiate between weather and climate?
Climate Changes due to Natural Processes
Case Studies in Decadal Climate Predictability
GEOGRAPHY REVIEW UNIT.
Intro to Earth Science-Part 1
Presentation transcript:

The Pliocene Warm Interval: Is It An Analogue For Future Warming? The Pliocene Epoch (5.3 to 2.6 Ma) is the last “great global warming” before the beginning of the Pleistocene ice age. Paleoclimate proxy data, such as animal and plant fossils on land or in the ocean, suggest that the Earth was 2 to 3 degrees C warmer than present, with the most pronounced heating found in the polar regions. There may also have been a persistent El Niño-like feature, called El Padre, that led to increased warmth of tropical ocean surface waters. Despite these differences, the concentration of atmospheric CO2 during the Pliocene was similar to current day levels (380 ± 40 ppm). For this reason, climate researchers want to understand whether the Pliocene represents a warm world in an equilibrium state, a condition that we may eventually achieve in the near future even if CO2 emissions are stabilized. For our study, we used EdGCM/GISS GCM Model II to explore whether an El Padre could have contributed to the Pliocene global warming. We have also examined to what extent we can draw parallels between the regional climate impacts of an El Padre-driven Pliocene climate, and a strong modern El Niño, such as the 1997/1998 event, which has been projected to become a persistent feature of a future warm climate. We find that an El Padre/persistent El Niño could have played an important warming role for the Pliocene, and therefore has implications for our future climate. Abstract: The Pliocene Epoch (5.3 to 2.6 Ma) is the last “great global warming” before the beginning of the Pleistocene ice age. Paleoclimate proxy data, such as animal and plant fossils on land or in the ocean, suggest that the Earth was 2 to 3 degrees C warmer than present, with the most pronounced heating found in the polar regions. There may also have been a persistent El Niño-like feature, called El Padre, that led to increased warmth of tropical ocean surface waters. Despite these differences, the concentration of atmospheric CO2 during the Pliocene was similar to current day levels (380 ± 40 ppm). For this reason, climate researchers want to understand whether the Pliocene represents a warm world in an equilibrium state, a condition that we may eventually achieve in the near future even if CO2 emissions are stabilized. For our study, we used EdGCM/GISS GCM Model II to explore whether an El Padre could have contributed to the Pliocene global warming. We have also examined to what extent we can draw parallels between the regional climate impacts of an El Padre-driven Pliocene climate, and a strong modern El Niño, such as the 1997/1998 event, which has been projected to become a persistent feature of a future warm climate. We find that an El Padre/persistent El Niño could have played an important warming role for the Pliocene, and therefore has implications for our future climate. Objectives To determine if the Pliocene is a proper analog towards the future climate changes that have been projected by scientists. To determine if the Pliocene is a proper analog towards the future climate changes that have been projected by scientists. Compare and contrast the characteristics of the Pliocene warm climate and possible forcings, such as the El Padre (persistent El Nino) effect, to our own modern day climate characteristics. Compare and contrast the characteristics of the Pliocene warm climate and possible forcings, such as the El Padre (persistent El Nino) effect, to our own modern day climate characteristics. Importance of This Study Understanding the factors and forcings that produced the Pliocene’s warm stable climate can help us understand what our world may become like in the near future, even if the CO2 emissions are stabilized at or near current levels. Understanding the factors and forcings that produced the Pliocene’s warm stable climate can help us understand what our world may become like in the near future, even if the CO2 emissions are stabilized at or near current levels. Methods We used a software called EdGCM, which utilizes the NASA/GISS GCM Model II, to run all our climate simulations. We used a software called EdGCM, which utilizes the NASA/GISS GCM Model II, to run all our climate simulations. We first ran a series of sensitivity experiments using specified sea surface temperatures (SSTs) to examine the model’s response to certain forcings, such as greenhouse gas level changes. We first ran a series of sensitivity experiments using specified sea surface temperatures (SSTs) to examine the model’s response to certain forcings, such as greenhouse gas level changes. We then ran a series of predicted SST experiments, in which the model’s ocean was allowed to respond to climate forcings set for each simulation. We then ran a series of predicted SST experiments, in which the model’s ocean was allowed to respond to climate forcings set for each simulation. We ran a total of four ensembles of runs, two with specified SSTs and two with predicted SSTs. For each ensemble, we changed the CO2 concentration in 5 ppm increments, from 380 ppm to 425 ppm. To one specified and one predicted SST ensemble, we also added the El Padre phenomenon by increasing tropical SSTs between 16N-16S. We ran a total of four ensembles of runs, two with specified SSTs and two with predicted SSTs. For each ensemble, we changed the CO2 concentration in 5 ppm increments, from 380 ppm to 425 ppm. To one specified and one predicted SST ensemble, we also added the El Padre phenomenon by increasing tropical SSTs between 16N-16S. Results  In the predicted SST runs, we saw a greater increase in higher latitude temperatures when compared with the modern control run, consistent with Pliocene paleoclimate proxy data.  Our most extreme pSST run (425 ppm CO2) had a global average temperature increase of ~2 degrees Celsius compared to our modern control run. The polar regions showed a temperature increase of up to ~29 degrees Celsius. However, the mid-latitudes went through more warming in the northern hemisphere than in the southern hemisphere, most likely due to the distribution of land vs. ocean in the northern hemisphere vs. the southern hemisphere.  The equatorial regions did not change significantly in terms of temperature, with some areas even cooling (not by more than ~1 degree Celsius).  Global average precipitation is only slightly higher than that of the modern control run; however, many places undergo drastic increase or decreases. For example Central America, the Atlantic ocean, and the Asia-Pacific islands get significantly dryer than they are today (up to more than 3 mm/day less), whereas other places, such as Africa, South America, and the western Pacific ocean get a lot wetter (up to ~2.5 mm/day).  In the El Padre predicted SST runs, we saw a much warmer climate (> 3 degrees Celsius) than the modern control run; however, the maximum temperatures (present in Antarctica) remained the same as they did in the normal pSST runs. Surface air temperature-wise the El Padre runs simply showed more pronounced warming in the areas that where undergoing warming in the pSST runs.  Precipitation patterns in these runs do bare similarities to those regional patterns expected from Pliocene paleoclimate proxy data as well as with strong modern El Nino events. For example, we see a significant increase in precipitation in the equatorial west coast of South America, more precipitation in the Indian subcontinent (keep in mind there are also areas of decreased precipitation in the Indian subcontinent), decrease around the Japanese islands and a few areas of increased precipitation in Africa. Conclusions Our findings to date do suggest that an El Padre phenomenon, or persistent El Nino, did contribute to a global average increase in temperature during the Pliocene. Regional patterns of temperature and precipitation are also reasonably well reproduced by our Pliocene El Padre simulations although some differences remain. If the Pliocene does in fact represent a warm climate at equilibrium, it is very likely to be a good analog for our future warm world once our climate is no longer in transition. This is an anomaly map of our Pliocene control run minus out modern control run, showing us how different the Pliocene’s climate was from our own despite the similar forcings. Pliocene El Padre Time Series Sponsors: National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) NASA Goddard Space Flight Center (GSFC) NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies (GISS) NASA New York City Research Initiative (NYCRI) Contributors: Principal Investigator 1: Dr. Mark Chandler Principal Investigator 2: Dr. Linda Sohl Graduate Student: Sonali Shukla High School Teacher: Mohamed Shanap Undergraduate Student: Carimaxy Benitez NYCRI Apprentice: Francisco Benavides Surface Air Temperature- This map illustrates the similarities that the Pliocene/El Nino regional impact and our Pliocene maximum run minus our Pliocene control run. Precipitation- The arrows indicate where most of the precipitation is taking place, very similar to the regional precipitation shown above. This map is a Pliocene to its maximum 425 ppm minus our Pliocene control run 380 ppm. Pliocene/ El Nino like Regional Impacts- this is a map of the temperature and precipitation during the Pliocene which is very similar to El Nino. What we think is that during the Pliocene there was a permanent El Nino. To differentiate the two we call this El Padre. Pliocene Time Series without El Padre References Fedorov, A.V, Dekens, P.S, McCarthy, M, Ravelo, A.C, DeMenocal, P.B, Barreiro, M, Pacanowski, R.C, and Philander, S.G, The Pliocene Paradox (Mechanisms for a Permanent El Nino): Science, v.312, p , DOI: /science Molnar, P, and Cane, M.A, Early Pliocene (pre-Ice Age) El Nino-like Global Climate: Which El Nino?: Geosphere v.3, p , DOI: /ges