Limitations of Partial Quenching Stephen Sharpe and Ruth Van de Water, University of Washington, Seattle QCD with 3 flavors (u, d, s) possesses an approximate.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Lecture 1: basics of lattice QCD Peter Petreczky Lattice regularization and gauge symmetry : Wilson gauge action, fermion doubling Different fermion formulations.
Advertisements

Summing planar diagrams
1cteq ss 11 B. Properties of the PDFs -- Definitions First, what are the Parton Distribution Functions? (PDFs) The PDFs are a set of 11 functions, f i.
Direct CP Asymmetries in hadronic D decays Cai-Dian Lü ( 吕才典 ) IHEP, Beijing Based on work collaborated with Hsiang-nan Li, Fu-Sheng Yu, arXiv: ,
Solution of the Deuteron using Perturbation Theory (ongoing work with R. S. Azevedo and Prof. Bira van Kolck) University of Arizona Undergraduate Symposium.
1 Meson correlators of two-flavor QCD in the epsilon-regime Hidenori Fukaya (RIKEN) with S.Aoki, S.Hashimoto, T.Kaneko, H.Matsufuru, J.Noaki, K.Ogawa,
Introduction & motivation Baryons in the 1/N c expansion of QCD Photoproduction of excited baryons Summary & conclusions N.N. Scoccola Department of Physics.
QCD-2004 Lesson 1 : Field Theory and Perturbative QCD I 1)Preliminaries: Basic quantities in field theory 2)Preliminaries: COLOUR 3) The QCD Lagrangian.
1 Chiral Symmetry Breaking and Restoration in QCD Da Huang Institute of Theoretical Physics, Chinese Academy of
O(N) linear and nonlinear sigma-model at nonzeroT within the auxiliary field method CJT study of the O(N) linear and nonlinear sigma-model at nonzeroT.
Effective field theories for QCD with rooted staggered fermions Claude Bernard, Maarten Golterman and Yigal Shamir Lattice 2007, Regensburg.
On-Shell Methods in Field Theory David A. Kosower International School of Theoretical Physics, Parma, September 10-15, 2006 Lecture III.
Chiral Dynamics How s and Why s 3 rd lecture: the effective Lagrangian Martin Mojžiš, Comenius University23 rd Students’ Workshop, Bosen, 3-8.IX.2006.
QCD – from the vacuum to high temperature an analytical approach an analytical approach.
Lattice 07, Regensburg, 1 Magnetic Moment of Vector Mesons in Background Field Method Structure of vector mesons Background field method Some results x.
Antonio RagoUniversità di Milano Techniques for automated lattice Feynman diagram calculations 1 Antonio RagoUniversità di Milano Techniques for automated.
11 Primakoff Experiments with EIC A. Gasparian NC A&T State University, Greensboro, NC For the PrimEx Collaboration Outline  Physics motivation:  The.
R. Machleidt, University of Idaho University of Idaho The missing three-nucleon forces: Where are they? 2009 Mardi Gras “Special Symmetries and Ab Initio.
R. Machleidt, University of Idaho D. R. Entem, University of Salamanca Sub-Leading Three-Nucleon Forces in Chiral Perturbation Theory.
THE DEEP INELASTIC SCATTERING ON THE POLARIZED NUCLEONS AT EIC E.S.Timoshin, S.I.Timoshin.
Introduction to Flavor Physics in and beyond the Standard Model
Kab/SC-PAC Operated by the Jefferson Science Associates for the U.S. Department of Energy Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility SURA.
The Baryon octet-vector meson interaction and dynamically generated resonances in the S=0 sector Bao-Xi SUN ( 孙宝玺 ) Beijing University of Technology Hirschegg.
Chiral condensate in nuclear matter beyond linear density using chiral Ward identity S.Goda (Kyoto Univ.) D.Jido ( YITP ) 12th International Workshop on.
Eigo Shintani (KEK) (JLQCD Collaboration) KEKPH0712, Dec. 12, 2007.
Condensates and topology fixing action Hidenori Fukaya YITP, Kyoto Univ. Collaboration with T.Onogi (YITP) hep-lat/
In eq.(1), represent the MFA values of the sigma fields, G S,  P the corresponding coupling constants (see Ref.[3] for details), and is the MFA Polyakov.
Ignasi Rosell Universidad CEU Cardenal Herrera 2007 Determining chiral couplings at NLO: and JHEP 0408 (2004) 042 [hep-ph/ ] JHEP 0701 (2007)
4-quark operator contributions to neutron electric dipole moment Haipeng An, University of Maryland; PHENO 2009 In collaboration with Xiangdong Ji, Fanrong.
Study of chemical potential effects on hadron mass by lattice QCD Pushkina Irina* Hadron Physics & Lattice QCD, Japan 2004 Three main points What do we.
Introduction & motivation Baryons in the 1/N c expansion of QCD Photoproduction of excited baryons Summary & conclusions N.N. Scoccola Department of Physics.
Sketching the pseudoscalar mesons’ valence-quark parton distribution functions Chen Chen University of Science and Technology of China November 16 th,
Huey-Wen Lin — Workshop1 Semileptonic Hyperon Decays in Full QCD Huey-Wen Lin in collaboration with Kostas Orginos.
Chiral symmetry breaking and low energy effective nuclear Lagrangian Eduardo A. Coello Perez.
NEW TRENDS IN HIGH-ENERGY PHYSICS (experiment, phenomenology, theory) Alushta, Crimea, Ukraine, September 23-29, 2013 Effects of the next-to-leading order.
Amand Faessler, Tuebingen1 Chiral Quark Dynamics of Baryons Gutsche, Holstein, Lyubovitskij, + PhD students (Nicmorus, Kuckei, Cheedket, Pumsa-ard, Khosonthongkee,
Time Dependent Quark Masses and Big Bang Nucleosynthesis Myung-Ki Cheoun, G. Mathews, T. Kajino, M. Kusagabe Soongsil University, Korea Asian Pacific Few.
Pion Correlators in the ε- regime Hidenori Fukaya (YITP) collaboration with S. Hashimoto (KEK) and K.Ogawa (Sokendai)
* Collaborators: A. Pich, J. Portolés (Valencia, España), P. Roig (UNAM, México) Daniel Gómez Dumm * IFLP (CONICET) – Dpto. de Física, Fac. de Ciencias.
1 Longitudinal and transverse helicity amplitudes of nucleon resonances in a constituent quark model - bare vs dressed resonance couplings Introduction.
Denis Parganlija (Frankfurt U.) Excited QCD 2010, Tatranska Lomnica/Slovakia Nature of Light Scalar Mesons f 0 (600), a 0 (980), f 0 (1370) and a 0 (1450)
XXXI Bienal de la RSEF, Granada, España, septiembre Angel Gómez Nicola Universidad Complutense Madrid COEFICIENTES DE TRANSPORTE EN UN GAS.
Exotic baryon resonances in the chiral dynamics Tetsuo Hyodo a a RCNP, Osaka b ECT* c IFIC, Valencia d Barcelona Univ. 2003, December 9th A.Hosaka a, D.
Can a R  T be a renormalizable theory ? J.J. Sanz-Cillero Can a resonance chiral theory be a renormalizable theory ? J.J. Sanz-Cillero (Peking U.)
The nonperturbative analyses for lower dimensional non-linear sigma models Etsuko Itou (Osaka University) 1.Introduction 2.The WRG equation for NLσM 3.Fixed.
Toru T. Takahashi with Teiji Kunihiro ・ Why N*(1535)? ・ Lattice QCD calculation ・ Result TexPoint fonts used in EMF. Read the TexPoint manual before you.
Mass and running effects in the pressure for cold and dense matter Letícia F. Palhares Eduardo S. Fraga Letícia F. Palhares Eduardo S. Fraga.
An Introduction to Lattice QCD and Monte Carlo Simulations Sinya Aoki Institute of Physics, University of Tsukuba 2005 Taipei Summer Institute on Particles.
Tensor and Flavor-singlet Axial Charges and Their Scale Dependencies Hanxin He China Institute of Atomic Energy.
ANALYTIC APPROACH TO CONSTRUCTING EFFECTIVE THEORY OF STRONG INTERACTIONS AND ITS APPLICATION TO PION-NUCLEON SCATTERING A.N.Safronov Institute of Nuclear.
Hadrons from a hard wall AdS/QCD model Ulugbek Yakhshiev (Inha University & National University of Uzbekistan) Collaboration Hyun-Chul Kim (Inha University)
Departamento de Física Teórica II. Universidad Complutense de Madrid José R. Peláez ON THE NATURE OF THE LIGHT SCALAR NONET FROM UNITARIZED CHIRAL PERTURBATION.
Beijing, QNP091 Matthias F.M. Lutz (GSI) and Madeleine Soyeur (Saclay) Irfu/SPhN CEA/ Saclay Irfu/SPhN CEA/ Saclay Dynamics of strong and radiative decays.
Convergence of chiral effective theory for nucleon magnetic moments P. Wang, D. B. Leinweber, A. W. Thomas, A. G. Williams and R. Young.
1 NJL model at finite temperature and chemical potential in dimensional regularization T. Fujihara, T. Inagaki, D. Kimura : Hiroshima Univ.. Alexander.
Denis Parganlija (Frankfurt U.) Finite-Temperature QCD Workshop, IST Lisbon Non-Strange and Strange Scalar Quarkonia Denis Parganlija In collaboration.
Radiative Decays involving Scalar Mesons Masayasu Harada (Nagoya Univ.) based Japan-US Workshop on “Electromagnetic Meson Production and Chiral Dynamics”
C.A. Dominguez Centre for Theoretical Physics & Astrophysics University of Cape Town Department of Physics, Stellenbosch University South Africa XII WORKSHOP.
into a quark-antiquark pair self-coupling of gluons
Lattice College of William and Mary
Polarization in charmless B VV decays
Derivation of Electro-Weak Unification and Final Form of Standard Model with QCD and Gluons  1W1+  2W2 +  3W3.
Phases of QCD Normal points and phase transitions; types of transitions; order parameters and susceptibilities; phase diagrams; how transitions are.
Hadrons and Nuclei : Chiral Symmetry and Baryons
Chiral Nuclear Forces with Delta Degrees of Freedom
Polarized Structure Function of Nucleon and Orbital Angular Momentum
Adnan Bashir, UMSNH, Mexico
Neutron EDM with external electric field
Nuclear Forces - Lecture 5 -
Heavy-light weak matrix elements using all-to-all propagators
Presentation transcript:

Limitations of Partial Quenching Stephen Sharpe and Ruth Van de Water, University of Washington, Seattle QCD with 3 flavors (u, d, s) possesses an approximate SU(3) chiral symmetry This can be used to construct an effective Lagrangian in terms of the low-energy degrees of freedom – the pseudoscalar mesons (π’s, K’s, η): Chiral Perturbation Theory (χPT) Partially Quenched (PQ) Lattice QCD Partially Quenched χPT Determining L PQ New PQ Operator’s Contributions to Meson Masses and Decay Constants Analytic NNLO Contributions to Meson Masses from L 6 Operators Analytic NNLO Contributions to Meson Masses from L 6 Operators ConclusionsConclusions χPT is a perturbative expansion in both and The O (p 2, m π 2 ) Lagrangian is: and the O (p 4, m π 4 ) (Gasser-Leutwyler) Lagrangian is: (Here a linearly-dependent operator was eliminated using SU(3) group relations) Lattice QCD allows calculation of these coefficients from first principles, if one can simulate with sufficiently light quarks A practical obstacle is the computational expense of lower sea- quark masses A cheaper alternative is to lower valence-quark masses at fixed moderately light sea-quark masses (the Partially Quenched Approximation) Although PQ QCD is unphysical, the properties of pseudoGoldstone mesons can be expressed in terms of the physical coefficients of the QCD chiral Lagrangian through next-to-leading order (NLO) in χPT 1,2 Here we show that this does not hold at next-to-next-to- leading order (NNLO) Partial quenching introduces unphysical bosonic ghost quarks 3 Therefore partial quenching changes the low-energy symmetry structure– the chiral symmetry group becomes a graded Lie Algebra with both commutation and anti- commutation relations: This operator contributes to unphysical scattering processes involving ghost quarks at NLO and affects meson masses and decay constants at NNLO To simplify calculations we considered only two valence quarks, A and B, and N sea quarks of equal mass The charged meson, π AB, receives NNLO corrections to its renormalized mass from the following loop diagram: It also receives NNLO corrections to its decay constant from the following diagrams, the first of which renormalizes the meson wavefunction, and the second of which modifies the axial current: All of these diagrams receive contributions from the following classes of quark diagrams, which illustrate the flow of quarks within the mesons: We determined the following corrections to the renormalized meson mass and decay constant due to the new operator (using dimensional regularization and MS): (Quark line diagrams show the effect of partial quenching – valence quarks appear only as external states because ghost quarks cancel them in loops ) Because of the graded group structure a new operator exists in L 4 : Like f π and L 1 to L 8, L PQ can be obtained by fitting to lattice experiments To illustrate this we calculated meson scattering processes that only receive contributions from double Supertrace operators in PQχPT, such as: L 1, L 2, and L PQ can, in principle, be separately determined by using amplitudes for three such processes in PQχPT and fitting them to lattice data This amplitude vanishes at LO The O (p 4 ) terms in the scattering amplitude are: = Fits of present PQ lattice data require NNLO terms 4,5 Full non-analytic NNLO calculation for PQ QCD is not available; however, as an intermediate step we have determined the form of the analytic NNLO terms Mesons get NNLO corrections to their masses from operators in L 6 from the diagram: O (p 6,m 6 ) Over a dozen O (p 6,m 6 ) operators contribute to this diagram, such as: Fits to PQ data with 1/3m S < m Sea < 2/3m S are consistent with this 4,5 We expect a similar expression to hold for f AB PQχPT can be used in conjunction with PQ Lattice QCD to determine the low-energy constants of real QCD However, partial quenching changes the chiral symmetry group, and introduces an new linearly-independent O (p 4 ) operator This operator adds corrections to the meson masses and decay constants at NNLO in PQχPT These corrections can be determined, in principle, by calculating appropriate scattering amplitudes In this way, the program of using unphysical PQ simulations to determine physical parameters could be extended to NNLO (Here “V” and “S” indicate valence and sea quarks in the loop meson) (Here mesons are written in the quark basis, not the usual generator basis) A convenient linear combination is one that vanishes in the unquenched SU(3) limit: [1] S. Sharpe and N. Shoresh, Phys. Rev. D 62, (2000). [2] S. Sharpe and N. Shoresh, Phys. Rev. D 64, (2001) [3] C.W. Bernard and M.F.L. Golterman, Phys. Rev. D 49, 486 (1994). [4] F. Farchoni et al, hep-lat/ [5] F. Farchoni et al, hep-lat/ ReferencesReferences χ is defined such that at lowest order χPT allows analytic calculations of low-energy QCD processes, but the results are in term of undetermined coefficients, f π and L 1 to L 8, which must be determined experimentally However, we found that only four linear combinations of quark masses appear in the NNLO tree-level correction to an AB meson’s mass: (Here α i are combinations of NNLO constants)