Bio-based electricity: How biomass resources can support renewable electricity policies Matt Kocoloski and Paulina Jaramillo Carnegie Mellon University.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Chuck Kutscher National Renewable Energy Laboratory
Advertisements

An Institute of Local and Global Consequence Future of Biofuels in Alabama Larry Fillmer Auburn University.
Co-firing Biomass with Coal for Power Generation Suthum Patumsawad Department of Mechanical Engineering King Mongkuts Institute of Technology North Bangkok.
Opportunities and Challenges for Small Scale Biomass Heat and Power Systems in Alabama Dave Gamble Green Energy Technologies.
Economics and Social Benefits Eric Dodd HICEC Manager.
Heating with Biomass Timothy A. Volk, SUNY ESF SUNY Global Center February 8, 2013.
Hybrid Community Bioenergy Solutions for Sustainable Rural Living Michèle Clarke University of Nottingham.
The Potential for CHP in the Northeast Provided by the Industrial Energy Consumers Group, 1/18/07 Source: Energy and Environmental Analysis, Inc.
Advanced Biomass-based Combined Heat and Power System Combined Heat & Power in the Pacific Northwest October 15, 2002 Nathan E. Carpenter Manager, Energy.
Alternative Energy Overview and Cofiring Biomass at Cogen Cogen Neighbor Meeting April 28, 2010.
Center for Clean Energy Research and Education Eastern Illinois University ADM Partnership Meeting1 8/26/2011.
Steven Jay Mueller, President International WoodFuels
NREL is a national laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy operated by the Alliance for Sustainable.
Achieving a sustainable energy balance for the U.S. current energy mix - 80% fossil fuel increasing renewables (wind, solar, tidal, geothermal, etc) increasing.
Comparative Regional Economic Advantages for Cellulosic Feedstocks for Bioenergy Production. Burton C. English.
W HAT ROLE FOR BIOMASS POWER IN A CLEAN ENERGY STANDARD ? Mary S. Booth, PhD Partnership for Policy Integrity April 2, 2011.
Should We Use Wood for Energy? An Introduction. Brief History: Energy in the U.S. Source: EIA, 2007.
BIOMASS Leann Baer Brooke Edwards Nisarg Joshi Josh Olzinski.
Alternative Energy : Biomass By: Araceli Gallegos.
Special Report on Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation IPCC WORKING GROUP 3.
Biomass, Biofuels and Hydrogen Sectors in Context of SEDS
Biomass Electricity Megan Ziolkowski November 29, 2009.
Biomass By: Christina, Angel, Kathleen, Yscilla, Jasmine.
Clean Cities / 1 EAST BAY CLEAN CITIES COALITION Ethanol Overview Richard Battersby Director, East Bay Clean Cities Coalition Date.
The power of using plant and animal waste to generate energy By Evan Schafer, Jacob Carrick, and Maggie Weaver Room 7.
Biomass Energy and its future in Wisconsin David Donovan Manager, Regulatory Policy David Donovan Manager, Regulatory Policy.
Biomass Qualification under the MA RPS Program and Status of the Biomass Notice of Inquiry Robert Sydney, General Counsel Massachusetts Division of Energy.
Biomass Power Adele Freeman David Clem David Leonard
Energy Resources Nonrenewable.
Resource Planning Georgia Power’s Diverse Plan to Meet Georgia’s Energy Needs AWMA Fall 2010 Conference October 7, 2010 Jeff Burleson Director of Resource.
Biofuels Now and Tomorrow Tom Williams National Renewable Energy Laboratory FLC Far West / Mid-Continent Meeting September 2005.
Results of Geothermal Power Survey of Electric G&T Cooperatives Robert Putnam, CH2M HILL Bob Gibson, NRECA Steve Lindenberg, Lindenberg Consulting.
Wood for Energy Experience of Coillte to date Presentation to the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Marine, Communications and Natural Resources George McCarthy.
Biomass Defined  Biomass is wood, plants, animal mass and other substances that have recently been alive. They are burned directly for heat or power or.
Bio-energy Initiatives and Collaboration in New Brunswick Climate Change Hub Advisory Committee Meeting February 5, 2009 By: Bryan Pelkey Department of.
IPM Overview Elliot Lieberman U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Washington, D.C
August 22, 2012 Energy Opportunities: Renewables.
Pennsylvania Biomass Energy Opportunities. Co-firing Biomass with Coal The opportunity to burn biomass with coal to produce electricity is better in PA.
ENERGY Success factors of bioenergy for CHG mitigation in Scandinavia Satu Helynen VTT Energy 1. Use of biomass based fuels in Europe 2. Role of forest.
Environmental Impacts of Alternative & Future Energy Sources - Overview 2008 AWMA Southern Section Annual Meeting & Tech. Conf. 05 AUG – 08 AUG 2008 R.
 Ninth APEC Energy Ministers Meeting (Fukui Japan, 19 June 2010:  “We remain committed to the 2009 Leaders' Declaration to rationalize and phase out.
Sci. 5-4 Energy Resources Pages
Forest Biomass Sustainability: Policy Themes & Research Needs Alan A. Lucier, Ph.D. Senior Vice President, NCASI FIA User Group Meeting & Biomass / Bioenergy.
Gary Radloff, Sheldon Du, Pam Porter and Troy Runge.
Energy and Products from Agricultural Biomass: Prospects and Issues F. Larry Leistritz Donald M. Senechal Nancy M. Hodur Presented at: IAIA 2007 Conference,
Greening the Energy Supply Monga Mehlwana Tuesady, 05 October 2010.
Directorate General for Energy and Transport Euroforenet Conference 20/11/2007 Brussels European Commission Kyriakos MANIATIS Biofuels & Industry DG TREN.
1 Closing the Biomass Power Cost-Price Gap B.R. Bock 3/5/04 Southern Bio-Products Conference Green Power Track Biloxi, MS.
Taking the Lead: State Innovations to Reduce Greenhouse Gases Bill Becker STAPPA/ALAPCO February 28, 2002.
Brian Keaveny Climate and Energy Analyst2014 CMAS Conference NESCAUM October 29, 2014.
Energy Resources A natural resource that can be converted by humans into other forms of energy in order to do useful work.
Future Power Generation in Georgia Georgia Climate Change Summit May 6, 2008 Danny Herrin, Manager Climate and Environmental Strategies Southern Company.
1 Cogeneration in the Forest Products Industry January 2008 by Phil Zirngibl.
Energy Resources Revision. Different types of energy.
Natural Gas. Coal Power Petroleum Nuclear power.
Energy Resources. What are Fossil Fuels? Fossil Fuels are energy rich substances formed from the remains of once living organisms. The 3 main fossil fuels.
What is a renewable energy? -Resource that can be replenished rapidly through natural processes as long as it is not used up faster than it is replaced.
Energy Efficiency = changing current devices so they 1) do more useful work 2) not converting into low-quality(heat) 84% of all commercial energy used.
Energy. Energy and you People of all ages use energy and have the opportunity to reduce their environmental impact through energy efficient behaviors.
Chapter 8 Energy Sources and the Environment
Earth’s Resources Chapter Sixteen: Natural Resources and Conservation 16.1 Natural Resources and Energy 16.2 Supplying Our Energy Needs 16.3 Resources.
SAF 3/3/09 1 Potential Biomass Demand Impact on Forest Markets and Resources Bob Abt NC State University
3SW – Quiz#1 Vocabulary – Energy Resources. 1. Non- Renewable An energy resource that takes __________________ of years to form from the remains of plants.
Biomass/Biofuel/Biogas
Integrated Food Security, Power Generation and Environmental Conservation Initiative BY AMALI ABRAHAM AMALI for the 2015 National Engineering Innovation.
Biofuels CENV 110. Topics The Technology Current status around the world – Supply and trends in production Impact Benefits Costs – Carbon balance – Net.
Biomass Power Generation : Recent Trends in Technology and Future Possibilities Narasimhan Santhanam Energy Alternatives India,
Effect of Biomass as Energy By Zachary Smith. Table of Content  Issue  Target Audience  How to collect Energy from Biomass  Direct Burning for Domestic.
IEA Bioenergy Task 38 Case Study on the Greenhouse Gas Budgets of Peat Use for Energy in Ireland Kenneth Byrne and Sari Lappi Forest Ecosystem Research.
Closing the Biomass Power Cost-Price Gap
Presentation transcript:

Bio-based electricity: How biomass resources can support renewable electricity policies Matt Kocoloski and Paulina Jaramillo Carnegie Mellon University Tepper School of Business RenewElec Workshop Presentation October 22, 2010

Overview Biomass may be used to generate low-carbon energy compared to fossil fuels Policies encourage use of biomass for both transportation fuel (RFS, LCFS) and electricity (RPS) Project will examine benefits of using different biomass feedstocks and conversion technologies to meet different types of electricity demands in order to inform renewable electricity policies 2

Feedstock Characterization Mtons of biomass ~ X million kWh

Feedstock Characterization 4 Switchgrass: perennial, low-input grass; potential energy crop Photo courtesy sciencedaily.com

Feedstock Characterization 5 Photo from Glassner (1998) Corn Stover: portion of plant remaining once crop has been harvested

Feedstock Characterization 6 Forest residues: generated by logging operations, timberland clearing, or thinning measures Photo from nrcs.gov

Feedstock Characterization 7 Photo from EIA Primary mill residues and municipal solid waste: wood wastes generated by industrial or urban operations

Feedstock Characterization 8 Feedstock Type CostPotential Supply Currently Available Alkali Content Feedstock Impurities SwitchgrassHigh NoHighNo Corn StoverMedium YesHighNo Forest Residues HighMediumYesLowNo Urban/Mill Residues Low YesLowYes/No

Conversion Options Cofiring biomass with coal –Biomass blended at low- levels with coal and used in current boilers –Limited capital costs, but limited potential (5 – 10% in regions with coal-fired capacity) 9 Figure from Morrow (2008)

Conversion Options Dedicated biomass combustion –Requires boiler replacement, but may be option for older coal plants to meet emissions regulations 10 Diagram from EERE

Conversion Options Biomass gasification –Biomass converted into syngas, which powers a gas turbine –High capital costs, but may be better suited to load- leveling and CCS 11 Diagram from Rhodes (2005)

Conversion Options 12 Conversion Technology Capital Cost Generation Potential Regional Limitations Adds Capacity Ramping/Load- Leveling Ability Cofiring with coal Low YesNoLow Dedicated combustion Medium YesNoLow GasificationHigh NoYesHigh

Research Questions 1.What types of electricity demand should be met using biomass? Should biomass be used primarily to meet base load demands, peak demands, or coupled with intermittent renewable technologies (such as solar and wind generation) to act as a load-leveler? 13

Research Questions 2.What technologies should be used to convert biomass into electricity? Should conversion to electricity be accomplished through cofiring biomass with coal, dedicated biomass gasification or combustion, or in a combined heat and power system? 14

Research Questions 3.How does uncertainty in biomass feedstock availability impact electricity generation options? How does regional variability in electricity generation infrastructure impact conversion options? 15

Summary Biomass may make a positive contribution to meeting environmental goals for electricity generation Interesting decisions regarding: –Feedstock type –Conversion technology –Electricity demand type Project intends to explore these interconnected decisions with the goal of informing renewable electricity policies 16