0 Linking Policy, Planning and Budgeting : Korean Experience and Challenges February 7, 2007 February 7, 2007 Kang Ho Lee

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Linkages Between NPoA and MTEF
Advertisements

Recent Public Expenditure Reforms in Korea June 6, 2005 June 6, 2005 Young Kon Chin Director General, Ministry of Planning and Budget Republic of Korea.
Introduction to Program Budgeting Katherine Barraclough Consultant, World Bank Fiscal Management Reform Workshop, Istanbul, Turkey, June 6-8, 2005.
Introduction to MTEF in Korea Doyoung Min The World Bank.
Fiscal Rules Eldad Shidlovsky, Head of Economics and Research Department. Ministry of Finance May 2009 Ministry of Finance.
The Medium Term Expenditure Framework
Lusaka, 1 December 2010 Public Expenditure Review Workshop.
Nowook Park Ohio State University & Korea Institute of Public Finance Asian Regional Seminar: Promoting Fiscal Sustainability February 28 – March 2, 2011,
Country Study: South Korea. Overview Until 20 th century, Korea existed as an independent country. In 1910, it became a colony of Japan After WWII, Republic.
September 25, 2006 Kim, Yong-Moon (President of the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs) Economic Growth and Poverty Reduction Strategies in.
Public Finance Reform in Slovakia Roland Clarke World Bank Ministry of Finance Slovak Republic September 6, 2005.
OECD experience on fiscal sustainability Joint OECD/WHO Meeting on Financial Sustainability of Health Systems Edwin Lau Deputy Head, Budgeting & Public.
Achieving the MDGs: RBA Training Workshop Module 8: Developing the MDG-based poverty reduction strategy 9-12 May 2005.
0 Linking Policy, Planning and Budgeting : Korean Experience and Challenges February 6, 2007 February 6, 2007 Kang Ho Lee
1 MINISTRY EDUCATION AND TRAINING PUBLIC EXPENDITURE In education Hµ Néi – 28 June 2006 NguyÔn V¨n Ng÷ Director Planning and Finance Department.
Dr Odysseas Michaelides Auditor General of the Republic June 2014 The role of the SAIs in times of economic crisis Audit Office of the Republic of Cyprus.
1 Budgeting in Greece Presentation at the annual meeting of Senior Budget Officials, Vienna, June 2008 Ian Hawkesworth, Budgeting and Public Expenditures.
The MTEF in Practice - Reconciling Conflicting Claims Malcolm Holmes.
Fiscal constraints and budgetary reform - implications for IT investment in public sector An External Perspective Fergal O’Brien Chief Economist, IBEC.
PEFA Performance Measurement Framework A Tool For Budget Reforms THE GEORGIA EXPERIENCE.
1 Session 1. Sequencing and Pacing of Performance Budgeting Reforms: Observations and Lessons from Korea Nowook Park Center for Performance Evaluation.
The Future of Public Services: International Trends Rolf Alter Director Public Governance and Territorial Development 1.
Warsaw, Poland May 17, 2010 Poland Social Sector and Public Wages Public Expenditure Review From Maastricht to Vision 2030 Overview.
Towards Greater Policy Coherence: Lessons from Mauritius Mr S. Puran Analyst Ministry of Finance Mauritius 27 OCT 2008.
Medium term expenditure frameworks and performance budgeting – Swedish experience OECD Paris, October 27-28, 2008 Thomas Küchen Ministry of Finance Sweden.
MKUKUTA/PER Consultations 2007 DPG session MKUKUTA/PEFAR 22 May.
STATE TREASORY DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY Ministry of Finance Republic of Croatia.
Donor financing and expenditure for PHC in Uganda Dr. Betty Kyaddondo Population Secretariat Uganda.
INDONESIA BUDGET REFORM (Priorities and Challenges) International Conference Budgeting for Performance-Modernizing PFM in Indonesia May , Hotel.
Medium Term Budgeting Ilonda Stepanova Director Budget Department Ministry of Finance April 8, 2008.
Comments on Introducing MTEF in Korea Youngsun Koh March 15, 2004 Korea Development Institute.
Korea’s Experience on Linking Planning and Budgeting May 23, 2005 Byung-Seo Yoo Ministry of Planning and Budget Republic of Korea During the Development.
Reading the Budget Review and determining the fiscal framework 22 February 2011 Presenter: Joan Stott | Director: Fiscal Analysis, Budget Office, National.
Economic Policy Committee The President Medium term expenditure frameworks and performance budgeting: Elements of the Quality of Public Finances Dr. Christian.
Addressing the Medium- and Long- run Challenges: the Overall Policy Framework Lyubomir Datzov Deputy Minister of Finance Republic of Bulgaria May 2007.
Comments on Agriculture/Rural Development in the IFAPER National Workshop 20 October 2003.
PDF-WORKING GROUP ON DECENTRALIZATION AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT.
Medium-Term Budgeting in Moldova Progress and Future Challenges February 2008.
Information Flow For MTEF Operation and its implication to the Korean Government March, 19, 2004 Seoul, Korea Junghun Cho World Bank.
Successful Installation of MTEF in the Korea’s Fiscal System Seok-Kyun Hur Korea Development Institute March 15, 2004.
Budgeting in Turkey Dirk-Jan KRAAN OECD Secretariat.
The Government Budget Process and the Role of the Swedish Fiscal Policy Council Lars Calmfors Chairman.
MTEF and links to annual budgets Osten Chulu Economist – UNDP Lesotho.
Collaborative Africa Budget Reform Seminar Budget Reform in Mauritius
REPUBLIC OF BULGARIA MINISTRY OF FINANCE CURRENT CHALLENGES IN BUDGET REFORM SOFIAMR. LYUBOMIR DATZOV 03 DECEMBER 2004DEPUTY MINISTER
Linking between Planning and Budget : Korea’s Experience and Lessons Dong Yeon Kim Ministry of Planning and Budget Republic of Korea For PRODEV, Inter-American.
Presenter:- Mrs. Josette Maxwell-Dalsou Chief Economist Economic Planning Ministry of Finance, Economic Affairs and National Development.
PUBLIC FINANCE IN THE REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA: REFORMS AND THE DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY PLENARY SESSION OF THE TREASURY COMMUNITY OF PRACTICE JUNE 1-3, 2015, KISHINEV,
1 Public Finance Management Reform The Georgian Experience 2008 ICGFM Winter Conference December, 2008.
REPUBLIKA SLOVENIJA MINISTRSTVO ZA FINANCE 1 PLANNING WAGE BILL EXPENDITURES Saša Jazbec, Director General / Budget Directorate Ministry of Finance Ljubljana,
1 ST APG FORUM ON LOCAL FINANCE MANAGEMENT 7-8 May 2015, Lombok, Republic of Indonesia Camila Vammalle Economist/Policy Analyst OECD, Public Budgeting.
Medium-Term Expenditure Planning
Introduction to Program Budgeting
Current Fiscal Policy and Expenditure Management in Korea
Medium Term Expenditure Planning for Sustainable Development.
Reform of the Public Financial Management System in Korea
Program budgeting in the Kyrgyz Republic
Medium-Term Expenditure Framework: Lessons
Public Finance and Economic Development
KNOWLEDGE PERSPECTIVE ON ECONOMIC POLICY IN EU ACCESSION COUNTRIES
IMF Spring Meetings April 2011 Public Financial Management
Progress in reforming budget elaboration process
Determining the fiscal framework
Local Expenditure and Local Fiscal Management System in Korea
Budget Sustainability Policies in the Republic of Belarus
DST CORPORATE STRATEGY: GOVERNMENT SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY SYSTEM
Making Budget Reform Matter for the Poverty Reduction
Challenging the Budget :- Creating incentives and driving for results
Gauteng Provincial Legislature Money Bills Act Discussion
MTEF Implementation in Korea Ministry of Planning and Budget
Presentation transcript:

0 Linking Policy, Planning and Budgeting : Korean Experience and Challenges February 7, 2007 February 7, 2007 Kang Ho Lee Director, Growth Strategy Division Ministry of Planning and Budget Republic of Korea

1 1. Background of Fiscal Reforms in Korea  Forecasting on additional spending in the future additional spending additional spending –Need extra resources, 1,100 trillion won for vision 2030 vision 2030vision 2030  Reallocation of expenditure between economic and social welfare resulted in aging and polarization problems Reallocation –social welfare as % of total expenditure : 9.9% (1980) → 25.2% (2005)  40.0% (2030) 9.9% (1980) → 25.2% (2005)  40.0% (2030) –% of the population over 65: 7.2% (2000)  14.4%(2019)  24.1%(2030)  Increasing national debts after 1997’s Korean financial crisis national debts national debts –% of GDP : 12.3(1997)  23.0(2003)  33.4(2006)  Need to enhance the efficiency in public spending

2 2. Framework of Major Fiscal Reforms Top-down Budgeting System Increased efficiency Enhanced linkage Operation Building an advanced Public Expenditure Management System National Fiscal Management Plan National Fiscal Management Plan Performance Management Legal Frame- work National Fiscal Act in 2006 Program Budget

3 Maintaining Growth Momentum Maintaining Growth Momentum Upgrading Human Resources Advanced Social Welfare System Advanced Social Welfare System New Social Capital New Social Capital All-out Globalization Overall Scheme Innovative, vibrant Economy Stable, posed Nation Stable, posed Nation Safe, equitable Society Safe, equitable Society Korea: New Stride of Hope for New Opportunities Institutional Reforms Proactive Investment Vision Action Plan Vision Goals Strategy Vehicles Overall Scheme of Vision 2030

ratio of budget Economy welfare The Change of Resource Allocation in Vision 2030 Increase of social welfare expenditure in the budget : 9.9% (1980)  25.2% (2005)  40.0% (2030) Decrease of economic spending in the budget : 26.0% (1980)  19.9% (2005)  10.0% (2030)

5 3. Linking Budget to Plans  Discordance of 2007 budget between ’06~’10 NFMP and’04~’08 NFMP –Difference of total expenditures : 1.8% –Difference of Revenue : 4.4% 3-1. NFMP(MTEP) (unit : trillion won) 2007 Budget in NFMPs ’04~’08(2004)’05~’09(2005)’06~’10(2006) Expenditure Revenue Managed fiscal balance (Ratio of GDP, %) National Debt (Ratio of GDP, %) GDP growth rate5%4.9%4.6%

Performance Management System  Establishment of an ex-post control system that reflects the performance in budgeting reflects the performance in budgeting –1/3 of budgetary programs are evaluated and reflected (unit : trillion won) ’06 (555 projects) ’07 (577 projects) budget Change to the previous year budget Total Effective Mod effective Adequate Ineffective

7  Program budget is a critical “building block” to link NFMP, Top-down budgeting, and PMS in a whole Process –For NFMP: provide program initiatives to represent medium-term national priorities represent medium-term national priorities –For Top-down Budgeting: provide the consultative bases to decide expenditure consultative bases to decide expenditure ceilings between line ministries and MPB ceilings between line ministries and MPB –For Performance Management System: provide the units to link resources and results provide the units to link resources and results 3-3. Program Budgeting Program Budget NFMP (MTEF) PMS Top- Down Budget

Top-down Budgeting(1) Budget Range Bottom-up : expenditure of program A goes to T, and spending of program B goes to T R Top-down : expenditures of program A and B go to 2 times ß  ̄

9  Basic Hypothesis –Cost function –Utility function of line ministry –Scale of budget –Net value –Total Value Theoretical background of Top-down budgeting(1) Theoretical background of Top-down budgeting(1)

10  Incentive compatibility(IC) and Individual rationality(IR)  Maximized condition  Optimized budget Theoretical background of Top-down budgeting(2) Theoretical background of Top-down budgeting(2)

Top-down Budgeting(2) Enhancing accountability of line ministries Actual case of Bottom-up → Top-down : Ministry of Maritime Affairs and Fishery

12  Low incentives from performance evaluation  Too focused on the adequate category (85% of 2007 budget)  Difference between evaluating year and reflecting year  Difficulties in building effective evaluation index 4. Challenges to Performance Management System(1)

13  Align the annual budget classification with the classification in the NFMP  Keep programs within the organizational structure  Combine all activities according to program objectives regardless of revenue sources  Simplify the grouping of object levels 4. Challenges to Program Budget (2)

14  Time constraint on the MTEF  How to meet expenditure ceilings  Mainly focused on the next year budget  Unit in setting expenditure ceilings : program or subsection program or subsection  How to harmonize the top-down budget and deliberation process 4. Challenges to MTEF and Top-down Budget (3)

15 Top-downBottom-up Ex) Behavior Changes in Requesting Budget from Line Ministries

16 Thank You