Teaching and evaluating interviewing technique in a specialty-based clinic structure poses unique challenges:Teaching and evaluating interviewing technique.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Feedback in Clinical Skills Session in Pre-clinical Years Dr. Steve Martin Island Medical Program.
Advertisements

Standards Definition of standards Types of standards Purposes of standards Characteristics of standards How to write a standard Alexandria University Faculty.
Self Study Orientation Community Living Burlington.
Comprehensive Organizational Health AssessmentMay 2012Butler Institute for Families Comprehensive Organizational Health Assessment Presented by: Robin.
HOUSTON EMPLOYEE ASSESSMENT AND REVIEW (HEAR) INTERIM APPLICATION ORIENTATION FOR TRAINERS & HEAR ADMINISTRATORS For more information, visit
Training Module for Cooperating Teachers and Supervising Faculty
Michigan Community Dental Clinics Quality Improvement with a Patient Centered Perspective August 5, 2014.
Project Monitoring Evaluation and Assessment
Historically, teaching on the Consultation-Liaison Psychiatry (CLP) Service was case-based. As a result, second year residents (R2s) were not systematically.
Family Resource Center Association January 2015 Quarterly Meeting.
“LEADS”: Leadership Enhancement And Development System.
Virtual Workbenches Richard Anthony Dept. Computer Science University of Greenwich Distributed Systems Operating Systems Networking.
Happy semester with best wishes from all nursing staff Dr Naiema Gaber
Preceptor Orientation For the Nurse Practitioner Program
Standards and Guidelines for Quality Assurance in the European
“Charting the Course Together” Implementing the Common Core State Standards -Mathematics- Middle School Leadership Teams February 6, 2014.
Looking at Student work to Improve Learning
Assessment Surveys July 22, 2004 Chancellor’s Meeting.
Foundation Modules (FOM 011, 013, 014) FOM Team.
Evidence Based Teaching Strategy: Applied to Student Orientation
Excellence in Clinical Teaching Your Name Here Your Organization.
Implementing Active Learning Strategies in a Large Class Setting Travis White, Pharm.D., Assistant Professor Kristy Lucas, Pharm.D., Professor Pharmacy.
Intending Trainers Course. 1. Communication and consultation skills – communication with patients, and the use of recognised consultation techniques 2.
Portfolio Assessment in Clerkship Michelle Gibson - Geriatrics (thanks to Chris Frank and Melissa Andrew too)
TEMPLATE DESIGN © Faculty Response to Development of an Innovative Consultation-Liaison Psychiatry Curriculum J Hunter,
Functional Behavior Assessments: Rationale, Tools, and Expectations.
Integrated Education – Improving the Team Whitfield A, Little A, Iro R, Gangopadhyay H, Charlesworth C. Eastern Health Intensive.
Standard 9 - Assessment of Candidate Competence Candidates preparing to serve as professional school personnel know and demonstrate the professional knowledge.
Background: As students complete their clerkships throughout their M3 year they gain in clinical experience and confidence, which may translate into improved.
THE DANIELSON FRAMEWORK. LEARNING TARGET I will be be able to identify to others the value of the classroom teacher, the Domains of the Danielson framework.
Teacher Evaluation and Professional Growth Program Module 4: Reflecting and Adjusting December 2013.
RPPS Education Development Process Debbie Bender.
D1.HRD.CL9.06 D1.HHR.CL8.07 D2.TRD.CL8.09 Slide 1.
RESULTS Survey Results 1. What is the utility of medications in the resolution of mental health problems? Anchors: 1 = “Detrimental”, 4 = “Neutral”, 7.
“R.I.M.E.” MODEL – A SYNTHETIC EVALUATION CONCEPT R eporter I nterpreter M anager- E ducator Pangaro LN. A new vocabulary and other innovations for improving.
Becoming a Skilled Mentor: Tools, Tips, and Training Vignettes Rebecca Pauly, M.D. Cecilia Lansang, M.D. Gwen Lombard, PhD. Gwen Lombard, PhD. *Luanne.
Academic Practicum Winter Academic Practicum Seminar2 Agenda 4 Welcome 4 Burning ??’s 4 Routines & Organizational Systems 4 Overview of Academic.
Professional Learning Resources Download presentations and resources from today’s sessions!  Go to BISD homepage  Departments  Professional Learning.
MEDICAL STUDENT TRANSITION COURSE Professionalism in the Clinical Environment ANTHONY A. MEYER, MD, PHD CHAIRMAN, DEPARTMENT OF SURGERY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH.
Bryan Touchet, M.D. Ashley Walker, M.D.. Describe how Team-Based Learning and online collaboration are integrated into a journal club seminar for residents.
Workplace Based Assessment for GP Specialist Trainees in hospitals: how well does it work? Abby Sabey, Senior Lecturer, UWE Michael Harris, Associate Postgraduate.
STACEY T. GRAY, MD PROGRAM DIRECTOR, HARVARD MEDICAL SCHOOL.
National DRS Patient Feedback Angela Ellingford 2010.
Assessing Learners The Teaching Center Department of Pediatrics UNC School of Medicine The Teaching Center.
Program Evaluation Making sure instruction works..
Time Efficient Clinical Teaching
Educational Outcomes Service Group: Overview of Year One Lynne Tomasa, PhD May 15, 2003.
ASSESSMENT and EVALUATION (seeing through the jargon and figuring out how to use the tools)
To Scribe or Not to Scribe: Effective Utilization of Scribes in a Family Medicine Residency Center John Gazewood, MD, MSPH; Rebekah Compton, RN, DNP, FNP-C;
360 DEGREE FEEDBACK: A NOVEL FORMAT FOR A PROGRAM EVALUATION COMMITTEE IN AN ACADEMIC EMERGENCY MEDICINE RESIDENCY PROGRAM Holly Caretta-Weyer, MD; Morgan.
Kristin DeJonge QUALITY & SAFETY COURSE Course Description  This two session course provides new graduate nurses with an overview of current quality.
The Workplace Learning Environment July BETTER TRAINING BETTER CARE Role of the Trainer.
Exploring Non-Physician Roles in Competency-Based Resident Education April 1, 2016 Nicole McGuire, Education Coordinator, Union Hospital FMR (Terre Haute,
Click to edit Master subtitle style Competence by Design (CBD) Foundations of Assessment.
Practice CSE-3: A Formative, Low Stakes Experience for Third Year Family Medicine Clerkship Students Jeri R. Reid, MD Donna M. Roberts, MD Mary B. Carter,
North Carolina Standard for School Executives Standard 1 By: Barbara Bumgardner Aleen Besmer James Westbrook Kristy Christenberry.
Jennifer Kusch, PhD Simon Griesbach, MD Before Rotation Introductory Essentials for Faculty (BRIEF): A Pilot Project in Collaboration with the Faculty.
Family Medicine Wants You! Techniques to Improve Medical Student Recruitment Natasha J. Pyzocha, DO Megan B. Mahowald, MD Douglas M. Maurer, DO, MPH, FAAFP.
Hamad Medical Corporation
Preceptor Orientation For the Nurse Practitioner Program
Where We Are and Where We Want to Be
Collaborative residency training in Kenya and Ethiopia
The FDA Early Feasibility Study Pilot and the Innovation Pathway
Evaluation and Assessment
Tejal Parikh, MD Paul Gordon, MD, MPH Frank A. Hale, PhD
Rank Ordered Items How do students, residents, and faculty define professionalism and rank order the items?
Advanced Nurse Practioners Physician Assistants
Addressing the challenges of preceptor development and recruitment
Planning and Designing Scenario-based Simulations
Presentation transcript:

Teaching and evaluating interviewing technique in a specialty-based clinic structure poses unique challenges:Teaching and evaluating interviewing technique in a specialty-based clinic structure poses unique challenges: Balancing trainee observation and corrective feedback with delivery of clinical care.Balancing trainee observation and corrective feedback with delivery of clinical care. Overcoming faculty and trainee discomfort with corrective feedback.Overcoming faculty and trainee discomfort with corrective feedback. Protecting time for immediate feedback.Protecting time for immediate feedback. To standardize expectations and evaluation of psychiatric interview technique across diagnosis-specific specialty clinics.To standardize expectations and evaluation of psychiatric interview technique across diagnosis-specific specialty clinics. To improve quality of formative feedback across varied specialty clinics.To improve quality of formative feedback across varied specialty clinics. To improve transparency of educational expectations by making methods of evaluating performance and competence available to trainees and faculty, alike.To improve transparency of educational expectations by making methods of evaluating performance and competence available to trainees and faculty, alike. BACKGROUND: PURPOSE DISCUSSION ASSESSMENT INTERVIEW STRUCTURED CLINICAL OBSERVATION: DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION IN A SPECIALTY-BASED TRAINEE CLINIC Tracy Foose, MD UCSF Department of Psychiatry METHODS RESULTS REFLECTIVE CRITIQUE Incorporating the use of video vignettes of a psychiatric interview into orientation to the AI-SCO would have helped to standardize expectations of interview structure and technique.Incorporating the use of video vignettes of a psychiatric interview into orientation to the AI-SCO would have helped to standardize expectations of interview structure and technique. Colleagues with expertise in education suggested descriptive rather than subjective anchors next to numerical ratings: i.e. replacing “done with suggestions for improvement” with “partially done,” given even superb interviewees can benefit from suggestions for improvement.Colleagues with expertise in education suggested descriptive rather than subjective anchors next to numerical ratings: i.e. replacing “done with suggestions for improvement” with “partially done,” given even superb interviewees can benefit from suggestions for improvement. Adding the AI-SCO to the intake screening packet provided to the interviewing teams prior to the interview has markedly improved participation.Adding the AI-SCO to the intake screening packet provided to the interviewing teams prior to the interview has markedly improved participation. The initiation of quarterly meetings attended by all specialty-based clinic attendings will provide an efficient and accessible forum for feedback about the AI-SCO and its utility in varied clinics.The initiation of quarterly meetings attended by all specialty-based clinic attendings will provide an efficient and accessible forum for feedback about the AI-SCO and its utility in varied clinics. The appreciable trend among the survey results reveals a willingness within the culture of our clinic, among both faculty and trainees, to consider using an observational tool as a means to facilitate, standardize, and improve direct-observation teaching.The appreciable trend among the survey results reveals a willingness within the culture of our clinic, among both faculty and trainees, to consider using an observational tool as a means to facilitate, standardize, and improve direct-observation teaching. Although evidence of a wariness toward “cookbook” or “checklist” teaching and feedback persists, the degree of initial qualitative success indicates potential for our clinic to embrace the SCO model.Although evidence of a wariness toward “cookbook” or “checklist” teaching and feedback persists, the degree of initial qualitative success indicates potential for our clinic to embrace the SCO model. The generalizability of the AI-SCO was informally demonstrated as trainees (residents) adopted it as an interview template and structured feedback tool for our rotating medical students, and several faculty endorsed its influence on their own interview technique.The generalizability of the AI-SCO was informally demonstrated as trainees (residents) adopted it as an interview template and structured feedback tool for our rotating medical students, and several faculty endorsed its influence on their own interview technique. The proportion of completed AI-SCOs to scheduled interviews reveals that they are being utilized in approximately 1/4 of interviews, about one time per month per team. It is our hope that frequent, repeated observations will give trainees opportunity to incorporate feedback toward mastery of the interview technique over the course of the year.The proportion of completed AI-SCOs to scheduled interviews reveals that they are being utilized in approximately 1/4 of interviews, about one time per month per team. It is our hope that frequent, repeated observations will give trainees opportunity to incorporate feedback toward mastery of the interview technique over the course of the year. Implementation of the AI-SCO was inexpensive and demanded little in time and resources from clinic staff, faculty, and trainees.Implementation of the AI-SCO was inexpensive and demanded little in time and resources from clinic staff, faculty, and trainees. This year, we move into the process of gathering data from the AI-SCO tool, having received 29 thus far: 0.88 per trainee/faculty pair/month.This year, we move into the process of gathering data from the AI-SCO tool, having received 29 thus far: 0.88 per trainee/faculty pair/month. We focus on the results of our initial implementation captured by response to an anonymous questionnaire provided subsequent to orientation to the AI-SCO tool.We focus on the results of our initial implementation captured by response to an anonymous questionnaire provided subsequent to orientation to the AI-SCO tool. Response to survey: 10/14 faculty supervisors, 6/14 residentsResponse to survey: 10/14 faculty supervisors, 6/14 residents Distribution of responses presented in modified Likert scale with question material provided in the table below.Distribution of responses presented in modified Likert scale with question material provided in the table below. Faculty and trainee comments are provided in caption.Faculty and trainee comments are provided in caption. The Assessment Interview Structured Clinical Observation (AI-SCO) was designed as a single-page tool serving as both interview template and a means by which to organize qualitative feedback during a structured clinical observation. (Copies of AI-SCO provided, please help yourself.)The Assessment Interview Structured Clinical Observation (AI-SCO) was designed as a single-page tool serving as both interview template and a means by which to organize qualitative feedback during a structured clinical observation. (Copies of AI-SCO provided, please help yourself.) Its format was based on a design familiar to our faculty and trainees – the Pharmacologic Interview Structured Clinical Observation, with the hope this would facilitate its acceptance into clinic structure and ease of use.Its format was based on a design familiar to our faculty and trainees – the Pharmacologic Interview Structured Clinical Observation, with the hope this would facilitate its acceptance into clinic structure and ease of use. Early development involved incorporating the collaborative suggestions, requests and feedback of experienced clinic faculty to create a tool that would capture the needs of a wide variety of specialty clinics.Early development involved incorporating the collaborative suggestions, requests and feedback of experienced clinic faculty to create a tool that would capture the needs of a wide variety of specialty clinics. Participating faculty and trainees received a 15-minute orientation to the background, goals, and intended application of the tool followed by an anonymous questionnaire to gather concerns, suggestions and initial impressions of the tool prior to its application.Participating faculty and trainees received a 15-minute orientation to the background, goals, and intended application of the tool followed by an anonymous questionnaire to gather concerns, suggestions and initial impressions of the tool prior to its application. “This doesn’t need to be done every week- gets burdensome.” “This doesn’t need to be done every week- gets burdensome.” “It should be structured so that more or less is expected depending on level of trainee.” “It should be structured so that more or less is expected depending on level of trainee.” “Too cookbook - a double-edged sword – directs attention to specific tasks, but doesn’t capture subtle dynamic between patient and doctor.” “Too cookbook - a double-edged sword – directs attention to specific tasks, but doesn’t capture subtle dynamic between patient and doctor.” Trainee Comments: : Faculty Comments: “One time per month should be sufficient.” “One time per month should be sufficient.” “This is too simplistic for residents, seems OK for medical students.” “This is too simplistic for residents, seems OK for medical students.” “Starting or ending on time shouldn’t be on here – that’s under the control of the highest ranking person present – not the trainee.” “Starting or ending on time shouldn’t be on here – that’s under the control of the highest ranking person present – not the trainee.”