Breast Cancer Surveillance Consortium: Progress in Understanding Screening Delivery and Early Detection Rachel Ballard-Barbash, MD, MPH, Associate Director,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Reducing Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care
Advertisements

Presentation Name Recruitment and Accrual of Special Populations Special Population Committee Elizabeth A. Patterson M.D., Chair.
Linking Actions for Unmet Needs in Children’s Health
UPenn Prevention Research Center’s CPCRN Collaborating Center University of Pennsylvania (UPenn) Prevention Research Center is a new PRC, Principal.
Capturing the impact of research Briony Rayfield.
Linking Multilevel Analysis to Health Policy Interventions Richard B. Warnecke, Sarah Gehlert, Carol Ferrans, Richard Barrett, Julie Darnell, Young Cho,
1 Ben George – Poet, Al Zantua & David Little Raven – Drummers.
Re-Engaging Dropouts: Local Innovations & New Opportunities for Federal Policy April 4, #aypfevents.
Capacity Task Force Virginia Health Reform Initiative January 14, 2011
The NIH Roadmap for Medical Research
Proposed Cross-center Project Survey of Federally Qualified Health Centers Vicky Taylor & Vicki Young.
GSU-NACDD-CDC Chronic Disease and Public Health Workforce Training Training Needs Survey and Public Health Certificate in Chronic Disease Training for.
TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER 7.0: Community Health Indicators Chart 7.1: U.S. Population Trends and Projections by Age, 1980 – 2050 Chart 7.2: U.S. Population.
Health Systems – Access to Care and Cultural Competency Tonetta Y. Scott, DrPH, MPH Florida Department of Health Office of Minority Health.
10/ Introduction to the MA Department of Children and Families’ Integrated Casework Practice Model (ICPM) Fall 2009.
Wishwa N. Kapoor, MD, MPH, Director Doris M. Rubio, PhD, Co-Director Multidisciplinary Clinical Research Scholars Program.
Recognition Of Team Science Faculty Appointments, Promotions and Titles at The Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth “Recognition by peers as an investigator.
1 Introduction to Grant Writing Beth Virnig, PhD Haitao Chu, MD, PhD University of Minnesota, School of Public Health December 11, 2013.
The NIDCR funded Collaborating Research Centers to Reduce Oral Health Disparities (CRCROHD) represent an innovative approach to understanding determinants.
1 Sex/Gender and Minority Inclusion in NIH Clinical Research What Investigators Need to Know! Presenter: Miriam F. Kelty, PhD, National Institute on Aging,
Implementing universal Lynch Syndrome screening in a large healthcare system.
Perspectives on Impact Evaluation Cairo, Egypt March 29 – April 2, 2009 Presented by: Wayne M. Harding. Ed.M., Ph.D., Director of Projects, Social Science.
CDC’s Preemie Act Activities Wanda Barfield, MD, MPH, FAAP Director, Division of Reproductive Health National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and.
Asthma Disparities – A Focused Examination of Race and Ethnicity on the Health of Massachusetts Residents Jean Zotter, JD Director, Asthma Prevention and.
Enhancing Community Capacity to Meet Environmental Health Needs in Rural Alaska Mary B. O’Connor, M.S., REHS – Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium,
Elizabeth A. Martinez, MD, MHS Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions September 10, 2008 Organization of Care and Outcomes in Cardiac Surgery AHRQ grant 1K08HS A1.
ACS MapPlace – Health Profile and Community Resources Mapping Project Carolina Casares, MD MPH Kenneth Portier, PhD.
A Proposal to Develop a Regulatory Science Program under Carleton University’s Regulatory Governance Initiative Presentation to the fourth Special Session.
Chapter 6 – Data Handling and EPR. Electronic Health Record Systems: Government Initiatives and Public/Private Partnerships EHR is systematic collection.
Alaska Native Tumor Registry Alaska Native Epidemiology Center 40-Year Trends in Cancer Incidence among Alaska Native People
CISNET and BCSC: Working Together To Model The Population Impact Breast Cancer Screening A Celebration of the Work of the Breast Cancer Surveillance Consortium.
1 Overview of CPCRN and Recent Accomplishments Kurt M. Ribisl, PhD University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill CPCRN Coordinating Center CPCRN Dialogue.
CLINICAL PREVENTIVE SERVICES Chartbook on Healthy Living.
California Stroke Registry Right Care Initiative Meeting August 13, 2012.
Breast Cancer Surveillance Consortium (BCSC): Impact of the BCSC What is left to be done Stephen Taplin, MD, MPH, Senior Scientist NCI/DCCPS/ARP BCSC Program.
University of Iowa Cancer Prevention and Control Research Network Sue Curry, Ph.D., Principal Investigator This presentation was supported by Cooperative.
State and Regional Approaches to Improving Access to Services for Children and Youths with Epilepsy Technical Assistance Conference Call Sadie Silcott,
Belinda Seto, Ph.D. Acting Deputy Director for Extramural Research National Institutes of Health Human Subjects Research Enhancements Awards Renaissance.
Data Sources-Cancer Betsy A. Kohler, MPH, CTR Director, Cancer Epidemiology Services New Jersey Department of Health and Senior Services.
Strategic Plan Strategic Goals (Thrusts) 1. Achieve Performance Excellence CRJ uses metrics of performance to evaluate, manage and plan its.
An Integrated Approach to Breast Cancer Control A flexible approach that can be adapted to national or local circumstances.
FAVOR F actors A ssociated with V ariability O f R adiologists (2000 to present) Supported by grants from the National Cancer Institute (R01 CA ;
Building Sustainable Community-Linked Infrastructure to Enable Health Science Research (RC4) RFA OD Pre-application workshop October 23, 2009.
Why a CPCRN? CDC Expectations Katherine M. Wilson, PhD, MPH CPCRN Technical Monitor Division of Cancer Prevention and Control CDC.
Measuring and Improving Radiologists’ Interpretative Performance on Screening Mammography Karla Kerlikowske, MD Diana Buist, PhD Patricia Carney, PhD Berta.
Indian Health Service April 18, Background information Government-to-government relationship between the federal government and the Indian tribes.
Judy S Caines, MD FRCP Gerald H Schaller, MD FRCP Jennifer I Payne, PhD Dolon Chakravartty, MHSc GIS as a Tool to Evaluate Breast Screening International.
The HMO Research Network (HMORN) is a well established alliance of 18 research departments in the United States and Israel. Since 1994, the HMORN has conducted.
Joni Reynolds, RN-CNS, MSN Director of Public Health Programs Winnable Battles: Cancer in Colorado.
Ryan White All Grantees Meeting Washington, DC November, 2012 Supporting National HIV/AIDS Strategies: the domestic experience and the AETCs.
Incorporating Multiple Evidence Sources for the Assessment of Breast Cancer Policies and Practices J. Jackson-Thompson, Gentry White, Missouri Cancer Registry,
11 The CPCRN, DCPC, NCI, and the Community Guide: Areas for Collaboration and Supportive Work Shawna L. Mercer, MSc, PhD Director The Guide to Community.
Breast Cancer Surveillance Consortium (BCSC): sponsored by the National Cancer Institute Cancer Screening Surveillance in Clinical Practice Tracy Onega,
Reducing Health Disparities Through Research & Translation Programs Francis D. Chesley, Jr., M.D. Francis D. Chesley, Jr., M.D. Director, Office of Extramural.
HRSA Health Disparities Collaboratives 2006: Perinatal & Patient Safety Pilot Ada Determan, M.P.H Division of Clinical Quality Bureau of Primary Health.
Wishwa N. Kapoor, MD, MPH, Director Doris M. Rubio, PhD, Co-Director Multidisciplinary Clinical Research Scholars Program.
Why Write A Grant? Elaine M. Hylek, MD, MPH Professor of Medicine Associate Director, Education and Training Division BU CTSI Section of General Internal.
University of Kentucky Center for Clinical and Translational Science (CCTS) November 2015 Stephen W. Wyatt, DMD, MPH Senior Associate Director Center for.
Healthy People 2010 Focus Area 3 Cancer Progress Review October 16, 2002.
The Cancer Registry of Norway Jan F Nygård Head of the IT-department.
TCE Clinic Consortia Policy and Advocacy Evaluation Clinic Consortia Policy Advocacy: Increased Clinic Financial Stability or Follow the Money Annette.
Comparative Effectiveness Research (CER) and Patient- Centered Outcomes Research (PCOR) Presentation Developed for the Academy of Managed Care Pharmacy.
National Institutes of Health U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Planning for a Team Science Evaluation ∞ NIEHS: Children’s Health Exposure Analysis.
NIH R03 Program Review Ning Jackie Zhang, MD, PhD, MPH College of Health and Public Affairs 04/17/2013.
National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS) Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Educator Equity Resource Tool: Using Comprehensive Equity Indicators
National Cancer Center
Center for Outcomes and Effectiveness Research Education
Using Large Databases for Research
Presentation transcript:

Breast Cancer Surveillance Consortium: Progress in Understanding Screening Delivery and Early Detection Rachel Ballard-Barbash, MD, MPH, Associate Director, NCI/DCCPS/ARP National Cancer Institute

Establishing the Breast Cancer Surveillance Consortium  Origins and Purpose of the BCSC and SCC  Complexities of creating the Consortium  Resource for research  Research Evidence  Key factors for success  Challenges and opportunities remain

Establishing the BCSC and SCC  In the beginning, much was unknown  No community measures of mammography quality and no source of national data  Limited experience collecting data in the course of care – required protection for providers as research subjects  Many challenges to establishing the BCSC  Shifted from independent RO1 to coordinated pooled data, mapping to CDE, new statistical methods for complex data  Moved from paper to electronic data capture in early years  Field of delivery research in practice was new and many of the Principal Investigators were new researchers

Scenes from the Beginning A Daunting Task Editor Extraordinaire IBSN meeting Safety First

Breast Cancer Legislation and Funding  The BCSC began as mammography screening was increasing  1990, CDC’s National Breast and Cervical Early Detection Program  1991, Department of Defense Breast Cancer Research Program  1991, NIH launches Women's Health Initiative  Mammography Quality Standards Act of 1992 (MQSA) mandated NCI to develop a breast cancer screening surveillance system  NCI Response  Pilot studies in SEER registries supported development of 1993 RFA  Expanded with 1994 RFA (new sites and Statistical Coordinating Center) to address racial/ethnic, geographic, and health system diversity in screening  BCSC renewed in 2000 and 2005

BCSC Purpose  Evaluate performance of mammography screening in practice  Individual, health professional and system level factors  Increase capacity to examine provider and system factors  Define biologic characteristics of cancers that influence detection  Quantify population effect of screening  Longer term survival and mortality  Track new technologies in screening  Imaging, tissue, molecular markers, proteomics

BCSC Structure Cancer Multiple Research Uses Radiology Facilities Geographic Site Pathology Facilities Cancer Registry

BCSC Sites

BCSC Local Facilities (N=164)

Demographics of Women 7,335,521 mammograms from AgeBCSC - N (%)US population 2008 – N (%) ,294 (4.3%)11,387,968 (16%) ,164,444 (29.%)21,515,659 (30%) ,208,148 (30.1%)15,938,332 (22%) ,465,980 (20%)10,802,003 (15%) ,472 (13%)9,134,000 (13%) ,183 (3%)3,110,470 (4%) Race/Ethnicity BCSC - N (%)US population 2008 – N (%) White, non-Hispanic5,218,642 (71%)57,167,145 (71%) African American, non-Hispanic424,840 (5.8%)9,460,539 (11.8%) Asian, non-Hispanic453,569 (6.2%)3,637,776 (4.5%) Hispanic636,119 (8.7%)8,716,664 (10.4%) Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander3,073 (< 1%)114,817 (< 1%) American Indian or Alaska Native92,044 (1.3%)653,440 (1%) Mixed (Two or more)54,974 (0.7%) 766,436 (1%) Other31,872 (0.4%)n/a Unknown420,388 (5.7%)n/a

Cumulative Number of Mammograms by Submission Year

Cumulative Number of Cancer Cases by Submission Year

Core Pooled BCSC Data: Women & Physician Level Variables & Outcomes Self-administered questionnaire Direct data entry or questionnaire Annual linkage WomenRadiologists Tumor registry & Pathology lab

BCSC as a Research Resource  Since 1994, BCSC collected data on a cohort of over 2 million women  8,374,024 million mammograms (2,323,252 unique women)  86,700 breast cancers (65,313 invasive and 13,263 In Situ)  Screening data linked to Medicare data  107 radiology facilities and 1300 radiologists  Collective insight of BCSC PIs about breast cancer risk factors, screening, and related outcomes  Data complexity  Statistical methods  Research utilizing the core BCSC data focuses on delivery, performance and quality of care

Uses of Pooled BCSC Research Resources  Research and modeling  Data source for simulation models (CISNET)  Investigators have collaboratively published 374 papers  Engaged new and junior investigators  36 publications by junior investigators (2005-8) – most non-BCSC  Three career development awards  Enabled new grants  Supported the generation of more than 65 research grants from many agencies – many investigators from outside the BCSC  New data linkages – BCSC-Medicare linked data

Selected Ancillary Studies  Assessing and Improving Mammography (AIM)  Assesses accuracy of interpretation of mammograms  Develops tools and guidance for training of radiologists  Co-funded by ACS (Longaberger funds) and NCI (Breast Cancer Stamp )  Factors Affecting Variability Of Radiologists (FAVOR)  R01 utilizing BCSC data to study the variability in radiologists in community mammography settings (PI Joann Elmore)  Comparative Effectiveness Research  Comparative Effectiveness of Breast Imaging Strategies in Community Practice – GO Grant (ARRA funds, PI Diana Miglioretti)  Collaboration to evaluate digital vs. film-screen mammography – BCSC- CISNET-EPC (ARRA funds, PI Diana Miglioretti)

Use of BCSC Research Evidence  Delivery research generates questions for discovery and development research  Within the BCSC, special research projects at individual sites used for discovery and development questions  Address targeted translation issues Eg: Develop quantitative, automated method for measurement of breast density  Individuals sought as members of panels related to breast cancer on a diversity of topics (IOM, ACR)  Contributed evidence to federal reports and policy  IOM, GAO, WHO

Factors for Success  Team Science approach, utilized variety of disciplines within each site  A secure, centralized resource, shared by many  Incorporation of collecting patient data for research purposes into clinical care practice  Anticipate and understand the complexities of building a longitudinal dataset  Creating new ways to provide feedback on performance

Challenges Remain…  Delivery, performance and quality of care is dynamic – need ongoing data reflecting current clinical practice  Requires prospective, longitudinal data  Evaluate longer term outcomes beyond process measures  Large, multiregional data to answer questions in specific groups  Growth in investigator-initiated research utilizing the BCSC research resource indicates an enormous potential for addressing questions in delivery beyond the current scope  Comparative effectiveness of digital and screen-film  Innovative template for the future