Bahar Mehmani 3 September 2015 Reviewer Recognition Program Elsevier and Innovations in Peer Review

 Reviewer Page  Publishing Peer Review Report  Cross-Review

Reviewer Page

| 5

| 6 My Elsevier Reviews Profile Advisors: Prof. Dr. Lutz Prechelt Dr. Simon Gosling Objective Make peer review a measurable research output Current Status +400K review profiles +700 Elsevier Journals Thousands of Volunteers

| 8

| 9

| 10

| 11 Create your Reviewer Page

Publishing Peer Review Reports

Only Peer Reviews of Published articles Only those approved by the Editor Reviewer's consent to reveal his/her name How?

Peer review reports as articles on Science Direct

Freely available Interlinked to the article Separate DOI Typeset

Survey Results

Cross-Review

| 18 Once all review reports on a manuscript are submitted, handling editor can choose to invite reviewers for a discussion. This approach has proven to be very efficient mostly in the case of conflicting review reports. What is Cross-Review? Editor invites reviewers to a forum where all review reports are anonymized. Editor moderate s the discussion and reviewers can comment on each others report. Editor informs author about the summary of the discussion and the final decision. Reviewers get notificatio n about the final decision.

Thank you!

| 20 Elsevier Reviewer Recognition Platform s are sent to reviewers after review with link to personal profile page

Annals of Medicine and Surgery International Journal of Surgery Engineering Fracture Mechanics Journal of Hydrology Agricultural and Forest Meteorology Publishing peer review reports for 5 journals Publishing Peer Review Reports on Science Direct