Primary and Secondary Sources
“the leavings, the shards, the remnants of people who once lived and don't live any more." A definition of a Primary Source http://www.lib.washington.edu/subject/history/historyday/his.html
What is going on in this photo? What questions does it raise? This is a photo of a family funeral in North Dakota in the 1890s. I talk about what I was curious about when I look at this photo. First question that occurs to me – Who is in the casket? How did that child die? Epidemic? Starvation? Wolves? Then, who is in this family? Why so many kids? How isolated is the family? What is going on in this photo? What questions does it raise?
Why do we use primary sources in history? No bias, no viewpoint Only your interpretation Can give additional information Materials Textures Printing methods Technologies
What is a Primary Source? An informational source from the time of the event Autobiographies Diaries Documents Eyewitness accounts Film footage Laws Letters Newspaper articles Novels Objects from the time Oral histories Photographs Poems, art, music Speeches
Does a Primary Source have to be the original material? No – it can be in another form, but it can’t be edited or interpreted in any way. For example, Patrick Henry’s “Give Me Liberty or Give Me Death!” speech can be found in 100 Key Documents in American History
Why Use Primary Sources in the Classroom? Expose Students to Multiple Perspectives Develop knowledge, skills,and analytical abilities Bring lessons to life Motivate students More interesting for you and your students
Questions to ask yourself when looking at Primary Sources Who wrote this? How do they know the information they are telling me? When did they write it? Why did they write it? Who did they write it for?
What are Secondary Sources? An informational source that analyzes the event. These sources often use several primary sources to compile the information. Biographies Encyclopedias History books Textbooks
Are Secondary Sources useful for Lessons? Yes – They provide the necessary background or context to be able to interpret Primary Sources For example, World Book 2005 or your Social Studies textbook can provide background information about the events leading up to Revolutionary War.
Is it possible for a Secondary Source to be completely objective? Beware of Bias! Is it possible for a Secondary Source to be completely objective?
Wikipedia’s entry on President Bush The following passage describes his National Guard service: In May 1968, at the height of the Vietnam War, he entered the Texas Air National Guard. He trained in the guard for two years, where he was among the last to learn to fly the F-102, a plane not used in Vietnam and due to be retired. While this could be true, why would it be important to know that he was “among the last to learn to fly the F-102”? Is this a commentary on President Bush flying an outdated plane? Is it an unbiased point of view?
Encarta’s entry on President Bush (note that Encarta lets people edit its pages but with editor approval) Upon completing college, [Bush] became eligible for the military draft. To meet his service obligation, Bush enlisted in the Texas Air National Guard in 1968. He told the admitting officer that he wanted to become a pilot like his father, who was a highly decorated Navy flier in World War II. He did his basic training at Lackland Air Force Base in Texas, and entered a pilot-training program at Moody Air Force Base Georgia. He received favorable reports from his superiors, attained the rank of second lieutenant, and was certified to fly the F-102 jet fighter during training missions in the South and along the Gulf Coast. Encarta doesn’t mention that President Bush being one of the last to fly the F-102, and instead notes patriotically how President Bush wanted to fly a jet like his father.
Where to Find Primary Sources Online Library of Congress American Memory Collection
Where to Find Primary Sources Online National Archives and Records Administration
Where to Find Primary Sources Online Eyewitness: History Through the Lives of Those Who Lived It
Where to Find Primary Sources Online Primary Sources on the Web
Where to Find Primary Sources Online Early America
Where to Find Primary Sources Online History and Politics Out Loud
Where to Find Primary Sources Online Vincent Voice Library
Where to Find Primary Sources Online History Channel Speech Archive
Where to Find Primary Sources Online New York Public Library Digital Library Collection
Where to Find Primary Sources Online Newspaper Archive
Where to Find Primary Sources Offline Teacher Created Materials Primary Sources Kits
Where to Find Primary Sources Offline Metropolitan Museum of Art Resources for Educators
Where to Find Primary Sources Offline Antiques Fairs and Dealers Photographic Reproductions http://www.historicfotos.com/main.html Palmer Wirfs Antiques and Collectibles Fairs http://www.palmerwirfs.com/
Where to Find Primary Sources Offline Books
Copyright and Primary Sources Educational Use Allowed Check Copyright on Websites
How to Use Primary Sources in the Classroom Analyzing Documents and Photos Time to observe Put yourself in the time Cover part of photo Ask questions Notice details
How to Use Primary Sources in the Classroom Discussion Questions Higher Order Thinking Skills
Sample Questions Who was the author? What might the purpose of this document have been? If you were at the scene, what might you report? Does this picture or document accurately portray these people? Where might this document or photo be found today?
Activities Problem Solving Cooperative Groups Assessment
Creating Your Own Primary Sources with Students Journals Interviews Newspapers Websites Photos Software FlipAlbum
Final Thoughts Start small. Keep it simple. Think outside the box. Have fun!