Wei Pan PubH 8403 Presentation Manuscript Submission and Review: My Views and Stories as an Author.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

How to get published (in EJHG)?. Questions to ask Is your paper within the scope? Does the journal reach an appropriate audience? How easy is electronic.

Advertisements

Choosing a Journal APS Professional Skills Course: Writing and Reviewing for Scientific Journals.

AUTHORSHIP SKILLS: QUESTIONS SCIENTISTS FREQUENTLY ASK ABOUT THE WRITING AND PUBLISHING OF JOURNAL ARTICLES.

How to write my paper and have it published in a computational biology journal? Phil Bourne University of California San Diego

Genetic epidemiology (GE) Claire Infante-Rivard MD, PhD Professor

Duplicate Submission: Journal Roles and Responsibilities Diane M. Sullenberger Executive Editor, PNAS.

Approaches to Publish rather than Perish: Some Lessons from the School of Hard Knocks Dr. John Loomis, Professor Dept. of Ag & Resource Economics Colorado.

Maximizing Your Success at Asia Pacific Journal of Management ChungMing Lau The Chinese University of Hong Kong Editor, Asia Pacific Journal of Management.

Preparing for Submission or Avoiding the desk reject! Allan Macpherson.

MedEdPORTAL Providing Online Resources To Advance Learning Grace Huang, MD Director of Assessment Reynolds R, Candler C, MedEdPORTAL.

How to choose a journal and submit a manuscript Papa Salif Sow.

How does the process work? Submissions in 2007 (n=13,043) Perspectives.

Experiences from Editing a Journal: Case EJOR Jyrki Wallenius Helsinki School of Economics EJOR Editor Outgoing Editor till June 30, 2005 EJOR.

ALEC 604: Writing for Professional Publication Week 11: Addressing Reviews/Revisions.

How to get published in the NGWA publications Groundwater and Groundwater Monitoring & Remediation.

Partially Missing At Random and Ignorable Inferences for Parameter Subsets with Missing Data Roderick Little Rennes

Publishing Research Papers Charles E. Dunlap, Ph.D. U.S. Civilian Research & Development Foundation Arlington, Virginia

Publishing Your Work Jennifer L. West, Ph.D. Cameron Professor of Bioengineering and Director, Institute of Biosciences and Bioengineering, Rice University.

Selection of a journal for the manuscript Kıymet Kübra YURT, PhD Student Department of Histology and Embryology Medical School Ondokuz Mayıs University.

Tips for writing well and getting your work published Madhukar Pai, MD, PhD McGill University, Montreal Editorial board member: Lancet Infect Dis PLoS.

Passive vs. Active voice Carolyn Brown Taller especializado de inglés científico para publicaciones académicas D.F., México de junio de 2013 SELECTING.

Dr. Dinesh Kumar Assistant Professor Department of ENT, GMC Amritsar.

How to Get Research Published in Journals Rafael Ibarra.

Title Name Institute. Background -1 (Main problem)

Ginny Smith Managing Editor: Planning and Urban Studies Taylor & Francis Ltd.

Publishing in journals Nick Sangster Faculty of Veterinary Science.

Nature Publishing Group Quality, Impact & Vision 1 Presented by Managing Editor, Professor Roger K Butlin and Publishing Manager, Rebecca Vickerstaff

PLoS Enlivening Scientific Culture Dr Chris Surridge Managing Editor, PLoS ONE Public Library of Science.

Ian White Publisher, Journals (Education) Routledge/Taylor & Francis

Georgia Institute of Technology Publish or Perish Gilda Barabino, Ph.D. Vice Provost for Academic Diversity Professor and Associate Chair for Graduate.

GEE Approach Presented by Jianghu Dong Instructor: Professor Keumhee Chough (K.C.) Carrière.

Testing the Impact Toolkit Anne Weist Staff Development Manager 22 October 2008.

Reviewing Papers© Dr. Ayman Abdel-Hamid, CS5014, Fall CS5014 Research Methods in CS Dr. Ayman Abdel-Hamid Computer Science Department Virginia Tech.

How to Satisfy Reviewer B and Other Thoughts on the Publication Process: Reviewers’ Perspectives Don Roy Past Editor, Marketing Management Journal.

Meet the Editors SMA 2007 Marla B. Royne, Editor The University of Memphis Eric Haley, Associate Editor The University of Tennessee Susan Myers, Editorial.

FEMS Microbiology Ecology Getting Your Work Published Telling a Compelling Story Working with Editors and Reviewers Jim Prosser Chief Editor FEMS Microbiology.

Medical Writing How to get funded and published November 2003.

Jim Neaton PubH 8403 Presentation. Perspective of an Editor: How it Works Controlled Clinical Trials (now Clinical Trials) –25 Associate Editors; a Book.

Approach to Research Papers Pardis Esmaeili, B.S. Valcour Lab Mentoring Toolbox Valcour Lab Mentoring Toolbox2015.

Copernicus Gesellschaft © Copernicus Gesellschaft The Two-Stage Publication Process for Journals published by Copernicus Gesellschaft Foster scientific.

Scientific Peer Review Yixin Chen, Associate Professor Computer & Information Science University of Mississippi April 9, 2013.

Journal of the International AIDS Society To do and not to do in manuscript submission Manuscript submission Adapted slides courtesy.

Editorial decision making and common reasons for rejection Shirin Heidari.

ACADEMIC PUBLISHING How a manuscript becomes an article.

Dr Karen Smith Educational Development Unit. We will (briefly) cover:  the mechanics of getting published in journals  how to choose the right journal.

Writing scientific papers and publishing your research 1) Writing a paper helps you identify missing information 2) Helps develop new ideas 3) Documents.

Jim Neaton PubH 8400 December 12, Perspective of an Editor: How it Works Controlled Clinical Trials (now Clinical Trials) –25 Associate Editors;

HOW TO PUBLISH Nancy E. Hill, Ph.D. Professor Harvard Graduate School of Education Past Editorships: Associate Editor, Child Development Editorial Board.

Being a journal editor: scholar or secretary? Liz Todd Co-editor of International Journal of Research and Method in Education

1 Getting published University College London February 2009 Robert West.

BD2K Efforts in Pitt Biostatistics! Jong H. Jeong, Interim Chair

Writing for Publication

Manuscript Submission and Review: Perspective of an Editor and Author

Ethics course seminar 1 Group 5

Experimental Psychology

International Journal Publication: the Editorial Perspective

GETTING PUBLISHED IN URBAN LIBRARY JOURNAL

Publishing a paper.

The peer review process

Dr Carol Hawley, Dr Tom deBurgh, Colonel Robert Russell, Andrew Mead

PhD candidate in (desperate) need to publish faces biased request from journal The researcher is working with a hypothesis rather different from “accepted.

IEEE Transactions on Evolutionary Computation Status Report

Associate Editors papers per year

Machine Learning Course.

Writing for Publication

Getting published Frances Gardner.

Writing scientific papers and publishing your research

Scholarly Writing: Term Papers to Publication

MANUSCRIPT WRITING TIPS, TRICKS, & INFORMATION Madison Hedrick, MA

Presentation transcript:

Wei Pan PubH 8403 Presentation Manuscript Submission and Review: My Views and Stories as an Author

How to Choose A Journal Why to publish? -- to disseminate your results -- to advance your career Factors –Journal reputation, impact factor –Readerships –Review time, open access, publishers etc –A practical approach: where are the references published?

Some Journals Example, but not complete, list; debatable –Top Stat methods/theory journals: JASA, JRSS-B, Biometrika, Ann Statist –Top Biostat or applied stat journals: Biometrics, JASA (Case Studies), JRSS-C (Applied Statistics), Ann Applied Statist, (Controlled) Clinical Trials, … –More specialized Stat journals: JCGS, SADM, JBES, BA, … –Top Machine Learning Journal: JMLR –Bioinformatics and Stat Genetics journals: Nature Genetics, AJHG, Bioinformatics, Genetic Epidemiology, …

Personal stories My first (and only one) in Comm Statist: Pan and Chappell (1998); EMS (EM + Smoothing) algorithm ~ a penalized/regularized method; My first (and only one ) in Controlled Clinical Trials: Pan (2001); sample size calculations for GEE; the editor at the time? My first in Biometrika: Pan (2001); a small-sample size adjustment in GEE; needed a theory. My QIC paper in Biometrics: Pan (2001); model selection in GEE; my most highly cited paper; implemented in SAS Genmod and other packages.

More stories My first in Bioinformatics: Pan (2002), stat analysis of microarray data; barely got published; now my 2 nd most highly cited. My first in Genetic Epi: Pan (2009); testing H0: b1=b2=…=bk in a GLM: g(u)=b0+X1*b1+X2*b2+…+Xk*bk; X1,…, Xk are correlated; use the Wald (or Score or LR) test? Surprises: in forming a test stat, 1) incorrect assuming b1=b2=…=bk; 2) incorrectly ignoring the correlations among the estimates of b’s;

Finally Of course I have bad ones: rejected after 1 or 2 revisions (after 2 or 3 years); some comments are not nice; … Most important: don’t give up! Do what you are interested in. I look forward to hearing your own stories, hopefully successful ones…