Investigating Surface Loss in Fused Silica Steve Penn, Andri Gretarrson, Gregg Harry (MIT), Scott Kittelberger, Peter Saulson, Joshua Smith Syracuse University.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Investigation on annealing effect in a Suprasil sample and loss measurements in silicon samples 4° ILIAS-GWA Annual Meeting - Tubingen (D), October 8-9,
Advertisements

1 News in the thermo-mechanical measurement in the Firenze facility Gianpietro Cagnoli a,b), Enrico Campagna a,c), Elisabetta Cesarini a), Matteo Lorenzini.
2 mm diameter region 300 micron thermoelastic noise cancellation section Neck region, for transition from 2 mm stock to 300  m fibre 150  m section for.
Nawrodt 10/07 #1/21 R. Nawrodt, A. Schröter, C. Schwarz, D. Heinert, M. Hudl, W. Vodel, A. Tünnermann, P. Seidel STREGA Meeting Tübingen 10/
G R LIGO Laboratory1 Advanced LIGO Research and Development David Shoemaker LHO LSC 11 November 2003.
Low Mechanical Dissipation in Fused Silica S. D. Penn, G. M. Harry, A. M. Gretarsson, S. E. Kittleberger, P. R. Saulson, J. J. Schiller, J. R. Smith, S.
Currently: 3 year ( ) NSF-supported UF/IAP collaborative project "Methods and Instruments for High-Precision Characterization of LIGO Optical Components"
Nonstationary electrical charge distribution on the fused silica bifilar pendulum and its effect on the mechanical Q-factor V.P. Mitrofanov, L.G. Prokhorov,
LIGO-G W Status of LIGO Installation and Commissioning Frederick J. Raab, LIGO Hanford Observatory.
Fused Silica Research for Advanced LIGO Alexander Ageev, Gregg Harry, Jim Hough, Steve Penn, Sheila Rowan, Phil Willems.
Dublin/July'04 1 BLTS interferometers: Big, Low-temperature Transparent Silicon Interferometers Warren Johnson Louisiana State University LIGO-G Z.
Nawrodt 05/2010 Thermal noise in the monolithic final stage Ronny Nawrodt Matt Abernathy, Nicola Beveridge, Alan Cumming, Liam Cunningham, Giles Hammond,
Development of a CO 2 laser machine for pulling and welding of silica fibres and ribbons D. Crooks for the GEO 600 collaboration Aspen January 2005 LIGO-G Z.
G O D D A R D S P A C E F L I G H T C E N T E R 1 GW Interferometry at Goddard Space Flight Center Jordan Camp NASA / Goddard Space Flight Center Jan.
Substrate mechanical loss studies Sheila Rowan (Stanford University) for: LIGO Laboratory (Caltech, MIT, LLO, LHO) LSC Partners (University of Glasgow,
Low noise Fused Silica suspensions: from the GEO600 experience to the 2 nd generation requirements Geppo Cagnoli INFN Sez. Firenze University of Glasgow.
LIGO-G W Status of LIGO Installation and Commissioning Frederick J. Raab, LIGO Hanford Observatory.
Overview of Research in the Optics Working Group Gregory Harry, on behalf of the OWG Massachusetts Institute of Technology July 25, 2007 LSC Meeting –
Thermal Noise from Coatings Gregg Harry; Andri Gretarsson, Scott Kittelberger, Steve Penn, Peter Saulson; Marty Fejer, Eric Gustafson, Roger Route, Sheila.
SUSPENSION DESIGN FOR ADVANCED LIGO: Update on GEO Activities Norna A Robertson University of Glasgow for the GEO 600 suspension team LSC Meeting, Louisiana,
Anti-Reflection Coated Silica Windows for Electra Stuart Searles, John Sethian Naval Research Laboratory Washington, D.C. Russell Smilgys Science Applications.
LIGO-G Z TNI Progress and Status Greg Ogin LSC Meeting March 22, 2007 Eric Black, Kenneth Libbrecht, Dennis Coyne Grad students: Akira Villar,
G M LIGO Laboratory1 Responses to Review Questions David Shoemaker, Peter Fritschel NSF Review of Advanced LIGO 12 June 2003.
Australia-Italy Australia 6, October 2005 LCGT project Kazuaki Kuroda LCGT Collaboration Cryogenics for LCGT.
Thermal noise from optical coatings Gregory Harry Massachusetts Institute of Technology - on behalf of the LIGO Science Collaboration - 25 July
Thermal Compensation in Stable Recycling Cavity 21/03/2006 LSC Meeting 2006 UF LIGO Group Muzammil A. Arain.
The investigation of optical inhomogeneities of the multilayer mirrors progress report Moscow State University Bilenko I.A
LIGO-G M Major International Collaboration in Advanced LIGO R&D Gary Sanders NSF Operations Review Hanford February, 2001.
Thermal Noise in Initial and Enhanced LIGO Gregg Harry, Steve Penn, Peter Saulson, David Malling Massachusetts Institute of Technology Hobart and William.
SUSPENSION DESIGN FOR ADVANCED LIGO: Update on GEO Activities Norna A Robertson University of Glasgow for the GEO 600 suspension team LSC Meeting, Hanford.
LIGO- G D LSC Meeting, Hannover, GE August LIGO Scientific Collaboration1 Advanced LIGO Optics Status Report Dave Reitze University of Florida.
TEM charcaterization Basic modes – Bright field microscopy – Dark field Microscopy –STEM – EDAX – EELS.
Low temperature dissipation in coating materials S. Reid 1, I. Martin 1, H. Armandula 3, R. Bassiri 1, E. Chalkley 1 C. Comtet 4, M.M. Fejer 5, A. Gretarsson.
LIGO-G Z Thermal noise in sapphire - summary and plans Work carried out at: Stanford University University of Glasgow Caltech MIT.
Cold damping of fused silica suspension violin modes V.P.Mitrofanov, K.V.Tokmakov Moscow State University G Z.
Effect of Charging on Thermal Noise Gregory Harry Massachusetts Institute of Technology - Core Optics and Suspensions Working Groups - March 19, 2004 –
Friedrich-Schiller-Universität Jena Institute of Solid State Physics – Low Temperature Physics Christian Schwarz19 th May GWADW Kyoto 1 Losses in.
LIG O HW S LIGO-G Z1 Fused Silica Research for Advanced LIGO Alexander Ageev, Garilynn Billingsley, David Crooks, Gregg Harry, Jim Hough, Steve.
Chunnong Zhao for ACIGA
Coating Program Update Gregory Harry LIGO/MIT on behalf of the Coating Working Group March 22, 2006 LSC Meeting – LHO G R.
Thermoelastic dissipation in inhomogeneous media: loss measurements and thermal noise in coated test masses Sheila Rowan, Marty Fejer and LSC Coating collaboration.
Sapphire for the LCGT project Eiichi Hirose ICRR, University of Tokyo Kyohei Watanabe, Norikatsu Mio PSC, University of Tokyo GT Advanced Technology, Sep.
Mechanical Mode Damping for Parametric Instability Control
C1) K. Tokmakov on behalf of the Advanced LIGO Suspensions Team Monolithic suspensions of the mirrors of the Advanced LIGO gravitational-wave detector.
LIGO-G D LIGO Laboratory1 Advanced LIGO Test Mass Material Selection Status GariLynn Billingsley LSC 20 March 2003.
Monolithic suspensions in Virgo Helios Vocca Dipartimento di Fisica & INFN di Perugia LIGO-G Z.
LIGO-G D Downselect: Silica. What Were We Thinking? Phil Willems, Caltech -representing- the Downselect Committee: David Shoemaker, Jordan Camp,
LIGO PAC11, Nov 2001 Syracuse proposal to NSF LIGO-G Z 1 Proposal to NSF: “Research in Gravitational Wave Detection with LIGO” Peter R.
LIGO-G Z Silicon as a low thermal noise test mass material S. Rowan, R. Route, M.M. Fejer, R.L. Byer Stanford University P. Sneddon, D. Crooks,
LIGO-G R 1 Gregory Harry and COC Working Group Massachusetts Institute of Technology - Technical Plenary Session - March 17-20, 2003 LSC Meeting.
LIGO Scientific Collaboration
LIGO-G D 1 R&D Technical Review LIGO Lab October 8, 2002 Core Optics.
Internal Mode Qs of Monolithically Suspended Test Masses in GEO600 Joshua Smith, Harald Lück, Stefan Goßler, Gianpietro Cagnoli, David Crooks, Sheila Rowan,
LIGO-G Z 1 Report of the Optics Working Group to the LSC David Reitze University of Florida March 20, 2003.
1/16 Nawrodt, Genoa 09/2009 An overview on ET-WP2 activities in Glasgow R. Nawrodt, A. Cumming, W. Cunningham, J. Hough, I. Martin, S. Reid, S. Rowan ET-WP2.
Studies of materials to reduce coating thermal noise K. Craig 1, I.W. Martin 1, S. Reid 2, M. Abernathy 1, R. Bassiri 1,4, K. Borisenko 3, A. Cumming 1,
Low temperature dissipation in coating materials S. Reid 1, I. Martin 1, E. Chalkley 1, H. Armandula 3, R. Bassiri 1, C. Comtet 4, M.M. Fejer 5, A. Gretarsson.
LSC meeting, Hanford, 2002 LIGO-G Z Remote in situ monitoring of weak distortions Ilya Kozhevatov, Efim Khazanov, Anatoly Poteomkin, Anatoly Mal’shakov,
Update on the Fused Silica Suspension for Advanced LIGO Giles Hammond, on behalf of the Suspension Team L-V Meeting, Amsterdam, 22 nd -25 th September.
LIGO-G Z Bilenko I.A. Gromova E.S. 1 Recent Results on the Measurement of Transmission and Scattering Structure on Doped and Non-doped Mirrors.
Material Downselect Rationale and Directions Gregory Harry LIGO/MIT Kavli Institute for Astrophysics and Space Technology On behalf of downselect working.
Mechanical Loss in Silica substrates
Steve Penn, Gregg Harry (MIT)
S. Rowan, M. Fejer, E. Gustafson, R. Route, G. Zeltzer
Mechanical Loss Measurements of Coated Substrates for Gravitational Wave Interferometry Thaddeus Baringer1, Gregory Harry1, Jonathan Newport1, Hannah Faire1,
Overview of Advanced LIGO Coating Status
LIGO Scientific Collaboration
Main Efforts of the Core Optics WG
Status of LIGO Installation and Commissioning
Lowering Mechanical Loss in Fused Silica Optics with Annealing
Presentation transcript:

Investigating Surface Loss in Fused Silica Steve Penn, Andri Gretarrson, Gregg Harry (MIT), Scott Kittelberger, Peter Saulson, Joshua Smith Syracuse University LIGO-G Z

LSC March 2001Syracuse University Experimental Relativity Group2 Synopsis Identifying a surface-dependent loss in fused silica and understanding the loss for different surface preparations. Reducing surface loss. “Can we repair the surface?” Proposal for experiment to explore laser polishing of optics. Measurements of loss in Silicate Bonds

LSC March 2001Syracuse University Experimental Relativity Group3 When we last talked … Q measurements on flame polished fibers show strong surface dependence. Q = 66 million measured in 6 mm flame polished fiber. Catalogue of known fused silica Q’s suggests similar surface dependence for other surface types.

LSC March 2001Syracuse University Experimental Relativity Group4  vs V/S — Part I

LSC March 2001Syracuse University Experimental Relativity Group5  vs V/S — Part II

LSC March 2001Syracuse University Experimental Relativity Group6 Surface Damage and Repair Polish-induced surface damage »Water and/or slurry absorption »Microcracking »Plans for SEM and TEM measure of surface defects Flame polishing repair of superpolished sample »Improve the mechanical Q »Destroy the optical quality Can we improve the Q and maintain the optical properties of a superpolished sample?

LSC March 2001Syracuse University Experimental Relativity Group7 Q of Superpolished/Flame-Polished Disk Superpolished Disk. »Fused silica (II ?) thin disk (3”OD x 0.1”) with superpolished faces. »Standard Syracuse resonant Q ringdown. (Double-bob suspension. Electrostatic comb excitor, birefringent sensor) »Q = 6 million (f = 4.5 kHz, drumhead) »Q = 4 million (f = 3 kHz, butterfly) Flame-Polished Disk »H-O torch used to flame polish the faces. Flame heats 1 cm OD regions to transition temperature. Final surface “mottled” into flame- sized regions »Subsurface defects seen during flame polishing. (ie. extruded rod) »Q = 28 million (both modes)

LSC March 2001Syracuse University Experimental Relativity Group8  vs V/S — Part III

LSC March 2001Syracuse University Experimental Relativity Group9  vs V/S — Part IV

LSC March 2001Syracuse University Experimental Relativity Group10 Laser Polishing A focused CO2 laser can heat a small region on the surface to the glass transition temperature without ablation. The diameter and depth of the heated region can be tuned to optimize repair of defects (few micron) but maintain the flatness and roughness of the optic (< 0.1 micron). Beam is rastered to polish entire surface. Collaborative effort by Syracuse, Florida, and MIT.

LSC March 2001Syracuse University Experimental Relativity Group11 Q of Silicate Bonds (Glasgow-Syracuse Collaboration) Unbonded sample. »Fused silica half cylinders (10cm x 0.5 cm OD) extruded rod with superpolished flat. »Standard Syracuse resonant Q ringdown. (Double-bob suspension. Electrostatic comb excitor, shadow sensor) »Q (f = 1.3 kHz) ≈ 9 million for the two fundamental modes. Bonded sample. »Two half cylinders bonded along superpolished flat and offset 1 cm »Two fundamental modes measured »Q(f = 2455 Hz ) = 2x10 5 Q(f=2303 Hz) = 3x10 5 FEA modeling required to extract  bond.

LSC March 2001Syracuse University Experimental Relativity Group12  vs V/S — Part V

LSC March 2001Syracuse University Experimental Relativity Group13  vs V/S — Part VI