1 Structural Roots of Japan’s Malaise Richard Katz The Oriental Economist Report Brookings Institution April 9, 2002
2 I. How Bad Is It?
3 Private Recovery Never Happened
4 Five-Year Growth Turning Negative
5 Japan’s Lost Decade vs. Others’
6 Share of Rich Country GDP Falls
7 Japan Share of World Exports Down
8 Slow Income = Slow Spending
9 ZIRP Erodes Household Income
10 Excess Capacity = Weak Investment
11 Investment Still Below 1991 Peak
12 II. The Causes
13 Lost GDP: ¾ Supply, ¼ Demand The horizontal zero line shows where GDP would be if growth had continued. Grey area shows lost GDP due to demand shortfall. Black area shows lost GDP due to slowdown in potential growth—not counting slowdown in labor force growth which is shown in diagonal stripes.
14 Competition in Efficient Sectors...
15...But Not in Inefficient
16 Low Trade Means Low Productivity
17 More Imports Leads to Higher Productivity Growh
18 Low Consumption From Low Income
19 Chronic Excess Business Savings
20 III. Banking Crisis
21 NPLs Keep Rising...
22... As Banks Slacken on Disposal
23 Non-Performing Borrowers
24 Govt Guarantee of Private Loans
25 IV. Fiscal and Monetary
26 Lost Taxes At Heart of Deficit
27 ZIRP Enables Govt to Fund Debt
28 Koizumi Budget: Asking For Trouble Since stimulus operates with a lag, the chart shows how changes in GDP follow from changes in the deficit one year earlier shows GDP growth in 1998 and budget change in 1997.
29 BOJ Printing Money; Economy Not Responding
30 Deflation Symptom of Weak Demand
31 V. Weak Yen No Panacea
32 Shrinking Share of Global Surplus
33 Shrinking Share of U.S. Deficit
34 Yen and Stocks Move in Tandem