Background Questionnaires: Why Ask About Social Identity? Ruth A. Childs & Orlena Broomes Ontario Institute for Studies in Education University of Toronto.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Assessment Adapted from text Effective Teaching Methods Research-Based Practices by Gary D. Borich and How to Differentiate Instruction in Mixed Ability.
Advertisements

AREA OF STUDY ONE: PARLIAMENT AND THE CITIZEN Legal Studies Unit 3.
2.06 Understand data-collection methods to evaluate their appropriateness for the research problem/issue.
1 Evaluation Reviews and Reevaluations Macomb ISD Special Education Management Services August, 2006.
OFFICE OF EQUITY & ACCESS
Understand the concepts of equality, diversity and rights in relation to health and social care It is really important in this learning outcome that you.
Practicing Community-engaged Research Mary Anne McDonald, MA, Dr PH Duke Center for Community Research Duke Translational Medicine Institute Division of.
Research methods – Deductive / quantitative
Research Ethics Levels of Measurement. Ethical Issues Include: Anonymity – researcher does not know who participated or is not able to match the response.
Assessing Student Academic Achievement The General Education Skills.
Data Collection Methods In Transportation Planning Part 2.
Developing a Questionnaire. Goals Discuss asking the right questions in the right way as part of an epidemiologic study. Review the steps for creating.
Situated Information Literacy A Model of Students’ Information Uses and Practices Jim Nichols, SUNY Oswego.
Measuring Learning Outcomes Evaluation
Human Rights in Ontario. Human Rights Activity- let’s do a Human Rights Quiz… Individuals should be treated fairly as human beings regardless of the age.
Test Validity S-005. Validity of measurement Reliability refers to consistency –Are we getting something stable over time? –Internally consistent? Validity.
 Background information  Age, sex, grade, education level, etc.  Only ask if relevant to your study  Do not ask for real names  May want to define.
Vertical Scale Scores.
The Operationalization Process Making Your Concepts Measurable.
Ethno-cultural groups in Population Censuses An evaluation of the UNECE/EUROSTAT Recommendations for Population Censuses and proposals for the 2010 round.
Community Input Discussions: Measuring the Progress of Young Children in Massachusetts August 2009.
A brief introduction to Impact Assessments Kuldip Sohanpal.
Module 4 TED 356 Curriculum in Sec. Ed.. Module 4 Explain the current official federal and state standards, including professional and accrediting groups.
Creating Assessments with English Language Learners in Mind In this module we will examine: Who are English Language Learners (ELL) and how are they identified?
Gender-Based Analysis (GBA) Research Day Winnipeg, MB February 11, 2013.
“Knowledge” Do Now: As a teacher, what does this statement make think about or feel: “He Who Can Does He Who cannot Teaches” George Bernard Shaw.
Gender and Diversity Analysis MB Status of Women Family Services & Labour.
Data collection compiled by Anna Bączkowska 2  Questionnaires  Interviews  Accounts  Observation  tests.
Copyright © 2004 McGraw-Hill Ryerson Limited, a Subsidiary of The McGraw-Hill Companies. All rights reserved. 1 CHAPTER 5 Sociocultural Diversity.
Questions Teachers Have Related to Equity and Some Possible Solutions
Civic and Citizenship Education in Times of Change: Curriculum and its Implementation Some Results of the IEA Studies Civic Education in Iraq: Study Tour.
1. 2 Roots of Ontario Legislation and Policy Bill 82 (1980), An Amendment to the Education Act: –Universal access: right of all children, condition notwithstanding,
Charter of Rights and Freedoms. How does the Charter of Rights protect an individual?
‘Delivering Equality’ Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Trans (LGB&T) Module 6: Monitoring LGB&T.
Leaders of Learners HOW DO WE LEAD THE CHANGE WE WANT TO SEE IN OUR SCHOOLS?
Session 4 Engagement, Continuous Improvement, and Accountability CLAS Training [ADD DATE] [ADD PRESENTER NAME] [ADD ORGANIZATION NAME]
© CCSR Building Pathways from the Middle Grades to College: Learnings from the work of the Chicago Consortium of School Research (CCSR) and CRIS Presented.
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY IN A GLOBAL SOCIETY
Disability Rights Promotion International: A Holistic monitoring methodology for evidence-based data collection on human rights violations Radoš Keravica.
Racism and Education Outcomes of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Children Talia Avrahamzon, Dr Nicholas Biddle, Dr Naomi Priest ANU Centre for Social.
Legal Requirements and Changes: Child Find, Evaluation, Eligibility Administrative Training Carie Hurford Emily McCambridge.
How Male and Female Students Perform in Toronto District School Board (TDSB) Schools Equally Prepared for Life?
Research into survey errors and interview bias has advance thinking about larger issues of how people create social meaning and achieve cultural understanding.
Equality Impact Assessment (EIA) Inspector Christian Ellis.
Learning outcomes Understand the importance of diversity, equality and inclusion. 2. Know how to work in an inclusive way 3. Know how to access information,
Session 2 Talk English Friends. Would I lie to you? Write 5 sentences about yourself- at least 3 should be true and at least 1 should be false. Share.
Diversity Diversity encompasses visible and invisible differences among people with respect to, but not limited to, gender; age; ethno-culture; socio-economic.
Culturally Relevant Pedagogy. Visual Synectic Activity Task  Individually, create 1 comparison for a visual image in one of the four quadrants by relating.
1 Chapter 13 Collecting the Data: Field Procedures and Nonsampling Error © 2005 Thomson/South-Western.
1 Equality Impact Assessment- Legal & Policy Context Presented by Ionann Management Consultants Ltd ionann.co.uk January 2008 Qmul-EiaTrng SlideShow.ppt.
State Education Agency Strategies for Promoting Equity: Students of Color “ALL” means ALL Darlene Morgan Brown, Ph.D. SECC/TXCC Regional.
Background questionnaires: Why ask about social identity Ruth Childs (OISE-UT) Orlena Broomes (OISE-UT) 1.
Teacher Responsibilities for teaching diverse learners Maintain good order and discipline in the classroom and school at all times. Provide and optimum.
Core: Social & Cultural Continuity & Change Section I of the exam: -Multiple Choice (8 marks) -Short Response (12 marks)
National Science Education Standards. Outline what students need to know, understand, and be able to do to be scientifically literate at different grade.
Promote equality, diversity and inclusion in work with children and young people Unit 8.
ASCCC Cultural Competency and Advocacy Plan Update Cleavon Smith, Berkeley City College Carolyn Holcroft, Foothill College.
Learning Objectives for Senior School Students. Failing to plan is planning to fail. / Psychology of Achievement /
TESTS FOR YOUNG LEARNERS. GENERAL APPROACH Children aged from about 5 to 12 Testing provides an opportunity to develop positive attitudes towards assessment,
Deciphering the College Admissions Process. “The image of admissions officers as gatekeepers is a powerful one in American culture. High school students.
How to Use These Modules 1.Complete these modules with your grade level and/or content team. 2.Print the note taking sheets. 3.Read the notes as you view.
Markisha Smith, EdD & Rudyane Rivera-Lindstrom, MEd
Attitudes.
Test Validity.
Characteristic of Teachers
Who wants to be a teacher
Welcome and Announcements
Multi-Tier System of Supports
Answering 4 mark questions
EQAO Grade 10 Results Ontario Secondary School Literacy Test
Presentation transcript:

Background Questionnaires: Why Ask About Social Identity? Ruth A. Childs & Orlena Broomes Ontario Institute for Studies in Education University of Toronto Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Canadian Society for the Study of Education, Montreal, May 2010.

Why have Background Questionnaires?  Large-scale assessments provide important information about what students know and what they know how to do  But, not which students are performing well and which are struggling – or, more importantly, why  Background Questionnaires often include questions about…  Students  Social identities  Experiences  Attitudes & Beliefs  Goals  Teachers  Social Identities & Experiences  Instruction & Assessment Practices  Beliefs  Resources  Schools  Community

What do we mean by “Social Identity”?  Carla O’Connor, a professor at the University of Michigan describes social identity as  “how people are differentially positioned in the social world”  She emphasizes that  “any one individual reflects multiple social identities”  “these identities are simultaneously structured and cultured and operate differentially across place and time”

Why ask about Social Identity?  The Ontario Human Rights Code gives four reasons for collecting social identity data:  To monitor and evaluate potential discrimination  To identify and remove systemic barriers  To ameliorate or prevent disadvantage  To promote equality  One of the Ontario Ministry of Education priorities is “Reduced gaps in student achievement”  A gap is a difference between groups  To reduce gaps in achievement, we have to first identify the gaps  To identify the gaps, we need to have information about group membership

An Example  Ontario Secondary School Literacy Test (OSSLT)  High School graduation requirement  In 2007/08, 156,151 Grade 10 students who were eligible to sit the English-language version of the test  Results  122,324 students passed  23,279 failed  4,357 were absent  6,191 received permission to defer taking the test

Writing the Questions  Choose the dimensions that matter in the particular context (this may vary regionally and by the academic subject being tested)  Explain why the information is important and how it will be used – why would someone respond?  Specify if the information will be anonymous or confidential  Describe social identity dimensions clearly (e.g., sex vs. gender; race vs. ethnicity)  Choose categories thoughtfully  What distinctions are important?  What level of specificity is needed? Gerber (1999) found that respondents “paid close attention not only to the category that applied to their own group, but to the categories available for others as well,” wanting to “make sure that the categories were evenhanded, and did not give preferential treatment to specific groups” (p. 230)  What is the precise meaning of terms? What terms will respondents recognize?  Include an “I prefer not to respond” option

Testing the Questions  Approaches  Expert review  Cognitive interviewing (think-alouds)  Questions  How do respondents decide whether to answer?  How do respondents decide how to answer?  Do students at different ages understand the questions differently? Roger Levine in testing NAEP questions found differences by age.