THE PSYCHO-ONCOLOGY: THE GENERATOR POWER OF NARRATIONS IN THE SICK IDENTITY CONSTRUCTION Erica Bagni, Eleonora Braga, Gian Piero Turchi University of Padova,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Reflective writing Jill Wilson September From Samuel Johnsons dictionary (born 18 th September yrs ago today) Reflective: Considering.
Advertisements

Qualitative text analysis. Why do qualitative text analysis? A number of scholars say you cannot capture the meaning of a text by counting the number.
How should the HDR Thesis Hang Together?
Abnormal Psychology Discuss to what extent biological, cognitive, and sociocultural factors influence abnormal behaviour Evaluate psychological research.
Drug addiction= illness Medical model works is focused on the behaviour with an intervention of physiological kind Epistemologically unfounded (it joins.
Offender Health, What Role for the Probation Service? Coral Sirdifield 19 January 2011.
PROFESSIONAL NURSING PRACTICE
The Landscape of Educational Research
Understanding the Research Process
Reflexivity: The Facilitator’s Guide
1 Scientific arguments as learning artifacts: Designing for learning from the web with KIE 2004/1/12 吳秋儀 Bell, P. & Linn, M. C. (2000). Scientific arguments.
TEMPLATE DESIGN © The Positive Side of Negative Emotions: The Role of Guilt and Shame in Coping with Interpersonal Conflicts.
EVAL 6000: Foundations of Evaluation Dr. Chris L. S. Coryn & Carl D. Westine October 7, 2010.
Deviant Behaviour Amongst Adolescent Youth An analysis using the Theory of Planned Behaviour Grace Skrzypiec October 2005.
The efficacy evaluation of interventions with tobacco’s consumers: an action that modifies the discursive configuration Dalila Barbanera and Eleonora Pinto.
EVAL 6000: Foundations of Evaluation Dr. Chris L. S. Coryn Kristin A. Hobson Fall 2011.
Good Research Questions. A paradigm consists of – a set of fundamental theoretical assumptions that the members of the scientific community accept as.
The roles of the Architect ARBE121 - INTRODUCTION  Designer Knowledge of science, technology, history & theory etc  Advisor Knowledge of legal, financial,
Four Dark Corners of Requirements Engineering
Turn to Discourse and DISCOURSE ANALYSIS What did we learn? That we make interpretations about speakers we fell judgments about poor guys.
Narrative, discourse, and psychology “NOT” Narrative Psychology Discursive Psychology Relational Psychology Dialogic “Science” Promises of turns to Discourse.
A.A Bachelor, Master an Phd Programs In Psycholgy, Education and Social Science Faculty of Medicine and Psychology.
Understanding Career Choice: A Turn to Narrative
THE GENERATION AND MAINTENANCE OF STEREOTYPE OF THE CONSUMER OF ILLEGAL SUBSTANCES: AN EXEMPLIFICATION THROUGH A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF DISCURSIVE PRACTICES.
The Development of Youth With Cancer and Their Siblings Amy Green Youth Development Leadership.
Lecture: Debates on theory and method in the social sciences Harold Wilhite SUM 3011/4011a 2010.
Quality school library – how do we find out? Polona Vilar Department of LIS&BS, Faculty of Arts, University of Ljubljana, SLO Ivanka Stričević Department.
Copyright © 2011 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Chapter 8 Qualitative Inquiry.
Evidence in Planning Presented at the Data Leading to Action-From Chaos to Clarity Symposium Winnipeg, January 19-20, 2009 Dexter Harvey.
Ed 555 Teacher As Researcher. Research In research we are always making decisions about what we see. We are also making decisions about what not to.
Iaps 18 - Vienna, July 2004 Trends in Environmental Psychology: A comparison between JEP and E&B M. V.Giuliani, C. Plaino & A. M. D’Amico ISTC-CNR – Roma,
FOR 500 PRINCIPLES OF RESEARCH: PROPOSAL WRITING PROCESS
The personal psychological peculiarities as a resource in the complex human care for old people Natalia Alexandrova, prof. Sofia University, Faculty of.
Sharing Design Knowledge through the IMS Learning Design Specification Dawn Howard-Rose Kevin Harrigan David Bean University of Waterloo McGraw-Hill Ryerson.
Departments in Business Business Name 1 Business Name 2.
Fifth International Conference on Dialogical-Self, Cambridge, PRÂGMATA laboratorio di consulenza per le organizzazioni FROM “PERSONAL MOTIVATION”
Saliha Bava, PhD Taos-Tilburg Research Topic Call November 4, 2009 Contact: A systematic process of knowledge creation.
Teachers Changing Practice in Their Schools: Implications for School Libraries Rosemary Abbott Loreto Mandeville Hall SLAV Conference March
School of Education, CASEwise: A Case-based Online Learning Environment for Teacher Professional Development Chrystalla.
Sveinung Sandberg. ISS, UiO The narrative dimension of substance use Sveinung Sandberg, University of Oslo Sébastien Tutenges, University of Aarhus.
LEARNING FROM LIFE Gert Biesta University of Stirling the ‘Learning Lives’ project: a 3-year longitudinal study into the ‘learning biographies’ of adults.
Amina Pizzala, Elena Fogliata, Gian Piero Turchi, Dalila Barbanera
Doping practice and sport: dialogic identities within different levels of sporting practices Gian Piero Turchi, Gilberto Guastalla, Eleonora Braga Cambridge,
1 Introduction to Social Analysis Week 1 Introduction.
Copyright © 2011 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Chapter 5 Theory, Research, and Evidence-Based Practice.
Psychology Lesson 2.
Evaluation design and implementation Puja Myles
University of Padova General Psychology Department From cure to biography. Ungrounding of medical model in intervention on “drug abuse”: a research among.
Research for Nurses: Methods and Interpretation Chapter 1 What is research? What is nursing research? What are the goals of Nursing research?
1 Human Behavior and the Social Environment: Theories for Social Work Practice Bruce A. Thyer, Catherine N. Dulmus, and Karen M. Sowers, Editors Chapter.
Master’s degree in Mediation as an operative tool within the penal, family and communitarian field MEDIATION AS INSTRUMENT TO MANAGE CONFLICTS: the generation.
1 DIALOGICAL SELF Cambridge – UK, 2008 General Psychology Departement - University of Padovapresents THE DIALOGICAL CONSTRUCTION OF THE “ULTRAS FAN” Claudia.
Analysis and perspectives of GPs gathering models in Italy according to the latest Italian National GPs Joint Agreements Mazzeo M.C.*, Ceccarelli A.* °,
Intercultural Communication
HIV: A REALITY GENERATED BY THE “DIALOGICAL MEETING” BETWEEN SELF-DESCRIPTION AND SELF-NARRATIONS: AN EXAMPLE OF HEALTH PROMOTION INTERVENTION AND ITS.
The research process Psych 231: Research Methods in Psychology.
Type author names here Social Research Methods Chapter 24: Qualitative data analysis Alan Bryman Slides authored by Tom Owens.
Perceptions of successful ageing by senior adults in Hong Kong: Implications for lifelong learning Panel Discussion at Book Launch 28 February 2012 Dr.
THE AGING FROM “DISEASE” TO BIOGRAPHIC PROCESSES: INTERGENERATIONAL PROGRAM AS STRATEGY TO HEALTH PROMOTION Fattori Luca*, Angelo Tesi*, Gian Piero Turchi**
“AN INTEGRATIVE FRAMEWORK FOR COMMUNITY PARTNERING TO TRANSLATE THEORY INTO EFFECTIVE HEALTH PROMOTION STRATEGY” Allan Best, Daniel Stokols, Lawrence W.
1 DIALOGICAL SELF Cambridge – UK, 2008 General Psychology Departement - University of Padova “altreStrade” – Social Cooperative, Padova present THE “CHAIN”
Simona Creazzola National Representative ED Italy Europa Donna Italian Forum : Lobbing action and breast cancer experienced working women Workshop “Promoting.
Career Theories Part I. Cognitive Information Processing Theory  Cognitive means of, or relating to mental activity such as thinking, remembering, learning.
Director, ESRC Wales Doctoral Training Centre
Presented by Xi Wang September 3rd, 2008
Knowledge Basis for Design Steve Frezza, Ph. D., C.S.D.P.
VOCIS Vocational training of the Inner Self Training Continous VET Program Delia Zingarelli & Pietro Ragni.
Maria Francesca Freda, Giovanna Esposito, Maria Luisa Martino
Reflective writing Jill Wilson September 2009.
Scaling up in Health Sciences.
Presentation transcript:

THE PSYCHO-ONCOLOGY: THE GENERATOR POWER OF NARRATIONS IN THE SICK IDENTITY CONSTRUCTION Erica Bagni, Eleonora Braga, Gian Piero Turchi University of Padova, General Psychology Department – ITALY NARRATIVISTIC PARADIGM REALITY IS A DISCURSIVE CONFIGURATION ALWAYS IN TRANSORMATION IT IS GENERATED BY PEOPLE KNOWLEDGE WAYS HEALTH IS A DIALOGICAL PROCESS THEORY OF DIALOGICAL IDENTITY (Turchi et al. 2007) TO DESCRIBE DISCURSIVE WAYS USED ‘TO TALK ABOUT’ ‘ONCOLOGICAL SICKNESS’ BY DIFFERENT PEOPLE THAT CONTRIBUTES TO CONSTRUCT IT AIM CONCLUSIVE CONSIDERATIONS - The discursive productions of people who were/are oncologic patient present discursive elements that inscribe ‘sickness” as possible ‘event’ of biographic path (dialogical self) and so not as central event that construct the whole identity - More than the other, the ‘common sense’ describes people who are affected by tumour only through knowledge way of “sickness”. In general, the ‘sickness theories’ are used, more by the ‘common sense’: in this way, the whole “biographic career” turns around the biographic event of pathology. The sick person builts its “dialogical self” in a “less pathologic” way than other people do about it ANALYSIS RESULTS (The follow tables show the comparison among repertories founded in the questions analysis that generate the same reality configuration) SICK PEOPLE  it is the unique group that individuates a change perspectives and projects future narrative possibilities. HEALED PEOPLE  the members of this group describe themselves in reference to “what they do” today, comparing this with the past. They assumes a position that imply the break of “sick” narrative coherence. COMMON SENSE  the person afflicted by a tumour is described only like a sick person HEALTH SUBSUMES SANITY Sanity as one of the narrative possibilities of health THE RESEARCH SAMPLE 47 people actually affected by a tumour (“SICK” SAMPLE) 20 people affected in the past by a tumour (“HEALED” SAMPLE) 30 healthy people, never affected by a tumuor (“COMMON SENSE” SAMPLE) SURVEY TOOL OPENED QUESTIONS QUESTIONNAIRE QUESTIONNAIRE TEXTUAL ANALYSIS M.A.D.I.T. METHODOLOGY (Turchi et al. 2007) DISCURSIVE DISCURSIVE REPERTORIES “How do I describe myself ‘today’ after my sickness diagnosis?” (“sick” sample and “healed” sample) “How do you think a person describes itself after a tumour diagnosis?” (“common sense” sample) SICK PEOPLEHEALED PEOPLECOMMON SENSE PEOPLE Comparison repertory Change repertory Sickness repertory Reality sanction repertory Relativization repertory Future projection repertory Action repertory Generalization repertory Problem attribution repertory Explanation repertory Consequences repertory “How did I describe myself in the past, before my sickness diagnosis?” (“sick” and “healed” samples) “How do you think a person described itself before to know its tumour diagnosis?” (“common sense” sample) SICK SAMPLEHEALED SAMPLECOMMON SENSE SAMPLE Action repertory Tautology repertory Future projection repertory Sickness repertory “How will I describe myself ‘tomorrow’?” (“sick” sample and “healed” sample) “How do you think a person affected by tumour describes itself in a future life perspective?” (“common sense” sample) SICK SAMPLEHEALED SAMPLECOMMON SENSE SAMPLE Relativization repertory Anticipation repertory Future projection repertory Action repertory Reality sanction repertory Problem attribution repertory SICK PEOPLE  doesn’t use descriptions about pathology, but description about a reality configuration in pragmatic sense. HEALED PEOPLE  it describes itself in reference to the future. COMMON SENSE  it is the unique group that uses the sickness repertory as a central element of identity  “typization process” ALL THREE SAMPLES  they use discursive modalities that refer to a projection toward future scenarios COMMON SENSE  is the only group who uses discursive configurations that keep a narrative coherence of “problem”, so it remains a static reality  typization process HEALTH PROMOTION INTERVENTIONS HAVE TO PROMOTE A TRANFORMATIVE PROCESS THAT INVOLVES ALL ROLES OF THE DISCURSIVE CONTEXT OF REALITY. AIM OF HEALTH PROMOTION INTERVENTION: TO RECONSIDER THE PATHOLOGY INSURGANCE AS ‘POSSIBLE BIOGRAPHIC EVENT’ Bibliography - Federspil, G., “Il concetto di malattia”, Medicina - Rivista E.M.I., 7, Turchi G.P., “M.A.D.I.T. – manuale per la metodologia di analisi dei dati informatizzati testuali”, Armando Editore, Roma, Turchi G.P., Della Torre C., “Psicologia della Salute – dal modello bio-psico-sociale al modello dialogico”, Armando Editore, Roma, 2007 THEORETICAL FRAME CONNECTED TO THIS PAPER YOU CAN FIND: in the section “HEALTH PSYCHOLOGY” - Health in the territory as a shared responsability, paper and slides files - HIV: a reality generated by the “dialogical meeting” between self-descrption and self-narrations: an example of health promotion intervention and its efficacy evaluation, poster files in the section “DIALOGICAL MODEL” - Epistemological foundation and methodological exactness regarding research in the discursive science, symposium and slides files