The Ground Rules of Physics (Science) New Observation Reproducible ? New Theory Prediction Confirmed or Busted ?

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Big Bang, the LHC and the God Particle Cormac ORaifeartaigh (WIT) Faster than the speed of light Was Einstein wrong? Cormac ORaifeartaigh (WIT)
Advertisements

Mr Green sees the shorter, straight, green path and Mr. Red sees the longer, curved, red path.
Relativity Theories. The Principle of Relativity Although motion often appears relative, it’s logical to identify a “background” reference frame from.
Chapter 18: Relativity and Black Holes
15.1Tenets of General Relativity 15.2Tests of General Relativity 15.3Gravitational Waves 15.4Black Holes General Relativity CHAPTER 15 General Relativity.
Theories and Models SNC2D. Theories and Models: Daily Learning Goal The student will be able to differentiate between scientific laws and scientific theories.
Chapter 20 Dark Matter, Dark Energy, and the Fate of the Universe.
January 2011 David Toback, Texas A&M University Texas Junior Science and Humanities Symposium 1 David Toback Texas A&M University Texas Junior Science.
General Relativity I The need for a more general theory of relativity… Einstein’s tower experiment The strong equivalence principle.
Announcements Homework 14 due Wednesday (5 questions) Monty Python Challenge offer good through this Wednesday! Final exam in SL 228 next Monday or Tuesday.
March 2011 David Toback, Texas A&M University Davidson Scholars 1 David Toback Texas A&M University Davidson Scholars March 2011 The Big Bang, Dark Matter.
The latest experimental evidence suggests that the universe is made up of just 4% ordinary matter, 23% cold dark matter and 73% dark energy. These values.
Black Holes Dennis O’Malley. How is a Black Hole Created? A giant star (more than 25x the size of the sun) runs out of fuel –The outward pressure of the.
PHY 042: Electricity and Magnetism Introduction Prof. Pierre-Hugues Beauchemin.
13.3 Black Holes: Gravity’s Ultimate Victory Our Goals for Learning What is a black hole? What would it be like to visit a black hole? Do black holes really.
All science was based on the teachings of the ancient Greek philosophers Aristotle taught that there was natural and unnatural motion for objects Unnatural.
Scientific Theory and Scientific Law
Origin of the Universe Big Bang Theory.
Dark Matter Masses of Galaxies Gravity and Light Black Holes What is Dark Matter?
1 CDT403 Research Methods in Natural Sciences and Engineering Theory of Science GOLEM ANALYSIS OF SCIENTIFIC CONFIRMATION: THEORY OF RELATIVITY Gordana.
Einstein’s Universe 20 th Century Physics and Relativity.
Stationary Elevator with gravity: Ball is accelerated down.
Renaissance Astronomy Nicholas Copernicus (Niklas Koppernigk) Developed a mathematical model for a Heliocentric solar system.
Ch. 4 Sec. 5 The Expanding Universe Discover activity- How Does the Universe Expand pg What happens to the distances between galaxies that are.
Chapter 26 Relativity. General Physics Relativity II Sections 5–7.
How research is done – two examples. Feynman "The first principle is that you must not fool yourself--and you are the easiest person to fool. So you have.
Origins of the Universe By: K.Pease 8 th grade
Dark Matter and Dark Energy Just because something is unknown does not make it unknowable 1.
The Theory of Relativity. What is it? Why do we need it? In science, when a good theory becomes inadequate to describe certain situations, it is replaced.
Dark Matter in Galaxies and Clusters AST 112. Matter Galaxies appear to be made up of stars, gas and dust Reasonable to think that’s the end of the story…
1 Martin L. Perl SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory and Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology at Stanford.
Relativistic Mass and Energy
Lecture 4: General Relativity. Einstein’s Progress in General Relativity Einstein knew Special Relativity could only treat situations where gravity was.
Relativity ds 2 = ( 1 - ) dt 2 – (1 + ) dr 2 – r 2 d  2 – r 2 sin 2  d 2 “ 2GM R R Twinkle, twinkle little star How I wonder where you are “1.75 seconds.
Chapter 13 Black Holes. What do you think? Are black holes just holes in space? What is at the surface of a black hole? What power or force enables black.
Gravity, Energy, and Light Einstein and Newton 1.
How Does Gravity Work?!?! General Relativity. Aristotle described the effect of gravity as the natural motion of an object to return to its realm. Kepler.
 Albert Einstein’s Conjecture  Sir Arthur Eddington’s Test  Popper’s Account.
October 2011 David Toback, Texas A&M University Research Topics Seminar 1 David Toback Texas A&M University Mitchell Institute for Fundamental Physics.
Gravitational Lensing
Fundamental Principles of General Relativity  general principle: laws of physics must be the same for all observers (accelerated or not)  general covariance:
The Big Bang, the LHC and the God Particle Cormac O’Raifeartaigh (WIT) Faster than the speed of light Was Einstein wrong? Cormac O’Raifeartaigh (WIT)
So, how’s it gonna end? The Big Bang started the universe expanding fast, but gravity should have put on the brakes. Expansion should slow down after.
Galileo Galilei. Early Years Born 15 Feb in Pisa Born 15 Feb in Pisa Educated in Camaldolese Monastery Educated in Camaldolese Monastery Father.
Cultural Project faster than light neutrinos faster than light neutrinos By Gejing Xu.
H8: Evidence for general relativity
Astronomy 1143 – Spring 2014 Lecture 22 The Nature of Dark Matter: MACHOs and WIMPs.
ORIGINS …. LEARNING GOALS I WILL BE ABLE TO EXPLAIN THE THEORY FOR THE FORMATION OF OUR SOLAR SYSTEM. I WILL BE ABLE TO EXPLAIN THE BIG BANG THEORY.
More to the universe than meets the eye
Physics 55 Monday, December 5, Course evaluations. 2.General relativity with applications to black holes, dark matter, and cosmology. 3.Hubble’s.
Unit 13 Relativity.
Dark Matter Inquiring Minds Want to Know Prof. David Toback Texas A&M University.
Gravity, Energy, and Light Einstein and Newton 1.
Energy-Mass Equivalence
The cosmic connection There is a very close connection between particle physics and astrophysics. I’m going to show two examples: Type II supernovas Dark.
Probably the first astronomers. Measured time using sundials and water clocks. Believed the Earth was flat with a dome shaped sky. Studied astronomy to.
A recap of the main points so far… Observers moving uniformly with respect to each other do not agree on time intervals or distance intervals do not agree.
The Big Bang, the LHC and the God Particle Cormac O’Raifeartaigh (WIT) Faster than the speed of light Was Einstein wrong? Cormac O’Raifeartaigh (WIT) Maths.
The quest for Gravitation Waves By Benjamin Thayer.
The Scientific Revolution GALILEO ON TRIAL Describe Aristotle's model of the Universe: A Geocentric view: Earth is in the middle of the universe. The.
Dark Matter, Dark Energy
A warning light in the engine of a fast-moving train flashes once each second according to a clock on the train. Will an observer on the ground measure.
Inquiring Minds Want to Know Prof. David Toback Texas A&M University
General Theory of Relativity
BC Science Connections 8
CHAPTER 15 General Relativity
SECOND TRIMESTER Unit Two: Astronomy
General relativity Special relativity applies only to observers moving with constant velocity. Can we generalize relativity to accelerated observers.
Dark matter and dark energy
This Week Today: Wednesday Friday: We finish up with Gravity
Presentation transcript:

The Ground Rules of Physics (Science) New Observation Reproducible ? New Theory Prediction Confirmed or Busted ?

How Does our Knowledge Grow ? Unexpected observations can lead to a new theory Mathematical elegance can be a powerful guide (general relativity) Sometimes, a radically new concept is needed (quantum physics) New concepts are not accepted easily (Galileo’s trials and tribulations with the church, Einstein’s concerns about quantum theory) The ultimate test is the experiment (if reproducible) A new theory does not invalidate a tested theory, it extends it to new territory  steady progress (general relativity extends Newton’s gravity)

1) Acceleration and gravity cannot be distinguished. 2) Acceleration deflects light. 3) Therefore, gravity should deflect light. Einstein’s logic (Lect. 16): Confirmed by experiment: Stars can be detected close to the Sun during a solar eclipse. Their light is indeed deflected by the Sun’s gravity. Example 1 : General Relativity Moon Star’s real position Star’s apparent position Starlight deflected by Sun’s gravity

Eddington’s Eclipse Expedition 1919 British astronomer Eddington traveled to Principe Island in the Gulf of Guinea to observe deflection of starlight during a solar eclipse. After months of drought, it was pouring rain on the day of the eclipse. The clouds parted just in time for the eclipse. The photographs produced a deflection in agreement with Einstein’s prediction. Einstein instantly became a star.

Gravitational lensing The Sun acts like a lens deflecting the light from stars behind it. Galaxies can also act as lenses by deflecting light from more distant galaxies. This gives rise to the faint arcs and streaks in this image.

Example 2 : Einstein’s Speed Limit Nothing travels faster than light Energy increase Length decrease c = speed of light Otherwise the energy of this object would go to infinity. And its length would shrink to zero.

Do Neutrinos Travel Faster than the Speed of Light? Neutrinos are fundamental particles similar to the electron, but not charged. They interact very little with matter and easily pass through the Earth. On September 23, 2011, a press release from CERN, the European Organization for Nuclear Research, announced a seminar to be held that very afternoon. Members of the OPERA neutrino experiment would describe their observation of what appeared to be a new property of neutrinos. The webcast of a garden-variety CERN seminar attracts an average of a couple of hundred viewers. When the proceedings got under way on the afternoon of September 23, some 120,000 people tuned in. There aren't that many particle physicists in existence, even allowing for parallel universes. Clearly, plenty of regular people were also listening. More than 6000 neutrino news stories appeared on September 23rd and 24th alone, with thousands more in following days. Job applications to CERN climbed by 50 percent on the day of the press conference. Who wouldn't want to work where they make neutrinos that break the speed limit? Judith Jackson, Symmetry Magazine

Speedy Neutrinos Einstein: “Do you realize how fast you were going?” Neutrino: “No. Was I speeding?” (Neutrinos kept the strict speed limits of Switzerland but were speeding in Italy.)

The Story of the OPERA Experiment Another team of physicists whose apparatus lives right next door to the Opera group — under the Gran Sasso mountain in Italy — reported that they had clocked neutrinos over the same path exactly at the speed of light. The second group, which goes by the acronym Icarus, was led by Carlo Rubbia, a former director of CERN and Nobel-Prize winner. After some searching the OPERA scientists found the flaw. A bad connection of a fiber optic cable caused a 60 nanosecond delay of their clock, such that the neutrinos appeared to arrive 60 nanoseconds earlier. On June 8, 2012, at the 25th International Conference on Neutrino Physics and Astrophysics in Kyoto, CERN's research director Sergio Bertolucci presented data on behalf of four separate instruments at Gran Sasso that had tried to replicate the anomalous result. All of them had failed to do so, finding that the neutrinos respected the universal speed limit.

Post-Mortem Analysis of the OPERA Experiment There were warning signs that should have kept OPERA from going to the press prematurely: 1)A previous measurement found that the speed of neutrinos was equal to the speed of light with much higher accuracy: Neutrinos and light from a supernova arrived at the same time. The OPERA team argued that neutrinos from CERN and from the supernova had different energy, therefore different speed. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Carl Sagan 2)There was no credible theory explaining the result. Apart from the energy going to infinity, there was a problem with causality. Going faster than light might make it possible to go back in time. That leads to logical problems (and neutrino jokes): You go back in time and kill an ancestor, wiping yourself out in the process. But if you don’t exist, how can you kill someone ? No experiment should be believed until it has been confirmed by theory. Arthur Eddington

The Good News: Physics corrects itself.