THE JUDICIARY
“JUSTICE”
DUAL COURT SYSTEM
LARGER OR SMALLER ROLE THAN OTHER NATIONS???
FOUNDERS IDEA?? SMALL ROLE…
DON’T EVEN ASK…
BUT, IF YOU MUST…
STRICT CONSTRUCTIONIST VS. ACTIVIST (LOOSE)
ORIGINALIST VS. “LIVING DOCUMENT” THEORY
NOT THE SAME AS LIBERAL/DEM. VS. CONSERVATIVE/REP.
1 ST AMENDMENT 2 ND AMENDMENT
JURISDICTION (“RIGHT TO SAY”)
ORIGINAL VS. APPELLATE
FEDERAL COURTS (LIMITED)
FEDERAL QUESTIONS (Constitution) AND DIVERSITY CASES (state issues)
STATE COURTS (GENERAL)
EVOLUTION OF THE COURTS
THREE ERAS
1787 TO 1865 *LEGITIMACY *SLAVERY
THE M&M CASES
MARBURY V. MADISON 1803
JUDICIAL REVIEW M v. M (1803)
McCULLOCH V. MARYLAND 1819
NATIONAL SUPREMACY AND THE ELASTIC CLAUSE “NECESSARY AND PROPER”
DRED SCOTT V. SAN(D)FORD 1857
AMENDMENTS ( ) DUPE (INCORPORATION)
1865 TO 1937 *ECONOMY
REGULATION OF COMMERCE?
THE COMMERCE CLAUSE!!!
THE COMMERCE CLAUSE!!
1938 TO PRESENT *CIVIL LIBERTIES
TODAY’S ERA? INTERNET GUN SALES ABORTION RIGHTS MARRIAGE “OBAMACARE”
COURT STRUCTURE
SELECTING JUDGES
PRES.-APPOINTS SENATE-CONFIRMS
FDR-1936 REELECTION “COURT PACKING”
SENATORIAL COURTESY
“BLUE SLIP”
LITMUS TEST (KEY ISSUES?)
GETTING TO THE SUPREME COURT
“STANDING”
WRIT OF CERTIORARI (RULE OF 4)
1%-2%
ROLE OF LAW CLERKS
IN FORMA PAUPERIS (GIDEON V. WAINWRIGHT – 1963)
FEE SHIFTING
CLASS-ACTION SUITS
BROWN V. B.O.E. “separate but equal” (1954)
PLESSY v. FERGUSON -1896
“WITH ALL DELIBERATE SPEED…
SCHOOL EQUALITY TODAY??? SOLON H.S. HUDSON H.S.
AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF
COURT OPINIONS
MAJORITY OPINION 9-0, 8-1, 7-2, 6-3, 5-4
CONCURRING OPINION
DISSENTING OPINION (MINORITY)
“STARE DECISIS” “let the decision stand” (PRECEDENT)
REMEDY
ENFORCEMENT POWER IS LOW
CHECKS ON THE COURTS
CONFIRMATION
IMPEACHMENT (15)
(JURIS)(DICTION) “the right to speak the law” CHANGES
QUALITIES OF A JUDGE
TODAY’S COURT
JOHN ROBERTS (George W. Bush)
ANTONIN SCALIA (Ronald Reagan)
ANTHONY KENNEDY (Ronald Reagan)
CLARENCE THOMAS (George HW Bush)
RUTH BADER GINSBURG (Bill Clinton)
STEPHEN BREYER (Bill Clinton)
SAMUEL ALITO (George W. Bush)
SONIA SOTOMAYOR (Barack Obama)
ELENA KAGAN (Barack Obama)
APPOINTEES … G.W. BUSH – 2 G.H.W. BUSH – 1 REAGAN – 2 CLINTON – 2 OBAMA - 2
AGES… ave.=65.6
DEFINITION OF “JUSTICE”