The composition of presolar spinel grain OC2: constraining AGB models Maria Lugaro University of Utrecht, The Netherlands Amanda I. Karakas McMaster University,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The origin of heavy elements in the solar system
Advertisements

Acceleration of GCR in stellar winds and the GCR 22 Ne/ 20 Ne source ratio N. Prantzos (Institut d’Astrophysique de Paris)
The Standard Solar Model and Its Evolution Marc Pinsonneault Ohio State University Collaborators: Larry Capuder Scott Gaudi.
Asymptotic Giant Branch. Learning outcomes Evolution and internal structure of low mass stars from the core He burning phase to the tip of the AGB Nucleosynthesis.
Li Abundance of TO stars in globular clusters Zhixia Shen Luca Pasquini.
FORMATION OF CRUST AND ATMOSPHERE Planets of solar system probably formed from remnants of supernovas, i.e., disc-shaped clouds of hot gases (solar nebula).
Chemical Models of Protoplanetary Disks for Extrasolar Planetary Systems J. C. Bond and D. S. Lauretta, Lunar and Planetary Laboratory, University of Arizona.
Oxygen Isotopes Anomalies of the Sun and the Original Environment of the Solar System Jeong-Eun Lee UCLA.
Chemical evolution of Super-AGB stars The Giant Branches Lorentz Center, May 2009 Enrique García-Berro 1,2 1 Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya 2 Institut.
S-Process in C-Rich EMPS: predictions versus observations Sara Bisterzo (1) Roberto Gallino (1) Oscar Straniero (2) I. I. Ivans (3, 4) and Wako Aoki, Sean.
Branchings, neutron sources and poisons: evidence for stellar nucleosynthesis Maria Lugaro Astronomical Institute University of Utrecht (NL)
Trace Element Abundances in Single Presolar SiC Stardust Grains by Synchrotron X-Ray Fluorescence (SXRF) Zhonghu Cai (XOR) Barry Lai (XOR) Steve Sutton.
New Science from new Technology: NanoSIMS and RIMS Peter Hoppe Max-Planck-Institute for Chemistry IAU Meeting 2006 Prague August 21, 2006.
Definition of “fossil” A fossil is defined as any remains, trace or imprint of a plant or animal that has been preserved by natural processes in the Earth’s.
Helium-enhancements in globular cluster stars from AGB pollution Amanda Karakas 1, Yeshe Fenner 2, Alison Sills 1, Simon Campbell 3 & John Lattanzio 3.
Abundances in Presolar Grains, Stars and the Galaxy Larry R. Nittler Department of Terrestrial Magnetism Carnegie Institution of Washington.
Neutron Star Formation and the Supernova Engine Bounce Masses Mass at Explosion Fallback.
SOLUTION 1: ECLIPSING BINARIES IN OPEN CLUSTERS The study of eclipsing binaries in open clusters allows strong constraints to be placed on theoretical.
Stellar Structure Section 6: Introduction to Stellar Evolution Lecture 16 – Evolution of core after S-C instability Formation of red giant Evolution up.
Stellar Structure Section 6: Introduction to Stellar Evolution Lecture 14 – Main-sequence stellar structure: … mass dependence of energy generation, opacity,
Center for Stellar and Planetary Astrophysics Monash University Summary prepared by John Lattanzio Abundances in M71.
S-Process in low metallicity Pb stars: comparison between new theoretical results and spectroscopic observations Sara Bisterzo (1) Roberto Gallino (1),
Institute for Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of Tübingen, Germany July 5, 2004Cool Stars, Stellar Systems and the Sun (Hamburg, Germany)1 Turning.
The travel diary of a micron-sized sphere, found in the Murchison meteorite Timothy Joseph Volkert and P. Fraundorf Physics & Astronomy and Center for.
The r+s CEMP stars and AGB supernovae Maria Lugaro University of Utrecht (NL)
The massive zero metal stars: their evolutionary properties and their explosive yields. Alessandro Chieffi Istituto Nazionale di AstroFisica (Istituto.
Energy and Specific Heat Date:. Energy The ability to do work Multiple forms of energy We are going to focus on heat, q.
The structure of the atom ParticleRelative MassRelative Charge Proton11 Neutron10 Electron0 MASS NUMBER = number of protons + number of neutrons SYMBOL.
Superbubbles, Wolf-Rayet Stars, and the Origin of Galactic Cosmic Rays W.R. Binns, M.H. Israel, L.M. Scott: Washington University M.E. Wiedenbeck: Jet.
“ Analysis and interpretation of stellar spectra and nucleosynthesis processes in evolved stars ” D. A. García-Hernández (IAC Support Astronomer) Instituto.
Atomic Spectroscopy for Space Applications: Galactic Evolution l M. P. Ruffoni, J. C. Pickering, G. Nave, C. Allende-Prieto.
26 June 2008SHINE, Zermatt, UT1 High-energy Elemental, Isotopic, and Charge-State Composition in 3 He-rich Solar Energetic Particle Events M.E. Wiedenbeck.
Presolar grains and AGB stars Maria Lugaro Sterrenkundig Instituut University of Utrecht.
Isotopic constraints on nucleosynthesis, Solar System composition & accretion Nikitha Susan Saji Centre for Star and Planet Formation, Natural History.
The Chemistry of Extrasolar Planetary Systems J. Bond, D. O’Brien and D. Lauretta.
Earth’s Mantle: A View Through Volcanism’s Window William M. White Dept. of Earth & Atmospheric Sciences Cornell University Ithaca NY USA William M. White.
14 N/ 15 N ratios in AGB C-stars and the origin of SiC grains Eurogenesis- Perugia Workshop, Nov 12-14, 2012 C. Abia R. Hedrosa (Granada) B. Plez (Montpellier)
Stellar Evolution Beyond the Main Sequence. On the Main Sequence Hydrostatic Equilibrium Hydrogen to Helium in Core All sizes of stars do this After this,
Element abundances of bare planetary nebula central stars and the shell burning in AGB stars Klaus Werner Institut für Astronomie und Astrophysik Universität.
The neutron source for the weak component of the s-process: latest experimental results Claudio Ugalde University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and.
永島一秀, 小林幸雄, 坂本直哉, 殿谷梓, 圦本尚義 東工大・地球惑星科学 Presolar Silicates in meteorites Presolar Silicates in Primitive Chondrites Mar. 02, 2005 K. Nagashima, S. Kobayashi,
Composition and Mass Loss. 2 Two of the major items which can affect stellar evolution are Composition: The most important variable is Y – the helium.
3D Numerical Simulations of Thermohaline Mixing in Low-Mass Red Giants Pavel Denisenkov, UVic.
Percentage Composition. Percent Composition Compounds are ALWAYS composed of elements in fixed ratios. This is often referred to as the Law of Definite.
Setting the Stage for Evolution & Nucleosynthesis of Cluster AGB Stars Using Pulsation Analysis Devika Kamath Research School of Astronomy & Astrophysics.
Study of the s-process in low mass stars of Galactic disc metallicity
Yields from single AGB stars Amanda Karakas Research School of Astronomy & Astrophysics Mt Stromlo Observatory.
LMS & IMS: their evolution, nucleosynthesis and dusty end S. Cristallo in collaboration with Oscar Straniero and Luciano Piersanti Osservatorio Astronomico.
Atoms: The Building Blocks of Matter Unit 2.  Introduction to the Atom Modern Atomic Theory Subatomic Particles Isotopes Ions Essential Standards and.
ERMSAR 2012, Cologne March 21 – 23, 2012 Analysis of Corium Behavior in the Lower Plenum of the Reactor Vessel during a Severe Accident Rae-Joon Park,
Two types of supernovae
6 - Stellar Evolution-I. The life history of a star is determined by its mass…..
The Chemistry of Extrasolar Planetary Systems Jade Bond PhD Defense 31 st October 2008.
Some preliminary conclusions i) This mini-workshop: intended as an inter-CRP Eurogenesis meeting ii) Putting it immediately after Acona helped in having.
Evolution of Newly Formed Dust in Population III Supernova Remnants and Its Impact on the Elemental Composition of Population II.5 Stars Takaya Nozawa.
Center for Stellar and Planetary Astrophysics Monash University Summary prepared by John Lattanzio, Oct 2003 Abundances in M92.
The Abundances of Light Neutron- Capture Elements in Planetary Nebulae Nick Sterling NASA Goddard Space Flight Center June 19, 2007 Collaborators: Harriet.
Institute for Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of Tübingen, Germany June 29, 2005Planetary Nebulae as Astronomical Tools, Gdansk, Poland1 Light and.
Physical Conditions of Supernova Ejecta Probed with the Sizes of Presolar Al 2 O 3 Grains - 超新星起源プレソーラー Al 2 O 3 粒子の形成環境 - (Nozawa, Wakita, Hasegawa, Kozasa,
Naomi Pequette. 1.Core Hydrogen Burning 2.Shell Hydrogen Burning 3.First Dredge Up 4.The Bump in the Luminosity Function 5.Core Helium Flash 6.Core Helium.
Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research High resolution X-ray spectroscopy of the Interstellar Medium (ISM) C. Pinto (SRON), J. S. Kaastra (SRON),
Presolar Grains & Meteorites
Ciro Pinto(1) J. S. Kaastra(1,2), E. Costantini(1), F. Verbunt(1,2)
Presolar Grains Bulk of material in the solar system is a mixture from a large number of stellar source---mixing in interstellar medium or during solar.
Magnesium-rich Basalts on Mercury
The Giant Branches Workshop - Lorentz Center,
Department of Terrestrial Magnetism Carnegie Institution of Washington
Sachiko Amari Washington University St. Louis MO, USA
Nucleosynthesis in Early Massive Stars: Origin of Heavy Elements
Composition and Mass Loss
Presentation transcript:

The composition of presolar spinel grain OC2: constraining AGB models Maria Lugaro University of Utrecht, The Netherlands Amanda I. Karakas McMaster University, Canada Larry R. Nittler, Conel M. O'D. Alexander Carnegie Institution of Washington, USA Peter Hoppe Max-Planck-Institute for Chemistry, Germany Christian Iliadis University of North Carolina, USA John C. Lattanzio Monash University, Australia

Scanning electron microscope image of presolar spinel grain OC2. This 800nm ruby- like gem is sitting on a gold pedestal, following the ion probe isotopic analysis, because the gold substrate sputters faster than the grain does.

The most remarkable feature of the composition of OC2 is large excesses of the heavy Mg isotopes. Of ≈600 known presolar oxide grains, only 10 have 18 O/ 16 O ratios as low as that of OC2. The origin of grain OC2 has been tentatively attributed to an intermediate-mass AGB star ≈ M  +117% of solar +43% of solar 3.3  solar solar/26

The temperature in the convective pulses exceeds ≈350 million degrees. 25 Mg and 26 Mg are produced in similar amount by 22 Ne+  and then mixed into the envelope by the third dredge-up. The temperature at the base of the convective envelope exceeds ≈50 million degrees and hot bottom burning, (HBB) occurs: 17 O is produced, 18 O is destroyed, and 25 Mg can be turned into 26 Al.

26 Al is incorporated in spinel and decays into 26 Mg in 0.7 million years. Aluminium was incorporated in spinel grains ≈25 times more preferentially than Mg, given that spinel is MgAl 2 O 4, i.e. Al/Mg=2 while it is 0.08 in the Solar System. We find the following conditions to match the Mg composition of OC2: 1.T in the convective pulses > 352 million degrees and/or total mass TDU > 0.05 M  2.T at the base of the convective envelope ≈ million degrees. These are verified in our 5,0.008 and 6.5,0.02 models. We compare the composition of OC2 to our detailed models of AGB stars Maximum temperatures at the base of the convective envelope in million degrees.

All models deplete 18 O very quickly and cannot match OC2. However, the measured 18 O/ 16 O ratio can be explained by a 2% level of terrestrial contamination, which is reasonable O/ 16 O ≈ 16 O(p,  ) 17 F/ 17 O(p,  ) 14 N. This increases with T and is too high in our models to match OC2.

If we take the upper limit for the 17 O(p,  ) 14 N rate (+25%) and the lower limit for the 16 O(p,  ) 17 F rate (-43% ) we obtain a solution for the 17 O/ 16 O ratio of OC2 using the same models that match its Mg composition.

Alternative solution: a low-mass ( M  ) low-Z ( ) AGB star. In this case 25 Mg and 26 Mg are also produced by n-captures in the 13 C pocket. To get the extra needed 26 Al and the right O ratios, one must invoke some extra mixing - cool bottom processing.

The Fe and Cr composition:  ( 57 Fe/ 56 Fe)  ( 54 Cr/ 52 Cr)  ( 50 Cr/ 52 Cr)  ( 53 Cr/ 52 Cr) IM AGB Z ≈ Z  LM AGB Z ≈ 0.3 Z  OC2 ≈ 80≈  191 ≈ 180 Negative? +≈  117 ≈ 0 Negative? 26   45 Effect of Galactic chemical evolution?

Summary and conclusions 1 1.The O, Mg and Al composition of OC2 could be produced by an IM-AGB of Z≈Z , or by a LM-AGB of Z≈0.3 Z  with efficient extra mixing. The large uncertainty in the Fe composition of OC2 does not allow us to determine which model is better, but the Cr composition favors the origin in an IM-AGB star. 2.Using our IM-AGB models it is possible to find a solution. Conditions are: TDU mass > 0.05 M  and/or T intershell > 360 million degrees, T HBB ≈ million degrees, upper limit for the 17 O(p,  ) 14 N rate, lower limit for the 16 O(p,  ) 17 F rate.

Further laboratory analysis may identify additional grains with isotopic compositions similar to OC2 and thus provide more opportunities to test the findings of the present work. We need to compare OC2 to models computed with different physics assumptions to analyze stellar model uncertainties and derive constraints on the choice of the physics in AGB models. Summary and conclusions 2: this is just the beginning!