1 An Introduction to Carbon Markets Financial Markets Group London School of Economics 15 May 2008 Sam Fankhauser IDEAcarbon.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Latin American Carbon Forum 2011 C ARBON TRADING BEYOND 2012: NEW APPROACHES AND EMERGING MARKET INSTRUMENTS Latin America Carbon Forum San José, Costa.
Advertisements

Global GHG Market Update Daniele Violetti Team Leader Registration and Issuance Unit Sustainable Development Mechanisms Programme UNFCCC Carbon Forum America.
The CDM: a review of its development and status of the carbon markets Dr. Oscar Coto II National CDM Workshop Belize August 2011.
Carbon Emissions. Increasing atmospheric CO2 concentration Atmospheric increase = Emissions from fossil fuels + Net emissions from changes in land use.
UNFCCC Secretariat Overview of the CDM and the CDM project Cycle Training-Workshop to support the “Uganda Municipal Waste Compost Programme” Kampala, Uganda,
Federal Cap-and-Trade Policy: Overview of Design Options Ray Hammarlund, KCC Energy Programs Division Director Presentation to Kansas Energy Council Greenhouse.
1 TETRIS Work Package 6 – Quantitative Analysis of International Emissions Trading Christoph Böhringer, Ulf Moslener, and Niels Anger TETRIS Final Conference,
South Africa and Climate Change. Economy Middle-income, emerging market with and abundant supply of natural resources Well developed financial, legal,
Japan in Copenhagen Fix the Unfair Kyoto Burden-Sharing! 5 May 2009 Anna Korppoo Senior Researcher The Finnish Institute of International Affairs.
Green investment scheme and climate change mitigation policy in Ukraine Stavchuk Iryna Climate change program coordinator National ecological centre of.
30/10/2006 MARKET BASED MECHANISMS TO FIGHT CLIMATE CHANGE Jean-François Conil-Lacoste Chief Executive Officer, Powernext SA APEX Conference October 30,
Lessons learned from EU Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS)
UNDP, Bangkok, 1 April 2008 AWG on Further Commitments In-session workshop on means to reach emission reduction targets CDM Experiences and Lessons.
EU Roadmap for moving to a competitive low carbon economy in 2050
EcoSecurities Group Ltd All Rights Reserved EcoSecurities is the leading global GHG advisor (selected by Readers of Environmental Finance.
CARBON CREDITS.
The proposed Carbon Pricing Scheme Minerals Week 2011 Seamus French Chief Executive Anglo American Metallurgical Coal.
EU and UK experience: Lessons learned Martin Nesbit Deputy Director, Climate and Energy – Business and Transport UK Department for Environment, Food and.
Carbon Trading How does the EU Scheme function and how important is it? Tony White Head of Research Climate Change Capital.
Introduction to Climate Change: - global warming - basis steps in a clean development project - connection of CDM with European Trading Scheme Wim Maaskant.
Carbon markets An international tool for cost-effective GHG mitigation.
Page 1 AEM Board Meeting August 2007 Climate Change Calculations And Implications John T. Disharoon Sustainable Development Manager Caterpillar Inc.
GF I NVEST AG F INANCIAL S OLUTIONS 1 Introduction to the Emissions Market February 2008 Mélanie Stauffer GF I NVEST AG F INANCIAL S OLUTIONS.
Market Mechanisms to Curb Greenhouse Gases: Challenges and Future Directions Joe Kruger February 20, 2007 Joe Kruger February 20, 2007.
INTERNATIONAL EMISSIONS TRADING ASSOCIATION Crans Montana, CH September 19, 2008 Henry Derwent President and CEO International Emissions Trading Association.
Overview of Carbon Markets and US Federal Proposals to Regulate GHGs American College of Construction Lawyers and Princeton University Joint Symposium.
The implementation status of specific mechanisms under Kyoto Protocol EU-ETS 13 May 2013 Geta Diaconu.
1 Cap and Trade for Regulating Greenhouse Gases Presented by Scott Murtishaw Advisor to President Peevey, CPUC NASUCA Mid-Year Meeting San Francisco June.
Overview of Carbon Markets Voluntary & Compliance Markets: Existing Carbon Reduction Units Vladimir Litvak RBEC Energy and Environment Practice Leader.
....innovating clean energy solutions…. Glenn S. Hodes UNEP Risø Center CARBON FINANCE.
1 Macroeconomic Impacts of EU Climate Policy in AIECE November 5, 2008 Olavi Rantala - Paavo Suni The Research Institute of the Finnish Economy.
© 2006 UNDP. All Rights Reserved Worldwide. Proprietary and Confidential. Not For Distribution Without Prior Written Permission. State and Trends of the.
Carbon credits - origination to commercialisation© 2006 EcoSecurities Group plc CleanTech and Carbon in the Pacific Northwest Seattle, WA November 8, 2007.
International Framework and Kyoto Protocol. UNFCCC Conference of the parties (annual meeting) –Review implementation –Consider new needs –Subgroups Creates.
Current Trends in the Carbon Market Robbie Louw 26-27June 2007.
Regulation Against Global Warming in an Unequal World Sylvestre Gaudin Hultberg.
Presentation to the Climate Change Leadership Forum 1.Proposal for an Australian ETS 2.Update on USA, Japan & EU ETS 6 August 2008 Dave Brash.
AGEC/FNR 406 LECTURE 21 Atmospheric Concentrations of Carbon Dioxide,
Deregulation and Cap/Trade Gary Flomenhoft, Energy Policy Week 2.
Lessons from implementing the EU Emission Trading System DG Environment European Commission Side event 2009 Climate Change.
1 “Using Carbon Markets to Encourage the Uptake of Low Carbon Vehicles” Meeting the Low Carbon Challenge The Low Carbon Vehicle Partnership Third Annual.
ECOPLAN 1 Climate-Policy Induced Technology Exports – Potential and Risk Technology Transfer and Investment Risk in International Emissions Trading Summary.
The Carbon Market Karan Capoor World Bank Carbon & Environmental Finance BioCarbon Fund Washington DC, 12 September 2005 The findings and opinions expressed.
Large Industrial Emitters Emissions Trading Natural Resources Canada March 14, 2003.
Kyoto Protocol IDC3O3 Ms. Nguyen.
Offsets as Common Currency: U.S. and Canadian Offset Programs World Resources Institute Exploring the Challenges and Opportunities for Establishing a North.
Overview on CDM By Ann Gordon Ministry of Natural Resources and the Environment 14 th July 2011.
Carbon Revenue and MFIs: Making it Work Marco van der Linden Ramesh K. Gautam.
Training Seminar for the BioCarbon Fund Projects
Permit supply from the CDM Nico van der Linden ECN Policy Studies, the Netherlands.
Ch. 6. Externality Examples Cap and Trade –Acid rain and SO2 –CO2 and greenhouse gases.
The EU Emissions Trading Scheme and its review Thomas Bernheim DG Environment, unit C.2 European Commission.
Challenges and Opportunities for Addressing Global Climate Change February 2006.
Clean Development Mechanisms and New Market Developments Presentation at the Regional Conference on Gas Flare Reductions Tashkent, 15 th June 2012.
The Challenges of Regional Climate Policy Cooperation – A Canadian Perspective David McLaughlin President and CEO NRTEE.
Environmental Industries Sector Unit CDM Opportunities in South Korea Greg Dunne, Director, ICECAP Ltd. Seoul, 25 th September 2006 EISU Seminar Mission.
Sustainable Development: Cooperation in FEALAC Sustainable Development: Cooperation in FEALAC October ,200 7 Economy and Society WG Delegation of Japan.
 Cap and Trade Application: Global Warming 6. 2.
Overview of Carbon Markets SIO Fall 2007 Environmental Science and Policy Forum Mitigation and Adaption in a High CO2 World 1 Melanie McCutchan MPIA Candidate.
Dutch presidency agenda on ensuring industrial competitiveness Erik Janssen, Ministry of Economic Affairs The Netherlands.
1 9 th February 2008 © New Carbon Finance, 2007 Cap and Trade Systems: The European Experience Milo Sjardin Head, New Carbon Finance North America.
Brief Overview of Legal Framework: UNFCCC and Kyoto Protocol M.J.Mace Climate Change and Energy Programme, FIELD LDC Workshop Montreal Canada November.
World Regional Geography Unit I: Introduction to World Regional Geography Lesson 4: Solutions to Global Warming Debate.
Clean Technology (PB386) Click to edit Master title style Numfon Eaktasang, Ph.D.
September 29, 2009 Sagacarbon seminar, sofia.
The Failure of Cap and Trade in GHG Emissions Controls
Pricing carbon International Consulting Economists’ Association London 11 November 2014 Sam Fankhauser London School of Economics and Vivid Economics.
2018/11/29 Prospect and future of climate change regime: Implications of Unilateral CDM linked with CER discounting scheme for Korean commitment beyond.
Carbon Finance Unit, The World Bank
Canada’s Regulatory Framework for Greenhouse Gas Emissions
Presentation transcript:

1 An Introduction to Carbon Markets Financial Markets Group London School of Economics 15 May 2008 Sam Fankhauser IDEAcarbon

2 Overview Why markets? The efficiency of markets Permits vs. taxes Carbon markets EU Emissions Trading System The Kyoto mechanisms Voluntary markets The future of carbon markets Creating a market Policy environment: the global deal

3 The need for emission cuts From the Stern Review

4 United States Can-Aus-NZ Russia Japan W. Europe E ITs Middle East China Latin America Other Asia Other Africa India Population (Million) Emissions (Tonnes of Carbon Per Capita) South Africa Developing country (non-Annex I) countries Sharing the abatement burden

5 The benefits of emissions trading Source: Manne and Richels (1998) US$ billion Cost of meeting Kyoto targets for the USA, 2010 Effectiveness Track record in reducing emissions Efficiency emission reduction at lower costs Integration Finance and technology flow to emerging markets

6 Taxes vs permits Economic efficiency argument Taxes: certain cost, uncertain quantity Permits: uncertain cost, certain quantity Optimal choice depends on the slope of marginal abatement, damage cost curves (Weitzman)

7 Taxes vs permits Marg. Abatement Cost Flat MB curve Marg. Abatement Cost Steep MB curve target MAC MB

8 Taxes vs permits Marg. Abatement Cost Choose tax Marg. Abatement Cost Choose permits target MAC MB

9 Taxes vs permits Political economy arguments are more conclusive International carbon tax agreement difficult to achieve Domestically, industry prefers (grandfathered) permits

10 Grandfathering – a source of profit Meuro (2006) CEZ: Revenues EBITDA Value of EUAs Net sales 5,625 2, Drax: Revenues EBITDA Value of EUAs Compliance purchases RWE: Revenues EBITDA Value of EUAs Compliance purchases 44,256 7,861 2,

11 Overview Why markets? The efficiency of markets Permits vs. taxes Carbon markets EU Emissions Trading System The Kyoto mechanisms Voluntary markets The future of carbon markets Creating a market Policy environment: the global deal

12 More than one carbon market Allowance market (cap-and-trade) EUAEU Emissions Trading System AAUKyoto International Emissions Trading Kyoto mechanisms (baseline-and-trade) CERClean Development Mechanism ERUJoint Implementation Voluntary market CFIChicago Climate Exchange VERVoluntary carbon offsets

13 …dominated by the EU ETS Source: World Bank

14 Heterogeneous prices Source: Reuters Interactive

15 Clean Development Mechanism Annex I firm/country financing emission reductions in a non-Annex I country Joint Implementation Same as CDM but between entities in Annex I countries International emissions trading Trade of AAUs between Annex I parties Green Investment Schemes The Kyoto Mechanisms

16 TechnologiesSellers Source: World Bank A closer look at the CDM

17 A growing pipeline Source: IDEAcarbon / ECON Global Carbon Report

18 Accounting for project risks

19 Kyoto supply Number of Projects PDD volume pre (mt) Predicted delivery (mt) CDM - issuing CDM –registered CDM - under validation 1,5481, CDM - before validation 3, JI - all stages Total pre-20126,2363,0502,052

20 CER Supply

21 Compliance Demand CategoryPurchaserAmount per yearTotal Non-EU ETSEU Governments Canada1470 Switzerland210 Norway735 New Zealand735 Australia Japan (public) Japan (private) Sub-total EU ETS*15 – 90*45 – 450* Total , ,920

22 Serve public sector demand first Less price elastic Price differentiation allows to charge more Serve private sector demand Price elastic, demand determined by in-house abatement options Downward pressure on prices Bank supplies into post-2012 period Regulatory uncertainty means sale at a discount Clearing the market Inventory is larger than potential demand

23 The market

24 Question mark: AAUs Source: World Bank

25 11,000 installations in 27 EU countries Energy, refining, minerals, metals, pulp&paper Annual compliance requirement Targets set in National Allocation Plans Mostly grandfathering, some auctioning Possibility to import Kyoto carbon At least three trading phases Phase I Phase II Phase III EU Emissions Trading Scheme

26 Price volatility Source: IDEAcarbon / ECON Global Carbon Report … a sign of insufficient market information

27 Collapse of phase I price Source: IDEAcarbon / ECON Global Carbon Report

28 National Allocation Plan Both phase II and phase III through banking Ratio of coal to gas price Determines fuel switching Marginal abatement cost elsewhere Weather Cooling / heating demand Hydro availability Output / GDP Process emissions in industry Electricity demand Price drivers in the EU ETS

29 Prospects for Phase II

30 Chicago Climate Exchange Self-described as “world’s first and North America’s only voluntary, legally binding, rules- based GHG reduction and trading system” Established in 2000 with currently 312 (voluntary) members power, automotive, chemical industry; banks, universities, municipalities; project developers, offset aggregators, NGOs Six gases, both allowance-based and offset credits In 2006 about 10.3 MtCO 2 e were transacted, worth US$91m; as of July MtCO 2 e had been traded on the exchange

31 Overview Why markets? The efficiency of markets Permits vs. taxes Carbon markets EU Emissions Trading System The Kyoto mechanisms Voluntary markets The future of carbon markets Creating a market Policy environment: the global deal

32 Growing European market Source: IDEAcarbon, ECX

33 US state-level Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) Western US Initiative California AB 32 US federal level Lieberman-Warner Climate Security Act Before the Senate in H Other bills in both House and Senate Canada Intensity targets for large emitters North America

34 New Zealand (NZ ETS) Starts trading in summer 2008 with forestry Covering all emissions by 2013 (industrial processes by 2010) Australia (AETS) Starts trading in 2011 Covering >70% of emissions (ex. Agriculture, forestry, fugitive emissions) Japan Focus on voluntary schemes (JVETS) Asia - Pacific

35 Permit allocation Auctioning, grandfathering, benchmarking Scope Difficult sectors like agriculture, transport Upstream vs. downstream Safety valves against price spikes Carbon leakage and competitiveness Linking with other schemes CDM imports Linking with other schemes (e.g. NZ – Aus) Open issues

36 Carbon markets in practically all OECD countries Regional schemes linked by an extended, enhanced CDM Underlying assets: 7.5 billion allowances, worth 200 billion? Of which > 4 billion in a US federal scheme? Trading volume: 8 – 13 billion tCO2 What is the global deal? Long-term: Markets in 2020

37 The “global deal” Long-term target: a 50% cut by 2050 For a ppm stabilisation target Consistent with G8, EU rhetoric Equitable burden-sharing Up to 80% cut in developed countries Developing countries get help on technology, carbon finance The next 6 months are crucial Target: agreement by 2009, ratified in 2012 Next step: G8 Japan (summer); COP (Poznan)

38 Contact Details Tel