Southern & Eastern Asia Government SS7CG7a. Compare and contrast the federal republic of The Republic of India, the communist state of The People’s Republic of China, and the constitutional monarchy of Japan, distinguishing the form of leadership and the role of the citizen in terms of voting rights and personal freedoms.
Use the Governments of Southern & Eastern Asia chart to take notes
Republic - form of government in which power is explicitly vested in the people, who in turn exercise their power through elected representatives.
India
The Republic of India has a parliamentary system of government. Structure of Government: India The Republic of India has a parliamentary system of government.
Form of Leadership: India The President is the head (chief) of state and is elected by an electoral college to a 5-year term The Prime Minister is the head of the government and the head of the majority party of the legislative branch (and head of the cabinet).
Role of the Citizen: India Parliament is divided into two houses. The “House of the People” is elected by Indian citizens. The “Council of States” is elected by the “House of the People”. All citizens 18 and over may vote for their legislators
Personal Freedoms: India Other than voting, the Indian constitution also gives citizens the freedom of speech, freedom of assembly, and freedom of religion Indians are given the right to conserve their language and culture and to establish schools to teach about their cultures http://www.state.gov/j/drl/rls/hrrpt/humanrightsreport/index.htm#wrapper
Federal Republic of India India has 28 states and seven union territories that have the independence to settle problems of law and order This information is already typed on the table because students do not have to know this information specifically. However, they will use the information to answer the question about how India’s government distributes power as a way to review standard CG6a. (individual states in India are more tightly controlled by the central government than states in the U.S.) *This is already typed on your table in the other column*
Based on the information about India, turn to a seat partner and answer the following questions on your notes: 1. How does the government distribute power: unitary, confederation, or federal. Provide evidence for your answer. 2. How does the government determine citizen participation: autocratic, oligarchic, or democratic. If democratic, identify which type. Provide evidence for your answer.
China
The Communist state of the People’s Republic of China Structure of Government: China The Communist state of the People’s Republic of China
Structure of Government: China A communist state in theory is when all means of production are owned in common, rather than by individuals. In practice, a single authoritarian party controls both the political and economic systems. Although China is called a republic, true power lies with the ruling Communist Party (Chinese Communist Party the CCP)
Form of leadership: China The President is the head of state and is elected by the National People’s Congress (China’s legislature) The Premier is the head of government and is the head of the ruling party, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) The State Council, which functions as a cabinet, is appointed by the National People’s Congress.
Role of the Citizen: China The communist constitution gives rights to Chinese citizens, including the right to vote for every person over the age of 18. However, these rights are meaningless because in communist China the actions of citizens are dictated by the government.
Role of the Citizen: China For example, Chinese citizens have the right to vote, but only for candidates of the CCP. These candidates when elected have little power because high-ranking officials appointed by the government make the decisions.
Personal Freedoms: China China’s communist government has a history of violating the personal freedoms of its citizens by denying them freedom of speech, freedom of worship, and even safety from physical harm and political persecution. Recently, China has begun to make efforts to better protect its citizens’ personal freedoms. http://www.state.gov/j/drl/rls/hrrpt/humanrightsreport/index.htm#wrapper
*This is already typed on your table in the other column* China China has 23 provinces which have provincial People’s Congresses. However, only CCP approved candidates may be elected. This information is already typed on the table because students do not have to know this information specifically. However, they will use the information to answer the question about how India’s government distributes power as a way to review standard CG6a. *This is already typed on your table in the other column*
China’s official name is The People’s Republic of China China’s official name is The People’s Republic of China. Based on our earlier definition of a republic and your knowledge now of China’s system of government, why is this name inaccurate?
Based on the information about China, turn to a seat partner and answer the following questions on your notes: 1. How does the government distribute power: unitary, confederation, or federal. Provide evidence for your answer. 2. How does the government determine citizen participation: autocratic, oligarchic, or democratic. If democratic, identify which type. Provide evidence for your answer.
Japan
Structure of Government: Japan Constitutional Monarchy that follows a parliamentary system of government
Structure of Government: Japan After World War II, Japan worked with Western powers to establish a new constitution that preserved the traditional empire of Japan while creating a modern system of democracy Students do not have to write this down. It will be covered more in-depth in the history lesson.
Form of leadership: Japan Japan is a constitutional monarchy because the power of the Emperor is very limited. As a ceremonial figurehead, he is defined by the constitution as "the symbol of the state and of the unity of the people.“ Therefore, the Emperor is the head of state. The Prime Minister is the head of government that is elected by the Diet (Japan’s legislature)
Role of the Citizen: Japan The Prime Minister is also the leader of the majority party of the House of Representatives (one of the two houses of the Diet) Japanese citizens elect members of the House of Representatives Japanese citizens have the right to vote after the age of 20.
Personal Freedoms: Japan The constitution established rights and personal freedoms for Japanese citizens including freedom of speech, freedom of religion, equal rights for women, and equal education. The constitution renounces war as a method of solving problems in Japan and prohibits Japan from having a military.
Constitutional Monarchy of Japan Japan has 47 Prefectures (Japan’s word for states), but they do not have any independent authority. Instead, they carry out the laws and policies of the national government. This information is already typed on the table because students do not have to know this information specifically. However, they will use the information to answer the question about how India’s government distributes power as a way to review standard CG6a. *This is already typed on your table in the other column*
Based on the information about Japan, turn to a seat partner and answer the following questions on your notes: 1. How does the government distribute power: unitary, confederation, or federal. Provide evidence for your answer. 2. How does the government determine citizen participation: autocratic, oligarchic, or democratic. If democratic, identify which type. Provide evidence for your answer.
The next few slides are going to show different images The next few slides are going to show different images. Your task is to identify which country or countries the image could represent. You must include an explanation for your choices.
1. Illustrates India and Japan because the people are able to elect representation in their government. Chinese citizens can elect officials, but it is not a true free election
2. Illustrates China because the people are really not free to be and do what they really want to do because of government oppression and persecution
3. Illustrates India and Japan because of the parliamentary system in which the head of government is selected from the legislative branch and not elected separately.
4. Illustrates more than likely China because the people really do not have their own voice.
4. Illustrates India, China, and Japan because all three countries do allow citizens to vote. The freedom of that vote varies from India and Japan to China.
Constitution 5. Illustrates India, China, and Japan because all three countries have constitutions.
6. Illustrates China because one again citizens do not really have their own voice
7. Illustrates India, China, and Japan because all three do allow citizens to vote at some level.