“No Quantum, Little Solace” Big Data & Analytics In Government of Karnataka Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Our Vision To create a “Single Source of Truth Platform” for all the departments and to Sanitize their databases by leveraging the uniqueness of AADHAAR. This is to ensure that eligible person gets his/her service through transparent, accountable and streamlined processes. Karnataka Resident Data Hub,CeG,Government of Karnataka

Authentication & e-KYC Services of KRDH Services of KRDH SEEDING Cross reference (Golden record) Resident Portal Authentication & e-KYC eSign (In Process) Digital Locker Change Data Control (CDC) KRDH through mobile Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) Karnataka Resident Data Hub,CeG,Government of Karnataka

Without KRDH Karnataka Resident Data Hub,CeG,Government of Karnataka NAME :VINODA SATISH GANGAVATI OCCUPATION : GROUP D GOVERNMENT OFFICER BENEFITS IN THE NAME OF ELEGIBILITY CRITERIA FOOD AND CIVIL SUPPLIES HEAD OF THE FAMILY : SATISH GANGAVATI SHREEDHAR PRATIMADEVI VINODA NON GOVERNMENT OFFICIAL HRMS Smt . VINODA C M NO PENSION (PHYSICALLY HANDICAPPED PENSION) VINODA SATHISH GANAGAVATI SHOULD BE POOR BPL CARD SATHISH GANGAVATHI YES NOT AN GOVERNEMNT EMPLOYEE Smt. VINODA C M NREGA ( JOB CARD ) ADDRESS PROOF(LOCALITY OF THAT GRAMA PANCHAYATH) VOTER ID VINOD VERIFYING DEPT NAME MATCH RESULT Smt . VINODA C M GOT BPL CARD FOR FAMILY VINODA VINODA SATHISH GANGAVATHI VINODA SATHISH GANAGAVATI GOT OAP FOR HIMSELF Smt . VINODA C M VINODA Smt . VINODA C M GOT JOB CARD FOR HIMSELF VINOD Karnataka Resident Data Hub,CeG,Government of Karnataka

With KRDH Karnataka Resident Data Hub,CeG,Government of Karnataka NAME :VINODA SATISH GANGAVATI OCCUPATION : GROUP D GOVERNMENT OFFICER With KRDH BENEFITS IN THE NAME OF ELEGIBILITY CRITERIA VERIFYING DEPT NAME MATCH RESULT FOOD AND CIVIL SUPPLIES HEAD OF THE FAMILY : SATISH GANGAVATI 231745072202 SHREEDHAR PRATIMADEVI VINODA NON GOVERNMENT OFFICIAL HRMS Smt . VINODA C M 745072202 YES PENSION (PHYSICALLY HANDICAPPED PENSION) VINODA SATHISH GANAGAVATI SHOULD BE POOR NO DATA FOUND NOT AN GOVERNEMNT EMPLOYEE Smt. VINODA C M NO NREGA ( JOB CARD ) 231746072202 ADDRESS PROOF(LOCALITY OF THAT GRAMA PANCHAYATH) VOTER ID VINOD 23174507220 231745072202 BPL CARDS CANCELLED 231745072202 PHP CANCELLED 231745072202 231745072202 231745072202 JOB CARD CANCELLED Karnataka Resident Data Hub,CeG,Government of Karnataka

Cross Reference/ Golden Record Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

KRDH Roadmap 1 2 3 4 7 5 6 10 11 12 8 9 MILESTONES…. VERSION 2 Department:8 Data count: 207125 2 3 4 KUA/KSA PVC card printing 7 VERSION 1 Department:13 Data count: VERSION 3 Department:12 Data count: 74487 AUA/ASA Department:1 5 VERSION 4 Department:12 Data count: 12.21 crores 6 ELEGIBILTY ANALYITCS 10 11 12 Dec 2012 July 2013 14 Dec 2014 17 Dec 2014 Mar 2015 Sep 2015 Nov 2015 Feb 2016 June 2016 June 2016 Dec 2016 2017 Seeding through mGov 8 eSIGN 9 DIGILOCKER CDC DBT 2017v Karnataka Resident Data Hub,CeG,Government of Karnataka

Desired outcomes through Analytics Intra Departmental Analytics Duplicates/Multiples in schemes within department Duplicates/Multiples in terms of location Age analysis Gender analysis Migration analysis Ghost entries Inter Departmental Analytics Eligibility criteria analysis Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

KRDH – Data Processed of beneficiary departments Category FCS NREGA DSSP Minority BCWD-Scholarship Education department Number of Beneficiary 52740802 14272000 4543591 127909 2323000 10000000 In KRDH 6361355 (12.06%) 5666203 (39.7%) 1209209 (26.61%) 59464 (46.49%) 376927 (16.23%) 66825 (0.67%) Error in Data 2183177 (34.32%) 2448411 (43.21%) 52363(43.30%) 23223 (39.05%) 230364 (61.12%) 35274 (52.79%) Mapped 4178178 (65.68%) 3217792 (56.79%) 690312 (57.09%) 36162 (60.81%) 146563 (38.88%) 31551 (47.21) Auto cleansed 1516126 (36.29%) 1774564 (55.15%) 244623 (35.44%) 17131 (47.37%) 87563 (59.74%) 16850 (53.41%) Rejected 109565 (2.62%) 175630 (5.46%) 7675 (1.11%) 43 (0.12%) 20 (0.01%) 93 (0.29%) To be Cleansed 2552487 (61.09%) 1267598 (39.39%) 438014 (63.45%) 18988 (52.51%) 58980 (40.24%) 14608 (46.3%) Duplicate 103136 (2.47%) 184 (0.01%) 14839 (2.15%) 384 (1.06%) 0 (0%) 590 (1.87%) Triplicate 8042 (0.19%) 0 (0%) 520 (0.08%) 7 (0.02%) Multiple 2629 (0.06%) 30307 (4.39%) 0( 0%) 212 (0.67%) Karnataka Resident Data Hub,CeG,Government of Karnataka

KRDH – Data Processed of Eligible departments Category Election Commission HRMS BCWD (Survey) Number of Beneficiary 47000000 560000 61100000 In KRDH 23604762 (50.22%) 60184 (10.75%) 29897094 (48.93%) Error in Data 10813297 (45.81%) 16764 (27.85%) 13359586 (44.69%) Mapped 12791465 (54.19%) 43420 (72.15%) 16537508 (55.31%) Auto cleansed 3014030 (23.56%) 16365 (37.69%) 4798916 (29.02%) Rejected 2127895 (16.64%) 18 (0.04%) 5043271 (30.5%) To be Cleansed 7649540 (59.80%) 27037 (62.27%) 6695321 (40.49%) Duplicate 8838205 (69.09%) 268 (1.82%) 1643927 (9.94%) Triplicate 578874 (4.53%) 0 (0%) 22973 (0.14%) Multiple 1208224 (9.45%) 261 (1.77%) 778373 (4.71%) Karnataka Resident Data Hub,CeG,Government of Karnataka

Intra Department ineligibilities Category DSSP (690312) FCS (4178178) NREGA (3217792) Minority (36162) BCWD (Scholarship) (146563) Multiple Schemes 9169 - 8272 Multiple Locations 11 1007 184 35 Age Analysis <14 757 31865 12 26 14-17 819 18-30 11494 31-40 40070 330 323 41-59 61243 102 233 60-80 63487 9 33 81-100 2490 13525 1 2 >100 29 295 3 Gender Analysis ( DSSP - DWP & Maitri) M 2259 F T 15 Migration Analysis 2060 7964 949 Note: The above figures are indicative. The analysis is performed on the data set provided to KRDH by the department . The actual figures may vary.

Inter Department ineligibilities Departments FCS NREGA DSSP Minority HRMS BCWD(Scholarship) HRMS ( Employees and Dependents) 527 598 128 39 - 65 * Labour Department (Entrepreneur availing benefits) 205 96 22 6 1 Note: The above figures are indicative. The analysis is performed on the data set provided to KRDH by the department . The actual figures may vary. * - Department is yet to onboard KRDH. However, department has shared data with KRDH

Group A employee having BPL Ration Card HRMS - Group A FCS - BPL Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Group C employee Availing AAY HRMS –Group C FCS- AAY Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Group A employee possessing NREGA Job Card HRMS –Group A NREGA Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Group D employee Availing Pension HRMS –Group D DSSP - PHP Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Group C employee Availing Post Metric Scholarship HRMS –Group C Minority - Post Metric Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Group B employee Having Ration Card & Job Card FCS- Ration Card NREGA-Job card HRMS-Group B Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Old Age Pension < 10 yrs Can Old Age Pension be availed by 3 year old kid ??? Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Widow Pension for Male Despite registered as male in department database, he is availing widow pension The beneficiary is registered as female in department database however in AADHAAR the gender is identified as Male Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Gender mismatch in AADHAAR and Dept database. MAITRI taken by male Gender mismatch in AADHAAR and Dept database. Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

MANASWINI for Male The beneficiary is registered as Male in department database and still avails MANASWINI scheme pension Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Job card availed by <10yrs Is a kid < 10 years of age entitled for a Job Card ??? Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Widow Pension + Physically Handicapped Pension + Manaswini DSSP- MANASWINI DSSP- WP DSSP- PHP Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Pension availed at two locations Availing benefit in Navalagund Availing benefit in Ramdurg Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

FCS : Availing benefits at Multiple locations Availing Benefit in Kunigal Availing Benefit in Channapatna Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Minority Welfare : Merit cum Means Scholarship Availed by 43 Years Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Minority Welfare : Post Metric Scholarship Availed by < 10 Years Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Minority Welfare : Post Metric Scholarship Availed for over 60 Years Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Minority Welfare: Availing Benefits in multiple locations Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

NREGA: Availing Benefits in multiple locations Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

FCS - APL: Availing Benefits from DSSP Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka

Questions and Discussion Thank You Karnataka Resident Data Hub, CeG, Government of Karnataka