©Ofcom The Future of Regulation David Clarkson 30 th November 2005 Consult21 Broadband Working Group.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
BTs Plans for its NGN EU Open Workshop on NGN Policy and Regulatory Issues 22 June 2005 Ittai Hershman Director, 21CN Commercial Development BT Wholesale.
Advertisements

©Ofcom ERG views on continued development of roaming regulation March 2007.
1 Price squeeze tests in electronic communications: ARCEPs experience Competition Law and Electronic Communications Brussels, June 19, 2008.
Current Status of Notifications under the EU Consultation Procedure regarding Cable Networks CLEC Seminar - Electronic Communications Regulation and Cable.
11 Ofcom Consumer Switching final statement Next steps for BT Bev Bytheway-Jackson WBC Product Manager 10 th February 2014.
Connect. Communicate. Collaborate TNC Bruges, 22 May 2008 GÉANT2: The Good the Bad and the Ugly - What worked and what didn’t work? Robin G. Arak.
Colchester’s model for NGA deployment: approach, infrastructure and applications Jim Leask Senior Enterprise Officer Strategic Policy and Regeneration.
Water Quality Trading Claire Schary Water Quality Trading Coordinator U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Region 10, Seattle, WA Region 10, Seattle,
Into the Ofcom era Ed Richards Senior Partner, Strategy & Market Developments, Ofcom.
LLU and Broadband Regulation in France July 2005 Autorité de Régulation des Communications Electroniques et des Postes.
Market reviews and Narrowband Internet access Justin Moore Internet Project Manager, Oftel 9 April 2003.
© Copyright Ovum The role of the BTA and competition law A presentation to the Stakeholders’ Forum on further liberalisation David Lewin.
CEPS workshop: Promoting investment through competition ECTA European Competitive Telecoms Association.
©Ofcom A regulatory perspective on FTTx deployments Chinyelu Onwurah, Head of Telecoms Technology, Ofcom 19 th June 2007 FTTx Summit.
©Ofcom Review of the Framework Some issues under discussion by regulators Jim Niblett International Policy Director 22 December 2005.
©Ofcom Voice – the need to take a long term view on sector evolution Chris Rowsell 18 October 2007.
EStorage First Annual Workshop Arnhem, NL 30, Oct Olivier Teller.
Review of BEREC Common Positions Stage 1: high level principles on issues of non-discrimination Lara Stoimenova – Remedies EWG Chair Public workshop Brussels,
Regulatory issues raised by access upgrade investment: where we are in the UK debate Richard Budd Senior Regulatory, Economist, BT 16 September 2008
Regulatory Barriers to the Adoption and Diffusion of Stationary Fuel Cells in Ohio William M. Bowen Professor, Public Administration and Urban Studies.
1 ATUG Forum ACS Telecommunication Society of Australia (ACS-TSA) National Broadband Network Reference Model.
14 November 2014 PROGRESS ON BROADBAND POLICY & REGULATIONS Briefing to Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Telecommunications and Postal Services.
UK Broadband Regulatory Framework David Clarkson 16 th November 2011 NextGen 11 Conference, Bristol, November.
Cost sharing models of NGN rollout in rural or remote areas BEREC-EaPeReg-REGULATEL-EMERG Summit Barcelona, 2-3 July 2015.
©Ofcom NGN-based competition: An Ofcom perspective Dr Stephen Unger Director of Telecoms Technology 24 March 2005.
1 Broadband Delivery UK NextGen10 Robert Sullivan, CEO 23 rd November 2010.
Ofcom’s ‘Strategic Review’ of telecoms, 2004/5 Martin Fransman Professor of Economics and Founder-Director Institute for Japanese-European Technology Studies.
Broadband Internet Current and future challenges for regulators: a selection Athens – June 1, 2007 Philippe Defraigne Cullen International
Prentice Hall, Inc. © STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT & BUSINESS POLICY 10 TH EDITION THOMAS L. WHEELEN J. DAVID HUNGER CHAPTER 5 Internal Scanning: Organizational.
Instructore: Tasneem Darwish1 University of Palestine Faculty of Applied Engineering and Urban Planning Software Engineering Department Requirement engineering.
BT Transformation Working with the CWU. Defend Traditional Calls decline - 5 main factors Dial IP - Market declines, driven by Broadband Price - Market.
Financing Renewable Energy for Village Power Applications Grace S. Yeneza Managing Director, Preferred Energy, Inc. APEC Village Power Workshop Hanmer.
1 The Ladder of Investment in Spain NEREC, FEDEA Madrid, March 17, 2009 Ángel L. López SP-SP Research Center, IESE Business School.
Imposing access obligations under the new framework Karen Hardy.
Prof. Valeria Termini AEEGSI Commissioner CEER Vice-President CEER DSO WG co-Chair The Future Role of European DSOs 1.
1 Ensuring Competition & Growth in Next Generation Network (NGN) Presented by Melinda Tan 23 March 2006.
Envisioning the Future of Minnesota Transportation Finance Advisory Committee April 20, 2012.
PAKAMILE PONGWANA South Africa’s International and National Competitiveness 3-4 February 2015.
The Hard to Reach Areas NextGen 11 Scotland May 2011 © Avanti Communications Group plc.
Local Loop Unbundling PRESENTATION TO THE PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE 6 th JUNE 2007.
Can Offsets Deliver a Conservation Gain for Koalas in Queensland? Malcolm Eadie Director of Netgain Environments.
Telecommunications competition - a new entrant’s perspective on the UK experience Rickard Granberg 2 December 2008.
C.H. Montin, Tbilisi, 12 November Tbilisi, 12 November 2014 Developing Regulatory Impact Assessment In Georgia Defining the problem (issue), the.
Special Railways Phase III Proposed approach to regulatory changes Jakarta 16 May 2011.
1 Bandwidth for All Judith Mariscal Mexico City, September 5 th Acorn Redecom Conference 09.
POLICY DIRECTIONS David Bray, Economic and Policy Services Pty Ltd.
IMPLEMENTING THE AID: OFTEL CONSULTATION ON GUIDELINES BT’S PERSPECTIVE PAUL RICHARDS RAD July 8th 2002.
The public information campaign to communicate about the process of migration to BT’s next generation network Version 14 – 03 November 2008 Information.
Consult21 Consult21 Working Group – Broadband and LLU 3rd Meeting 19 April :00 – 14:00 WELCOME.
Consult21 Information is subject to change and is for discussion purposes only. Any dates/timings are the current anticipated timescales and may be subject.
Outlines Overview Defining the Vision Through Business Requirements
Constructing An Effective Statutory & Regulatory Framework for Broadband Networks Phoenix Center Symposium December 1, 2005 Disclaimer: Views presented.
Broadband and LLU Working Group 18 January Broadband and LLU Working Group Membership BT Industry representatives Terms of Reference To ensure a.
Economic regulation of electricity and gas network businesses Mark Feather, Acting Executive Director 23 November 2011.
t What is VoIP? t How this technology is changing business model in telecom industry?  How this theme has been discussed in the world ? t What are the.
State aid for broadband Internet development in Lithuania TAIEX Multi-beneficiary Workshop on TAIEX Assistance within Chapter 10 – Information society.
Mec1224 EETT: From Telecommunications to Electronic Communications Athens, 28 March 2005 “Investment and competition in electronic communications services.
Local loop Unbundling Dr. ZOUAKIA Rochdi ANRT. Presentation outline Definition of Unbundling local loop (LLU) Importance of LLU Types of LLU : Description.
Making Communications Work for Everyone: Ofcom’s Strategic Review of Digital Communications Jonathan Oxley, Group Director – Competition Group 10 May 2016.
Broadband Workshop Facilitating Broadband Investment French regulatory framework Bertrand Vandeputte ARCEP European Commission – DG INFSO March 23rd, 2011.
Broadband regulation in Denmark 24. September 2009 TRIS workshop Tomas Skov Lauridsen National IT and Telecom Agency, Denmark.
City of Cape Town input on the National ICT Policy March 2015.
©Ofcom EU Communications package : State of Implementation Kip Meek, Senior Partner, Content & Competition Brussels, 30 May 2005.
CARILEC. An Association of Electric Utilities CARILEC An Association of Electric Utilities The Caribbean Electric Utility Service Corporation (CARILEC)
CEF Action n° 2016-EU-SA-0009 "CYnergy"
Overview on Renewable energy in Bulgaria
12 March 2007 PT 2 TRIS Copenhagen Meeting March 2007
IP and NGN Projects in ITU-T Jean-Yves Cochennec France Telecom SG13 Vice Chair Workshop on Satellites in IP and Multimedia - Geneva, 9-11 December 2002.
Template and Process for Expression of Interest by Countries
Very High Capacity and 5G Networks: from the EU code to the EU market
Presentation transcript:

©Ofcom The Future of Regulation David Clarkson 30 th November 2005 Consult21 Broadband Working Group

©Ofcom1 Disclaimer The contents of this presentation do not represent Ofcom’s view about the outcome of the forthcoming Wholesale Broadband Access market review.

©Ofcom2 Agenda Overview of Current Regulatory Structure Ofcom’s Strategic Principles Current Products – Natural Selection LLU and FAS Next Generation Bit-stream Possible Future Regulatory Structure Ofcom’s High Level Goals

©Ofcom3 Overview of Current Regulatory Structure LLU DataStream IPStream Geography ex-post ex-ante (Retail -) ex-ante (Cost +) Margin Rule Retail CAct Case Urban Cost + Rural

©Ofcom4 Ofcom’s Strategic Principles Avoid reliance on exploiting arbitrage opportunities Promote competition at the deepest level of infrastructure where it will be effective and sustainable – Where appropriate limit regulation to the ‘deepest’ level only, thus allowing the removal of downstream regulation Accommodate varying regulatory solutions for different products, and where appropriate, different geographies – Where a single regulatory solution does not adequately address all geographies it may be appropriate to have different regulatory solutions in different geographies, rather than ‘stacking’ regulatory solutions along the value chain

©Ofcom5 Current Products – Natural Selection! Geography LLUDSIPS LLU DataStream IPStream UrbanRural

©Ofcom6 LLU and FAS LLU is one of Ofcom’s primary regulatory solutions for promoting ‘deep’ infrastructure competition and where it is effective Ofcom is seeking to reduce/remove downstream regulation, but… Ofcom recognises that the economics of LLU are such that it is unlikely to be effective in all areas – Therefore likely to need an additional ‘downstream’ regulatory solution that compliments LLU – Next Generation Bit-stream? – Ofcom’s preference is for a single additional regulatory solution and this must be effective in all the areas where LLU is not FAS (as currently defined) appears to replicate DataStream (albeit using Ethernet instead of ATM) – It is scale dependent and thus more attractive in urban areas, but this is where LLU is expected to be the preferred regulatory solution – Unlikely to address all areas where LLU is not effective, in which case additional regulatory solution necessary

©Ofcom7 Next Generation Bit-stream In order to be effective in all the areas where LLU is not, it seems likely that any Next Generation Bit-stream product will need to be sufficiently aggregated – Multiple providers will need to share common network resources However there is normally a trade-off between aggregation and control/flexibility (as per IPStream v DataStream) – IPStream is seen as an aggregated (fixed price) product but with limited flexibility – DataStream is seen as a reasonably customisable product but is susceptible to scale economies It seems as though industry discussions, thus far, have accepted that aggregated and dedicated bit-stream products within 21CN will have similar cost and technical characteristics to IPStream and DataStream respectively Ofcom is keen to understand whether this is necessarily the case

©Ofcom8 De-regulate if LLU is effective Possible Future Regulatory Structure LLU Next Gen Bit-stream Downstream (w/s & retail) products Geography UrbanRural Regulate if LLU is not effective EoI

©Ofcom9 Ofcom’s High Level Goals What we would like to achieve – Ensure that CPs have ability to innovate and produce differentiated downstream products – Ensure that the correct incentives exist for CPs to deploy their own infrastructure What we would like to avoid – Regulating multiple margins within a single value chain However, Ofcom does not have all the answers and is looking to industry (inc BT) to come up with options/solutions – What do CPs want? (This is a different question than which of BT’s proposals is best!) – What are the QoS capabilities of NGNs? – There are likely to be trade-offs and as such industry may need to see if a suitable compromise can be found

©Ofcom The Future of Regulation Thank you Consult21 Broadband Working Group