Optimising Manufacture of Pressure Cylinders via DoE Dave Stewardson, Shirley Coleman ISRU Vessela Stoimenova SU “St. Kliment Ohridski”

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Prof. Steven D.Eppinger MIT Sloan School of Management.
Advertisements

Running a model's adjoint to obtain derivatives, while more efficient and accurate than other methods, such as the finite difference method, is a computationally.
CSUN Engineering Management Six Sigma Quality Engineering Week 11 Improve Phase.
Chapter 6 The 2k Factorial Design
Experimental Design Fr. Clinic II. Planning Begins with carefully considering what the objectives (or goals)are –How do our filters work? –Which filter.
Fractional Factorial Designs of Experiments
Experimental Design, Response Surface Analysis, and Optimization
11.1 Introduction to Response Surface Methodology
Using process knowledge to identify uncontrolled variables and control variables as inputs for Process Improvement 1.
14-1 Introduction An experiment is a test or series of tests. The design of an experiment plays a major role in the eventual solution of the problem.
Experimental Design Fr. Clinic II Dr. J. W. Everett.
L Berkley Davis Copyright 2009 MER301: Engineering Reliability Lecture 14 1 MER301: Engineering Reliability LECTURE 14: Chapter 7: Design of Engineering.
Chapter 8 Two-Level Fractional Factorial Designs
MAE 552 Heuristic Optimization
Elementary hypothesis testing Purpose of hypothesis testing Type of hypotheses Type of errors Critical regions Significant levels Hypothesis vs intervals.
Industrial Applications of Response Surface Methodolgy John Borkowski Montana State University Pattaya Conference on Statistics Pattaya, Thailand.
MAE 552 Heuristic Optimization Instructor: John Eddy Lecture #16 3/1/02 Taguchi’s Orthogonal Arrays.
Chapter 28 Design of Experiments (DOE). Objectives Define basic design of experiments (DOE) terminology. Apply DOE principles. Plan, organize, and evaluate.
EEM332 Design of Experiments En. Mohd Nazri Mahmud
Maximum likelihood (ML)
Introduction – Concept of Stress
P M V Subbarao Professor Mechanical Engineering Department
1 14 Design of Experiments with Several Factors 14-1 Introduction 14-2 Factorial Experiments 14-3 Two-Factor Factorial Experiments Statistical analysis.
Introduction to Design of Experiments
Design of Experiments Chapter 21.
Fractional Factorial Experiments (Continued) The concept of design resolution is a useful way to categorize fractional factorial designs. The higher the.
Chapter 8Design and Analysis of Experiments 8E 2012 Montgomery 1 Design of Engineering Experiments The 2 k-p Fractional Factorial Design Text reference,
CPE 619 2k-p Factorial Design
Design-plots for factorial and fractional-factorial designs Russell R Barton Journal of Quality Technology; 30, 1 ; Jan 1998 報告者:李秦漢.
DOX 6E Montgomery1 Design of Engineering Experiments Part 7 – The 2 k-p Fractional Factorial Design Text reference, Chapter 8 Motivation for fractional.
Dr. Gary Blau, Sean HanMonday, Aug 13, 2007 Statistical Design of Experiments SECTION V SCREENING.
1 Statistical Analysis Professor Lynne Stokes Department of Statistical Science Lecture 6 Solving Normal Equations and Estimating Estimable Model Parameters.
14-1 Introduction An experiment is a test or series of tests. The design of an experiment plays a major role in the eventual solution of the problem.
Engineering Statistics ENGR 592 Prepared by: Mariam El-Maghraby Date: 26/05/04 Design of Experiments Plackett-Burman Box-Behnken.
EQT373 STATISTIC FOR ENGINEERS Design of Experiment (DOE) Noorulnajwa Diyana Yaacob School of Bioprocess Engineering Universiti Malaysia Perlis 30 April.
Experimental Design If a process is in statistical control but has poor capability it will often be necessary to reduce variability. Experimental design.
1 The General 2 k-p Fractional Factorial Design 2 k-1 = one-half fraction, 2 k-2 = one-quarter fraction, 2 k-3 = one-eighth fraction, …, 2 k-p = 1/ 2 p.
Application of Designed Experiments in determining achievable work standards Dave Stewardson 1, Matt Linsley 1 1 Industrial Statistics Research Unit, University.
IE341 Midterm. 1. The effects of a 2 x 2 fixed effects factorial design are: A effect = 20 B effect = 10 AB effect = 16 = 35 (a) Write the fitted regression.
III.7 Blocking Two-level Designs _ Blocking _ Example _ Four Blocks _ Exercise.
ANALYSIS OF VARIANCE (ANOVA) BCT 2053 CHAPTER 5. CONTENT 5.1 Introduction to ANOVA 5.2 One-Way ANOVA 5.3 Two-Way ANOVA.
MSE-415: B. Hawrylo Chapter 13 – Robust Design What is robust design/process/product?: A robust product (process) is one that performs as intended even.
Introduction – Concept of Stress
Overview of Mechanical Engineering for Non-MEs Part 2: Mechanics of Materials 6 Introduction – Concept of Stress.
Solutions. 1.The tensile strength of concrete produced by 4 mixer levels is being studied with 4 replications. The data are: Compute the MS due to mixers.
The American University in Cairo Interdisciplinary Engineering Program ENGR 592: Probability & Statistics 2 k Factorial & Central Composite Designs Presented.
Design of Experiments.. Introduction.  Experiments are performed to discover something about a particular process or system.  Literally experiments.
Lecture 18 Today: More Chapter 9 Next day: Finish Chapter 9.
ESD Systems Engineering Session #11 Supplementary Session on Design of Experiments.
1 Simulation Scenarios. 2 Computer Based Experiments Systematically planning and conducting scientific studies that change experimental variables together.
 Will help you gain knowledge in: ◦ Improving performance characteristics ◦ Reducing costs ◦ Understand regression analysis ◦ Understand relationships.
ETM U k factorials Recall our example from last time … Estimate the effects Determine significant effects Develop regression model Examine.
Designs for Experiments with More Than One Factor When the experimenter is interested in the effect of multiple factors on a response a factorial design.
2 k factorial designs l Examine the response for all possible combinations of k factors at two levels l Are carried out as replicated or unreplicated experiments.
Engineering Statistics Design of Engineering Experiments.
1 Chapter 8 Two-level Fractional Factorial Designs.
TAUCHI PHILOSOPHY SUBMITTED BY: RAKESH KUMAR ME
2 k-p Designs k factors two levels for each factor will only run 2 -p of the possible factor combinations will only run 2 k-p observations total.
Design of Experiments (DOE)
Martin Shaw – Reliability Solutions
INVESTIGATION OF SQUEEZE CAST AA7075-B4C COMPOSITES
IE-432 Design Of Industrial Experiments
Confounding the 2k Factorial Design in Four Blocks
Using Baseline Data in Quality Problem Solving
III.7 Blocking Two-level Designs
ENM 310 Design of Experiments and Regression Analysis Chapter 3
DESIGN OF EXPERIMENTS by R. C. Baker
14 Design of Experiments with Several Factors CHAPTER OUTLINE
Presentation transcript:

Optimising Manufacture of Pressure Cylinders via DoE Dave Stewardson, Shirley Coleman ISRU Vessela Stoimenova SU “St. Kliment Ohridski”

This presentation was partly supported with funding from the 'Growth' programme of the European Community, 'Growth' programme of the European Community, and was prepared in collaboration by member organisations of the Thematic Network - Pro-Enbis - EC contract number G6RT-CT

Background German Company with site in Northumberland UK Major producer of safety and breathing equipment Fire-fighters a major customer

Main Objectives Product Improvement Compressed Air Cylinders Carbon Fibre - Resin matrix is used to wrap Seamless Aluminium liner ‘Wrapping’ process critical for producing Strong cylinders

Completed Cylinders

Systematic Investigation To find optimum settings Cylinders normally tested to Destruction Second objective: Find a non-destructive test!

Main Rationale of Designed Experiments Experiment over a small balanced sub- set of the total number of possible combinations of factor settings Minimum effort - Maximum Information

Sub-sets called Orthogonal Designs Means ‘balanced’ All combinations of factors investigated over an equal number of all the others Known since 1920s after Fisher (UK) Made Popular by Taguchi, a Japanese Engineer

Idea here to get a good mathematical model that predicts effect on cylinder of changing various factors We can then find the optimum in terms of safety Vs profit Vs ability to make it Minimum number of trials to do this

Want to Maximise life of cylinder European Standard = prEN Tested by varying internal pressure Bar up to 15 cycles per minute up to total of 7500 cycles MUST pass 3750 cycles or Fail test

Testing machine

New Test Permanent Expansion after Auto-Frettage Via Water displacement test

Auto-Frettage Procedure Fill cylinder with water Now Pressurise This deforms the liner Stresses Carbon fibre Improves cylinder resistance

Four factors Carbon Fibre Winding Tension Auto-Frettage Pressure Resin Tack ‘Advancement’ Level

FactorLabelLow (-1)High (+1) Carbon Fibre UTSUTS5.4 Gpa5.85 Gpa Resin Tack LevelRTLowHigh Winding TensionWF3.6 kg4.5 kg Auto-Frettage pressureAF580 bar600 bar Experimental factors and their settings

If we choose only 2 levels of each Factor the total possible combinations is 16 We will run half of these, a balanced sub- set of the ‘full factorial’ 8

DoE §The statistical design of experiments is an efficient procedure for planning experiments so that the data obtained can be analyzed to yield valid and objective conclusions

STEPS §Determine the objectives §Select the process factors §Well chosen experimental designs maximize the amount of information that can be obtained for a given amount of experimental effort §The statistical theory underlying DOE generally begins with the concept of process models §Linear models, for instance: §Y=B 0 +B 1* A+B 2* B+B 12* A+error §Factors and responses

TWO-LEVEL DESIGNS

ANALYSIS MATRIX

THE MODEL OF THE EXPERIMENT §Y = X*B + experimental error §X 16x16 - design matrix §B - vector of unknown model coefficients §Y - vector consisting of the 16 trial response observations §X t X = I - orthogonal coding

Full factorial designs §A design with all possible high /low combinations of all the input factors is called full factorial design in two levels §If there are k factors, each at 2 levels, a full factorial design has 2 k runs §we can estimate all k main effects, h- factor interactions and one k-factor interaction §cannot estimate the experimental error if we do not have replications

Fractional Factorial Designs §A factorial experiment in which only an adequately chosen fraction of the treatment combination required for the complete factorial experiment is selected to be run §balanced and orthogonal

2 4-1 fractional factorial design

Confounding §I = ABCD : generating / defining relation §Set of aliases: { A=A 2 BCD=BCD; B=AB 2 CD=ACD; C=ABC 2 D=ABD; D=ABCD 2 =ABC} §AB=CD; AC=BD; BC=AD

2 3 full factorial design

Effects are calculated by taking the average of the results at one level from the average at the other It is all very simple!

Orthogonal Array with Results

Calculated Effects

Half-Normal plot of Permanent Expansion effects

Permanent Expansion Predicted by all the Main-effects alone Cycle Life Effected by ‘Interactions’

Predictive Equation Permanent Expansion = (UTS) + 2.7(RT) (WT) + 3(AF) + e UTS, RT, WT, AF = 1 or -1

Cycle Life Need to do four further tests to ‘untangle’ the interactions However a plot of the UTS x WT interaction is given next – this assumes that the RT x AF interaction doe not exist

Interaction Plot

Findings We can link the tests completely once the interactions are untangled We can already predict how the factors effect Permanent Expansion So we will be able to use the new test as a substitute for the destructive test

By choosing the ‘best’ settings for the manufacturing process, maximising Cycle life against cost, we can then use the new test. For example: we know that if we choose mid levels for WT and AF then we can already predict Cycle life directly from the Permanent expansion alone.

In that case we know that as Permanent Expansion goes up by 1 unit then: Cycle life goes up by at least 195 cycles, and by as much as 250 cycles, on average.