Dealing with Lawbreakers
Medieval Criminal Justice Trial by ordeal Severe public punishment/executions
A Reform Movement The Enlightenment Depart from “supernatural” theory Assumptions about human nature
Classical Response to Crime On Crimes and Punishment, Beccaria (1764) Underlying theory
Principles of Deterrence Certainty Swiftness Severity
Empirical Research on Deterrence There is moderate support for the effect of certainty, little to none for severity
Specific v. General Deterrence Specific Deterrence General Deterrence
Formal v. Informal Punishment Informal = unofficial punishment Informal enhances formal sanctions
Goals of Punishment Deterrence Incapacitation Rehabilitation Retribution
The “System” of Criminal Justice An Ideal Model Crime Police Prosecutor Court Corrections
The Ideal Courtroom Adversarial System The facts of each case are heard Witnesses are called Justice prevails
Courtroom Reality The Courtroom Workgroup Punishment based on the “going rate”
State Felony Convictions by Guilty Plea (No Trial) Source: Bureau of Justice Statistics, 1998
Sentencing: Three Focal Concerns Offender’s blameworthiness Protection of the community Practical concerns Use an example: young. Black, male versus Professor convicted for drug possession
Prison Prison (currently ~ 1/2 million inmates) Current conditions Recidivism Expensive Current conditions Overcrowding Few rehabilitative services Aging prison population Security is main concern
Community-Based Corrections Less costly than prison If revoked -> prison (technical violations) Probation involves the most offenders (about 2 million)
Criminal Justice Funnel 1,000 felony crimes 63% not reported 370 reported to police 80% not arrested 42 prosecuted 2% not convicted 41 convicted in court 32% no prison/jail 28 imprisoned Tough and weak on crime - KEEP 2-3% of felony crimes result in imprisonment