GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 1 THE GROW PROGRAMME: preliminary results of the independent evaluation Tim Cordy Director.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Measuring social added value A model for public authorities
Advertisements

EU-Regional Policy Structural actions 1 GROWING EVALUATION CAPACITY THE MID TERM EVALUATION IN OBJECTIVE 1 AND 2 REGIONS 8 OCTOBER 2004.
REGIONAL POLICY EUROPEAN COMMISSION The urban dimension : State of play and perspectives Władysław Piskorz DIRECTORATE-GENERAL.
The Role of Cities & City Regions in EU Regional Programmes: Experiences from NE England Kevin Richardson
Measuring social added value A model for public authorities Floriana Nappini [ Network: Better Future.
The 2 nd Call for Proposals Thematic Poles Meeting 09 June Paris.
1 Regional Policy contributing to smart growth in Europe 2020 Standard presentation Brussels, November 2010 Pierre GODIN Policy Analyst, DG Regional policy.
Analysis of research and innovation projects in the region Ivan FILUS, BIC Bratislava Joint PA7 SG and Danube-INCO.NET GA workshop Vienna,
Analytical Evidence on Research & Innovation in the Danube Region Progress of WP4 Vienna, Béla Kardon, PhD; RCISD
Addressing the Employment Aftermath: an ILO approach Stephen Pursey Director, Policy Integration and Statistics Department, ILO.
European Social Fund Evaluation in Italy Stefano Volpi Roma, 03 maggio 2011 Isfol Esf Evaluation Unit Human Resources Policies Evaluation Area Rome, Corso.
Entrepreneurship youth
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Women’s Fund Incorporated ATSI Women’s Initiatives For the advancement of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Women.
The Lisbon strategy and the Hungarian employment strategy László Kordás 29 April 2006 Balatongyörök.
Pierre GODIN, Policy Analyst
Young Enterprise Nordland A regional success for implementing entrepreneurship in education Steve Hernes Regional Manager YE Nordland.
GREEN GROWTH ‘Reducing the impact on our environment’ Fabienne Poulet Environment Agency, UK.
Linking the European Youth Strategy to the YOUTH IN ACTION opportunities Hans-Georg Wicke JUGEND für Europa – NA for YOUTH IN ACTION in Germany Rotterdam,
EUROPEAN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT FUND GreenInfraNet/Smart Europe final conference, 4 November 2014, Almere EU Interregional Cooperation State of play and.
THE INDIA/ NORWAY VIEW OF YOUNG WELDERS AT THE IPN CONFERENCE Local Economic Development and Youth Employment.
“Strengthening the National Statistical System of RM” Joint Project By 2011, public institutions with the support of civil society organizations (CSOs)
Land as a Resource State of play 5 March Land as a Resource: at the crossroad of objectives 1 and 2 of 7 th Environmental Action Programme (EAP)
Financing Growth and Cohesion in the enlarged EU 24 November 2005 Financing urban actions and sustainable communities Financing urban actions and sustainable.
Ministerstwo Rozwoju Regionalnego - ESF support for inclusive entrepreneurship in Human Capital Operational Programme Brussels,
South-South Sharing of Successful Tax Practices (S4TP) Special Unit for South-South Cooperation United Nations Development Programme.
The value of a functioning M&E System for Military Procurement: South Africa as a case study Gwendolyn Wellmann, PhD Research Associate Nelson Mandela.
Igor Kaniecki | Joint Secretariat Interreg South Baltic Programme
Outputs and Outcomes Building Better Opportunities Neil King - Director – CERT Ltd.
EU Structural and Investment Funds Climate Change and Environmental Protection SWOT Workshop Martin Budd, Hull City Council Nadine Senior, Hull.
Twinning Project RO/06/IB/SPP/01 Support to Authority for Coordination of Structural Instruments (ACIS) to ensure a sound and efficient management of the.
South Kerry Development Partnership Ltd. Noel Spillane CEO February 24 th 2012.
FLLLEX – Final Evaluation
The Draft Operational Programme Objective 3 Transnational territorial cooperation North West Europe IIIB NWE Joint Technical Secretariat, Lille,
Contribution of the Territorial Cooperation Programmes to the EU Strategy for the Danube Region Kiril Geratliev, Director General “Territorial Cooperation.
EU Cohesion Policy 2014 – 2020 Measures, tools, methods for supporting cross-border cooperation prepared used for adoption and implementation of joint.
PRESENTATION ON HARNESSING PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS (PPP) OPPORTUNITIES FOR SOCIO-ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT. A GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE AND EXPERIENCE BY ROUND.
EUROPEAN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT FUND Insight into interregional cooperation Elena Ferrario| Project Officer Joint Technical Secretariat FLIPPER final conference.
Evaluation Seminar Czech Republic CSF and OP Managing Authorities Session 5: Ex-Ante Evaluation and Lisbon Strategy.
Break Gender Stereotypes, Give Talent a Chance Brussels, 27 November 2008 Helen Hoffmann, UEAPME Social Policy Adviser “The benefits of overcoming gender.
Partnership in social innovation: capacity for building and managing synergies between Public and Private partners, ESI Funds, and other EU instruments.
Budapest, June 2014 Hermina Golob Head od Development Policies Division SLOVENIA Partnership agreement and Operational programme
EUROPEAN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT FUND Cogita Final Conference, 23 October 2014, Bologna EU Interregional Cooperation State of play and perspectives Elisa.
Transnacionalno teritorialno sodelovanje Program Jugovzhodna Evropa Margarita Jančič, MOP,DEZI Novo mesto,17. april 2008.
Results achieved under IFAD VII and directions for results measurement under IFAD VIII Edward Heinemann Programme Manager, Action Plan Secretariat, Office.
Partnership in the SF Programmes. GRDP For IRT 2 Influencing the future programmes” 3 main topics were identified –SEA –Greening projects –Partnership.
OPTIONS AND REQUIREMENTS FOR ENGAGEMENT OF CIVIL SOCIETY IN GEF PROJECTS presented by Ermath Harrington GEF Regional Focal Point.
Monitoring and Evaluation of Roma projects and policies, Brussels, 30/11/2010 Evaluating the European Social Fund support to Roma inclusion: processes,
2012 EFA Global Monitoring Report Skills development: Expanding opportunities for marginalized groups.
Application procedure From theory to practice Dieter H. Henzler, Steinbeis-Transfercenter Cultural Resources Management, Berlin.
MINISTRY OF EUROPEAN INTEGRATION General Directorate for Regional Development Regional Policy and Pogramming Directorate REGIONAL OPERATIONAL PROGRAMME.
1 EUROPEAN FUNDS IN HALF-TIME NEW CHALLENGES Jack Engwegen Head of the Czech Unit European Commission, Directorate General for Regional Policy Prague,
European Economic and Social Committee ACP -EU Private Sector – Engine for Development Brussels October 31, 2014 Ivan Voleš.
GROW Kathy Vuillaume, Programme Manager Information Day Guildford 12 September 05 INTERREG IIIC Regional Framework Operation
Sectoral Operational Programme “INCREASE OF ECONOMIC COMPETITIVENESS” October 2005 MINISTRY OF ECONOMY AND TRADE.
GROW Information Day 7 February 2006 Workshop on Applications, Finance and Monitoring GROW Secretariat Alison Partridge and Sally Kneeshaw Contract Manager.
URBACT IMPLEMENTATION NETWORKS. URBACT in a nutshell  European Territorial Cooperation programme (ETC) co- financed by ERDF  All 28 Member States as.
Małopolska experiences in interregional cooperation INTERREG and Programmes of Investment for Growth and Jobs Grzegorz First Marshal Office of the Małopolska.
Katowice – the capital city of the Silesia region: Highly urbanized The highest population density in Poland – 4,64 mln people 12 cities with population.
Commission européenne EU Employment Strategy for people with Disabilities Final Conference Conversion Strasbourg, 21 Sept Egbert Holthuis European.
Kick-off meeting Szekesfehervar 6-7 July 2009 Development of Innovative Business Parks to Foster Innovation and Entrepreneurship in the SEE Area Presentation.
Filippo Compagni - UK Contact Point – Atlantic Area
Rosa Expósito Coordinator of the Liaison Office ENPI CBC Mediterranean Sea Basin Barcelona, 7 July 2016 From ENPI CBC MED to ENI CBC MED : main results.
EUROPEAN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT FUND CLUE final conference, 24 September 2014, Turin EU Interregional Cooperation State of play and perspectives Johanna.
The strategy for lifelong learning
Approaches and instruments for sustainable rural development
The Draft Operational Programme
Bartosz Grucza Successful Project Management
SWEDISH INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT COOPERATION AGENCY :
‘Regional Policy contributing to Sustainable Growth in EU 2020’
INFORMATION SEMINAR Interreg V-A Latvia-Lithuania programme
Presentation transcript:

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 1 THE GROW PROGRAMME: preliminary results of the independent evaluation Tim Cordy Director Global to Local Ltd

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 2 OUR TASK to evaluate GROW in respect of: the outputs and results of the 16 projects the management of the programme in order to make recommendations for a GROW2

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 3 METHODOLOGY THREE-LEVEL ANALYSIS: 1.OBJECTIVE, via a study of the project’s documents, systems etc. 2.FORMAL, via a questionnaire survey of all project-partners. 3.SUBJECTIVE, via a programme of structured interviews done by phone

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 4 STRUCTURE Development and Evaluation of the projects Management of the programme Partnership issues Impact of the programme The future

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 5 TIMELINE May11draft survey 18commence survey June1complete survey 8prepare interviews 15interviews 22steering group meeting July6complete interviews 13discuss Draft Report with GROW Programme Management 27final Report to GROW Programme Management

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 6 Responses by region Emilia Romagna89% Malopolska82% Andalucía75% South East England58% Noord-Brabant50% OVERALL66%

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 7 MANAGEMENT Programme management tools generally rated “Satisfactory” or “Good” On-line monitoring guidance the best Regional Correspondents: 54% ‘very useful’ + 46% ‘useful’ =100% satisfaction

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 8 MANAGEMENT The online monitoring system made: financial monitoring ‘a bit/lot easier’ for 62% ‘a bit more difficult’ for 36% activity monitoring ‘a bit/lot easier’ for 79% ‘a bit more difficult’ for 19%

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 9 PARTNERSHIP WORKING Working in partnership adds ‘a bit/a lot’ for 85% within region for 89% in other regions Would you consider working with partners again when this project is finished? 96% ‘yes all/some of my partners’

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 10 IMPACT Policy influence, direct/indirect: Local: 80% Regional: 92% National: 51% Project contributions, significant/very high innovation 61% sustainable development 50% improve environment 32% equal opportunities 32% social cohesion 29% create jobs 27%

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 11 GROW: strong/weak points? WEAKNESSES bureaucracy of the EU ‘no weaknesses’ slow flow of finances not enough time [various] STRENGTHS working with hundreds of EU partners ambitious and very interesting objectives 3P idea support from GROW secretariat addresses issues that really matter

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 12 THE FUTURE % never been involved in a cooperation project before 58% % wanting to be in GROW2?100%

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 13 What sub-themes (indicative)? GREEN GROWTH Waste Management41% Environmental Technologies39% Sustainable Construction34% Climate Change34% Resource Management27% Environmental Management Systems27% Sustainable Public Procurement25% Environmentally friendly means of travel23% Water Management23% Brownfield Regeneration16% Flood Risk Management14%

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 14 What sub-themes (indicative)? BUSINESS GROWTH Culture of Entrepreneurship66% High Quality Workforce59% Technology transfer50% Cluster development39% Incubation34% Trading25%

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 15 What sub-themes (indicative)? INCLUSIVE GROWTH Education and training to young people50% Public / Private / Community partnerships39% Integrating marginalised and excluded groups39% Social Enterprises36% Labour market functionality34% Human Resource Management25% Urban Renaissance25% Demographic change – ageing population23%

GROW conference 20-Jun-07 Tim Cordy: EVALUATION AND THE FUTURE 16 Thank you for your attention!