Topic 3: Criminal Justice 22/10/13
What is a criminal justice debate? E64 E64 Tough on Crime vs. Hug a Hoody THS the 3 strikes and your out THW release all prisoners if it can be shown they provide no threat to the public THW only incarcerate violent offenders Particular groups in society – impoverished, paedophiles, politicians
Principles STATE OF NATURE – “SOLITARY, SHORT, NASTY AND BRUTISH” PUNISHMENT OF PRISONERS – VIRTUOUS? PROTECTION of SOCIETY REHABILITATION DETERRANCE
State of Nature Lets be tough on crime: “If you do the crime you should do the time” Laws are important to safeguard rights. Rights are artificial. Perception of crime – can have actual consequences on other peoples lives – broken windows effect.
Punishment/ Retribution Tough on CimeNicer on crime VindicationJust? Social determinism is a thing FamiliesForgiveness – civilized? Closure – catharsis for victims? State buyins
Protection of Society Tough on CrimeNicer on Crime Safer when locked upCost Point to trade off with rehabilitation
Rehabilitation Tough on CrimeNicer on crime Better to be in prison? Life outside, Opportunities inside In prison people don’t rehabilitate: Culture of crime, Race to the bottom, Knowledge economy Characterisation of mechanism to re- integrate back into society Don’t know how to live in society Empirically true
Deterrence Tough on CrimeNicer on Cirme People need a strong deterrent. How do people commit crimes? Is rationality a thing? White collar crimeDo people have any other choice
Debate THW ALLOW THE OPTION OF EUTHANASIA FOR ALL PRISONERS SERVING LIFE SENTENCES