Vincent MASSAUT 24/10/2006 1 of ? slides Final meeting tasks TW5-TSW-001, -001B, -002 Recycling issues Introduction V. Massaut 23-24 October 2006 UKAEA,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Computer English For Computer Major Master Candidates
Advertisements

Regulation of Low Level Waste Management
IAEA International Conference on the Safe and Secure Transport of Radioactive Materials: Session 4B P2 Liability Issues Thursday 20 October 2011 Kevin.
1 KRB-A (Grundremmingen, Germany). 2 Type:Boiling Water Reactor Power: 250 MW(e) Started in 1966, shut down in 1977 First commercial power reactor in.
International Atomic Energy Agency IX.4.3. Waste management.
Exemption, Clearance, Discharges
1 RADIOACTIVE WASTE MANAGEMENT (PART 1) A RAHMAN RWE NUKEM Ltd (UK)
Legacy Waste Retrieval And Treatment Processing Methods At RSRL Harwell Site Author : Marc Rigby Presented by : Malcolm Adam 28 th May 2009.
School for drafting regulations Nuclear Safety Decommissioning Vienna, 2-7 December 2012 Tea Bilic Zabric.
Presentation on recent IAEA activities on RWM Y. Kumano WES / NSRW
Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)
11 April th International High-Energy Physics Technical Safety Forum 1 Radiation Protection and Safety in High-Energy Physics Kenneth R. Kase, Ph.D.
Portfolio Selection of IT Service Products – Case Study Antti Vikman
MODULE “STRATEGY DEVELOPMENT”
1 CHAPTER 9 MATERIAL MANAGEMENT Demeulemeester Yves BR3 Dismantling project SCKCEN.
H IGH L UMINOSITY LHC WP1 - CERN S AFETY R EQUIREMENTS Stefan Roesler - Phillip Santos Silva – Ralf Trant EDMS# HSE Unit April 2011.
Mid-long term R&D step by step plan in order to implement the recycling at the maximum extension possible Gunnar Olsson and Lise-Lotte Spontón TW5-TSW-001,
SAFESPUR FORUM - Challenges in reducing the burden on the UK’s national Low Level Waste Repository 29 April 2009, Birchwood.
Recycling Nuclear Waste: Potentials and Global Perspectives Mikael Nilsson Department of Chemical Engineering and Materials Science University of California,
World Nuclear Association 38th Annual Symposium September 2013, Central Hall Westminster, London Nuclear Operation and Radioactive Waste Management.
Goal: Understand the stages in design process and the role of computer aided design. Objectives: After this chapter, you should understand the following.
Associazione EURATOM ENEA sulla FUSIONE Final Meeting of the contracts TW5- TSW-001 and -002 Garching. January 17 th, 2006 Final Meeting of the contracts.
Update on progress with development of DS459
SAFESPUR 9/7/08 1 Innovation in Nuclear Decommissioning: New Technologies and Research, SAFESPUR Forum, July 9, 2008 G.R. Elder Bradtec Decon Technologies.
A Cleaner Production Project in the South African Paper Industry – Lessons learnt Iain Kerr, MSc (Env. Biotech.) University of KwaZulu Natal, School of.
TM Technical Meeting on the Disposal of Intermediate Level Waste
Vincent MASSAUT Meeting 28/03/ Meeting on Revision of the Occupational Radiation Exposure assessment for the Port-Interfacing Systems (WBS5.0) Garching.
Lay-out of Proposed Scheme. Positives – Well located for integration into both NMBM Potable and Industrial supply infrastructure Can supplement either.
EFDA EUROPEAN FUSION DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT V. MASSAUT 1 Kick-off Meeting TW5-TSW-001, -001B and -002 Garching 18/01/2006 Participants: CEA, ENEA, NNC,
Estimation of storage capacity needed or limits. Comparison with existing storage facilities. Lise-Lotte Spontón TW5-TSW-001, D4 Final meeting, TW5-TSW-001.
1 Chapter 6: Material Management Helmut Steiner Ulrich Priesmeyer Kernkraftwerk Gundremmingen GmbH Priesmeyer, KRB A, 6. Material Management.
Practical Implications of changes to the Exemption Orders for Project Teams Alan Fisher, on behalf of The Clearance and Exemption Working Group.
Study on recycling of fusion activated materials: Identify activation levels, characteristics and decay time requirements of irradiated material (deliverable.
Final Meeting TW5-TSW-001 Deliverable 7 SCKCEN, L. OomsCulham, October 23–24, 2006.
Nuclear Fuel Cycle.  According to World Nuclear Association:  The nuclear fuel cycle is the series of industrial processes which involve the production.
MODULE “PROJECT MANAGEMENT AND CONTROL” SAFETY ASSESSMENT DURING DECOMMISSIONING SAFE DECOMMISSIONING OF NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS Project BG/04/B/F/PP ,
Vincent MASSAUT 10/10/ EFDA Task TW6-TSS-SEA 2.1 Occupational Radiation Exposure - ALARA in ITER: further refinement Kick off meeting Garching, 10/10/2006.
Final Meeting TW5-TSW-001 Deliverable 2 SCKCEN, L. OomsCulham, October 23–24, 2006.
IAEA International Atomic Energy Agency Summary and Overview of TECDOC Russel Edge Decommissioning and Remediation Unit Division of Radiation,Transport.
Main Requirements on Different Stages of the Licensing Process for New Nuclear Facilities Module 4.5/1 Design Geoff Vaughan University of Central Lancashire,
An Introduction to Software Engineering
MODULE “PREPARING AND MANAGEMENT OF DOCUMENTATION” SAFE DECOMMISSIONING OF NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS Project BG/04/B/F/PP , Programme “Leonardo da Vinci”
MODULE “PROJECT MANAGEMENT AND CONTROL” WASTE MANAGEMENT SAFE DECOMMISSIONING OF NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS Project BG/04/B/F/PP , Programme “Leonardo.
1 Design for Remanufacturing and Reverse Logistics
56th Regular Session of the IAEA General Conference
Radiation Protection optimisation 3D planning tools and their applicability to occupational exposure at a fusion power plant F.Vermeersch SCKCEN EFDA 24.
Associazione EURATOM ENEA sulla FUSIONE Final Meeting of the Tasks TW5-TSW-001, 001B, October 2006, UKAEA, Culham, UK Final meeting tasks TW5-TSW-001,
Radiation Protection optimisation 3D planning tools and their applicability to occupational exposure at a fusion power plant F.Vermeersch SCKCEN EFDA 27.
Associazione EURATOM ENEA sulla FUSIONE KOM Meeting of the contracts TW5- TSW-001 and -002 Garching. January 18 th, 2006 Kick Off Meeting of the contracts.
IAEA International Atomic Energy Agency IAEA Safety Standards for Research Reactors W. Kennedy Research Reactor Safety Section Division of Nuclear Installation.
MONITORING MEETING EFDA Technology Workprogramme 2005 Activities Field: Safety and Environment Task Area: Waste Management TW5-TSW-001 Mol, June.
EFDA EUROPEAN FUSION DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT V. MASSAUT 1 Monitoring Meeting TW5-TSW-001, -001B and -002 Mol 27/06/2006 Participants: ENEA, NNC, STUDSVIK,
IN BIOPROCESS INDUSTRY Introduction to Waste Treatment
Safety-related Issues for the Disposal of Intermediate Level Waste (ILW) Dr. Jürgen Wollrath Federal Office for Radiation Protection (BfS) Department Safety.
Vincent MASSAUT Meeting 28/03/ Meeting on ITER water chemistry and implication on the PACTITER development / CORELE experiments Garching / Cadarache.
Gunnar Olsson and Lise-Lotte Spontón
International Atomic Energy Agency IX.4.2. Principles of radioactive waste management Basic technical management solutions: concentrate and contain, storage.
Associazione EURATOM ENEA sulla FUSIONE Monitoring Meeting of the Tasks TW5-TSW-001, 001B, June 2006, SCKCEN, Mol, Belgium Monitoring Meeting.
Study on recycling of fusion activated materials: Identify activation levels and decay time requirements of irradiated material (deliverable 3) R. Pampin.
P3 Business Analysis. 2 Section F: Project Management F1.The nature of projects F2. Building the Business Case F4. Planning,monitoring and controlling.
Garching, January 17th, 2006: L. Ooms EFDA Technology Workprogramme 2005 Activities Field: Safety and Environment Task Area: Waste management.
Automation Chapter 2 Manufacturing Operations The University of Jordan
PhD Bursary Scheme Rick Short, Research Manager 1
Preliminary Decommissioning Plan for the Canadian Light Source
E n v i r o n m e n t a l s o l u t i o n s f o r t h e e n e r g y i n d u s t r y Assessment, Treatment and Management of NORM in the Norwegian.
Automation Chapter 2 Manufacturing Operations The University of Jordan
Principles of Radiation Protection
Radioactive waste management - status
Summer School on Nuclear Decommissioning and Waste Management
Preparation for the IRRS mission
Presentation transcript:

Vincent MASSAUT 24/10/ of ? slides Final meeting tasks TW5-TSW-001, -001B, -002 Recycling issues Introduction V. Massaut October 2006 UKAEA, Culham, United Kingdom

V. Massaut 24/10/ of ? slides The waste and recycling aspect is of very high strategic importance the claim on low radioactive waste production from fusion must be substantiated and based on solid analysisthe claim on low radioactive waste production from fusion must be substantiated and based on solid analysis the recycling process is the main part of the waste minimization processthe recycling process is the main part of the waste minimization process recycling materials always produces secondary waste; it should be interesting to know which proportion these wastes representrecycling materials always produces secondary waste; it should be interesting to know which proportion these wastes represent the sorting and classification of materials cannot be based on the radiation level alonethe sorting and classification of materials cannot be based on the radiation level alone

V. Massaut 24/10/ of ? slides Two tasks were launched for this purpose TW5-TSW-001: Study on Recycling of Fusion Activated Materials, which covers a large overview of the recycling loop for fusion materialsTW5-TSW-001: Study on Recycling of Fusion Activated Materials, which covers a large overview of the recycling loop for fusion materials TW5-TSW-001B ( ): Complex Recycling of Fusion Activated Materials which mostly covers the return of experience from the nuclear industry to deal with rather highly active materials for recyclingTW5-TSW-001B ( ): Complex Recycling of Fusion Activated Materials which mostly covers the return of experience from the nuclear industry to deal with rather highly active materials for recycling There were already tasks carried out under TW3 and TW4 preparing the approach.

V. Massaut 24/10/ of ? slides Some questions needed to be answered… It is not obvious that all the materials and parts can be recycled; what is the return of experience to date ?It is not obvious that all the materials and parts can be recycled; what is the return of experience to date ? The radioactivity is not the only parameter leading to recycle or not; what are the other parameters to look at ?The radioactivity is not the only parameter leading to recycle or not; what are the other parameters to look at ? Recycling “noble” or valuable materials involves also other challenges (separation, metallurgy, refining, machining, joining, leak-tightness, changes in properties,…); what is the current experience and what need to be developed ?Recycling “noble” or valuable materials involves also other challenges (separation, metallurgy, refining, machining, joining, leak-tightness, changes in properties,…); what is the current experience and what need to be developed ? What is the experience in remote handling for all these steps (dismantling – separation – raw material processing – machining and fabrication)?What is the experience in remote handling for all these steps (dismantling – separation – raw material processing – machining and fabrication)? Are there needs for further R&D (like e.g. mechanical testing of reused material)?Are there needs for further R&D (like e.g. mechanical testing of reused material)?

V. Massaut 24/10/ of ? slides Therefore it was proposed to work in steps Define components and materials involved; Determine volumes & masses+ properties + main boundary conditionsDefine components and materials involved; Determine volumes & masses+ properties + main boundary conditions Define activity limits for the dismantling, (melting), fabrication or reuse (&waste )Define activity limits for the dismantling, (melting), fabrication or reuse (&waste ) Define duration before recycling, activation of materials and decay time (depending on parts & components concerned)Define duration before recycling, activation of materials and decay time (depending on parts & components concerned) Estimate storage capacity needed or limits. Compare with existing storage facilities.Estimate storage capacity needed or limits. Compare with existing storage facilities. Summarize the whole process and cycleSummarize the whole process and cycle Category of wastes (based on international standards) and on results of the cycle analysisCategory of wastes (based on international standards) and on results of the cycle analysis Define the categories of materials based on the different routes in the cycleDefine the categories of materials based on the different routes in the cycle Define the needed R&DDefine the needed R&D Finalised In parallel, study on the so-called “Complex Recycling” industrial experience

V. Massaut 24/10/ of ? slides Some “results” were already presented at the SOFT’06 conference 6 Li enrichment allowing reuse High activity Li-containing materials (liquid Li, Li-Pb, ceramics pebbles) Recycling process to develop High activityHigh value or scarce materials Route to be defined Medium to high activity Remaining components:  Various geometries and materials  Various activity  Physical properties Melting / crushing < 1000 Bq/g < 10’s μSv/h Low value, low radiation Free release Clearance Index < 1 Clearable RouteLevel Category

V. Massaut 24/10/ of ? slides One should notice that we tend to step away from former classification… The notions of NAW, SRM, CRM and PDW need to be revisitedThe notions of NAW, SRM, CRM and PDW need to be revisited As discussed at the monitoring meeting we should look at the origin of some of these levels (like the one for NAW, the one between SRM/CRM, the upper limit of CRM etc…)As discussed at the monitoring meeting we should look at the origin of some of these levels (like the one for NAW, the one between SRM/CRM, the upper limit of CRM etc…) The names were not always judiciously chosen (NAW and PDW in particular)The names were not always judiciously chosen (NAW and PDW in particular)

V. Massaut 24/10/ of ? slides …to propose a new approach Based on actual recycling possibilitiesBased on actual recycling possibilities Based on current radioactive waste and materials classificationBased on current radioactive waste and materials classification Tending to avoid the use of arbitrary limitsTending to avoid the use of arbitrary limits Using internationally accepted limits and levels, used and defined in different fields (like e.g. the IAEA clearance index, the ICRP 60 recommendations etc)Using internationally accepted limits and levels, used and defined in different fields (like e.g. the IAEA clearance index, the ICRP 60 recommendations etc) 6 Li enrichment allowing reuse High activity Li-containing materials (liquid Li, Li-Pb, ceramics pebbles) Recycling process to develop High activityHigh value or scarce materials Route to be defined Medium to high activity Remaining components:  Various geometries and materials  Various activity  Physical properties Melting / crushing < 1000 Bq/g < 10’s μSv/h Low value, low radiation Free release Clearance Index < 1 Clearable RouteLevel Category CI<<1D<10 μSv/hD < 2mSv/hD > 2mSv/h Cleared Hands on“Shielded”Remote Handling Example: Can produce

V. Massaut 24/10/ of ? slides …or even more developed classification Specific activity Route Dose Rate ProcessCI<1Clearance < 10μSv/h Classical(melting, milling, powdering, etc.) <1000Bq/g Melting in existing foundries Levels to define RecycleorStoreorDispose <2mSv/h Shielded work (some foundries; few developments) >2mSv/h Remote handling proposal

V. Massaut 24/10/ of ? slides In parallel, there was also another task TW5-TSW-002: Watching brief activities in the field of radioactive waste management and decommissioningTW5-TSW-002: Watching brief activities in the field of radioactive waste management and decommissioning –Report on the implications from the differences between IAEA TECDOC 855 and RS-G-1.7. –Report on review of the Radioprotection optimization planning tools and use for fusion plant

V. Massaut 24/10/ of ? slides The agenda was distributed… The main points are: Introduction (this presentation)Introduction (this presentation) Rationale for the SRM/CRM levels definition (following discussion at the monitoring meeting)Rationale for the SRM/CRM levels definition (following discussion at the monitoring meeting) Monitoring of TSW-001 including 9 deliverables…Monitoring of TSW-001 including 9 deliverables… LunchLunch Monitoring of TSW-001B 11from only 1 AssociationMonitoring of TSW-001B 11from only 1 Association Monitoring of TSW-002 including 2 deliverablesMonitoring of TSW-002 including 2 deliverables Future actions and plan for delivery of the final reportsFuture actions and plan for delivery of the final reports Discussion on the tasks outcomesDiscussion on the tasks outcomes Proposal of potential future workProposal of potential future work

V. Massaut 24/10/ of ? slides Before letting you present and discuss… I would like to set the scene and put the task into perspective….I would like to set the scene and put the task into perspective…. Nice sites to visit…. Brussels Paris