Investing in a healthy community: making the most of NICE’s ROI tools Judith Richardson Health & Social Care Directorate.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Preventing Chronic Disease: The New Public Health Jeffrey Levi, PhD Alliance for Health Reform Briefing June 10, 2011.
Advertisements

MEASURING COST- EFFECTIVENESS AT A LOCAL LEVEL Pamela Meadows National Evaluation of Sure Start Team.
Implementing NICE guidance
NICE Public Health Guidance and return on investment tools Kay Nolan ( Wednesday 26 th March 2014.
Self Directed Support Housing Support and Personalisation: a providers seminar 11 th December 2012 Louise Dunlop, Sue Johnston and Maureen Grant.
Kevin Mullins National IAPT Director National IAPT Programme Update December 2011.
Tobacco control and the new structures for public health Professor Kevin Fenton Director of Health & Wellbeing Twitter:
Integrated Intelligence in Kent Dr Abraham P George Consultant / Asst Dir in Public Health
People, families and communities NHS Commissioning Board Children’s Trust Westminster’s Joint Health and Wellbeing Board Local Healthwatch Providers West.
Hope on the Horizon for Children, Youth and Families: Re-visioning mental health using a public health approach Sandra A. Spencer, Executive Director National.
Healthy People, Healthy Lives Our strategy for public health in England.
Healthy People, Healthy Lives Our strategy for public health in England Transparency in Outcomes Funding and Commissioning routes for public health.
Leading the future of the Family Nurse Partnership: Transition Alex Morton 4 November 2014.
Public Health challenges in the South West Dr Shona Arora Centre Director, Avon, Gloucestershire and Wiltshire Public Health England.
Teenage conceptions in Wales The challenge of intervention and evaluation.
NEW HORIZONS: MEETING THE MENTAL HEALTH NEEDS OF PEOPLE WITH LEARNING DISABILITIES Including Everyone, Everywhere 9th December 2009.
Healthy Life Expectancy and EU Policy
Good for Regeneration, Good for Health Using an HIA approach to develop indicators for regeneration Erica Ison on behalf of Belfast Local Support Group.
Making the case for investment in local tobacco control – tools available SEPHIG, City of Westminster Archives Centre, London 23 September 2014 Allan Gregory,
Personal Health Budgets
Session 4: Making a case - ROI and business case for tobacco control ARCH Technical Workshop Bali August 2014 Matt Glover Health Economics Research Group.
Understanding how commissioners work, and the ways in which HITs can influence their decisions Louise Rickitt & Mel Green June 2015.
Eastern and Coastal Kent & West Kent Historic changes in Public Health Our approach in Kent Graham Gibbens Cabinet member Adult Social Services and Public.
Aquatics and health Using aquatics strategically to improve population health Dr Ann Hoskins Deputy Regional Director of Public Health NHS North West.
Patient Advice and Liaison Service NHS Devon, Plymouth and Torbay The work of PALS Patient transport Health and Wellbeing Boards.
Healthy Ireland A framework for improved health and wellbeing Healthy Food for All 20 November 2013 Dr Miriam Owens.
Improving outcomes for children and young people: a Public Health perspective Sally Hogg Assistant Director of Public Health Suffolk County Council.
Commissioning for Culture, Health and Wellbeing Ian Tearle Head of Health Policy Directorate of Public Health, NHS Devon Wednesday 7 th March 2012.
Action to cut smoking rates and reduce tobacco use needs to take place locally, nationally and regionally if we are to have the most cost effective policies.
Satbinder Sanghera, Director of Partnerships and Governance
Health Promoting Health Service: Development day.
The impact of public involvement Sarah Buckland Director INVOLVE
Tobacco harm reduction: NICE guidance and recent developments Linda Bauld.
Kevin Mullins National IAPT Director The Aspirations of the IAPT Programme November 2011.
JOINT STRATEGIC NEEDS ASSESSMENT Rebecca Cohen Policy Specialist, Chief Executive’s.
Applying for a North West Regional Innovation Fund award Manchester, 29 July 2010.
The emerging regulatory model SSRG Annual Workshop, 21 April 2009 Alan Rosenbach, Head of Strategy and Innovation.
NICE social care work programme. What are NICE guidance and quality standards EvidenceGuidance Quality Standards A NICE quality standard is a concise.
The New Public Health System
What’s on the Horizon Anita Corrigan Nurse Director
UKMi Strategy 2007 Replaces 2000 Strategy Launched 31/10/2007 Takes account of political, policy, organisational and operational NHS changes Takes account.
DETERMINE Working document # 4 'Economic arguments for addressing social determinants of health inequalities' December 2009 Owen Metcalfe & Teresa Lavin.
Berkshire Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust The Community Health Services of Berkshire East and Berkshire West are part of Berkshire Healthcare NHS Foundation.
Investing in prevention: time for systems to work together Association of Directors of Public Health conference 2 nd November 2015 Professor Brian Ferguson.
Access to data for local authority public health AGW Public Health Network Training Event: Public Health Data, Information and Intelligence 11 th November.
Choose Life Evaluation Phase 2. Purpose Phase 2 – Outcome - inform future investment in, and the direction of, Choose Life from 2010 onwards and.
NHS Education & Training Operating Model from April 2013 Liberating the NHS: Developing the Healthcare Workforce From Design to Delivery.
Health Impact Assessment HIA Forum 28 th October 2008 Teresa Lavin Public Health Development Officer
Five Year Forward View: Personal Health Budgets and Integrated Personal Commissioning Jess Harris January 2016.
Tools and techniques to measuring the impact of youth work (Caroline Redpath and Martin Mc Mullan – YouthAction NI)
SEPHIG Health Inequalities. Introduction 1.Background – where have we come from 2.Where are we now? 3.The future – where are we going 4.Discussion 2SEPHIG.
1 News from the Smoking Toolkit Study: December 2012 University College London December 2012 Robert West.
AssessPlanDo Review QuestionYesNo? Do I know what I want to evaluate and why? Consider drivers and audience Do I already know the answer to my evaluation.
ChiMat user survey and feedback: highlights ChiMat Board Meeting – 29 March 2010.
The ‘impossible dream’ Implementing a No Smoking Policy on hospital grounds - Why preventing smoking in the workplace requires more than just policy Trina.
21st May  Demographic & Social  Aging population  Multiple long term conditions / skills development  Health & Social Care system design  Integration.
Health Economics Tools for JSNA Susan Hamilton Sandra Shcherba.
South West Public Health Observatory The Public Health Observatories: an introduction Presentation to Health Statistics User Group Liz Rolfe 25 March 2011.
Health Reforms in Lancashire and improved health and wellbeing outcomes for Children and Young People and their families.
SIGN ROCKETS & Implementation Support Ali El-Ghorr Implementation Advisor SHTG/12 June 2009/Paper 02 HSRE_SHTG_Meetings_ _Paper 2_ SIGN Rockets.
Rebecca Mason Knowsley Metropolitan Borough Council Simon Capewell University of Liverpool 8 th December 2015.
Health Research: promote it, use it, do it Lynne Goodacre Assistant Director NHS Research & Development North West.
Annual Public Health Report Appendix 3: Key resources (1) Key resources for residents: ● Redbridge Do More guide: www2.redbridge.gov.uk/cms/leisure_and_libraries/leisure_and_culture/do.
Monitoring and Evaluation Systems for NARS organizations in Papua New Guinea Day 4. Session 10. Evaluation.
Public Health England South West 9 th Feb 2016 Torbay Active Schools & Communities Russ Moody Health & Wellbeing Programme Lead.
Ailsa Rutter, Director, Fresh: Smokefree North East
PHE Aims and Actions in Maternal and Child Health
Kate Yorke, Project Manager – MECC
Kate Yorke, Project Manager – MECC
Early help: councillor training
Presentation transcript:

Investing in a healthy community: making the most of NICE’s ROI tools Judith Richardson Health & Social Care Directorate

Step 1 Cost effectiveness –To determine whether the benefits from public health interventions are worth the costs

NICE public health guidance (Owen et al 2012): 200 cost effectiveness estimates modelled for various interventions

Step 2 Resource Impact –estimates the impact on annual healthcare use and cost for the first, second and subsequent years after the introduction of the new product for a population –helps estimate the cost of implementation

NICE resource impact tools Aim to identify key resource issues for each piece of guidance Not just the costs – savings too where possible Build business cases

Step 3 Return on Investment –designed to support investment decisions by commissioners and policy makers in local authorities and the NHS. –Evaluate a portfolio of interventions in a geographical area (e.g. region, county or local authority) and models the economic returns that can be expected in different payback timescales

Approach to ROI Cost impact project – to inform approach taken Key elements of the tools –Report health and non-health outcomes and costs in disaggregated format –Report a range of economic metrics for short, medium and long term time horizons –Develop scenario analyses around different intervention options

What can ROI tools be used for? Build a business case for investment Protect what is currently being done Inform allocation of resource within a programme Inform allocation of resource across programmes

“…essentially, all models are wrong, but some are useful” Not the full answer Needs interpretation and contextualising Full awareness of assumptions in models Starting point for discussions Part of the evidence base to support decision making

NICE Return on Investment Tools 3 tools (MS Excel) –Tobacco –Alcohol Use –Physical Activity 2 in development –Mental wellbeing across the life-course –Children & young people Available from we-do/into-practice/return-on-investment-toolshttp:// we-do/into-practice/return-on-investment-tools

Example questions the ROI tool can help you to answer What is physical inactivity/Tobacco/Alcohol costing in my local area? What is the ROI for my current package of services? What happens if I increase the strategies to reduce physical inactivity/alcohol/Tobacco? If I would like to improve a particular service, how does that affect the ‘value for money’ of my package of interventions? –Can I save more money? –When can I start saving money (how many years)?

Examples of how tools have been used In 2013 the tobacco programme lead in Kent Council secured £0.5m for tobacco control over and above existing expenditure on smoking cessation services using outputs from the tobacco ROI tool. In 2012, the regional tobacco programme manager for the South West used the tobacco ROI tool to maintain funding levels when cuts had been planned. The North East region has also used the tool to secure funding

Support for using the tools NICE & PHE PHE “super-users/SPOCs” – assumptions and health warnings, shared learning NICE website Technical manual/user guide Video Ongoing work Case studies (how used in local practice) Convert existing tools to web-based functionality