Workshop on Technology Pathways Forward for Carbon Capture & Storage on Natural Gas Power Systems United States Energy Association Theresa Pugh April 22,

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

CO 2 Capture & EOR Potential For: Wyoming Pipeline Authority July 25, 2006 By: PLASMA, Inc. Rich Schuller PLASMA, Inc. 58 West Quartz Butte, MT

Advertisements

Joe Chaisson April 21, Integrated Coal Gasification Combined Cycle (IGCC) Power Plants and Geologic Carbon Sequestration Joe Chaisson.

Carbon Dioxide Emission: 24 billion tons per year.

EPA’S DRAFT GUIDELINES TO STATES FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF STATE 111(d) PLANS MIDWESTERN POWER SECTOR COLLABORATIVE JUNE 17, 2014 FRANZ LITZ PROGRAM CONSULTANT.

Coal to Liquids Plant Site Selection in WV Douglas G. Patchen October 25, 2007.

Carbon Capture and Sequestration Update APPA Energy & Clean Air Task Force April 26, 2010.

Group 8: Kevin Carpenter Cong Nguyen Getastigen Woldeyes

After 2020: Opportunities and Challenges for All Independent Energy Producers Annual Meeting September 26, 2013 Nancy E. Ryan Director of Policy and Strategy,

CAIR & MATS 2012 Southern Sectional AWMA Annual Meeting & Technical Conference September 12, 2012 Chris Goodman, P.E. Environmental Strategy.

1 AEP Perspectives on Development and Commercialization of CCS Technology for Natural Gas Power Generation Matt Usher, P.E. Director – New Technology Development.

Carbon Capture and Storage Climate Change and Sustainable Development: New Delhi, April 7-8, 2006 Pernille Holtedahl, PhD, Norad NORWAY.

Don Scott Director of Sustainability National Biodiesel Board Biodiesel Liquid Solar Energy.

B9 Coal Deploying Fuel Cells to Generate Cheap, Clean Electricity from Fossil Fuels.

Tenth Annual Midwest Energy Conference March 7, 2007 How Best Satisfy Midwest Electric Load Growth? Thomas R. Casten Chairman Recycled Energy Development.

Toward a Sustainable Future Name of Conference, Event, or Audience Date Presenter’s Name | ©2011 Synapse Energy Economics Inc. All.

Recent EPA Regulation Development Presented by Bill Luthans to the 56 th Meeting of the Joint Advisory Committee Meeting for the Improvement of Air Quality.

Director of Technology Development, Emerging Technology Department

Air Protection Branch 1. 2 Air Quality Activities Support the Mission of the Air Protection Branch Monitor and Report Air Quality Data Analysis and Planning.

CO 2 Sequestration Options for California Larry Myer WESTCARB Technical Director California Energy Commission (916) ; ETAAC.

Capturing Carbon dioxide Capturing and removing CO 2 from mobile sources is difficult. But CO 2 capture might be feasible for large stationary power plants.

Clean Air Act Section 111(d) Indiana Energy Association September 11, 2014 Thomas W. Easterly, P.E., BCEE Commissioner IN Department of Environmental Management.

Carbon Capture and Storage State Legislation Kathy G. Beckett Midwest Ozone Group January 22-23, 2009.

Geothermal Energy for Electric Power Generation

Alexander Voice 24 November  Motivation for the development of CCS technology  Climate change  Energy profile and outlook  Public perception.

Challenges to the Development and Commercialization of CCS Cheyenne A. Alabanzas 2009 ASME Intern University of Alaska – Anchorage.

Carbon capture and geological sequestration:. Some numbers 40 % carbon emissions from power plants 90 % emission reduction proven operationally Eg. Geological.

Emerging sustainable energy technologies. Ferrybridge Power Station (Eric De Mare)

Climate Change: An Opportunity for a Bi-Lateral Approach Driving Technology Innovation Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars Canada Institute.

American Legislative Exchange Council America’s Clean Air Success Story and the Implications of Overregulation November 28, 2012 Thomas W. Easterly, P.E.,

WORKSHOP ON TECHNOLOGY PATHWAYS FORWARD FOR CARBON CAPTURE & STORAGE ON NATURAL GAS POWER SYSTEMS April 22, 2014 Revis W. James Director, Generation R&D.

Renewable Energy: Legal and Policy Issues Frank Prager Vice President, Environmental Policy Xcel Energy November 20, 2009 Frank Prager Vice President,

NamPower’s perspectives on CCS

Carbon Capture & Storage(CCS)

Can CCS Help Protect the Climate?. Key Points Climate Protection requires a budget limit on cumulative GHG emissions. Efficiency, Renewable Electric,

HYDROPOWER: A Comparative Energy Review J. Mark Robinson JMR Energy Infra, LLC NWHA February 23, 2011.

Economic assessment of the whole CCS technology cycle Ksenia Sidorova, PhD student Department of Organization and Management, National Mineral Resources.

Utility Perspective on Climate Change Frank Prager January 22, 2008 Frank Prager January 22, 2008.

Technology options under consideration for reducing GHG emissions SUSTAINABLE ENERGY ROUNDTABLE SERIES: Next Steps Post-Kyoto: U.S. Options January 13,

LONG TERM ELECTRICAL SUPPLY PLAN STAFF RESPONSE TO QUESTIONS, ISSUES, AND RECOMMENDATIONS MADE IN NOVEMBER 2004 Presentation to the Gainesville City Commission.

Sober Thoughts About CCS for Retrofit or New Fossil Plants as a CO 2 Mitigation Measure from Theresa Pugh Director, Environmental Services American.

New Generating Technology to Reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions ENERGY INFORMATION ADMINISTRATION 30 TH BIRTHDAY CONFERENCE April 7, 2008 Linda G. Stuntz.

Bill Harnett March 30, 2010 WESTAR Spring Meeting.

2008 Southern Section A&WMA Annual Meeting & Technical Conference Biloxi, Mississippi August 7, 2008 Danny Herrin, Manager Climate and Environmental Strategies.

Coal as a Future Generation Fuel Chris M. Hobson S enior Vice President and Chief Environmental Officer December 3, 2009.

2011 Governor’s Conference on Energy and the Environment LG&E and KU Carbon Capture and Storage Project September 27, /27/2011.

Clean Air Act Section 111(d) Indiana State Bar Association Utility Law Section September 4, 2014 Thomas W. Easterly, P.E., BCEE Commissioner IN Department.

Michigan Air Quality Division Greenhouse Gas BACT Analysis for Wolverine Power Supply Cooperative Inc. Mary Ann Dolehanty Permit Section Chief Air Quality.

January 14, Coal Power Summit January 14, 2008 Sponsored by: Sierra Club of IL Climate Justice Chicago.

ARKANSAS ENVIRONMENTAL FEDERATION GHG EMMISSIONS TRADING CONFERENCE LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS MARCH 2006 Interstate Oil and Gas Compact Commission.

Midwestern Governors’ Energy and Jobs Accords Rolf Nordstrom Executive Director GREAT PLAINS INSTITUTE Mid-America Regulatory Conference June 7, 2010.

California Energy Commission IEPR Lead Commissioner Workshop University of California, Irvine August 17,

Workshop of St Petersburg - 27 th October 2009 Expert sub-group on Emerging Technologies/Techniques EGTEI - Emerging technologies/ techniques for LCPs.

CO 2 Sequestration for Power Plants: Facing Sober Realities of Cost, Location, Liability and Permitting By: Theresa Pugh Director, Environmental Services.

Northwest Power and Conservation Council Overview of Draft Sixth Power Plan Council Meeting Whitefish, MT June 9-11, 2009.

Carbon Abatement Technologies – A new Strategy Brian Morris Head Cleaner Fossil Fuel Technologies Unit.

Carbon Capture and Sequestration Graham Friant and Rahul Ramanna Sustainability The main goal of CCS is to increase the sustainability of the current system.

Energy and the Environment: Tapping the Potential for Large Volume Storage of Carbon in the Gulf Coast Susan Hovorka Bureau of Economic Geology Jackson.

Energy to Power the World: I What is Energy Photosynthesis Fossil Fuels.

Proposed Carbon Pollution Standard For New Power Plants Presented by Kevin Culligan Office of Air Quality Planning And Standards Office of Air and Radiation.

Carbon Sequestration A Strategic Element in Clean Coal Technology Presentation to: Mid-America Regulatory Conference (MARC) Columbus, Ohio, June 20, 2006.

COAL MINE PROJECT OPPORTUNITY NALAIKH MINE POWER GENERATION AND HEATING PROJECT TSAGAAN SHONKOR HOLDING COMPANY NALAIKH DISTRICT, MONGOLIA OVERVIEW OF.

1 Canadian Clean Power Coalition: Delivering Results for Over a Decade 3) Fuel Cell Repowering Results.

Office of Fossil Energy CCS Experience Samuel S. Tam China Chief Representative Office of Clean Coal & Carbon Management Roadmap for CCS Demonstration.

Coal in a Carbon-Constrained World Ernest J. Moniz, Cecil and Ida Green Professor of Physics and Engineering Systems Director, MIT Energy Initiative Baker.

© 2015 Haynes and Boone, LLP Overview of the EPA Clean Power Plan Suzanne Beaudette Murray February 19, 2016 Tulane Environmental Law Summit.

Viability of Carbon Capture and Sequestration Retrofits for Existing Coal- fired Power Plants under an Emission Trading Scheme CEDM Annual Meeting May.

CH19: Carbon Sinks and Sources

CH19: Carbon Sinks and Sources

The Economics of Carbon Capture & Storage (CCS)

Michigan Air Quality Division

Presentation transcript:

Workshop on Technology Pathways Forward for Carbon Capture & Storage on Natural Gas Power Systems United States Energy Association Theresa Pugh April 22, 2014

Coal Plant Retirement Estimates as of Fall Graphic used with permission from Scott Madden Timing Sources: SNL; industry news; corporate announcements Notes: † 59 GWs “ripe for retirement” in addition to estimated 41 GWs announced; *includes ~9 GWs retired in 2012

CCS Adequately Demonstrated? 3

More to CCS Than Separation Technology

Storage and recycling of CO 2 for EOR and sequestering from power plants under CCS are similar but not at all the same. 5

Sequestration requires addressing many unknowns including: Laws to separate mineral rights vs. surface rights in most states Address western water law-- drilling is depth limited and first in right issues CERCLA RCRCA UIC system does not address other water and liability issues Products liabilities laws Trespass laws 6

Map of Existing CO 2 Pipelines 7

Map of Possible CO 2 Pipeline Corridors for a High CCS Case with Greater Use of EOR

Holland Board of Public Works (a case study about natural gas combined cycle and a BACT analysis for CCS in 2013) CCS for NGCC CHP Plant is theoretical as it has not been adequately demonstrated and did not meet 5 part Top Down BACT test Capital cost of $183 million for geologic sequestration for the proposed 114 MW plant nearly equates to the cost of the NGCC plants without CCS Inclusion of $37 million ANNUALLY in operating costs for geologic sequestration would exceed expected revenues without significant rate increases to customers

Holland Board of Public Works (a case study about natural gas combined cycle and a BACT analysis for CCS in 2013) CO2 from NGCC is only 1/4 the concentration of coal fired power plant and not easily captured CCS on a NGCC with higher renewables makes the operation too complex No large scale CCS has been demonstrated in Midwest Regional Carbon Sequestration Partnership region and that process in Northern Niagara Pinnacle Reef is expected to not be finished until 2015 Water usage for separation and sequestration

Comparison of CCS Cost for Coal and Gas-fired EGUs

Comparison of 90% CCS Cost for Coal and Gas-fired EGUs

Comparison of 90% CCS Cost for Coal and Gas- fired EGUs (550 MW nominal net)

Contact Information Theresa Pugh Director, Environmental Services (202)