Life –Long-Learning Framework for Medical University Teaching Staff Vasilieva E.Yu.-Vice-Rector for Quality, Northen State Medical University (Arkhangelsk) Final Conference Coordinating Council The results of achieved by the second expert group

Final Conference Coordinating Council "The time to gather stones“, or the formal and informal results BEFORE AFTER

Final Conference Coordinating Council Task of the European Universities – to provide «sites» for studying and analysis of experience of medical faculties, to open the process of teacher evaluation and to show peculiarities of organization of control of quality of training of future physicians at the medical faculties of the European universities. About the partners and the human factor Task of the Russian high schools – to study the experience, to generalize it, to separate progressive ideas, and, basing on that, to work out universal standards of control of quality of medical students’ training and to improve the mechanism of teachers’ evaluation.

About partners Final Conference Coordinating Council Тhe Project Chief Coordinator and deep analyst Gilbert Massard

Gilbert Vissent About partners Final Conference Coordinating Council Тhe guru in the sphere of administration (management) at the Medical Faculty of the Strasbourg University and organization of all our visits

Тhe bearer of «the heart» of pedagogy at the Medical Faculty of the Strasbourg University About partners Final Conference Coordinating Council Thierry Pottecher

Тhe «engine» of medical Didactics at the Rurh University and in the Tempus Project About partners Final Conference Coordinating Council Thorsten Schaeffer

About partners Final Conference Coordinating Council Andreas Bürger Кeeper of high moral values in medical education

About partners Final Conference Coordinating Council Тhe Project responsible and efficient participant, extremely optimistic Fernand Anton

About partners Final Conference Coordinating Council Stefano Elia Тhe wise Professor able to assess situations immediately and critically and to find optimal solutions

Final Conference Coordinating Council About partners Мy words of respect and gratitude to the Russian colleagues: V. Akulinin, T. Brodskaya, A. Svistunov, V. Mandrikov, S. Gorbacheva, M. Golubchikova, N. Vodolazsky, E. Lopanova, A. Artukhina

About partners Final Conference Coordinating Council Svetlana Pisklakova Special gratitude – to our interpreter, a wonderful person with the big heart, uneasy and responsible

The Project tasks: 1. Development of qualification requirements for teachers of medical universities 2. Modernization of the program of training of medical university teachers. 4. Creation of an interactive resource “Medical Education”. 3. Improvement of the teaching staff evaluation mechanisms and introduction of modern tools for control of medical education quality control Final Conference Coordinating Council

How did we go towards our goal ? Final Conference Coordinating Council What were the means of achievement of the group work goal ? 1.Training visits 2.The seminar in Arkhangelsk 3.Experience distribution as approbation of work results in the academic environment 4.External reviewing of materials 5.Publication of textbooks

How did we go towards our goal? Final Conference Coordinating Council STRASBOURG Training visits of the Russian teachers to the European universities

How did we go towards our goal? Final Conference Coordinating Council BOCHUM Training visits of the Russian teachers to the European universities

How did we go towards our goal? Final Conference Coordinating Council LUXEMBOURG Training visits of the Russian teachers to the European universities

How did we go towards our goal? Final Conference Coordinating Council ROME Training visits of the Russian teachers to the European universities

Statistics of training visits of RF teachers to the European universities Final Conference Coordinating Council 1. Strasbourg, France 2. Luxemburg, Luxemburg 3. Ruhr, Germany 5-17 November persons NSMU, Arkhangelsk OSMA, Omsk 1. Lille University, France 2. Nice University, France 3. Rome University Tor Vergata, Italy March persons NSMU OSMA VSMU Sechenov FMSMU IAAT 1. Strasbourg, France 2. Luxemburg, Luxemburg 3. Ruhr, Germany June persons NSMU, VolSMU, OSMA, VSMU, Sechenov FMSMU, IAAT University, countryVisit date Number of participants, RF high school

The seminar in Arkhangelsk as a means of achievement of the group work goal Final Conference Coordinating Council January 2012 Publication of a booklet with articles and education quality control standards for medical education (edition of 100 copies) 31 reports have been heard and discussed The number of the participants – 87 persons from 6 countries and 15 cities of Europe

Number of publications and presentations prepared by the second international expert group Final Conference Coordinating Council Form of distributionNumberHigher school Articles in journals reviewed by the Higher Attestation Commission 5NSMU VSMU Articles in RF journals 10NSMU VSMU, ISMACE Report abstracts at international conferences 3NSMU Report abstracts at all-Russian conferences 13NSMU VSMU, ISMACE Intrauniversity conferences 4NSMU VSMU Articles in university newspapers 4NSMU VSMU, ISMACE

Final Conference Coordinating Council Publications and presentations prepared by the second international expert group

Final Conference Coordinating Council External reviewing of materials – one more step on the way to the goal

Two textbooks – the main product of work of the second expert group Final Conference Coordinating Council E. Vasilyeva, A. Svistunov Mechanisms for Medical Teaching Staff Evaluation: textbook / Arkhangelsk, Education Quality Control Standards in Medical High Schools: textbook / E. Vasilyeva, A. Svistunov, G. Massard, O. Enina, M. Tomilova, D. Mizgirev, V. Akulinin, T. Pottecher, T. Schaeffer, S. Elia. – Arkhangelsk, 2012.

Textbook: Education Quality Control Standards in Medical High Schools Final Conference Coordinating Council Education Quality Control Standards in Medical High Schools: Contents Chapter 1. Standards of teaching/learning quality control for current evaluation of students Chapter 2. Standards of teaching/learning quality control for intermediate evaluation of students Chapter 3. Standards of teaching/learning quality control for final evaluation of the graduating students Chapter 4. Teaching/learning quality control at the European and Russian medical universities: practice and analysis Questions and tasks Appendix. Program Education Quality Assessment at Medical Universities CD with presentations of reports of the European and Russian professors

Textbook: Education Quality Control Standards in Medical High Schools Final Conference Coordinating Council Chapter 1. Education quality control standards for current evaluation of students Standard of oral questioning Standard of colloquium Standard of report Standard of situational task Standard of skills assessment Standard of clinical analysis 1.2. Written forms of current evaluation Standard of case Standard of test Standard of case history Standard of staging epicrisis Standard of essay Standard of summary Standard of abstract Standard of project Standard of control work for distant learning students

Textbook: Education Quality Control Standards in Medical High Schools Final Conference Coordinating Council Chapter 2. Education quality control standards for intermediate evaluation of students 2.1. Standard of intermediate attestation of medical students 2.2. Oral forms of intermediate control assessment of students Standard of oral examination Standard of oral credit 2.3. Written forms of intermediate control assessment of students аттестации студентов Standard of written examination Standard of course work

Textbook: Education Quality Control Standards in Medical High Schools Final Conference Coordinating Council Chapter 3. Education quality control standards for final evaluation of graduates 3.1. Standard of final state certification of graduates in medical school 3.2. Oral forms of control of final state certification of graduates Standard of state examination in the specialty «General Medicine» 3.3. Written forms of control of final state certification of graduates Portfolio standard The standard of the final qualification work (for the level of Bachelor and Specialist) The standard of the final qualification work (for the level of Master)

Textbook: Education Quality Control Standards in Medical High Schools Final Conference Coordinating Council Chapter 4. Education quality control in foreign and Russian medical universities: practice and analysis 4.1. Quality control of medical education abroad Quality control of medical education in France and Germany Objective Structured Clinical Examination: experience of the OSCE at the Medical Faculty of University of Strasbourg 4.2. Experience in developing and implementing of quality control standards of training in medical faculties and departments of the Northern State Medical University The standard of credit with the patient ‘s presence in the discipline "Surgical diseases“ Standard of assessment of practical skills of graduates in the surgical Disciplines Standard of situational task in surgical diseases Standard medical prescription

Textbook: Mechanisms for Medical Teaching Staff Evaluation Final Conference Coordinating Council Mechanism of teaching staff evaluation in medical high school Content Chapter 1. Regulatory legal acts for medical university teaching staff evaluation Chapter 2. Technological support for evaluation of medical university teaching staff

Final Conference Coordinating Council Distribution of textbooks in the RF Circulation of each textbook is 300 copies. The textbooks have been distributed to 47 medical high schools, to the RF Book Chamber, the Lenin State Library, the Saltykov-Shchedrin National Russian Library (S-Pb), the scientific libraries of Moscow and Arkhangelsk, the Ministry of Health Care of RF, the EMU for Continuous Medical and Pharmaceutical Education.

Something about unofficial results of the Project Final Conference Coordinating Council To see the world with our own eyes

Final Conference Coordinating Council Something about unofficial results of the Project The acquaintance with the experience of organization of medical education and the elite of medical education of the European countries

Something about unofficial results of the Project Final Conference Coordinating Council The acquaintance with different countries’ cuisines

Thank you for your attention! Final Conference Coordinating Council