Propagating atomic uncertainties into data analysis – Kang et al., 2004, XDAP fitting DEMs to high-resolution Chandra and EUVE grating spectra – wavelength.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Line Features in RHESSI Spectra Kenneth J. H. Phillips Brian R. Dennis GSFC RHESSI Workshop Taos, NM 10 – 11 September 2003.
Advertisements

Determination of 3D structure, avg density, total mass and plasma properties of an EUV filament observed by SoHO/CDS, SoHO/SUMER and VTT/MSDP Pavol Schwartz.
Fitting X-ray Spectra with Imperfect Models Nancy S. Brickhouse Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics Acknowledgments to Randall Smith and Adam Foster.
Spectral Study of CAL87 Ken Ebisawa (JAXA/ISAS) Dai Takei (Rikkyo University) Thomas Rauch (University of Tuebinen) 1Spectral Study of CAL87.
Super-Hot Thermal Plasmas in Solar Flares
Astrophysical Priorities for Accurate X-ray Spectroscopic Diagnostics Nancy S. Brickhouse Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics In Collaboration.
Sensitivity Analysis Applied to Atomic Data Used for X-ray Spectrum Synthesis (and other topics) T. Kallman NASA/GSFC with crucial help from M. Bautista,
Investing in a Transformed Market May 13, 2008 E/ME 103 Caltech Lecture.
Flare Dynamics in the Lower Solar Atmosphere H. S. Hudson Space Sciences Laboratory, University of California, Berkeley, USA Astronomy & Astrophysics Group,
Flare Dynamics in the Lower Solar Atmosphere H. S. Hudson Space Sciences Laboratory, University of California, Berkeley, USA Astronomy & Astrophysics Group,
Doppler signatures in EVE spectra, and flares H. Hudson, T. Woods, P. Chamberlin, L. Fletcher, and D. Graham The Extreme-ultraviolet Variability Experiment.
RHESSI/GOES Observations of the Non-flaring Sun from 2002 to J. McTiernan SSL/UCB.
COOL STARS and ATOMIC PHYSICS Andrea Dupree Harvard-Smithsonian CfA 7 Aug High Accuracy Atomic Physics In Astronomy.
RHESSI/GOES Xray Analysis using Multitemeprature plus Power law Spectra. J.McTiernan (SSL/UCB)
Joan T. Schmelz University of Memphis Monterey, Feb 2006 Limitations of TRACE/EIT Temperature Analysis for Coronal Loops UofM Student Workforce: K. Nasraoui.
RHESSI/GOES Xray Analysis using Multitemeprature plus Power law Spectra. J.McTiernan (SSL/UCB) ABSTRACT: We present spectral fits for RHESSI and GOES solar.
2/14/06AIA/HMI Science Meeting C3. Thermal Studies: Techniques Happy Valentine’s Day!
Possibility for Coronal Magnetic Field Measurements by EUV and X-ray Spectroscopy Sophie Canton (Charge exchange) Matt Carpenter (Algorithms,CX) Jaan Lepson.
From Accurate Atomic Data to Elaborate Stellar Modeling Franck Delahaye LUTh (Observatoire de Paris, France) Collaborations : Atomic Physic – Opacity:Claude.
Resolving X-ray Sources from B-Stars - Spectroscopically Ehud Behar Department of Physics Technion Prepared for the “Other Issues” Session of the XDAP.
08__050610_SCIP/SEB_PSR_Delivery.1 Temperature and Density Diagnostics with SECCHI EUVI J.S. Newmark Naval Research Laboratory (202)
SDO/AIA science plan: prioritization and implementation: Five Objectives in 10 steps [session no. C9] HMI/AIA science teams meeting; Monterey; Feb
Andrea Dupree SAO/CfA New England Space Science Consortium (NESSC) March 1, 2006 Some Stellar Problems of Interest to Solar Physics  Global properties.
SDO/AIA science plan: prioritization and implementation: Five Objectives in 10 steps [session no.] HMI/AIA science teams meeting; Monterey; Feb
Solar Prominence Properties derived from the UV-EUV SUMER spectral atlas S. Parenti, J.-C. Vial, P. Lemaire IAS, Univeristé Paris Sud.
Neon, Opacity the Universe and Everything Jeremy Drake Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory 2004: The “solar model problem” 2005: Neon in late-type stars.
AMD Absorption Measure Distribution Evidence for Thermal Instability? By Tomer Holczer Cambridge, MA July 2007.
Detection of FIP Effect on Late-type Giants D. Garcia-Alvarez, J.J. Drake, L.Lin, V. Kashyap and B.Ball Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory Coronal Abundances.
Characterizing Underconstrained DEM Analysis Mark Weber* *Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics CfA – Harvard – UCI AstroStats Seminar Cambridge,
Advanced Methods for Studying Astronomical Populations: Inferring Distributions and Evolution of Derived (not Measured!) Quantities Brandon C. Kelly (CfA,
Chandra and Newton Common Low-Energy Grating Observations Chandra Calibration Workshop Oct 25-27, 2004 Vinay Kashyap Jeremy Drake Sun Mi Chung Li Wei.
WG 1 Summary Techniques and Applications. WG1 sessions New algorithms: UV smooth, electron maps Source locations Source sizes Source fluxes (imaging spectroscopy)
X-ray Emission from Massive Stars David Cohen Swarthmore College.
Why do we Need a Mathematical Model? SAMSI/CRSC Undergraduate Workshop 2006 Moustapha Pemy.
David Henley, University of BirminghamX-ray & Radio Connections, Santa Fe, February 2004 Probing Colliding Wind Binaries with High-Resolution X-ray Spectra.
White Box vs. Black Box Testing Tor Stålhane. What is White Box testing White box testing is testing where we use the info available from the code of.
Variation of EUV solar irradiances along the cycle Vincenzo Andretta 1, Giulio Del Zanna 2, Seth Wieman 3 1 INAF – Osservatorio Astronomico di Capodimonte,
Age dependence of EM in AR Cores... and... Some thoughts on the Accuracy of Atomic Data Helen Mason, Durgesh Tripathi, Brendan O’Dwyer and Giulio Del Zanna.
Three data analysis problems Andreas Zezas University of Crete CfA.
Spectral Analysis, Uncertainties in Atomic Data, And AtomDB Randall Smith, Adam Foster (SAO) Stuart Loch & Connor Ballance, Auburn University Michael Witthoeft,
Where is Coronal Plasma Heated? James A. Klimchuk NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, USA Stephen J. Bradshaw Rice University, USA Spiros Patsourakos University.
ESWW4, Brussels, Novembre 2006 Retrieving the EUV solar spectrum from a selected set of lines for space weather purposes: A review of theories, models.
SLAC, HiRes T-461: “FLASH” part 1 Justin Findlay.
Assimilation of solar spectral irradiance data within the SOLID project Margit Haberreiter PMOD/WRC, Davos, Switzerland.
Photoionization Tim Kallman NASA/GSFC What is photoionization? Removal of a bound electron by a photon Loosely refers to any situation where external photons.
UCL DEPT. OF SPACE & CLIMATE PHYSICS SOLAR & STELLAR PHYSICS GROUP Atomic Data for Astrophysics VOTADA VO Tools and Atomic Data for Astrophysics Giulio.
Colin Folsom (Armagh Observatory).  Read input  Calculate line components (Zeeman splitting)  Calculate continuum opacity (per window, per atmospheric.
The 2p-3d Electron Transition Multiplet of Ar +13 : A Stellar Density Diagnostic Laura Heeter Kristina Naranjo-Rivera
XUV monochromatic imaging spectroscopy in the SPIRIT experiment on the CORONAS-F mission I. Diagnostics of solar corona plasma by means of EUV Spectroheliograph.
North Star Capella A  stellar-beacon-of-auriga-the-charioteer
Emission Measure Distributions: A Tutorial Nancy S. Brickhouse Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics From Spectral Lines to Emission Measures Emission.
Present Status of AME and NUBASE Meng WANG CSNSM, Orsay, France IMP,Lanzhou,China April 6, 2011, Vienna.
Spectrogram 2-40 A for varying temperature. Spectra this is how we find out what everything is made of Vinay Kashyap Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory.
On the spectroscopic detection of magnetic reconnection evidence with Solar B – I. Emission line selection and atomic physics issues P. F. Chen 1,2, H.
Eugenio Ursino on behalf of the UM Astrophysics Group University of Miami, USA Looking for the Missing Baryons.
UCL DEPT. OF SPACE & CLIMATE PHYSICS SOLAR & STELLAR PHYSICS GROUP Atomic Data for Astrophysics VOTada VO Tools and Atomic Data for Astrophysics Giulio.
Model Atmosphere Codes: ATLAS9 and ATLAS12
Chapter 29 Atomic Physics.
An Arecibo HI 21-cm Absorption Survey of Rich Abell Clusters
Tackling the Disk/Jet Connection in AGN: Timing Analysis Methods and
Difficult to relate EIT waves to other phenomena due to cadence
Improving Estimates of Tsunami Propagation Speed
Atmospheres of Cool Stars
Saturn's temperature profiles at high, medium and low latitudes derived from UVIS EUV solar occultations - updates Jacques Gustin LPAP ULg UVIS team meeting.
High-cadence Radio Observations of an EIT Wave
Lesson 1. Atoms 22 February, 2019.
VOTADA VO Tools and Atomic Data for Astrophysics
Physics 1 – Sept 5, 2017 P3 Challenge – Do Now
Fig. 2 Plasma diagnostics with DEM analysis.
Presentation transcript:

propagating atomic uncertainties into data analysis – Kang et al., 2004, XDAP fitting DEMs to high-resolution Chandra and EUVE grating spectra – wavelength errors, missing lines – correlated uncertainties (via MCMC) pre-compute tables of plausible ion balance Vinay Kashyap, SAOHMI/AIA Science Teams Meeting, Monterey, Feb 2006

DEM reconstruction cannot be a black box – fast, simple, robust: pick one – smoothing: a necessary evil – error bars.. bands.. bundles.. ropes – astrophysical limitations: changing densities and abundances flows and non-equilibrium ionization line opacities atomic data errors Vinay Kashyap, SAOHMI/AIA Science Teams Meeting, Monterey, Feb 2006

DEM reconstruction cannot be a black box – fast, simple, robust: pick one – smoothing: a necessary evil – error bars.. bands.. bundles.. ropes – astrophysical limitations: changing densities and abundances flows and non-equilibrium ionization line opacities atomic data errors Vinay Kashyap, SAOHMI/AIA Science Teams Meeting, Monterey, Feb 2006

coronal building blocks – moss DEM Fletcher & de Pontieu 1999; Lin et al – Sun as a star; stars as the Sun – the Capella spike at logT=6.8 Vinay Kashyap, SAOHMI/AIA Science Teams Meeting, Monterey, Feb 2006

DEM challenge: lessons learned MCMC_DEM in PINTofALE – incorrect by ~3x – always check for stability of the solution – watch out for artefacts next to sharp edges – data can be too good; proportionately more difficult to get out of local minima Vinay Kashyap, SAOHMI/AIA Science Teams Meeting, Monterey, Feb 2006