1 How Can We Get More Neutrons? Upgrade Paths for the EDM Geoff Greene University of Tennessee /Oak Ridge National Laboratory Oct 2006.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Neutron Lifetime Review: Status and future J. David Bowman Oak Ridge National Laboratory The 4th International Workshop on the CKM Unitarity Triangle December.
Advertisements

IV. Low Energy Probes of SUSY J Erler (UNAM) A Kurylov (Caltech) C Lee (Caltech) S Su (Arizona) P Vogel (Caltech) G Prezeau (Caltech) V Cirigliano (Caltech)
Thomas Parker, Head of Energy Division Responsible Renewable Recyclable Thomas Parker October 2013.
ESS Timing System Plans and Requirements Timo Korhonen Chief Engineer, Integrated Control System Division May 19, 2014.
IKON7, Instrument clip session, September 2014, ESS Headquarters and Medicon Village, Lund, Sweden A cold neutron beamline for Particle
1 FNPB “Common Magnet” Design Introduction Geoff Greene UT/ORNL.
Neutron-Antineutron Oscillation Search with Cold Neutrons ILL beam experiment Improved experiment with horizontal beam: (1)Reactor source, (2) pulsed source.
UCN beta decay Dan Melconian University of Washington.
1 Neutron Electric Dipole Moment Experiment Jen-Chieh Peng International Workshop on “High Energy Physics in the LHC Era” Valparaiso, Chile, December 11-15,
Helium 3 Neutron Precision Polarimetry CHRISTOPHER CRAWFORD, ROEL FLORES, CHRISTOPHER MENARD*, ELISE MARTIN, University of Kentucky *present address: Washington.
Neutron Generation and Detection Lee Robertson Instrument & Source Division Oak Ridge National Laboratory 17 th National School on Neutron and X-ray Scattering.
Managed by UT-Battelle for the Department of Energy Current and Future Instrument Development Projects at Oak Ridge Lee Robertson Instrument DevelopmentGroup.
HYSPEC Instrument: Status and Performance M. Hagen Neutron Facilities Development Division, SNS, Oak Ridge National Lab. W.J. Leonhardt and A. Ruga Condensed.
NPDGamma - LH2 Target - Relief/Ventline Systems Seppo Penttila NPDGamma Project Manager Predicted A  =5x10 -8 We are aiming to 10% measurement.
The n 3 He Experiment Probing the Hadronic Weak Interaction Abstract: Although QCD has had tremendous success in describing the strong interaction at high.
Electric Dipole Moment of Neutron and Neutrinos
Polarized Beams Using He-3 at the NCNR Triple-Axis Spectrometers Ross Erwin Tom Gentile Wangchun Chen Sarah McKenney.
1 Overview of the NPDGamma Experiment at the Fundamental Neutron Physics Beamline Geoff Greene UT/ORNL.
Introduction and Charge to the Review of ESS Target building and Instrument Hall design requirements Roland Garoby November 2014, Lund
NEUTRON EDM Philip Harris, on behalf of the CryoEDM collaboration: Rutherford Appleton Laboratory University of Oxford University of Sussex ILL University.
What happened to our shutter? and a brief description of our upstream beamline for those who were not around when it was built.
Yuri Kamyshkov/ University of Tennessee Mini-Workshop, WU St. Louis, February 11, 2011 (Playing with various factors)
Proposal for a High Intensity Chopper Spectrometer at LANSCE Science requiring high sensitivity neutron spectroscopy Limitations of current instrumentation.
Fundamental Physics With Cold and Ultra-cold Neutrons Albert Young North Carolina State University.
Overview Run-6 - RHIC Vadim Ptitsyn C-AD, BNL. V.Ptitsyn RHIC Spin Workshop 2006 RHIC Run-6 Timeline  1 Feb – Start of the Run-6. Start of the cooldown.
S2E optics design and particles tracking for the ILC undulator based e+ source Feng Zhou SLAC ILC e+ source meeting, Beijing, Jan. 31 – Feb. 2, 2007.
HYSPEC 1 Instrument design, shielding/background simulations for Hyspec Vinita J. Ghosh.
Normalization of the NPDGamma Experimental Data F. Simmons, C. Crawford University of Kentucky, for the NPDGamma collaboration Background: NPDγ Experiment.
Beam Polarimetry Matthew Musgrave NPDGamma Collaboration Meeting Oak Ridge National Laboratory Oct. 15, 2010.
Applications of polarized neutrons V.R. Skoy Frank Laboratory of Neutron Physics, Joint Institute for Nuclear Research Dubna, Moscow Region, Russia.
ISIS operational update David Findlay Accelerator Division ISIS Department Rutherford Appleton Laboratory / STFC DL-RAL Joint Accelerator Workshop, RAL.
The SNS Second Target Station and Instrument Optimization Across ORNL Neutron Sources K. W. Herwig Instrument and Source Division Oak Ridge National Laboratory.
Alexander Aleksandrov Oak Ridge National Laboratory
G-2 accelerator and cryo needs Mary Convery Muon Campus Review 1/23/13.
Projected performance of NPDGamma and new systematics introduced by SM polarizer Christopher Crawford University of Kentucky NPDGamma Collaboration Meeting.
HYSPEC HYSPEC: A High Performance Polarized Beam Hybrid Spectrometer at the SNS Beamline 14B I.Zaliznyak 1, S. Shapiro 1, L. Passell 1, V. Ghosh 1, W.
HWDB: Operations at the Spallation Neutron Source Workshop on Accelerator Operations August 6-10, 2012 Glen D. Johns Accelerator Operations Manager.
HYSPEC IDT Polarized Beam Operation of the Hybrid Spectrometer at the pulsed Spallation Neutron Source. Outline HYSPEC: project timeline and place in the.
1 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES NSLS-II Overview Satoshi Ozaki Director, Accelerator Systems Division NSLS-II Project March 27, 2007.
1 Status of FNPB Geoff Greene / Nadia Fomin University of Tennessee.
The NPD  Experiment David Bowman IScientific goals IIStatus.
O AK R IDGE N ATIONAL L ABORATORY U. S. D EPARTMENT OF E NERGY The Spallation Neutron Source Project: Update T. E. Mason Oak Ridge National Laboratory.
Takeyasu Ito University of Tennessee/Oak Ridge National Laboratory EDM Cost and Schedule Review February, 2005 Beam Splitter / State Selector, Polarizing.
Neutron Scattering Group February, 2001 A High Performance Instrument for the Single Crystal Spectroscopy at the Pulsed SNS. n What is the spectrometer.
Collab_NSAC 4/2/03 #1 EDMEDM Martin Cooper, Los Alamos Co-spokesperson for the EDM Project for presentation to EDM Collaboration Meeting Los Alamos, NM.
A New High Intensity Cold Neutron Spectrometer at NIST J. A. Rodriguez 1,3, P. Brand 3, C. Broholm 2,3, J.C. Cook 3, Z. Huang 3, P. Hundertmark 3, J. Lynn.
EDMEDM C&S Review 2/11/05 #1 Martin Cooper, Los Alamos Co-spokesperson for the EDM Project for presentation to LANL Cost and Schedule Review Committee.
EDM Assembly and Commissioning – or – How to Cut Two Years from the Project P. Huffman and V. Cianciolo.
Neutron Scattering Group March, 2001 A High Performance Hybrid Spectrometer for the Single Crystal Spectroscopy at the Pulsed SNS  Scientific case and.
Moving the NPDGamma Experiment to the SNS FnPB Christopher Crawford University of Kentucky overview of NPDGamma transition to the SNS expected.
Assembly 12/14/06 #1 Assembly and Commissioning Paul Huffman.
HYSPEC IDT Polarized Beam Mode for the Hybrid Spectrometer (HYSPEC) at the Spallation Neutron Source. Outline Polarization analysis and the HYSPEC place.
Proton Driver Keith Gollwitzer Accelerator Division Fermilab MAP Collaboration Meeting June 20, 2013.
HISTORY OF SNS DESIGN AND TECHNOLOGY CHOICES PROJECT X WORKSHOP NOVEMBER 12-13, 2007 R. KUSTOM.
October, 2001 Hybrid Spectrometer for Single Crystal Studies at the Pulsed SNS: an update. n Principal features of the proposed hybrid spectrometer. n.
Tailoring the ESS Reliability and Availability needs to satisfy the users Enric Bargalló WAO October 27, 2014.
ESLS Workshop Nov 2015 MAX IV 3 GeV Ring Commissioning Pedro F. Tavares & Åke Andersson, on behalf of the whole MAX IV team.
Very Crude Background Estimation Takeyasu Ito Los Alamos National Laboratory.
The ESS Target Station F. Mezei ESS target division NPPatLPS, 2013.
Muon Facility at J-PARC Proton Driver Efficiency WS 29/Feb/2016
Neutron and electron electric dipole moments
Very Cold Moderator Development at LENS
Spectrometer Magnetic Field for Neutron Beta Decay at the SNS
A cold neutron beam facility for particle physics at the ESS
Update of CLIC accelerating structure design
Neutron Detector Systems at ESS
The NPDGamma Experiment at the SNS FnPB
W. T. Weng Brookhaven National Laboratory
neutron lifetime experiments
Test Beamline System Requirements and Charge to PDR Committee
Presentation transcript:

1 How Can We Get More Neutrons? Upgrade Paths for the EDM Geoff Greene University of Tennessee /Oak Ridge National Laboratory Oct 2006

2 l Why is the Fundamental Neutron Beamline at the SNS designed the way it is? l Introduction to Sources & Neutronics Power, Moderators, Monochromators, and Guides l Possible Upgrade Paths Current SNS Target Station w/o monochromator SNS Long Wavelength Target Station NIST CNRF Upgrade Project

3 Observations/ Conclusions l There are other FNPB customers besides EDM. l The guide and monochromators are optimized to accommodate all users. l For a number of practical and political reasons, the EDM guide won’t change until EDM demonstrates that it is rate-limited*. l By the time that EDM demonstrates that it is rate limited, there will likely be several possible upgrade paths. *This represent my personal opinion and does not necessarily represent the opinions of the EDM Executive Committee, ORNL Physics Division, SNS management, DOE Office of Science, or Pete Domenici.

4 User Group (including representation from the EDM) recommended that FNPB be designed to allow parallel operation of Cold n and UCN Expts.

5 The First Round of FNPB Proposals Have Been Received and Reviewed FNPB Beamline Characterization and Commissioning Approved UCN Beam (SNS, ORNL, LANL, IUCF, NCSU,…) Determination of τ n Lifetime Using Magnetically Trapped UCN Conditional Approval (Harvard, NIST, NC State) Measurement of “a” & “b” Correlations in Neutron Beta Decay Deferred (U of Va., ORNL, LANL, Indiana, UNH,…) Measurement of “a,b,B,A” Correlations in Neutron Beta Decay Deferred (LANL, Indiana, Michigan, NIST, ORNL, UNH,…) Measurement of “A+B” Correlation in Neutron Beta Decay Deferred (Michigan, Indiana, NIST, ORNL, UNH,…) Measurement of Parity Violation in n-p CaptureConditional Approval (LANL, Indiana, Manitoba, NIST, Berkeley, ORNL,…) Measurement of Parity Violation in n-d Capture Further study (LANL, Indiana, Manitoba, NIST, Berkeley, ORNL,…) Precise Measurement of Neutron Spin Rotation in H 2 and He Conditional Approval (Indiana, Washington, NIST, NC State, Indiana, ORNL,…) New Search for an Electric Dipole Moment Approved UCN Beam (LANL, Caltech, Berkeley, ORNL, NC State, …)

6 Neutrons “On Target” Depends on Several Factors l Accelerator Power Neutron production is approximately linear in beam Power for 600 Mev ≤ E proton ≤ 3 GeV l Moderator efficiency 8.9Å) Moderation depends upon temperature, size, and composition of moderator, as well as adjacent materials. At 8.9Å, at the same power, there can be a significant difference between the brightness of “decoupled” and “fully- coupled” moderators. Selection of moderator is a trade-off between intensity and pulse width. l Efficiency of monchromator (reflectivity AND divergence) Reflectivity of graphite is ~80%. “Mosaic” crystal increases divergence which can reduce neutron guide transport efficiency. l Neutron guide transport Guide efficiency depends on details of “supermirror coating” (“m” value) as well as guide geometry (straight or ballistic)

7 ILL Core/moderator SNS Target/moderator(s) A “Totally Coupled” moderator provides a higher time averaged production of cold neutrons due to longer moderation times

8 Current EDM Beamline Design l Accelerator Power SNS scheduled for 1.4 MW operation when EDM begins operation l Moderator efficiency 8.9Å) FP13 is on cold moderator that is not fully optimized for maximum integrated long wavelength flux. l Efficiency of monchromator (reflectivity AND divergence) FNPB baseline calls for double crystal monochromator. This leads to a loss of ~x2 from reflectivity and ~x3.5 due to vertical divergence. l Neutron guide transport Ballistic guide design is fully optimized for 8.9Å transport. Use this performance as baseline

9 Current Beam Line Cold Beam with 6° Bend FP14a

10 Upgrade Path #1: Direct Path from FNPB “Cold Guide” to EDM Building l Accelerator Power GAIN x1 l Moderator efficiency 8.9Å) GAIN x1 l No monchromator, chopper used to select 8.9Å GAIN x6 l Neutron guide transport GAIN x1 TOTAL GAIN x6

11 SNS Upgrade Plan Phase 1 – Power Upgrade –3-4 MW –Completion FY10 Phase 2 - Long Wavelength Target Station (LWTS)* –1.0 20Hz –Long Pulse ? 60Hz, p + ) –Fully Coupled Moderators –VCN source ? –Completion FY13 ? *Details of final configuration is still under discussion. The SNS is designed to allow operations with two target stations

12 Upgrade Path #2: 2 nd Target Station Assumptions: Power 1 MW (possibly Long Pulse with higher power) Fully coupled VCN Source ? l Accelerator Power GAIN x0.7 l Moderator efficiency 8.9Å) 1 GAIN x4 – x8 l No monchromator, chopper used to select 8.9Å GAIN x7 l Neutron guide transport GAIN x1 – x1.5(can start ballistic guide sooner) 2 TOTAL GAIN x20 – x50 1 Phil Fergusson, SNS 2 Paul Huffman, NCSU

13 Upgrade Path #3: NIST Upgrade NIST has proposed a major upgrade that would include a new liquid D2 moderator as well as new system of guides. If : 1.The existing nuclear physics beamline (~60m, straight 58 Ni coated, 15x6cm 2 ) were replaced with a ballistic guide fully optimized to match our EDM experiment, AND 2.There was enough space in the reconfigured NIST guide hall, AND 3.A monochromator is not needed to reduce background, there would be a TOTAL GAIN x 10* * J. Cook, NIST

14 Conclusions l For a number of practical and political reasons, the EDM guide won’t change until EDM demonstrates that it is rate-limited. l By the time that EDM demonstrates that it is rate limited, there will likely be several possible upgrade paths.

15 End of Presentation