SOAR CONFERENCE 2015 THE GREAT PUBLIC INTEREST DEBATE.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

ALTERNATIVE METHODS OF DISPUTE RESOLUTION (ADR)

Advertisements

Immigrants and the landlord-tenant dispute mechanisms in Canada Identifying and addressing barriers to access Pablo Mendez PhD Candidate Department of.

Federalism and the judiciary Nathalie Des Rosiers Dean, Civil Law University of Ottawa, Canada.

Actg 6100 Legal Issues Chapter 3 Courts and Alternative Dispute Resolution.

ADR Alternative Dispute Resolution. Criminal Law vs. Civil Law Criminal LawCivil Law Deals with crime Deals with disputes between individuals/organizations.

New Frontiers of Merit in Tribunal Appointments Dr. Lilian Ma The Future of Administrative Justice Symposium – U of T Law School January 18, 2008.

Goals: Session 1 (Legal & Evidentiary Challenges Obtain contributions on the particular successes and challenges on key L&E issues in different jurisdictions;

Pre-Trial Management of Criminal Cases

/ Title 1 UNCLASSIFIED ADR in Tax Disputes UNCLASSIFIED Debbie Hastings First Assistant Commissioner Review and Dispute Resolution.

DISPUTE RESOLUTION Collie Edgar Norman Interim Program Director Office of Dispute Resolution.

Alternative Dispute Resolution. Introduction Alternative dispute resolution is often referred to as ADR. It describes the ways that parties can settle.

By Aidan, Lochie, Curtis. WORKPLACE DISPUTES  Negotiation: Is a method of compromising disputes within a workplace. This easygoing approach usually.

The Judicial System Duties of the Courts. The Responsibilities of the Canadian courts are: 1. Interpret the Laws made by the Legislative and Executive.

Topic 8 Alternative dispute resolution test Topic 8 Alternative dispute resolution test.

AS Citizenship Chapter 2 – Citizens and the Law. Session Aim : To explore law and order in communities Learning objectives: To identify and name Government.

Judicial Specialisation in Environmental Law: 12 Advantages By The Hon. Justice Brian J Preston Chief Judge Land and Environment Court of NSW.

Copyright © 2005 Pearson Education Canada Inc. Business Law in Canada, 7/e, Chapter 2 Business Law in Canada, 7/e Chapter 2 The Resolution of Disputes.

Business Law with UCC Applications, 13e

Niki K. Kerameus November 17, 2014 Cyprus Arbitration and Mediation Centre Is there a Role for Arbitration in the Development of the Rule of Law? A Comparison.

ANNUAL CONFERENCE CARRIBEA BAY RESORT, KARIBA 3 OCTOBER 2014.

Alternative Dispute Resolution Duncan Bunce Presentation by Duncan Bunce Read & Précis: Chapter 4, Issue 1, pages

1 Therapeutic Justice: The Art of the Possible The Independent Assessment Process Society of Ontario Adjudicators and.

Chapter 4 Alternative, Judicial, and E- Dispute Resolution.

UNRWA Dispute Tribunal Professionalized Transparent Independent & Impartial Judge –Selection of Judge by Internal Justice Committee comprised of staff.

ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION Ken Fields

QCAT Fair and just outcomes Version 1.2 – April 2015 Information in this presentation is general information only. If you are unsure about your legal rights.

 We use the Adversary system of trial.  HOWEVER, the Coroner’s Court, Family Court, Children’s Cases Program, some tribunals and some alternative methods.

Civil Dispute Resolutions. Judicial Determination  Judicial determination is when a dispute is resolve by a third party Judge. This is done in the Supreme.

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) Pages

Alternative Dispute Resolution Ensure all mobiles are switched off Feel free to ask questions – just raise your hand first Have your précis notes (Ch.10.

Procedure for the resolution of grievances in the ILO.

ALTERNATIVE METHODS OF DISPUTE RESOLUTION (ADR). WHY IS ADR NEEDED? Courts expensive Courts time-consuming Courts traumatic Public hearings bring unwelcome.

VCE Legal Studies: Evaluating the role of the court as a law-maker

Alternative Dispute Resolution Non-judicial methods of resolving disputes Increasingly used by businesses and government Most common forms: –Arbitration.

Realizing the Advantages of International Commercial Arbitration Henri C. Alvarez October 6, 2005.

© 2006 Pearson Education, Upper Saddle River, NJ, All Rights Reserved.Hames/Ekern: Introduction to Law, 3 rd edition Chapter Thirteen Alternative.

Civil Courts & ADR Advantages and Disadvantages. Learning Objectives I will be able to state the advantages and disadvantages of each form of civil dispute.

Pre-Hearing Conferences  If a tribunal’s process allows for a pre- hearing conference, it will be governed by s. 5.3 of the SPPA  The purpose of a pre-hearing.

DUE PROCESS, MEDIATION & AGENCY COMPLAINTS Elvin W. Houston December 7, 2011.

AS LAW: English Legal System Alternative Dispute Resolution  Understand why the use of alternative methods of dispute solving are rising in popularity,

Integrating Mediation Techniques with Formal Tribunal Processes to Advance the Protection and Welfare of Elderly Persons Pam Goodman Julie Ford.

Debate System. Parts of the debate: Pro Side 1.Lead Debater- opens the debate 2.Pro Cross-examiner- responds to what was presented by both the con cross-

By the Commission on Administrative Justice Training on Effective Complaints Handling Management.

CONCILIATION  Third party assists in the process of enabling parties to reach a decision between themselves.  Third party does not make a decision 

Conflict Resolution Program Catholic University College of Ghana Growing a Dispute Resolution System: One View from America Professor Paul F. Kirgis St.

Chapter 4.  What are some of the advantages of taking a dispute to court?  What are some of the disadvantages?

MEDIATION and other forms of ADR.

SOARing Ahead: Mindful, Proportional, Proactive SOAR's 28th Annual Conference – November 3, 2016 Workshop #7 - What’s Public, What’s Not? - Access to.

ARBITRATION AND MEDIATION:

How Civil Procedure allows for FAT

SIMAD UNIVERSITY Keyd abdirahman salaad.

Chapter 3 Alternative, Judicial, and Online Dispute Resolution

Quick Review What is it called when unions and business owners meet to discuss and negotiate labor issues? Collective bargaining When collective bargaining.

Perspectives on Judicial Administration: The View from Tribunals

3 Branches Review.

JUDICIAL Interprets the Law

Debate Format 28 August 2017.

Introduction to Theme 3: Justice

Alternative Dispute Resolution

Debate Format 18 January 2018.

Soar Annual conference September 27, 2018

Compulsory ODR: The Canadian Experience

Branches of Gov’t.

Use of Technology at The Property Assessment Appeal Board of BC

Debate Format 13 January 2015.

Debate Format 17 January 2019.

Law and Justice: Chapter 4

JUDICIAL Interprets the Law

ADR (Alternative Dispute Resolution). What is ADR? An out of court settlement. Disputes between 2 parties e.g. should the tree outside their house be.

Presentation transcript:

SOAR CONFERENCE 2015 THE GREAT PUBLIC INTEREST DEBATE

DEBATE FORMAT 6 rounds of 8-minute long debates 2.5 minutes PRO 2.5 minutes CON 0.5 minute PRO – rebuttal 2.5 minutes open discussion with entire panel – 30-second warning for time limits

DEBATE PAIRS 1.Kathy Laird and Lorne Sossin 2.Paul Daly and Freya Kristjanson 3.Paul Daly and Lorne Sossin 4.Freya Kristjanson and Kathy Laird 5.Paul Daly and Kathy Laird 6.Freya Kristjanson and Lorne Sossin

LIVE AUDIENCE POLLING After each mini-debate, use your BlackBerry, smartphone, tablet or laptop to choose one of the following answers to this question: What is your position on this issue now, and did this change because of the debate? 1. PRO – Unchanged 2. CON – Unchanged 3. NEUTRAL – Unchanged 4. PRO – Changed from Neutral or Con 5. CON – Changed from Neutral or Pro

Resolution for Debate Resolution 1 Resolution 2 Resolution 3 Resolution 4 Resolution 5 Resolution 6

RESOLUTION #1 A tribunal should limit how many cases it resolves without a hearing, because the ADR or mediation process is hidden from public scrutiny and it fails to contribute to the jurisprudence or predictability of the tribunal’s work.

Resolution Selection Home

RESOLUTION #2 The principles of natural justice – as interpreted by the courts – impose undue restrictions on tribunals because tribunals need to be more creative and proactive in managing their case processes and their hearings.

Resolution Selection Home

RESOLUTION #3 The adjudicative independence of tribunal members means that any proper performance appraisal of members will be ineffective and cursory in nature.

Resolution Selection Home

RESOLUTION #4 Members of adjudicative tribunals should be administrative law judges with full security of tenure for life – like the Tribunal administratif du Québec (TAQ) – rather than be appointed for limited terms as in Ontario.

Resolution Selection Home

RESOLUTION #5 Tribunals are running out of excuses about why they are stuck in the analogue world, and they must do much more to harness digital resources to advance public interest and access, including e-filing, live streaming of hearings and online dispute resolution.

Resolution Selection Home

RESOLUTION #6 Tribunals talk a good talk about increasing access to justice for disadvantaged users and unrepresented parties, but they can do much more with their existing resources.

Resolution Selection Home

SOAR CONFERENCE 2015 THE GREAT PUBLIC INTEREST DEBATE The End November 6, 2015 (G. Yee)

Resolution Selection Home