What’s the problem?
Flexible and part-time workers tend to be occupationally segregated Flexible working is rare at management and senior levels Flexible and part-time working is female- dominated Part-time work is generally low-paid
Overworked Stressed Undervalued part-time workers Part-time work does not offer opportunity for part-timers to use their abilities
Hidden brain drain 4/5 workers “working below potential”
Most common form of flexible working is part-time How come part-time is so under-valued?
Part-timers working below their potential Nearly 3 million women aged 25 –54 are working part-time below their potential
30% say working below past potential 50% believe have higher latent potential Increasingly working PT at start of career Working below potential because: - studying/ training for higher paid work 80% working below potential – women: - “stuck in job” - combining PT work with caring
65% working below proven past potential - could easily work at higher level - 40% of them: men - 85% not in training/ not looking for other work Many not want more intensive work - 46% have chosen less stressful jobs 25% held back because no opportunity in labour market - Not find work that uses experience & skills - No opportunity with current employers - Would prefer FT job, no chance with current employer - No suitable FT jobs in area
2m working below past potential 1m say working below latent potential 88% women - ¾ combining PT with caring 40% of male sample – combining with caring Not in education to improve chances - “stuck in job” Not chose PT career path, circumstances - only 15% work PT because it suits (caring, less stress)
Training & job-hunting in Pt-ers working under potential
Constraints on job choice for 25–54 year old women
For employers Extending the range of flexibilities within full-time work Broadening the range of part-time jobs at more senior levels Re-designing jobs to ensure they can draw in those with under-utilised talents who are currently driven to part-time work to avoid excessive stress.
Flexible working, full or part-time, is… … available in all sectors and industries … handled confidently and positively by line managers … valued by employers and trade unions
… undertaken at all levels of organisations, including senior management … easy to move in and out of … widely available on the open labour market
Employer Employee Economy Society
Enhance their ability to retain staff Improve morale, motivation and commitment among employees Reduced stress and absence in their workforce Increase productivity, improving retention, saving recruitment costs, helping with skill shortages, reducing stress related absence, improving motivation Tapping into untapped potential in today’s part- time workers opening up higher level work to them
More opportunity to work to potential in better-paid jobs Better work-life balance Remain with existing employers when need to change hours or patterns of work Move to new work when they work flexibly or part-time and move in and out of flexible and part-time working without penalty Not suffer financial penalties, other than pro- rata reductions, from reducing hours
Best possible use of skills, qualifications and talent available Better match between services required and labour market resources available Reduction in government spending on stress- related illness
Greater social cohesion, health and success from reducing inequality and deprivation Give children best possible start in life give families best chance of good health, education and relationships Fathers playing a more active role in bringing up future generation Better balance between male and female carers and role models, greatly enriching the lives of our young people
Managers’ skills & attitude Labour market flexibility Modernisation of job design
Good communication and trust is key for FW Encourage provision and take-up of training in managing flexible workers. Realistic about what flexibility is possible, go into negotiation well prepared Senior managers as champions for FW help achieve management ‘buy-in’ encourage take-up of FW policies.
training in business case for FW coaching to deal with flexible working requests to be open-minded to new ways of working case studies of different employees taking up various FW methods benefits to the business as well as individual active support of senior management in promoting flexible working
Performance management “seeing” = “performing” objective-setting inputs v outputs Communication schedule briefings so Fwers not get detached use of s for regular contact stress face-to-face contact vital conference calls Multi-skilling teams cover for each other self-roster
Building the organisation culture FW = business as usual Trust use of objective measures of output Fairness & consistency seen to be fair acceptable for all groups consistent line managers’ attitudes
More help for labour market returners from employers (if exist) from Government to update skills or learn new ones Finance for training to older workers out of work for less than six months Support for phased or delayed retirement
More effort and resource put into modernising job design Trial periods used by employers to try out different forms of flexible working for workers Impact on both business and individual evaluated openly and objectively
Responsibilities of employees, managers and HR: FW