Personality Profiling of the Modern Surgical Trainee: Insights into Generation X Jennifer A Swanson MD MPH Mara B Antonoff MD, Jonathan D’Cunha MD PhD,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
THE MYERS-BRIGGS TYPE INDICATOR © “INFPS DO IT BETTER” Presented by: Andrea Sides and Derek Brown.
Advertisements

Explore Career and Postsecondary Options 11th Grade Do What You Are #4.
The MBTI & YOU! The Promises and Pitfalls of Applying Type.
The Promises and Pitfalls of Applying Type Today’s Topics What is the MBTI? What is psychological type? What are preferences? Exercises in type Discovering.
PERSONALITY. Classification of Personality Tests n Uni-dimensional or Multi-dimensional n Theoretical or Psychometric (data reduction) Factor Analysis.
Explore Career and Postsecondary Options 11th Grade Do What You Are #4.
1 Myers-Briggs Type Indicator Carl G. Jung’s theory of psychological types Differences between normal healthy people Source of misunderstanding and miscommunication.
Erik Erikson was a psychologist that thought…
1 What is MBTI? Based on Jung’s personality theory Patterns of normal behaviour Doesn’t try to account for everything No right or wrong type You decide.
Self As Instrument Using self as an instrument for change “The world around us is continually in the process of being created anew.” --Trust, Jack Gibb.
Department of Surgery Who’s Covering Our Loved Ones: Surprising Barriers in the Sign-Out Process Mara Antonoff MD Elizabeth Berdan MD, Varvara Kirchner.
PERSONALITY. Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI) n Original development 1940 –Hathaway & McKinley n (MMPI ) MMPI-2-RF 2008 n Over.
1 CLASSIFYING TRAITS (I) TAXONOMIES & TYPOLOGIES JUNG’S TAXONOMY 3 dimensions YORK & JOHN’S TYPOLOGY.
Myers-Briggs Type Theory Applied to Career. Jung. (1921/1971). Psychological Types Concerned with what people pay attention to their world, And how they.
Objective Personality Tests. Personal Profiles n Internal-external n Need for control n Interests n Etc….
Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI). Description of the MBTI Based on Jung’s theory of types People are classified as one of 16 types (does not use dimensions)
Myers-Briggs Type Indicator
Art Sloan, eLearning Research Group, School of Computing, Dublin Institute of Technology, Kevin Street, Dublin 8, Ireland
What’s Your Type? Understanding personality types: How people see the world and make decisions differently Robert Ford World Academy Facilitator.
LEARNING ABOUT YOUR PERSONALITY TYPE YOUR CAREER DEVELOPMENT.
MBTI Myers Briggs Type Indicator
Lecture 5 PERSONALITY II: Dimensions of Personality.
Myers-Briggs Type Indicator Presented by: Jennifer Scott 1.
Myers-Briggs Type Indicator.
CAREER DECISION MAKING Copyright © 2007 Robert Cullen.
1 Stress and Personality. 2 How does your personality affect your response to stress?
1 Helping you discover your own personal leadership style using Meyers Briggs using Meyers Briggs Nick Mathys, Ph.D. Leadership Assessment.
DAVE JARMAN – ENTERPRISE SKILLS & EDUCATION MANAGER MBTI – Personality Profiling for individual and team development.
Myers-Briggs Type Inventory (MBTI) Carl Jung: Theory explaining predictable patterns of behavior Predictable differences caused by differences in how people.
Personality and the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator®
Looking At Type Looking At Type A Description of the Preferences Reported by The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator By Earle C. Page CAPT.
1 Professional Assessment Program The professional assessment (PA) program provides a systematic review of the student’s personal & professional gifts,
Inner Landscapes II A Visual Guide to the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator.
CARRIE ROBERSON North/Far North Regional Consortium Reporting Out Activity.
Understanding Yourself and Others An Invaluable Skill in Leadership Workshop 4 May Donna George EREA Women in Leadership National Forum.
Energy. introversion Gain energy through reflection and solitude. Prefer to delve deeply into a few interest and activities; few, but close friends; don’t.
MBTI: Personality Affecting Performance Jill Middleton & Ron Brassell.
Personality Types Week TWO
 In Class Activity: Write your own definition of what personality is using your non-dominant hand.
Carl Jung and Personality Types
LEARNING STYLES: How do you learn the best? Presented by: Annette Deaton Coordinator of Orientation Services.
Myers Briggs Type Indicator
Alice price rushmore.  Learn about your personality traits  Explore the different personalities  Discover your personal communication style.
The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI). Overview 1.Self-Report Instrument 2.Nonjudgmental Instrument 3.Preference Indicator 4.Well Researched Instrument.
Construction Leadership
Myers-Briggs Type Indicator Karen Copeland PSY 631 Francis Marion University.
The Communication Process
Completing the questionnaire: The Inventory items are arranged in pairs (a and b). Each statement of the pairing represents a preference you may or may.
The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) Will B. Goode University of Iowa.
MBTI – KGI Myers-Briggs Type Indicator – Klein Group Instrument Robert R. Klein, Ed.D.
Personality I: Measuring differences in organizations.
COMN 2111: COMMUNICATION IN EVERYDAY LIFE THREE ASPECTS OF THE SELF Lecture 9a.
PERSONALITYPERSONALITYPERSONALITYPERSONALITY PERSONALITYPERSONALITYPERSONALITYPERSONALITY.
How an English Major Became an Intern in a Metrology Lab Rebecca Shelton US Army Primary Standards Lab, Microwave Division 2009 NCSL International Workshop.
Unlocking the “Secret Sauce” of Great Teams Heather
THE FOUR PREFERENCE SCALES ARE… polar opposites! Extraversion or Introversion Sensing or Intuition Thinking or Feeling Judgment or Perception.
Unit 10: Personality. DO NOW How would you describe your personality?
Personality Perception Values (6) You Non verbal Empathic Responding Communicate Experience Emotion Needs Other.
MYERS-BRIGGS MYERS-BRIGGS. Personality Type The popular use of Personality Type is the result of the work of Swiss psychologist Carl Jung and two American.
Myers-Briggs Personality Assessment
Remember to check-out of your room!
Copyright Type Association Benelux
Myers Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) Rationale
The most widely used personality inventory in the world, the MBTI instrument provides an accurate picture of a person’s personality type. The MBTI instrument.
Personality Preferences
Today’s Agenda A little about the RAT Your feedback on class
Interpersonal Insights Model
Flavors of Leadership.
Myers Briggs Type Indicator
Presentation transcript:

Personality Profiling of the Modern Surgical Trainee: Insights into Generation X Jennifer A Swanson MD MPH Mara B Antonoff MD, Jonathan D’Cunha MD PhD, Michael A Maddaus MD

Apprenticeship Model Large care teams Learn by osmosis One service at a time No duty hour restrictions

Changing Surgical Education ACGME Core Competencies Resident education and evaluation Duty hour restrictions Smaller care teams Increased cross coverage

Generation Defined by historical time Similar events, icons, experiences Generation X Modern surgical trainee

Myers-Briggs Type Indicator Myers Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) Determines personality type Preferences for behaviors, reactions, perceptions, judgment Based on pairs of opposite preferences

Myers-Briggs Type Indicator Extraversion/Introversion (E/I) Inward vs outward personal orientation Sensing/iNtuition (S/N) Perceived facts vs insight Thinking/Feeling (T/F) Logical vs subjective approach to reasoning Judgment/Perception (J/P) Planning / organization vs spontaneity

Myers-Briggs Type Indicator Historically, surgeons have favored the ESTJ personality type: Extroversion Sensing Thinking Judging

Hypothesis Resident personality has changed

Methods IRB approval MBTI step I form M 41 categorical surgical residents Single institution

Methods Data published by the Center for Applications of Psychological Type Chi-square analysis used to determine difference between groups  =0.05

Results 39 (95%) of residents completed the survey 22 men and 17 women PGY-5 (6) PGY-4 (6) PGY-3 (15) PGY-2 (6) PGY-1 (6)

Results Residents represented 14 of the 16 personality types Residents preferred ISTJ: Introversion Sensing Thinking Judging Remainder less frequent n  4

Results

Historically, surgeons have favored the ESTJ personality type: Extroversion Sensing Thinking Judging

Results

Conclusions Validation of common perception of a new surgical resident Evolution to different personality Suggests attraction of new trainee

Future Implications Important implications for care team structuring Anticipate program expansion Potential applications Educational objectives Curricular development Relationship between trainees and staff