Early cranial surgery from Late Iron Age Switzerland Introduction Material and Methods Results Discussion Sandra Lösch 1, Negahnaz Moghaddam 1, Simone.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Musculoskeletal Trauma: An Introduction
Advertisements

The Importance of Numbers: What Large Skeletal Samples Can (and Cannot) Reveal About the Health Status of Earlier Human Population Phillip L. Walker Department.
Neuroanatomy/psychobiology
Forensic Anthropology. It’s the application of physical anthropology to the legal process. Identify skeletal, badly decomposed or unidentified human remains.
Forensic Anthropology. What Questions Can Forensic Anthropology Answer? Race Sex Approximate age Approximate stature Pathologies (diseases) Traumas (injuries)
To use evidence to find out about prehistoric medicine Before people wrote things down.
Honors Forensic Science.  A. “Bone Detectives”  B. Help police solve complex cases involving unidentified human remains.
Paranthropus robustus. Australopithecus africanus.
Medicine Through Time Pre-history. What was Prehistoric Medicine capable of doing? Make a list of some of the equipment that modern doctors use to diagnose.
Objectives Learn how scholars study the historical past.
Dr. S.K. Joshi M.D.Ay. (B.H.U.) Reader and Head of the Department, Shalya-tantra Additional Medical Superintendent Government Ayurvedic College, Gurukul.
Chapter 13 Forensic Anthropology: What We Learn from Bones By the end of this chapter you will be able to: describe how bone is formed distinguish.
1 Psych 5500/6500 The t Test for a Single Group Mean (Part 5): Outliers Fall, 2008.
CHRONIC SUBDURAL HEMATOMA-CRANIOTOMY VS BURR HOLE TREPANATION.
Drill 1. What are the function of bones? 2 How many bones do you have as an adult? 3. What are the three bones cells you have and what are their functions?
The Professional Development Service for Teachers is funded by the Department of Education and Science under the National Development Plan This unit explores.
Medical Practices in Ancient Egypt
The Role of Imaging in Sinusitis Dr Mohamed El Safwany, MD.
FORENSIC ANTHROPOLOGY WHAT IS IT? WHAT DOES A FORENSIC ANTHROPOLOGIST DO? HOW DOES ONE BECOME A FORENSIC ANTHROPOLOGIST?
International Survey on Management of Paediatric Ependymomas: Preliminary Results Guirish Solanki ¥, G Narenthiran § Department of Neurosurgery ¥ Birmingham.
EARLY HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
Lecture 1 Lecture 1 Introduction to History of Medicine. Medicine of Primitive Society.
Introduction to archaeology. What is archaeology? “Archaeology is the scientific study of physical evidence of past human societies recovered through.
A STUDY OF DEATH DUE TO TERRORISM IN EASTERN NEPAL. Dr. Manoj Kumar Department of Forensic Medicine Institute of Medical Sciences Banaras Hindu University.
TEKS 8C: Calculate percent composition and empirical and molecular formulas. Studying Early Humans.
Prehistoric medicine A recap. Aims of this revision session By the end of this revision lesson you should Understand the problems we have with the evidence.
FOCUS 1 Notes Human Origins In Africa. No written records of prehistoric peoples Prehistory dates back to 5,000 years ago.
Statistics for Managers Using Microsoft Excel, 5e © 2008 Pearson Prentice-Hall, Inc.Chap 8-1 Statistics for Managers Using Microsoft® Excel 5th Edition.
Essential Statistics Chapter 131 Introduction to Inference.
CHAPTER 14 Introduction to Inference BPS - 5TH ED.CHAPTER 14 1.
Central Tendency Introduction to Statistics Chapter 3 Sep 1, 2009 Class #3.
HIV Mortality for Florida and the Six (EMAs) Eligible Metropolitan Areas Florida Department of Health HIV/AIDS & Hepatitis Program Death data as of 07/12/2012.
Chapter 13 Forensic Anthropology: What We Learn from Bones By the end of this chapter you will be able to: describe how bone is formed distinguish.
Forensic Anthropology Mrs. Taktak. What Is Forensic Anthropology Anthropology is the study of humankind, culturally and physically, in all times and places.
INCLUSION OF DISABILITY IN NATIONAL AIDS STRATEGIC PLANS. KEY STEPS TOWARDS ACCESS AND RIGHTS By REGINA OMBAM HEAD, STRATEGY DEVELOPMENT National AIDS.
Chapter 12 Bioarchaeological Approaches to the Past.
Introduction  Populations are described by their probability distributions and parameters. For quantitative populations, the location and shape are described.
Forensic Anthropology What is it all about?. Forensic Anthropology When all that is left is a pile of bones, that's when the police know to call in a.
STONEHENGE Not just another bunch of rocks. The stones were roped off so the tourists would not be able to touch the stones. The following photos are.
Prehistoric Native Americans August 12, Introduction Long before Europeans ever arrived in North America, Native American tribes lived here Long.
Eastern European Alliance for Reproductive Choice REPRODUCTIVE CHOICE FOR HIV- INFECTED WOMEN Prof. POSOKHOVA S.P. UKRAINE УКРАЇНАУКРАЇНА.
What is Forensic Science? Primer on the investigation of suspicious deaths Discussed how to tell if a strangulation was masked as a suicide by hanging.
How healthy were prehistoric people?. What was the lifestyle of prehistoric people Lived in small communities Many nomadic Earlier – Hunter gathers Later-Farmers.
describe how bone is formed
8. GRADES 8-12 M. WETHERBEE THE SECRETS IN THE SKULL.
A Lesson on Skeletal Evidence. Works of Anthropologists 1. Assist in the identification of deceased individuals whose remains are decomposed, burned,
Artificial Cranial Deformation in the Americas
Comparing Two Proportions Chapter 21. In a two-sample problem, we want to compare two populations or the responses to two treatments based on two independent.
Benefits and gender differences in depression By Morgan and Laura.
 starter activity What sort of information can skeletons tell us about the health of ordinary people in the past?.
Disease and Infection Exam Technique The 8 mark question
Forensic Anthropology
Forensic Anthropology
Forensic Anthropology: Bones
A. Hegyi1 ‑ A. Marcsik1 – E. Molnár1
AN EARLY HISTORY MYSTERY
R.R. Paine1, D. Mancinelli2, V. d’Ercole3 & A. Coppa4
Unit 7 Today we will look at: Normal distributions
Forensic Anthropology
Starter Which factors are significant to the development of surgery and anatomy throughout history?
A Study of St Georges Park
describe how bone is formed
So what’s a caveman anyway?
Essential Statistics Introduction to Inference
Introduction Previous lessons have demonstrated that the normal distribution provides a useful model for many situations in business and industry, as.
Complete the sheet with your partner
Unit 32 Care of the Client with Surgery
Presentation transcript:

Early cranial surgery from Late Iron Age Switzerland Introduction Material and Methods Results Discussion Sandra Lösch 1, Negahnaz Moghaddam 1, Simone Mailler-Burch 1, Christian Jackowski 2 1 Department of Physical Anthropology, Institute of Forensic Medicine, University of Bern, Switzerland 2 Department of Forensic Medicine and Imaging, Institut of Forensic Medicine, University of Bern, Switzerland  Moghaddam N, Mailler-Burch S, Kara L, Kanz F, Jackowski J, Lösch S (accepted) Survival after trepanation – Early cranial surgery from Late Iron Age Switzerland. International Journal of Paleopathology Fig. 2: Skull A53 is determined as an adult male. There is an elliptically shaped lesion on the left os parietale with partly irregular margins and a funnel shape at the anterior and posterior area. The lesion measures 50x 37mm. No signs of healing are detectable on its margins. Skull A103 is determined as a mature male. This skull shows two nearly symmetric funnel-shaped openings on both ossa parietalia. The lesion on the left side measures 25x 22mm and broadens towards the outside. The lesion on the right side measures 44x 37mm. Both lesions show outward bevelling. A bony reaction is detectable on the right lesion. Trepanations are the oldest surgical procedures with archaeological evidence and are defined as intentional perforation of the calvarium through removal of skull bone. Underlying soft tissues are usually not damaged. Trepanations have been carried out to treat head injuries or other diseases, also mental ones. In Europe, they have been practiced at least since the Neolithic by four main techniques: scraping, grooving, drilling with cutting, and sawing. This study presents two skulls with lesions from the Late Iron Age burial site of Münsingen-Rain in Switzerland. The aim was to analyse the lesions and to determine whether they were caused by intravitam surgery or postmortal manipulation. Furthermore, the work surveys all trepanations found in Switzerland so far, calculates survival rates and considers sex, age and localization. Tab. 1: In total, 34 individuals with 43 alleged trepanations are found in Switzerland. Three cases were excluded due to insufficient information (*). Most cases are adults between years. The number of trepanations per cranium varied from one to four. 32% of the trephined skulls are from the Neolithic, 29% from the Iron Age, and 26% from the Early Middle Ages. A total of 57% (23/40) of the surgeries were described as intra vital due to bony reactions. Therefore, the survival rate during the Iron Age is 78%. For the Neolithic it is 72%, for both the Bronze Age and the Late Antiquity it is 100%, whereas a survival rate of 50% was found for the Early Middle Ages. One case with four trepanations from Pre-Modern times was described for which the survival rate was 75%. Acknowledgement We are grateful to Christine Cooper for language editing and Levent Kara for support with CT imaging. References Skull 53Skull 103 The Late Iron Age in Switzerland spans from 450 to 15BC. Little is known about the population as written sources are scarce. The burial site of Münsingen- Rain ( BC) is situated near Bern. It was excavated in 1906 with an abundance of grave goods. In total, 220 burials were found. Skulls of 77 individuals and a few long bones are preserved. The site showed a horizontal stratigraphy with individuals buried chronologically from north to south. Sex and age were investigated using current anthropological methods and imaging was performed with a multislice CT scanner. Additionally, all reported trepanations from different periods found in Switzerland were compiled and a survival rate was calculated. Every single trepanation rather than the individuals were taken into consideration by following formula (iv = intravitam, perim = perimortem): Survival rate = [iv / (perim + iv)] * 100 DatingSiteGraveSexAgeLocation Time of surgery Survival rate Neolithic Locras/Lüscherznd n.d.occipitalend 72% Auvernierndf35-40r frontoparietalperim Saint-Aubinnd adult+r occipitalnd Collombey-Muraz14f37-41r orbitalperim Sion, Petit-Chasseurndm?adult+frontal and parietaliv / iv Sion, Petit-Chasseur III (H15-204)ndm20-44l parietaliv Sion, Petit-Chasseur III (H15-209)ndm25-35sutura sagittalisiv Sion, Petit-Chasseur III (H )ndf25-35l frontal, l and r parietaliv / iv /iv Corseaux-sur-Vevey1965-3f?35r frontoparietaliv Zurich, Grosser Hafnerndf?20-30r parietalperim Bronze Age Cressier *ndmadult+r frontoparietalpm 100% Glandndf?adult+l frontaliv Iron Age Basel, Gasfabrik (1)80nd17r parietaliv 78% Basel, Gasfabrik *(2)ndm29l parietalpm Stettlen-Deisswil33m20-25l parietalnd Münsingen-Rain, (A53)16madultl parietalperim Münsingen-Rain, (A103)152madult+l and r parietalperim / iv Sion, Bramois10m40-60l and r parietaliv / iv Sion, Sous-le-Scex430f23-45l parietaliv Sion, Sous-le-Scex436nd> 40l frontaliv Sion, Sous-le-Scex439m50-70l frontoparietalnd Sion, Sous-le-Scex546m40-50l parietaliv Late AntiquityWindisch7m45r parietaliv100% Early Middle Ages Villigen10f?> 60l parietalnd 50% Villigen *25nd6-7frontalend Arlesheimnd 2frontaleiv Basel, Aeschenvorstadtndm30-39l parietaliv Basel, Kleinhüningen108m50l parietalpm Riaz184f?20-30r frontalnd Bonaduz40m20-29r parietaliv Bonfolndm70occipitaleperim MelsB1madult+l and r parietalperim / perim Middle AgesBasel, Münsternd adult+l parietalnd0% Pre-Modern Times Steinhausenndf> 35l frontal, l parietaliv / iv /iv/perim75% Fig. 1: Two individuals with lesions on the skull were found at Münsigen-Rain. Skull A53 The individual probably died during or shortly after the surgery due to the absence of a bony reaction. The treatment was carried out most likely with a combination of techniques. The anterior and posterior funnel-shaping suggests that scraping was performed and the middle part was probably drilled before removal. The elongated lesion leads to the suggestion that the surgery was performed after a trauma caused by a sharp or half-sharp weapon such as a sword. Skull A103 The trepanations were performed by the scraping technique and the right side shows evidence of healing. The right trepanation was done first, followed by the second one at the left side during or shortly after which the individual probably died. Due to their symmetry and shape a previous injury was probably not the reason for the surgery. Trepanations in Switzerland The trepanation frequency in Münsingen is relatively high with 2.6% (2/77) compared to 1% in central European Iron Age. The abundance of weapons found in male graves might suggest that “warriors” were buried here. Only one trepanned individual from Iron Age Switzerland was female (11%), two were not determined, and six (67%) were male. This unbalanced distribution suggests that trepanations may have been carried out as surgery of injuries sustained through violence. Additionally, most individuals show trepanations on the left os parietale. A previous combat with a right-handed adversary is suggested as an explanation. Survival rate Scraping technique showed the highest survival rates in ancient trepanations. Although this technique was applied to both individuals, none of them survived. During Swiss Iron Age the medical skills and knowledge may have varied between the different tribes or periods. All individuals from Sion and Basel, which date to BC show healing. An explanation for this, compared to the earlier individuals of Münsingen, could be that an improvement might have taken place over time. The chances of survival appear to be relatively high from the Neolithic to the Late Antiquity, but decreases after the Late Antiquity until the Pre- Modern time. This suggests limited infections through natural antiseptics and a certain medical knowledge in prehistoric times.