NSI versus NU at the Neutrino Factory Euronu meeting Strasbourg June 2-4, 2010 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg TexPoint fonts used in EMF: AAAAA A A.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Flavor Violation in SUSY SEESAW models 8th International Workshop on Tau-Lepton Physics Tau04 Junji Hisano (ICRR, U of Tokyo)
Advertisements

TeV scale see-saws from higher than d=5 effective operators Neutrino masses and Lepton flavor violation at the LHC Würzburg, Germany November 25, 2009.
Neutrinoless double beta decay and Lepton Flavor Violation Or, in other words, how the study of LFV can help us to decide what mechanism is responsible.
1 Lepton Flavor Violation Yasuhiro Okada (KEK) October 7, rd International Conference on Flavor Physics National Central University, Taiwan.
Near detectors and systematics IDS-NF plenary meeting at TIFR, Mumbai October 13, 2009 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg TexPoint fonts used in EMF: AAAAA.
Non-Standard Neutrino Interactions Enrique Fernández-Martínez MPI für Physik Munich.
CP violation searches with Neutrino Factories and Beta Beams Neutrinos in Particle, in Nuclear and in Astrophysics Trento, Italy November 20, 2008 Walter.
Bounds on Neutrino Non-Standard Interactions Enrique Fernández-Martínez MPI für Physik Munich Based on collaborations with: S. Antusch, J. Baumann, C.
Low-energy neutrino physics Belén Gavela Universidad Autónoma de Madrid and IFT.
3+1 sterile Jacobo López–Pavón IFT UAM/CSIC NuFact IIT, Chicago, July
CP violation and mass hierarchy searches Neutrinos in particle physics and astrophysics (lecture) June 2009 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg TexPoint.
NEUTRINOLESS DOUBLE BETA DECAY ANGULAR CORRELATION AND NEW PHYSICS Dmitry Zhuridov Particles and Fields Journal club Department of Physics National Tsing.
Neutrino phenomenology Lecture 2: Precision physics with neutrinos Winter school Schladming 2010 “Masses and constants” Walter Winter Universität.
Neutrino oscillation physics with superbeams and neutrino factories Nu HoRIzons workshop HRI, India February 13-15, 2008 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg.
Can we distinguish among different models for mass in the near future? Carla Biggio Max-Planck-Institut für Physik, München, Germany Convegno informale.
2-nd Vienna Central European Seminar, Nov 25-27, Rare Meson Decays in Theories Beyond the Standard Model A. Ali (DESY), A. V. Borisov, M. V. Sidorova.
Neutrino physics Lecture 2: Theory of neutrino mass, and physics BSM? Herbstschule für Hochenergiephysik Maria Laach Walter Winter Universität.
Effects of exotic interactions in Neutrino Oscillations in matter Mario Campanelli Université de Genève Andrea Romanino Scuola Normale Superiore, Pisa.
Superluminal neutrinos at OPERA (experimental results and phenomenology) Group meeting November 8, 2011 Würzburg, Germany Walter Winter Universität Würzburg.
Test Z’ Model in Annihilation Type Radiative B Decays Ying Li Yonsei University, Korea Yantai University, China Based on J. Hua, C.S Kim, Y. Li, arxiv:
Osamu Yasuda Tokyo Metropolitan University Model independent analysis of New Physics interactions and implications for long baseline experiments INTERNATIONAL.
Physics with a very long neutrino factory baseline IDS Meeting CERN March 30, 2007 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg.
New physics searches with near detectors at the Neutrino Factory MINSIS workshop UAM Madrid December 10-11, 2009 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg TexPoint.
CP violation and mass hierarchy searches with Neutrino Factories and Beta Beams NuGoa – Aspects of Neutrinos Goa, India April 10, 2009 Walter Winter Universität.
Physics at the VLENF (very low energy neutrino factory) IDS-NF plenary meeting October 19-21, 2011 Arlington, VA, USA Walter Winter Universität Würzburg.
Neutrino Factory and Beta Beam Experiment NO-VE 2006 Venice, Italy February 8, 2006 Walter Winter Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton.
Impact of large  13 on long- baseline measurements at PINGU PINGU Workshop Erlangen university May 5, 2012 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg TexPoint.
Neutrino Factories Andrea Donini Instituto de Física Teórica/Instituto de Física Corpuscular CSIC European Strategy for Neutrino Oscillation Physics -
Matter Effect on Neutrino Oscillation from Universality Violation in Neutral Current Interactions Naotoshi Okamura (YITP) and Minako Honda (Ochanomizu.
Tests of non-standard neutrino interactions (NSI) Cecilia Lunardini Institute for Nuclear Theory University of Washington, Seattle.
Neutrino factory physics reach … and impact of detector performance 2 nd ISS Meeting KEK, Tsukuba, Japan January 24, 2006 Walter Winter Institute for Advanced.
Flavor induced EDMs with tanbeta enhanced corrections Minoru Nagai (ICRR, Univ. of Tokyo) Aug. 4, 2007 Summer Institute 2007 In collaborated with: J.Hisano.
K.K. Gan The Ohio State University New Results on  Lepton July 17, 2003.
QFD, Weak Interactions Some Weak Interaction basics
Neutrino mass and DM direct detection Daijiro Suematsu (Kanazawa Univ.) Erice Sept., 2013 Based on the collaboration with S.Kashiwase PRD86 (2012)
Contents of IDR: PPEG IDS-NF plenary meeting RAL, UK September 22-25, 2010 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg TexPoint fonts used in EMF: AAAAA A A A.
Yukawa and scalar interactions induced by scalar relevant for neutrino masss generation are: Since is assumed to be an exact symmetry of the model has.
Neutrino mass models at the TeV scale, naturally BENE 2012 ICTP Trieste Sept , 2012 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg TexPoint fonts used in EMF:
Dynamical EWSB and Fourth Generation Michio Hashimoto (KEK) Mt. Tsukuba M.H., Miransky, M.H., Miransky, in preparation.
Long baseline neutrino oscillations: Theoretical aspects NOW 2008 Conca Specchiulla, Italy September 9, 2008 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg TexPoint.
Optimizing the green-field beta beam NuFact 08 Valencia, Spain June 30-July 5, 2008 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg.
Optimization of a neutrino factory for non-standard neutrino interactions IDS plenary meeting RAL, United Kingdom January 16-17, 2008 Walter Winter Universität.
Thoughts on the optimization of the VLENF VLENF meeting at Fermilab, USA September 1, 2011 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg TexPoint fonts used in EMF:
Gravitino Dark Matter in R-violating SUSY M. Lola MEXT-CT Work with N.E.Bomark, P.Osland and A.Raklev.
Near detectors for new physics searches IDS-NF plenary meeting at TIFR, Mumbai October 12, 2009 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg TexPoint fonts used.
Testing neutrino properties at the Neutrino Factory Astroparticle seminar INFN Torino December 3, 2009 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg TexPoint fonts.
PPEG plan for development of physics case for RDR IDS-NF plenary meeting October 19-21, 2011 Arlington, VA, USA Walter Winter Universität Würzburg TexPoint.
Sterile neutrinos at the Neutrino Factory IDS-NF plenary meeting October 19-21, 2011 Arlington, VA, USA Walter Winter Universität Würzburg TexPoint fonts.
Family Gauge Bosons with an Inverted Mass Hierarchy Yoshio Koide (Osaka University) in collaboration with Toshifumi Yamashita (Maskawa Insititute, KSU)
Mixing in Quarks and Leptons Xiao-Gang He NTU&SJTU NTU&SJTU 1. Mixing in Quarks and Neutrinos 2. Unitarity Tests of Mixing Matrices 3. Some Recent Hints.
Osamu Yasuda Tokyo Metropolitan University Summary of Phenomenology Subgroup International scoping study of a future Neutrino Factory and super-beam facility.
1 Summary of the session: Interplay between neutrino masses and other phenomenological signatures Tommy Ohlsson Department of Theoretical Physics, Royal.
Z’ Signals from KK Dark Matter Sabine Riemann (DESY) LCWS, Stanford, March 18-22, 2005 Outline  Universal extra dimensions (UED)  KK dark matter?  Sensitivity.
Optimization of a neutrino factory for large  13 Golden 07 IFIC, Valencia June 28, 2007 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg.
EDMs in the SUSY GUTs Junji Hisano (ICRR, Univ. of Tokyo) NuFact04 6th International Workshop on Neutrino Factories and Superbeams, Osaka University, Japan.
Systematics at the Neutrino Factory … and the global context NuInt 2012 Rio de Janeiro, Brazil Oct , 2012 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg TexPoint.
THE CONNECTION BETWEEN NEUTRINO EXPERIMENTS AND LEPTOGENESIS Alicia Broncano Berrocal MPI.
1-2 Mass Degeneration in the Leptonic Sector Hiroyuki ISHIDA (Tohoku University) Collaboration with : Takeshi ARAKI (MISC) Ref ; T. Araki and H.I. arXiv.
A model for large non-standard interactions of neutrinos leading to the LMA-dark solution Yasaman Farzan IPM, Tehran.
Carla Biggio Universidad Autónoma de Madrid Neutrino masses and new TeV scale HEP 2007, Manchester, England, 19-25/07/07 Based on: Antusch, CB,
and what we unsuccessfully tried to explain (so far)
Takaaki Nomura(Saitama univ)
NuGoa – Aspects of Neutrinos Goa, India April 10, Walter Winter
cLFV in Seesaw Models (after LHC12, θ and MEG13)
On systematics in GLoBES
PMNS Matrix Elements Without Assuming Unitarity
Probing non-standard neutrino physics at T2KK and neutrino factory
Will T2KK see new physics?
Theoretical Status of LFV and Rare Tau decays
A possible interplay between flavor and LHC Physics
Presentation transcript:

NSI versus NU at the Neutrino Factory Euronu meeting Strasbourg June 2-4, 2010 Walter Winter Universität Würzburg TexPoint fonts used in EMF: AAAAA A A A

2 Contents  Introduction: New physics from heavy mediators  Non-standard interactions (NSI)  Non-unitarity (NU)  NU versus NSI at the NuFact  Summary  Based on „Non-standard interactions versus non-unitary lepton flavor mixing at a neutrino factory“ by Davide Meloni, Tommy Ohlsson, Walter Winter, He Zhang, JHEP 04 (2010) 041, arXiv: [hep-ph], EURONU-WP arXiv: [hep-ph]

3  Effective operator picture if mediators integrated out: Describes additions to the SM in a gauge-inv. way!  BEYOND NEUTRINO MASS: Interesting leptonic dimension six operators Fermion-mediated  Non-unitarity (NU) Scalar- or vector-mediated  Non-standard int. (NSI) New physics from heavy mediators mass d=6, 8, 10,...: NSI, NU

4 Non-standard interactions  Typically described by effective four fermion interactions (here with leptons)  May lead to matter NSI (for  =  =e)  May also lead to source/detector NSI (e.g. NuFact:   NF for  =  =e,  =  ) These source/det.NSI are process-dep.!

5 Lepton flavor violation … and the story of SU(2) gauge invariance  Strong bounds ee e  NSI (FCNC) ee e  CLFV e  4 -NSI (FCNC) Ex.: e e  Affects neutrino oscillations in matter (or neutrino production)  Affects environments with high densities (supernovae) BUT: These phenomena are connected by SU(2) gauge invariance  Almost impossible to construct a model for large (O(0.1)) leptonic matter NSI with d=6 operators (Bergmann, Grossman, Pierce, hep-ph/ ; Antusch, Baumann, Fernandez-Martinez, arXiv: ; Gavela, Hernandez, Ota, Winter,arXiv: )  Even with d=8 effective operators, constructing a model with large NSI is not trivial!  This talk: Focus on „small“ O(0.01) – O(0.001) effects

6 d=6 NSI without CLFV  At d=6: Simplest possibility is operator of the type  Without cancellations: Singly charged scalar is the only possible mediator No CLFV:  d=6 NSI without CLFV imply, in general (even with loops): (Gavela, Hernandez, Ota, Winter, 2008) Projection on basisFeynman diagrams

7 Current bounds and measurements at NuFact  Compared to the model- independent bounds, the bounds for the scalar-mediated d=6 operators are strong (e.g. from lepton universality tests) (Antusch, Baumann, Fernandez-Martinez, arXiv: ; Biggio, Blennow, Fernandez-Martinez, arXiv: )  A  near detector at NuFact would help to improve these by a factor of a few (Tang, Winter, arXiv: ) ND5: OPERA-like ND at d=1 km, 90% CL

8 Non-unitarity of mixing matrix  Integrating out heavy fermion fields (such as in a type-I TeV see-saw), one obtains neutrino mass and the d=6 operator (de Gouvea et al, 2002; Abada et al, 2007)  Re-diagonalizing and re-normalizing the kinetic terms of the neutrinos, one has (Broncano, Gavela, Jenkins, 2003; Antusch et al, 2006)  This can be described by an effective (non-unitary) mixing matrix  with N=(1+  ) U  Similar effect to NSI, but source, detector, and matter NSI are correlated in a particular, fundamental way (i.e., process- independent)

9 Impact of near detector  Example: (Antusch, Blennow, Fernandez-Martinez, Lopez-Pavon, arXiv: )   near detector important to detect zero-distance effect Curves: 10kt, 1 kt, 100 t, no ND

10 NU versus NSI (d=6) Distinguish two classes of d=6 non-standard effects (NSE) without CLFV: 1.Fermion-mediated leptonic d=6 operator (NU, O F )  Particular correlation among source, propagation, detection effects  Experiment-independent: appear at NuFact + Superbeam! 2.Scalar-mediated leptonic d=6 operator (NSI, O S )  At tree level, no cancellations: Only mediated by scalars  Leads to source NSI at NuFact (not superbeam) and matter NSI  Can one identify these/distinguish these?  Theory: Can one distinguish between fermions and scalars as heavy mediators (simplest interpretation)? NB: These two are the only classes of d=6 operators leading to NSE without CLFV Hadronic NSI: not possible to cancel CLFV independently Antusch, Blennow, Fernandez-Martinez, Ota, arXiv:

11 Correlations Source – propagation - detection 1.O F (for ordinary matter with N p = N n ) Forbidden: (see e.g. Fernandez-Martinez, Gavela, Lopez-Pavon, Yasuda, 2007; Antusch, Baumann, Fernandez-Martinez, 2008) 2.O S (without CLFV) Forbidden: … and no detector effects (leptonic NSI)! (Gavela, Hernandez, Ota, Winter, 2008) 3.Other: No particular correlations, all effects allowed

12 NuFact versus Superbeam  One can exclude by the discovery of certain effects  Maybe most interesting: (Meloni, Ohlsson, Winter, Zhang, 2009)

13 Example:    Relationships: O F : O S :  Probability difference: (Kopp, Lindner, Ota, Sato, 2007 vs. Antusch, Blennow, Fernandez-Martinez, Lopez- Pavon, 2009; see Meloni, Ohlsson, Winter, Zhang, 2009)  Consequence: Difference depends on NSI CP-phase  If  appearance channel (SBL, NuFact) Not in Superbeam

14 Pheno consequences (NF)  Difficult to disentangle with NuFact alone  Use superbeam? (Meloni, Ohlsson, Winter, Zhang, 2009) ND-L: OPERA-like at 1km

15 Distinguishing NSI from NU  Can hardly distinguish with NuFact alone in region beyond current bounds  Need Superbeam exp. with sensitivity   << (90% CL) (Meloni, Ohlsson, Winter, Zhang, 2009)

16 Summary  There is a physics case for a NuFact  near detector for NSI, NU  For NSE from d=6 effective operators without CLFV certain correlation between source and propagation effects exist  For NuFact, because of the neutrino production by muon decays, these are partly similar for NSI and NU, which makes it hard to distinguish these effects  An independent measurement at a superbeam could lift this ambiguity  At d=6, the simplest interpretation of „NSI versus NU“ is: „Scalar versus fermion as heavy mediator“