SNS Modulator Fires; Causes, Mitigation, and Long-Term Plans David E. Anderson.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
ESLS 04 Daresbury Laboratory
Advertisements

SECTION 11 LEVEL B SUIT OUT. SECTION 12 AIR MONITORING.
Regional Gliding School Problems With The Fuel System n Very rapid and violent burning of the fuel in the cylinder. n Causes overheating and damage.
Brio 2000 / Brio 2000-M E-Learning Service Manual Rev. 0.0.
Emergency Action Plans
Setup/Installation/Operation of an Environmental Control Unit (ECU)
© 2012 Copyright, Phil Ackland and Associates Understanding Commercial Kitchen System Fires Sponsored by the Calgary Fire Department May 28-29,
Accident Investigation Root Cause Analysis
Presented by Malcolm Seltzer-Grant, HVPD Ltd
NERC Lessons Learned Summary December NERC lessons learned published in December 2014 Three NERC lessons learned (LL) were published in December.
Concept Design Review (CoDR) Shore Station DC Breaker Cable model Transient Analysis Components.
Design and Computer Modeling of Ultracapacitor Regenerative Braking System Adam Klefstad, Dr. Kim Pierson Department of Physics & Astronomy UW-Eau Claire.
© Siemens Industry, Inc Confidential / Drive Your Business Forward Ignite the Power of New Products and Partnerships Siemens Fire Partner Summit.
Maintenance At Your WWTP August 2010
ODH Fans and Work Planning Protecting Against the Big Event 10 Questions Before Starting a Job at C-AD Photo of the Week Collider-Accelerator Department.
KLINGE’S NMR 262 Two Independent Systems Integrated into one Unit This Requires Special Features:  Total Redundancy of Refrigeration Components  Total.
DECLERCQ Jan BE Alpha 4 – Block 2 Barcelona May TRANSFORMERS FOR WIND TURBINES NEED FOR NEW DESIGNS OR BUSINESS AS USUAL Dr. Jan Declercq.
1 Advanced Technology Reliable Quality Customer Satisfaction Copyright © CALB All Rights Reserved
Power Device Characteristics Voltage Rating: Off state blocking voltage – exceed and destroy! Current Rating: On (saturation) state maximum – exhibits.
Designing for LED electrical safety Presentation at the Lighting Fixture Design Conference 6 th June 2013 By Ken Dale, Principal Engineer, Harvard Engineering.
Lindy Hughes Fleet Fire Protection Program Engineer Southern Nuclear Operating Company June 4, 2013 Fire Protection.
ILC Marx Modulator Development Program G.E. Leyh, Stanford Linear Accelerator Center.
SAFETY FOLLOW-UP HL-LHC PROJECT WP17 – Infrastructures meeting S. La Mendola, Jose Gascon DGS/SEE 09 July 2015.
Lease Automatic Custody Transfer
Welcome Presentation On Office security system. Group Members: Md. Emdadul Haque Md. Sahed Hasan Md. Samsul Arefin Khokan Das.
Power Distribution Harmonics Case Study of 285-3F Chiller Plant Michael W. Harmon Principle Engineer Savannah River Nuclear Solutions, LLC Savannah River.
TEV DUMP SWITCH FAILURES OF 2/10/09 Dan Wolff/EE Support.
1 Power Quality Mary Santori, P.E. Senior Engineer September 12, 2013.
FSRUG Presentation – January 2014 Tennessee Valley Authority Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant Unit 3 Reactor Feed Water (FW) Clean Up Piping Break.
CV activities on LHC complex during the long shutdown Serge Deleval Thanks to M. Nonis, Y. Body, G. Peon, S. Moccia, M. Obrecht Chamonix 2011.
Linac Marx Modulator Update Trevor Butler 10/29/2014.
Electrical Distribution Training
1 INTRUSION ALARM TECHNOLOGY POWER SUPPLIES. 2 INTRUSION ALARM TECHNOLOGY Security systems shall have a primary power source and a secondary power source.
Ion Source Update. We now have 2 running sources Source B has been running since the first part of June Both sources have been modified extensively since.
Gek 16/6/041 ITRP Comments on Question 19 GEK 9/06/04 19) For the X-band (warm) technology, detail the status of the tests of the full rf delivery system.
Brookhaven Science Associates Accelerator Safety Workshop Lessons Learned at C-AD Accelerators E. Lessard August 7-9, 2007.
LSST Camera CD-3 Review Brookhaven National Laboratory, Brookhaven, NY LSST Safety Council Camera Review Bremerton, WA 2015 LSST Camera Environment,
Klystron Modulator for Proton Driver
Electrical Fire in Terminal Room at Collider-Accelerator Department Relay-Fire Investigation Committee
Management and Organisation of Electricity Use Electrical System Optimisation Belgrade November 2003.
Operational SNS Karen S. White Controls Group Leader 10/11/10.
CM1 Thermal Cycle CM1 Warmup –1/4/12 (Wed.) to 1/6/12 (Fri.) (~50 hours) –Verified turbo interlock system works CM1 Cooldown –Began 1/9/12 (Monday) –At.
September, 2009 H-BRIDGE MODULES AS BOX-LEVEL PULSED POWER COMPONENTS R.J Adler, V Weeks, J. A Gilbrech, and D. T Price Applied Energetics Tucson, AZ,
Utility Engineers, PC.  Generation  Transmission  Distribution.
Managed by UT-Battelle for the Department of Energy SCL Vacuum Control System Upgrade Derrick Williams
1 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES 2009 DOE Accelerator Safety Workshop BNL S-band LINAC Fire Safety Concerns August 19, 2009 A. Ackerman.
2011 PLANT OPERATIONS MODULE 8 Maintain Bulk Plant Systems and Equipment.
Teknologi Pusat Data 12 Data Center Site Infrastructure Tier Standard: Topology Ida Nurhaida, ST., MT. FASILKOM Teknik Informatika.
Ans Pardons (with input from Jean-Marc Cravero) CERN CNGS Horn Experience (issues since NBI2010) Ans Pardons, CERN 1 NBI2012.
Operational experience of high-power RF at Diamond Light Source
Power Systems J. Sandberg July 2006 RHIC Retreat 2006.
Utilities & Engineering Department16 Blossom St., Boston Introduction to the Hospital Emergency Power Supply System (EPSS) Jason D'Antona,
Reliability of SNS Superconducting Linac April 12, 2011 Jeff Saunders SNS/ORNL.
Chapter 3 PHYSICAL INJURY AND CONTROLS 3.2 Electrical Safety
Process Safety Management Soft Skills Programme Nexus Alliance Ltd.
PHENIX Smoke Alarms Incident, 27-May-2016 Mickey Chiu, for the PHENIX Operations Crew.
Reliability and Performance of the SNS Machine Protection System Doug Curry 2013.
Content: Introduction A Simple Gas Turbine Plant & It’s Working Plant Layout Types according to Cycle 1. Open Cycle Gas Turbine Plants 2. Close Cycle.
Temperature Test Allows monitoring of temperature changes.
Comparison of AIS and GIS Grid Station Muhammad Ali Ashraf Management Associate (Electrical) CPP Project.
The Survey of the Power Supply Reliability at SSRF
FIRE PROTECTION & SECURITY in ELI Beamlines
Novel Protection Schemes for HVDC System
Model Output Current Battery Life BATPSU VDC 2A 1.2Ah BATPSU VDC 2.3Ah
FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEM.
Operation of Target Safety System (TSS)
Presentation transcript:

SNS Modulator Fires; Causes, Mitigation, and Long-Term Plans David E. Anderson

2Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy HVCM Simplified Block Diagram

3Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy HVCM Major Subsystems

4Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy Cavity/Klystron/Modulator Layout Multiple HVCM/Klystron Configurations Peak Power 11 MW, Average Power 1 MW design 115 kV 125 kV ≤135 kV ≤75 kV 75 kV

5Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy HVCM “Smoke Generating” Events 70 Total Events 1 during last production run Most do not result in fires but response is consistent until incident evaluated

6Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy HVCM Fire Causes – Bus Arcing 1 st fire, none since, in RF Test Facility Workmanship or residual dirt believed responsible Repeated arcing acted as ignition source for combustibles Corrected with improved training of assemblers, no faults w/ same root cause since (Jan 07)

7Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy HVCM Fire Causes – Insulation Degradation Cause of 2 fires and likely many of the IGBT failures Original design relies on single layer of DMD to insulate cooling tubes from different polarity bus Interference fit between tube and bus compresses DMD and can cut material if sharp edges present Corona degrades insulation over time, resulting in arc event Insulation double, short-term sol’n., cutout long-term

8Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy HVCM Fire Causes – Capacitors Mfgr.’s cap lifetime ratings 100, V, Expanded the lifetime on the spec. to 1 million hours Experience indicates ≤ 2300 V Replaced all warm linac caps w/ higher lifetime spec caps Replacing all other caps with new caps, starting to see failures of RSO units

9Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy HVCM Capacitor Comparison Capacitor Type Oper. Temp. Range IPB °F BTDP small °F BTDP large °F RSO °F Solid Potted<100°F IPB no longer available, original batch of capacitors as delivered Others tried –Reconstituted mica, failed in tens of minutes –Another manufacturer’s RSO, failed in 18 hours IPB Isopropyl Biphenyl BTDP Benzyltoluene Diphenylethane RSO Rapeseed Oil

10Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy HVCM Fire Causes – IGBTs Usually less severe, lower collateral damage At transition to 60 Hz operation, incidents increased significantly Improved thermal bonding procedures implemented Overvoltage problem solved, minimal problems since

11Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy HVCM Fire Mitigation – CO 2 Suppression Dedicated CO2 system installed Smoke detector installed EPICS screens updated Manual discharge from CCR if smoke detector trips Prevent or minimize system damage

12Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy HVCM Fire Mitigation – Additional Over Current detection on energy storage capacitor bank to limit fault energy Retraining workers / rewriting procedures for operators Implement Alarm Handler for smoke detector events Installing shrapnel shields around capacitors to minimize collateral damage Emergency Off modified to remove 2100 V primary energy source automatically Replace combustible materials inside Enclosure with UL-94 V0 rated plastics (G9 Phenolic) Replace cables with plenum-rated cables Design new IGBT drive circuitry to shut IGBTs off if over current detected

13Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy Future Capacitor Replacement ICIC V CE VCVC RSO Plastic Case Self-Clearing Metallized Polypropylene Ran capacitors until July shutdown Assess self-clearing capacitor degradation Simulate 10 years of faults on preferred capacitor Choose and order capacitor selected Install when delivered during 1 st FY10 Extended Shutdown Period

14Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy Future “Series Switch” ICIC V CE VCVC Decouples primary energy storage when fault detected Minimizes energy delivered to fault, prevents collateral damage Can be used to add a future redundant H-bridge

15Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy Capacitor / IGBT Preventative Maintenance ICIC V CE VCVC Liquid dielectric – Monitor case temperature – Inspect periodically for leakage – Inspect for case dimensions out of tolerance – Return suspect units to manufacturer for analysis and design improvements Solid potted self-clearing – All of above – Periodically measure capacitance value and replace when 5% degradation occurs IGBTs – Monitor for changes in Turn on time Turn on delay Turn off time Turn off delay Gate characteristics Monitor substrate temperature with thermal interlocks All monitored via transformer flux monitoring system Periodically monitored during shutdowns

16Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy ORPS Reporting ORPS reporting threshold is the activation of an automatic fire suppression system but NOT a manually-actuated or detection system – No automatic suppression employed – Building central detection system (VESDA) rarely detects HVCM events – ORPS considers burn times > 5 minutes significant – No HVCM event has passed the reporting threshold – All events have been contained inside the aluminum / stainless steel Safety Enclosure UT/Battelle and DOE ORO periodically review the HVCM smoke event history through self-assessment and oversight activities

17Managed by UT-Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy Conclusion Many “smoke generating” events to date, none severe Engineering and procedural controls and protection systems put in place Nature of component failures believed to be well understood, PM and component replacement underway to address Additional protection systems in design to further enhance system availability Hopeful that these event can be significantly reduced in the future QUESTIONS?