Hedgehog Signaling Regulates Proliferation in Chondrosarcoma: Implications for Novel Therapy Dung Tiet* Sevan Hopyan Puvi Nadesan Ben Alman Jay Wunder Mount Sinai Hospital, Toronto, Canada Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Canada
Treatment of Chondrosarcoma Radiation resistant Chemotherapy resistant Requires radical surgery
Chondrosarcoma: Clues to Etiology Enchondromas are benign precursor lesions Enchondromas may arise from abnormal regulation of growth plate chondrocytes Normal growth plate regulation: Indian hedgehog (IHH) and Parathyroid hormone related protein (PTHrP)
Resting zone Proliferative zone Prehypertrophic zone Hypertrophic zone PTHrP-R Indian Hedgehog PTHrP Programmed Cell Death Growth Plate Chondrocyte Differentiation Perichondrium
Hedgehog Signaling PKA
GDP Gs GTP cAMP AC PKA PTH PTHrP PTHR-1 Gq DAG PLC IP3 Ca++ PKC NHERF Known pathways in PTHrP Signaling
IHH PTHrP Proliferation Differentiation
Chondrosarcoma: Clues to Etiology Some cases of enchondromatosis are caused by mutation of the PTHrP protein receptor (PTHR1) Constitutive activation of Hedgehog signaling Transgenic mice - mutant PTHR1 - Gli2 Multiple enchondroma-like lesions Hopyan et al, Nature Genetics 30: 306, 2002
Treatment Implications Hedgehog signaling causes cartilage neoplasia Hedgehog blockade might be used to treat these tumours
Chondrosarcoma: Study Goals Expression of IHH/PTHrP pathway genes Tumor explant culture system to assess the effects of Hedgehog blockade Tumor xenograft model to examine the effects of Hedgehog blockade
Chondrosarcoma: Methods Sarcoma tumor bank for frozen specimens Gene expression by quantitative RT-PCR Tumor explant culture system –4 growth plate, 2 enchondroma, 10 chondrosarcoma –agonists: Shh, PTHrP –Hedgehog blockade: cyclopamine –proliferation (thymidine), differentiation (ColX) Tumor xenograft model –12 chondrosarcoma –Hedgehog blockade: triparanol –proliferation (BrdU), cellularity, size, apoptosis (TUNEL), Hedgehog target gene expression,
Hedgehog Blocking Agents Cyclopamine identified as a teratogen binds and inactivates SMO Triparanol an inhibitor of cholesterol synthesis increases PTCH repression of SMO
Gene Expression in Chondrosarcoma
Are IHH/PTHrP pathway members expressed? IHH, PTCH, GLI1, GLI2, GLI3, PTHrP, PTHR1 Consistent expression in all ECA and CSA Is Hedgehog signaling active? Levels of PTCH and GLI1 were higher in ECA and CSA compared to normal articular cartilage or cortical bone Gene Expression in Chondrosarcoma
Chondrosarcoma Tumor Explants
GAPDH -Type X collagen + Cyclopamine
Growth Plate Enchondroma AS IHH AS IHH 0.1%FCS PTHrP PCR cycles Is the IHH/PTHrP Signaling Pathway Functional in Cartilage Tumors? IHH PTHrP Proliferation Differentiation
IHH PTHrP Proliferation Differentiation X Constitutively Active Hedgehog Signaling in Cartilaginous Neoplasia
Human chondrosarcoma samples (n=12) NOD-SCID mice Each tumor cut sample into 10 equal pieces Feed mice with triparanol Feed mice with olive oil Collect tumours Freeze samples for molecular analysis Place samples in fixative for staining Tumor Xenograft Model
Do Mice Uptake Triparanol? Serum Cholesterol Levels * n = 3, p-value < 0.01 using Student t-test
Does Triparanol Block Hedgehog Target Gene Expression in the Bones of Treated Mice? Olive OilTriparanol GAPDH PTCH n=12, p-value <0.05 using student t-test
* n =12, p-value = 0.01 using Student t-test Triparanol: Tumor Size
n=3, p-value < 0.05 using Student t-test Triparanol: Tumor Proliferation
Olive Oil Triparanol Triparanol: Cellularity n=12, p-value <0.05 using student t-test
Triparanol: Apoptosis n=3, p-value < 0.86 using Student t-test
Hedgehog signaling is active in chondrosarcoma PTHrP cannot downregulate IHH Constitutive Hedgehog signaling Triparanol attenuates the proliferative phenotype of chondrosarcoma Hedgehog blocking agents may provide a novel therapeutic strategy for chondrosarcoma Hedgehog signaling and blockade are also functional in other cancers: Breast, GI, Prostate, Basal cell carcinoma, Medulloblastoma Conclusion
Acknowledgements Nalan Gokgoz Irene Andrulis Bob Bell Peter Ferguson
Size mm 3 Triparanol Carrier Histology
Collaborators: Toronto J. Wunder, I. Andrulis, R. Bell, W. Cole, CC. Hui Boston H. Juppner, R. Gensure Funding: CIHR, IHRT, NCIC, Terry Fox Run, Hospital for Sick Children, Canadian Research Chairs program