International Telecommunication Union New Delhi, India, 19-20 December 2011 ITU Workshop on Standards and Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Issues Brad.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Defining Open Standards: A Comparison of Policy and Practice Steve Mutkoski Senior Standards Strategist.

Advertisements

MOTOROLA and the Stylized M Logo are registered in the US Patent & Trademark Office. All other product or service names are the property of their respective.

SOS Interop II Sophia Antipolis, September 20 and 21, 2005 IPRs and standards: some issues Richard Owens Director, Copyright E-Commerce Division Philippe.

GSC: Standardization Advancing Global Communications Towards a Common ITU/ISO/IEC Patent Policy by Masamichi Niiya Telecommunication Standardization Bureau.

Freescale Semiconductor Confidential and Proprietary Information. Freescale and the Freescale logo are trademarks of Freescale Semiconductor, Inc. All.

History of Ecma Rules and Patent Policy 29 June 2011 Michael Breidthardt.

International Telecommunication Union New Delhi, India, December 2011 ITU Workshop on Standards and Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Issues Dr.

International Telecommunication Union New Delhi, India, December 2011 ITU Workshop on Standards and Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Issues Arun.

ITU WORKSHOP ON STANDARDS AND INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS (IPR) ISSUES Session 5: Software copyright issues Dirk Weiler, Chairman of ETSI General Assembly.

Standards-Setting, IPR Policies, and Open Standards Steve Mutkoski Regional Director, Interoperability & Innovation Microsoft Corporation

The Life Cycle of Standards Presented by the International Electrotechnical Commission.

1 European Standardisation and the Identification of ICT Technical Specifications 13th XBRL Europe Day Rome, 6 May 2014 Antonio Conte, Project Manager.

Fostering worldwide interoperabilityGeneva, July 2009 "Update on Activities of the TIA IPR Standing Committee since GSC-13" Amy Marasco TIA Delegation.

KEY FACTORS DRIVING SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT Seow Hiong GOH Director, Software Policy (Asia) Business Software Alliance May 2007.

1 ABA 25 th Annual IPL Conference Patents, Standards, and Licensing Working (Well) Together At Texas Instruments Lawrence J. Bassuk Deputy General Patent.

Working Together for Interoperability Sandra K. Paul Immediate Past Chair Management Group of the IEC/ISO/ITU/UNECE Management Group of the IEC/ISO/ITU/UNECE.

Trends in ICT Standards in European Standardisation Bodies and Standards Consortia Knut Blind and Stephan Gauch 4th International Conference on Standardization.

An empirical study on the determinants of essential patent claims in compatibility standards Rudi Bekkers,Rene Bongard,Alessandro Nuvolari Research Policy.

International Telecommunication Union New Delhi, India, December 2011 ITU Workshop on Standards and Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Issues Dr.

Standards, Patents and Policy (Public and Private) Tim Simcoe, University of Toronto Marc Rysman, Boston University.

1Having confidence in certification CASCO Comms/ International Organization for Standardization.

International Telecommunication Union New Delhi, India, December 2011 ITU Workshop on Standards and Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Issues Rapporteurs:

INTERNATIONAL ELECTROTECHNICAL COMMISSION. established standards development process National Committees involved at each stage Technical Committees.

China’s Approach to Standards-related Intellectual Property Rights Development – Legal Framework and Implementation “Standards and Innovation Policy in.

Activities of ARIB - Standardization and IPR - Tadaaki YOKOO Executive Director, ARIB Document No: GSC-IPR- Source: Association of Radio Industries and.

Universal PV Interface™ Alliance Overview December 2011.

GSC-19 Meeting, July 2015, Geneva CCSA Report Zemin Yang, Secretary-General, CCSA Document No:GSC-19_012 Source:CCSA Contact:Zemin Yang Agenda Item:2.3.

Copyright 2006, ZTE CORPORATION Standardization Boosting The Overall Industry Development Guo Xiao Ming Chief Counsellor Director of IPR ZTE CORPORATION.

Practising open procurement of IT Thomas Vinje, Partner, Clifford Chance LLP, Brussels 10 June 2010.

Deepak Maheshwari Director – Corporate Affairs Microsoft India.

GSC-19 Meeting, July 2015, Geneva CCSA Report Zemin Yang CCSA Secretary-General Document No:GSC-19_012 Source:CCSA Contact:Zemin Yang Agenda Item:2.3.

GSC-8xxx SOURCE:TIA TITLE:IPR Working Group Report AGENDA ITEM:Closing Plenary Agenda Item 1.1 DECISION DISCUSSIONX INFORMATIONX 21/10/2015 Report on the.

An R&D Manager’s Perspective TechExpo October 5, 2004 Presented by: Veena Rawat.

1 Leveraging the WTO/TBT Agreement New Delhi, India September 11, 2008 Elise Owen Representative for China and India Affairs American National Standards.

International Telecommunication Union New Delhi, India, December 2011 ITU Workshop on Standards and Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Issues Philip.

1 Slides for Class #6 ASU Technology Standards Seminar March 1, 2010 Brad Biddle.

International Telecommunication Union New Delhi, India, December 2011 ITU Workshop on Standards and Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Issues Utsab.

1 Slides for Class #11 ASU Technology Standards Seminar April 12, 2010 Brad Biddle.

International Telecommunication Union ITU Workshop on Standards and Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Issues Yukio Hiramatsu Chairman, TTC IPR Committee.

Geneva, Oct 8, 2012 Latest developments in the field of IPR since GSC-16 Antoine DORE Senior Legal Officer, ITU Document No: GSC16bis-IPR-10 Source: ITU.

1 WIPO-KIPO-KIPA IP Panorama Business School, October 6 to 10, 2008 IP Strategies in Standards Setting Tomoko Miyamoto Senior Counsellor, Patent Law Section.

5 REASONS WHY PATENT DISCLOSURE IN STANDARDS SETTING ORGS DOESN’T WORK (AND WHAT TO DO INSTEAD) BRAD BIDDLE VISITING SCHOLAR, LEWIS AND CLARK LAW SCHOOL.

Moscow, Russia, 10 September 2012 HSE Intellectual Property Policy Aliya Ermakova, Head of IP Department, Innovation and Enterprise Office, HSE

1 Slides for Class #10 ASU Technology Standards Seminar April 5, 2010 Brad Biddle.

1 AIPPI Forum 2011 Hyderabad, India, 15 October AIPPI Forum 2011 Hyderabad, India, 15 October 2011 Standardisation and Software Protection Strategies.

International Telecommunication Union New Delhi, India, December 2011 ITU Workshop on Standards and Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Issues Dr.

Policy on the Management of Intellectual Property in Technology Transfer Activities at CERN CERN/FC/5434/RA Technology Transfer Network Meeting – 10 th.

1 Summary of issues and results from GSC-12 IPR WG Dan Bart, TIA Chair IPR WG SOURCE:Dan Bart, IPR WG Chair TITLE:Report of GSC-12 IPR WG AGENDA ITEM:Closing.

Telecommunications for Disaster Relief Page - 1 International Telecommunication Union Workshop on Telecommunications for Disaster Relief, February.

ITU Workshop on Standards and Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) issues IPR in ICT standards View ’ s of the European Commission Anne Lehouck New Delhi,

The form of foreign economic activities in Tajikistan Prepared by Dzhumaev Toh 3-rd course.

1 Slides for Class #7 ASU Technology Standards Seminar March 8, 2010 Brad Biddle.

Summary of GSC-13 IPR WG Meeting Tom Goode, ATIS IPR WG Chair DOCUMENT #:GSC13-CL-05r1 FOR:Presentation SOURCE:Tom Goode, IPR WG Chair AGENDA ITEM:3.4.

특허기술의 국제표준화 동향 및 대책 특허청 심사 4 국 특허청 심사 4 국정보심사담당관실 심사관 서 호 선 심사관 서 호 선.

International Electrotechnical Commission International Electrotechnical Commission.

International Telecommunication Union New Delhi, India, December 2011 ITU Workshop on Standards and Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Issues Antoine.

Internet Governance Forum 2006: Open Standards Workshop Susy Struble IT Standardization and Government Policy Sun Microsystems Creative Commons Attribution-Share.

Update on SDO IPR Policy Debates

Summary of issues and results from GSC-12 IPR WG

Standards and Intellectual Property Rights in ITU

IEEE Intellectual Property Discussion

TTC Activities on IPR in Standards

Arbitration – Telecoms Industry

NJTIP 8th Annual Symposium FRAND Overview

Summary of GSC-16bis IPR WG Meeting

Intel’s Views on IPR in Standards

Earl Nied Vice Chair, ANSI IPRPC

Towards a Common ITU/ISO/IEC Patent Policy

Review of GSC-10 IPR WG 45 attendees

Summary of GSC-13 IPR WG Meeting

Presentation transcript:

International Telecommunication Union New Delhi, India, December 2011 ITU Workshop on Standards and Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Issues Brad Biddle Arizona State University Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law How Many Standards in a Laptop (and Other Empirical Questions)

International Telecommunication Union 2 About the Authors Brad Biddle Adjunct Professor and Research Fellow, ASU Law Standards Counsel, Intel Corporation Andrew White and Sean Woods Students at ASU Law Paper and related comments reflect only our personal views New Delhi, India, December 2011

International Telecommunication Union 5? 50? 500? How Many Standards in a Laptop? New Delhi, India, December 2011

International Telecommunication Union 4 Counted Interoperability Standards in Various Technical Areas Memory Display Graphics Wireless Sound Power Input/Output (I/O) Security Processor Content Protection Software Networking (We know we missed some key areas) New Delhi, India, December 2011

International Telecommunication Union 5 Excluded Other Kinds of Standards Performance Accessibility Design Process Manufacturing Process Quality Safety Environmental Measurement Electromagnetic compatibility New Delhi, India, December 2011

International Telecommunication Union 6 “Standards” Technical specifications produced and made available for 3rd party adoption by: 1. Formal SDOs 2. Consortia 3. Individual companies Not popular/dominant proprietary technologies New Delhi, India, December 2011

International Telecommunication Union SSO Framework Standards Setting Organizations (SSOs) Formal standards development orgs (SDOs) Consortia (or Fora or “SIGs”) COMPANY Spec licensing programs Lightweight contractual SIGs, spec dev only Complex nonprofit orgs w/ spec dev, C&I and marketing programs Small accredited SDOs ISO, IEC, ITU New Delhi, India, December 2011

International Telecommunication Union 8 At least 251 – and probably closer to 500 How Many Standards in a Laptop? New Delhi, India, December 2011

International Telecommunication Union 9 Two Additional Questions Who made these standards? SDO, Consortia or Company? What intellectual property rules govern these standards? [Fair,] Reasonable and Non- Discriminatory (RAND) license commitment Royalty-Free (RF) (RAND-Z, RAND-Zero, RF-RAND, non-assert, etc…) Patent Pool

International Telecommunication Union 10 Only about 1/3 rd produced by formal SDO Who made these standards? New Delhi, India, December 2011

International Telecommunication Union Allocated into four “buckets” Caution: masks significant complexity What IPR Rules Govern? POOL (6) RF (43) RAND (148) UNKNOWN (54) New Delhi, India, December 2011

International Telecommunication Union 3/4 th RAND, very few Pools IPR Rules, Con’t New Delhi, India, December 2011

International Telecommunication Union 13 Key Observations ~500 interoperability standards in a laptop! Importance of Consortia, Company specs Historical dominance of RAND New Delhi, India, December 2011

International Telecommunication Union Other academic activity: Annual standards symposiums at ASU 2010: Consortia structure, SDO adoption of consortia specs, ethical duties of participants, patent pools, disclosure 2011: Standards development processes/methodology, cooperation between SSOs, government policy, academic works-in-progress Forthcoming paper re 2010 topics New Delhi, India, December 2011

International Telecommunication Union 15 Questions/Discussion Contact: - New Delhi, India, December 2011