Calibration WG Projects published QA Analysis Friedman L; Glover GH. Report on a multicenter fMRI quality assurance protocol. JMRI 23:827-839 (2006). Smoothness.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 st Level Analysis: design matrix, contrasts, GLM Clare Palmer & Misun Kim Methods for Dummies
Advertisements

Detecting Conflict-Related Changes in the ACC Judy Savitskaya 1, Jack Grinband 1,3, Tor Wager 2, Vincent P. Ferrera 3, Joy Hirsch 1,3 1.Program for Imaging.
1 Temporal Processing Chris Rorden Temporal Processing can reduce error in our model –Slice Time Correction –Temporal Autocorrelation –High and low pass.
Participants Negative BOLD and Aging: An fMRI Investigation K.M. McGregor 1,2, K.D. White 1,2,3, M. Benjamin 1,3, W.K. Berg 2, I. Fischler 2, J. Craggs.
HST:583 fMRI Acquisition Lab1 Susan Whitfield-Gabrieli TASKS: Self Reference Sensorimotor Breath holding Sternberg Self ReferenceSternberg Breath holding.
2005 All Hands Meeting Measuring Reliability: The Intraclass Correlation Coefficient Lee Friedman, Ph.D.
How do we process text with spatial information? Marijn E. Struiksma*, Matthijs L. Noordzij**, Bas F.W. Neggers*** & Albert Postma* *Universiteit Utrecht.
Reading salt activates the gustatory cortex. A. Barrós-Loscertales 1, J. Gonzalez, N. Ventura-Campos 1, J.C. Bustamante, V. Costumero, A.J. Cruz Gómez,
Signal and Noise in fMRI fMRI Graduate Course October 15, 2003.
Efficiency – practical Get better fMRI results Dummy-in-chief Joel Winston Design matrix and.
TSTAT_THRESHOLD (~1 secs execution) Calculates P=0.05 (corrected) threshold t for the T statistic using the minimum given by a Bonferroni correction and.
Controlling for Scanner-to- Scanner Variance in Multicenter FMRI Studies: Covariation with Signal-to-Fluctuation Noise Ratio (SFNR) Lee Friedman, Ph.D.
Lab 2: repeated measures ANOVA 1. Inferior parietal involvement in long term memory There is a hypothesis that different brain regions are recruited during.
Function BIRN: Quality Assurance Practices Introduction: Conclusion: Function BIRN In developing a common fMRI protocol for a multi-center study of schizophrenia,
Function BIRN Science. FBIRN Goals Develop multi-site functional neuroimaging tools. Develop the capability to analyze, as a single data set, data acquired.
Intrinsic Neural Connectiity of ACT-R ROIs Yulin Qin 1, 2, Haiyan Zhou 1, Zhijiang Wang 1, Jain Yang 1, Ning Zhong 1, and John R. Anderson 2 1. International.
Susceptibility Induced Loss of Signal: Comparing PET and fMRI on a Semantic Task Devlin et al. (in press)
Ongoing BIRN-GCRC Collaborations Medical College Wisconsin (non BIRN site) –Functional MRI acquisition calibration University of Texas (non BIRN site)
Purpose: Examine the reliability of functional MRI activation over time in schizophrenic outpatients and non- patients while they complete WM tasks. Examine.
Issues in Experimental Design fMRI Graduate Course October 30, 2002.
Control over brain activation and pain learned by using real-time functional MRI R.C. deCharms, F. Maeda, G.H. Glover, D. Ludlow, J.M. Pauly, D. Soneji,
BIOMEDICAL INFORMATICS RESEARCH NETWORK: FUNCTIONAL IMAGING RESEARCH IN SCHIZOPHRENIA TESTBED S.G. Potkin 1 ; J.A. Turner 1 *; G.G. Brown 2 ; G.H. Glover.
Types of Scaling Session scaling; global mean scaling; block effect; mean intensity scaling Purpose – remove intensity differences between runs (i.e.,
FMRI Activation in a Visual- Perception Task: Network of Areas Detected Using the General Linear Model and Independent Components Analysis Calhoun, Adali,
I. Improving SNR (cont.) II. Preprocessing BIAC Graduate fMRI Course October 12, 2004.
Calibration Working Group Progress visual stimulus calibration data smoothness effects on analysis Proposed tasks for competing renewal.
All Hands Meeting 2005 FBIRN AHM 2006 Statistics Working Group Update Greg Brown, UCSD Hal Stern, UCI.
Somatotopy of the Anterior Cingulate Cortex and Supplementary Motor Area for tactile stimulation of the hand and the foot D. Arienzo 1,2, T.D. Wager 3,
Moriah Thomason Lara Foland ‘n Me Radiological Sciences Laboratory Center for Advanced MR Technology* Stanford University School of Medicine Department.
Signal and Noise in fMRI John VanMeter, Ph.D. Center for Functional and Molecular Imaging Georgetown University Medical Center.
2009 Multimodal Neuroimaging Training Program fMRI Module: Experimental Design, Image Processing, & Data Analysis Courtney M. Bell, Gina D’Angelo, Huiqiong.
Spatial Smoothing and Multiple Comparisons Correction for Dummies Alexa Morcom, Matthew Brett Acknowledgements.
Spatial and temporal limits of fMRI Menon RS, Kim SG. Spatial and temporal limits in cognitive neuroimaging with fMRI. Trends Cogn Sci Jun;3(6):
INTRODUCTION ADULT AGE DIFFERENCES IN THE HEMODYNAMIC RESPONSE DURING VISUAL TARGET DETECTION MEASURED BY FUNCTIONAL MRI David J. Madden 1, Scott A. Huettel.
2006 FBIRN Meeting Welcome FBIRN Housekeeping first  Coffee breaks at 10:30 and 3:15 pm Please keep these to 15 minutes  Lunch down the hall and.
(Example) Class Presentation: John Desmond
Statistical Analysis An Introduction to MRI Physics and Analysis Michael Jay Schillaci, PhD Monday, April 7 th, 2007.
Methodological issues for scanning geriatric populations Andy James fMRI Journal Club October 12, 2004.
UMCG/RuG BCN - NIC Journal club 25 Apr. ’08 A method for functional network connectivity among spatially independent resting-state components in schizophrenia.
By 5 pm Tuesday  Each group delivers their action plan/milestones to achieve current goals Phase I publication plan and public access Phase II—Intersite.
Calibration WG Overall goals: 2.Develop and implement means for reducing intersite variations in fMRI sensitivity - Procedures on web site - Paper in press:
Goals of FBIRN ( )  Develop multi-site functional neuroimaging tools. Calibration: Assess and correct for the major sources of variation in multi-site.
Hierarchical statistical analysis of fMRI data across runs/sessions/subjects/studies using BRAINSTAT / FMRISTAT Jonathan Taylor, Stanford Keith Worsley,
Statistics and Processing Working Group AHM Fall 2009.
Robert W. McCarley, Presenter Cindy Wible, Marek Kubicki ( generated fMRI data), and Dean Salisbury (generated ERP data) Harvard, VA Boston Healthcare.
Older adult scanning methodology II: How to decide between conflicting literature? Andy James fMRI Journal Club October 26, 2004.
Introduction  Recent neuroimaging studies of memory retrieval have reported the activation of a medial and left – lateralised memory network that includes.
Vinci-Booher, S., Cheng, H., & James, K.H.
Representational Similarity Analysis
Non-linear Realignment Using Minimum Deformation Averaging for Single-subject fMRI at Ultra-high Field Saskia Bollmann1, Steffen Bollmann1, Alexander.
Representational Similarity Analysis
FMRI experimental design and data processing
Results: Behavioral Performance Area and Laterality of activation
Neural Changes following Remediation in Adult Developmental Dyslexia
Multiple Change Point Detection for Symmetric Positive Definite Matrices Dehan Kong University of Toronto JSM 2018 July 30, 2018.
Signal and Noise in fMRI
Volume 63, Issue 2, Pages (July 2009)
Neural Changes following Remediation in Adult Developmental Dyslexia
Graph Theoretic Analysis of Resting State Functional MR Imaging
Perceptual Learning and Decision-Making in Human Medial Frontal Cortex
Hierarchical Models and
Negative BOLD Differentiates Visual Imagery and Perception
Negative BOLD Differentiates Visual Imagery and Perception
Memory aging and brain maintenance
Volume 68, Issue 1, Pages (October 2010)
Will Penny Wellcome Trust Centre for Neuroimaging,
I Feel My Hand Moving Neuron
Under-Recruitment and Nonselective Recruitment
Volume 63, Issue 2, Pages (July 2009)
César F. Lima, Saloni Krishnan, Sophie K. Scott 
Presentation transcript:

Calibration WG Projects published QA Analysis Friedman L; Glover GH. Report on a multicenter fMRI quality assurance protocol. JMRI 23: (2006). Smoothness equalization Friedman L; Glover GH; Kranz D; Magnotta V; FIRST BIRN. Reducing Scanner-to-Scanner Variability of Activation in a Multi-center fMRI Study: Role of Smoothness Equalization. NeuroImage 32: (2006).

Calibration WG Projects published BH Thomason ME; Burrows BE; Gabrieli JDE; Glover GH. Breath holding reveals differences in fMRI BOLD signal in children and adults. NeuroImage 25: (2005). Thomason ME; Foland LC; Glover GH. Calibration of BOLD fMRI using Breath-holding reduces group variance during a cognitive task. Human Brain Mapping (Epub May 2006).

Calibration WG Projects eliminated SM None of the areas were deemed reliable, esp. for Sz.

Calibration WG Projects underway Perfusion measurement BH calib Coil comparison- Multichannel vs. single channel

Calibration WG Projects underway Perfusion measurement BH calib Coil comparison- Multichannel vs. single channel

No calib BH Calibration: Individual Subs Calib 5 ≤ t ≤ 20 M. Thomason et al. 2006

No calCalib 3.5 ≤ t ≤ 10 vol = p.001vol = 1.0 BH Calibration: Group Activation M. Thomason et al. 2006

Calibration: SWM 5 subjects, parietal M. Thomason et al. 2006

Control of Inspiration

no control BOLD Results w/control

Residuals across 8 trials * (p=0.006) * (p=0.005) N = 10 subs

const cntl no cntl Single Subject

SM BOLD response in normals: BH & SM BH Red: 4 non-smokers Blue: 4 smokers

Calibration WG Projects underway Perfusion measurement BH calib Coil comparison- Multichannel vs. single channel

Ratio 8/1 STAN SUB > 2.5-> ALL SCALES START AT 0.0 SFNR – CP COIL SFNR – 8-CHANNEL COIL COMPARING COILS ON SFNR UCIR SUB1 UCIR SUB2 MINN SUB1

Ratio 8/1 YALE SUB1YALE SUB > 2.5-> ALL SCALES START AT 0.0 SFNR – CP COIL SFNR – 8-CHANNEL COIL COMPARING COILS ON SFNR YALE SUB3

Unsmoothed Ratio 8/1 YALE SUB1YALE SUB2 2.5-> ALL SCALES START AT 0.0 COMPARING COILS ON SFNR YALE SUB3 Smoothed 10 mm FWHM Ratio 8/1 2.5->

Conclusions from Resting State Analyses 8 channel coil has less percent noise than 1 channel coil when unsmoothed Smoothing dramatically reduced noise Smoothing equalizes noise of the two coils to a remarkable extent Little to no advantage to multichannel coils in SFNR or Percent Noise when data smoothed to conventional levels (FWHM = 7 – 10)

Auditory Oddball Data 3 subjects 2 tasks/per study: –Auditory Oddball (4 runs, 143 TRs, 286 sec) FBIRN Phase II sequence, no PACE, ascending acquisition, TR=2.0, 64x64 matrix, no apodization filter.

Percent Signal Change Left Motor Cortex Left BA 40 Ant. Cingulate Left BA 22 Left BA 41 Right BA 47 Right CB Multi Single

1 Channel Coil8 Channel Coil T-value maps: t-values are for the 3-6 second time point  T=0.0  T=3.9, p < threshold T=2.81 p <0.005

Preliminary Conclusion Some evidence for a Superior-to-inferior gradient in the relationship between the coils. At superior levels (left motor cortex, left BA 40) both Percent Signal Change and CNR (t-values) are elevated in the 8 channel coil At inferior level (right cerebellum, BA47), single channel coil is stronger both for Percent Signal Change and CNR. At intermediate levels, the coils appear to perform similarly.

Thoughts on Why The Answer is Probably Hematocrit Smoking Increases Hematocrit Hemocrit declines with age. Hypothesis: Although both BOLD and BH depend on Hematocrit, BH dependence is much stronger, leading to increased BH response in smokers