M&E in ESA: progress and the way ahead Carlo Azzarri, Beliyou Haile, Cleo Roberts IFPRI M&E team ESA Review and Planning Meeting 9-11 September 2014 Arusha,

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Knowing if the RBF mechanism is working Incorporating Rigorous Impact Evaluation into your HRBF program Sebastian Martinez World Bank.

Advertisements

Kongwa/Kiteto Ganga Rao, NVRP, Kimaro, A,, Makumbi., D, Mponda, O., Msangi, R., Rubanza, C.D. Seetha, A., Swai, E. and Okori, P.

Farming systems analysis in Africa RISING Bernard Vanlauwe - IITA Jeroen Groot - WUR Carl Timler - WUR Lotte Klapwijk – IITA/WUR 28 May 2013 Lilongwe,

Africa RISING Research Framework. Research output 1: Situation Analysis and Programme-wide Synthesis. Includes the activities that are necessary to.

Africa RISING. Basic introduction / rationale  Provide pathways out of hunger and poverty for small holder families, particularly for women and children,

Africa RISING overview and update Irmgard Hoeschle-Zeledon Africa RISING Coordinator East and Southern Africa 3 rd Annual Review and Planning meeting,

Africa RISING: an overview

Sustainability Indicators for AR Beginners Peter Thorne International Livestock Research Institute Science Advisory Group – London 17 July, 2014.

Regional scale Participatory analysis Crop modeling Performance data Plot Participatory Modeling Survey Household Research 4 Development platform (extension,

SUPPORTING STRATEGIC INVESTMENT CHOICES IN AGRICULTURAL TECHNOLOGY DEVELOPMENT AND ADOPTION 1. HarvestChoice & Technology Platform 2. Household data 3.

Steering Committee Meeting WA Project 25 March 2015, Accra, Ghana I. Hoeschle-Zeledon Coordinator, ESA and WA projects.

Africa RISING Ethiopian Highlands Research Component 1 - Characterization Alan Duncan, Beth Cullen, Aster Grbrekristos, Stefan Shultz Africa RISING-EH.

Implementation of Data Management Plan; AR Project Mapping and Monitoring Tool 1

Impact Assessment of Africa RISING: Approaches and Challenges Beliyou Haile IFPRI March 2013.

Mali Work Packages. Crop Fields Gardens Livestock People Trees Farm 1 Farm 2 Farm 3 Fallow Pasture/forest Market Water sources Policy Landscape/Watershed.

Spatial data, FTF indicators and PMMT IFPRI HarvestChoice-AR M&E team IFPRI January 26, 2015 Washington, DC.

Year 1 Overview I. Hoeschle-Zeledon Africa RISING East/Southern Africa Coordinator Research Review & Planning Meeting Africa RISING – East & Southern Africa.

Northern Ghana Agricultural Household Survey Beliyou Haile IFPRI Northern Ghana Baseline Survey Instrument Design Workshop (Accra, Ghana) February 10,

Research framework J.Rusike Research Review & Planning Meeting Africa RISING – West Africa Project October 2012, Tamale, Ghana.

Intensification of maize-legume systems

Africa RISING update I. Hoeschle-Zeledon Coordinator, ESA and WA Projects ESA Annual Review and Planning meeting July 2015.

Towards the making of a workplan for the ESA Project Mateete Bekunda and Irmgard H.-Zeledon.

Africa Research in Sustainable Intensification for the Next Generation: Research outputs, design and approach in ESA Mateete Bekunda Farming Systems Agronomist.

Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E) Plan for AR Africa RISING Research Review & Planning Meeting – East & Southern Africa Project October 2012, Tamale,

Cost-Benefit Analysis of Africa RISING Technologies in Tanzania: Summary of initial results Bekele H. Kotu Contributing scientists: A. Kimaro, M. Swamila.

Carlo Azzarri, Beliyou Haile, Cleophelia Roberts, Melanie Bacou IFPRI/HarvestChoice London, July 17, 2014 M&E of Africa RISING.

Africa RISING Programme West Africa – Ghana and Mali East and Southern Africa – Tanzania, Malawi and Zambia Ethiopian Highlands – Tigray – Amhara – SNNPR.

Africa RISING WA Project - from the start until today I. Hoeschle-Zeledon Africa RISING Coordinator Stakeholder meeting Accra, Ghana, 23 January 2013.

BABATI RESEARCH FOR DEVELOPMENT PLATFORM Presentation to the 3 rd Research Review and Planning Meeting for the Africa RISING –East and Southern Africa.

Enhancing partnership among Africa RISING, NAFAKA and TUBORESHE CHAKULA Programs for fast tracking delivery and scaling of agricultural technologies in.

Enhancing partnership among Africa RISING, NAFAKA and TUBORESHE CHAKULA Programs for fast tracking delivery and scaling of agricultural technologies in.

Africa RISING West Africa Mega Site M&E Activities Summary Africa RISING West Africa Review and Planning Meeting February 3-4, 2014; Bamako, Mali Beliyou.

1 New features of the World Programme for the Census of Agriculture 2010 FAO Statistics Division November 2009.

Babati District Research–for–Development (R4D) Platform Jukwaa la Utafiti kwa Maendeleo Wilaya ya Babati (JUMBA) Africa RISING Review and Planning Meeting,

Africa RISING in the Ethiopian Highlands Peter Thorne International Livestock Research Institute Science Advisory Group – London 17 July, 2014.

Agriculture Sector Performance in Southern Africa By Pius Chilonda Sub-Regional Coordinator, ReSAKSS-SA ReSAKSS Africa -Wide Conference on Agriculture:

O1 group work report Tahirou, Sibiry, Gatien, Joseph, Naomie, Jerome, Annie.

Research Output #1 in ESA -Update from IFPRI- ESA Review and Planning Meeting, Mangochi, 14 July 2015 Carlo Azzarri, Beliyou Haile, Sara Signorelli, Cleo.

Africa RISING M&E Expert Meeting Addis Ababa, 5-7 September 2012.

Intensification of maize- legume based systems in the semi-arid areas of Tanzania Mathew Mpanda 9 th Sept 2014.

Africa RISING Evaluation Design Carlo Azzarri, Beliyou Haile, Cleo Roberts IFPRI Africa RISING M&E Meeting November 2014, Arusha, Tanzania.

Can a Market-Assisted Land Redistribution Program Improve the Lives of the Poor? Evidence from Malawi Gayatri Datar (World Bank, IEG) Ximena V. Del Carpio.

Africa RISING Mali team Achievements until 2013 Tom van Mourik & AR Mali team Africa RISING review & planning meeting Azalai Grand Hotel, 3-4 February,

Site Selection for Africa RISING in Northern Ghana Christopher Legg (IFPRI) Asamoah Larbi (IITA)

Feed the Future Indicators Africa RISING PMMT Training Addis Ababa - Ethiopia, August Tamale - Ghana, August Bamako - Mali, August Sara.

AR Mali Evaluation I. Hoeschle-Zeledon Coordinator Africa RISING ESA and WA Bamako, 8 January 2015.

Malawi Team: Agro-ecological Intensification Sept Day 1 discussions Africa RISING Planning Meeting, Lilongwe.

Africa RISING ESA I. Hoeschle-Zeledon Coordinator IITA.

Africa RISING yammer guide Tsehay Gashaw, East and Southern Africa Project 3 rd Review and Planning Meeting 9-12 September, 2014.

1Your reference The Menu of Indicators and the Core Set from the South African Point of View Moses Mnyaka 13/08/2009.

Year 2 Planning Boundaries and Principles I. Hoeschle-Zeledon Africa RISING East/Southern Africa Coordinator Research Review & Planning Meeting Africa.

1 OVERVIEW OF THE WORLD PROGRAMME FOR THE CENSUS OF AGRICULTURE 2010 FAO Statistics Division November 2005.

Achievements of Phase 1, loose ends and new research topics to focus on in Malawi, Tanzania and Zambia Kihara group.

Long term genetic gains implementation plan Johan van Arendonk ACGG team meeting May 18 th.

Farming systems analysis Ghana and Mali Bamako, February 3 rd, 2014 Wageningen University, IITA, ICRISAT, MSU.

Characteristics, challenges and opportunities Mulundu, M Sseguya, H Outline.

Science Advisory Group Meeting Objectives Science Advisory Group – London 17 July, 2014.

Fodder and feed as a key opportunity for driving sustainable intensification of crop livestock systems in Ethiopia “Quick Feeds” Presented by Alan Duncan.

Identifying recommendation domains for scaling improved crop varieties in Tanzania Dr. Francis Kamau Muthoni Dr. Haroon Sseguya Prof. Bekunda Mateete Dr.

The Africa RISING project in Ethiopia Peter Thorne International Livestock Research Institute SLATE Training for Africa RISING / NBDC Addis Ababa / Jeldu.

Reducing yield gaps in Babati district Tanzania: Potentials and Opportunities By: Lyimo S.D. 1*, Kihara J. 2, Kizito F. 2, Yangole L. 1 1 Selian Agricultural.

ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF IMPROVED GRAIN STORAGE TECHNOLOGY IN TANZANIA Hanney Mbwambo, Bekele Kotu and Zena Mpenda Africa RISING Writeshop White Sand Hotel.

Farm Typologies in Tanzania and Malawi Africa RISING IFPRI) ESA Africa RISING writeshop, Dar es Salaam July 1, 2016.

Labour Arrangements and Farmers’ Exchange Networks: Following a Maize-Fertilizer Intervention in Northern Tanzania Gundula Fischer, Simon Wittich (IITA)

ESA Project Evolution:

Farmers’ Willingness to Pay for Improved Agricultural Technologies: Results from Field Experiment Babati, Tanzania Apurba Shee, Carlo Azzarri and Beliyou.

TECHjOSH.COM TechJosh.com.

Sampling for Impact Evaluation -theory and application-

Integrated livestock feed interventions

Farm level case studies Tanzania

Presentation transcript:

M&E in ESA: progress and the way ahead Carlo Azzarri, Beliyou Haile, Cleo Roberts IFPRI M&E team ESA Review and Planning Meeting 9-11 September 2014 Arusha, Tanzania

Overview M&E Activities in ESA Mega-site stratification by drivers of SI and creation of “development domains” Identification of representative control sites Site visits and focus groups Babati IE of fertilizer vouchers and improved maize seeds Open access M&E data management platform (PMMT) dev’t and trainings (TZ: July trainees; MWI: Aug trainees; ZA: Aug trainees) FtF indicators reporting Meetings (survey design, project review & planning, annual M&E) ARBES: Malawi and Tanzania

MARBES: sample distribution in MWI

TARBES: sample distribution in TZA

MARBES: village characteristics in MWI

MARBES: MWI basic statistics/1

MARBES: MWI basic statistics/2

MARBES: MWI agric statistics/1

MARBES: MWI ploughing methods

MARBES: MWI agric statistics/2

MARBES: MWI agric statistics/3

MARBES: MWI farming system

MARBES: MWI typologies/1

MARBES: MWI typologies/2

MARBES: MWI livestock statistics

MARBES: MWI child anthropometrics

TARBES: village characteristics in TZA

TARBES: TZA basic statistics

TARBES: TZA agricultural statistics/1

TARBES: TZA ploughing methods

TARBES: TZA agricultural statistics/2

TARBES: TZA agricultural statistics/3

TARBES: TZA farming system

TARBES: TZA typologies/1

TARBES: TZA typologies/2

TARBES: TZA livestock statistics/1

TARBES: TZA livestock statistics/2

TARBES: TZA child anthropometrics

Conclusions Malawi -targeting- Action communities not different than control -the former slightly more remote- Beneficiaries seem to have different characteristics than the general population Tanzania -targeting- Action and control communities very similar Again beneficiaries seem to be better-off, more educated, with higher wealth, larger land size, etc. ->Implications for scaling-up? What about the external validity of ex-ante evaluation?

Way ahead ARBES public good/service for AR! (ESA ARBES data (partially) shared with MSU, WUR, ICRISAT, BioSight, Montpellier) Targeting analysis, tentatively matching Ex-ante evaluation (results by November) Continuous monitoring (now…)

Africa Research in Sustainable Intensification for the Next Generation africa-rising.net The presentation has a Creative Commons licence. You are free to re-use or distribute this work, provided credit is given to ILRI. Thank You!