WARM SPITZER PHASE VARIATIONS OF WASP-12B: DEFYING PREDICTIONS Nick Cowan CIERA Postdoctoral Fellow Northwestern University September 15 th 2011 with Louis.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
THESIS – the Terrestrial and Habitable-zone Exoplanet Spectroscopy Infrared Spacecraft a concept for a joint NASA/ESA exoplanet characterization mission.
Advertisements

Ge/Ay133 What can transit observations tell us about (exo)-planetary science? Part II – “Spectroscopy” & Atmospheric Composition/Dynamics Kudos to Heather.
Climate Forcing, Sensitivity and Feedback Processes.
Hubble Science Briefing Hubble Does Double-Duty Science: Finding Planets and Characterizing Stellar Flares in an Old Stellar Population Rachel Osten Space.
High-precision eclipse photometry for CoRoT planets CoRoT symposium 2009 Feb 2 - 5, Paris M. Gillon (Geneva - Liege) & A. Lanotte, T. Barman, B.-O. Demory,
Colors of Alien Worlds from Direct-Imaging Exoplanet Missions Renyu Hu Hubble Fellow Jet Propulsion Laboratory California Institute of Technology With.
Spitzer Observations of 3C Quasars and Radio Galaxies: Mid-Infrared Properties of Powerful Radio Sources K. Cleary 1, C.R. Lawrence 1, J.A. Marshall 2,
Doppler signatures of the atmospheric circulation of hot Jupiters Adam Showman University of Arizona Jonathan Fortney (UCSC), Nikole Lewis (Univ. Arizona),
Signatures of Exoplanets HD209458b: a Hot Jupiter Orbiting a Bright Star Sara Seager Carnegie Institution of Washington Image credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/R.
Exploring a Nearby Habitable World …. Orbiting an M-dwarf star Drake Deming NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center.
Atmospheric effect in the solar spectrum
Variability of young stars with LSST Gregory J. Herczeg KIAA.
Other Planetary Systems (Chapter 13) Extrasolar Planets
PX437 EXOPLANETS Outline 1.Before Exoplanets 2.Detecting exoplanets 1.Direct imaging 2.Reflex Motion of Star 3.Transiting exoplanets 3.Planet Formation.
Reflection Spectra of Giant Planets With an Eye Towards TPF (and EPIC & ECLIPSE) Jonathan J. Fortney Mark S. Marley NASA Ames Research Center 2005 Aspen.
Exoplanet Transits and SONG Angelle Tanner. Venus Transiting the Sun.
Theoretical Spectra and Atmospheres of Extrasolar Giant Planets (Sudarsky, Burrows, Hubeny 2003) Nick Cowan March 2006 Nick Cowan March 2006.
Lecture 14: Searching for planets orbiting other stars III: Using Spectra 1.The Spectra of Stars and Planets 2.The Doppler Effect and its uses 3.Using.
The Transient Universe: AY 250 Spring 2007 Extra Solar Planets Geoff Bower.
Extrasolar Planets.I. 1.What do we know and how do we know it. 2.Basic planetary atmospheres 3.Successful observations and future plans.
New Results from Kepler: Systems of Multiple Transiting Planets w/ Correlated TTVs Eric B. Ford Extreme Solar Systems II September 12, 2011 Based on a.
“Theory for Giant Exoplanets: A Potpourri” A.Burrows Dept. of Astrophysical Sciences Princeton University With collaborators D. Spiegel, I. Hubeny, N.
Astronomy News 2007/03/20 HEAG meeting Astronomers Puzzled by Spectra of Transiting Planet Orbiting Nearby Star.
Lecture III: Gas Giant Planets 1.From Lecture II: Phase separation 2.Albedos and temperatures 3.Observed transmission spectra 4.Observed thermal spectra.
New Results from Ground-Based Transit Spectroscopy Observations Jacob Bean Harvard-Smithsonian CfA University of Chicago.
TOPS 2003 Observing Projects Karen Meech Institute for Astronomy TOPS 2003 Image copyright, R. Wainscoat, IfA Image courtesy K. Meech.
Detecting molecules in the atmospheres of transit Exoplanets Giovanna Tinetti University College London Mao-Chang Liang Academia Sinica, Taiwan.
Lesson 2 AOSC 621. Radiative equilibrium Where S is the solar constant. The earth reflects some of this radiation. Let the albedo be ρ, then the energy.
Lecture 16: Searching for Habitable Planets: Remote Sensing Methods and parameters we can measure Mean density measurements: internal structure Measurements.
Lecture 13: Searching for planets orbiting other stars I: Properties of Light 1.How could we study distant habitats remotely ? 2.The nature of light -
Orbital motion, absolute mass & high-altitude winds of HD b Ignas Snellen, Remco de Kok, Ernst de Mooij, Simon Albrecht Nature – May 2010.
What stellar properties can be learnt from planetary transits Adriana Válio Roque da Silva CRAAM/Mackenzie.
David Henley, University of BirminghamX-ray & Radio Connections, Santa Fe, February 2004 Probing Colliding Wind Binaries with High-Resolution X-ray Spectra.
An Accretion Disc Model for Quasar Optical Variability An Accretion Disc Model for Quasar Optical Variability Li Shuang-Liang Li Shuang-Liang Shanghai.
Adriana V. R. Silva CRAAM/Mackenzie COROT /11/2005.
THE DIURNAL TEMPERATURE REGIME OF THE SURFICIAL REGOLITH OF PHOBOS IN THE LANDING SITE REGION OF THE FOBOS-GRUNT LANDER FOR DIFFERENT SEASONS: THE MODEL.
SPICA Science for Transiting Planetary Systems Norio Narita Takuya Yamashita National Astronomical Observatory of Japan 12009/06/02 SPICA Science Workshop.
Spots and White Light Flares in an L dwarf John Gizis Department of Physics and Astronomy University of Delaware May 24, Dwarfs Come of Age.
National Aeronautics and Space Administration Mark Swain THESIS – the Terrestrial and Habitable-zone Exoplanet Spectroscopy Infrared Spacecraft characterizing.
Transit Spectroscopy w/ WFC3 March 11, 2014 Avi M. Mandell NASA GSFC Collaborators: Korey Haynes Evan Sinukoff Drake Deming Adam Burrows Nikku Madhusudhan.
Star-disc interaction : do planets care ?
Phases of Venus. Share Question How much more solar energy does Venus receive than the Earth, due to the fact that Venus is 0.72 times as far from the.
Hee-Won Lee ARCSEC and Dept. of Astronomy Sejong University 2010 August 26.
Exoplanet Transit Spectroscopy February 7, 2014 Avi M. Mandell NASA GSFC Collaborators: Korey Haynes Evan Sinukoff Drake Deming Adam Burrows Nikku Madhusudhan.
Spectra What determines the “color” of a beam of light? The answer is its frequency, or equivalently, its wavelength. We see different colors because.
Atmospheric circulation of hot Jupiters on highly eccentric orbits Tiffany Kataria 1, Adam Showman 1, Nikole Lewis 1, Jonathan Fortney 2, Mark Marley 3,
A Warm Spitzer Survey of Atmospheric Circulation Patterns Image credit G. Orton Heather Knutson (Caltech) In collaboration with: N. Lewis (Arizona), N.
Lecture 14: The Discovery of the World of Exoplanets Indirect methods for planet detection The Astrometric method The Doppler shift method The Transit.
Texas Symposium, MelbourneDecember 14th 2006 Theoretical Properties of Ly  Cooling Radiation’ Mark Dijkstra (CfA) Collaborators: Z. Haiman, M.Spaans &
Transit Spectroscopy with HST/WFC3 January 18, 2012 Exoplanet Transit Spectroscopy with HST/WFC3: Probing H 2 O with New Precision Avi M. Mandell NASA.
From Clouds to Cores: Magnetic Field Effects on the Structure of Molecular Gas Shantanu Basu University of Western Ontario, Canada Collaborators: Takahiro.
COMPARATIVE TEMPERATURE RETRIEVALS BASED ON VIRTIS/VEX AND PMV/VENERA-15 RADIATION MEASUREMENTS OVER THE NORTHERN HEMISPHERE OF VENUS R. Haus (1), G. Arnold.
Exoplanet Characterization with JWST
Reflected Light: Albedo Measurements Radiated Light: Temperature In-transit and secondary eclipse spectroscopy: Atmospheric Features Characterization of.
Midterm Exam Material Covered –Chapter 1 to 6 Format of Exam –Multiple-Choice Questions: 40 to 50 questions –Facts –Concepts –Reasoning –Quantitative --
Atmospheric Circulation of hot Jupiters Adam Showman LPL Collaborators: J. Fortney, N. Lewis, L. Polvani, D. Perez-Becker, Y. Lian, M. Marley, H. Knutson.
1 The Validation of Kepler planets F. Fressin, G. Torres & the Kepler team.
JWST Spectroscopy of transiting planets Drake Deming University of Maryland at College Park K2 Science Conference, November 5, 2015.
Exoplanet atmospheres with JWST: degeneracy, systematics and how to avoid them Dr Joanna Barstow With thanks to: Patrick Irwin, Suzanne Aigrain, Sarah.
Characterisation of hot Jupiters by secondary transits observed with IRIS2 Lucyna Kedziora-Chudczer (UNSW) George Zhou (Harvard-Smithsonian CfA) Jeremy.
user perspective Status Report on SOFIA Exoplanet Transit Capability
BATMAN & SPIDERMAN: Saving the World One Exoplanet Light Curve at a Time talk about two open-source Python package for modeling transits, eclipses, and.
Akatsuki Mission Update: New Images and Status of the Mission
Astronomy Created by Educational Technology Network
SPICA for Transiting Exoplanets: Which SPICA instruments are useful?
High-cadence Radio Observations of an EIT Wave
The Universal Presence of Nightside Clouds
Pulsar Timing Score = 33 How it works
Instructor: Gregory Fleishman
Presentation transcript:

WARM SPITZER PHASE VARIATIONS OF WASP-12B: DEFYING PREDICTIONS Nick Cowan CIERA Postdoctoral Fellow Northwestern University September 15 th 2011 with Louis Shekhtman (NU undergrad) Machalek, Croll, Burrows, Deming

Sept 15, 2011Nick Cowan's Talk at ESS II2 WASP-12b: a Tortured World ~1 day orbit: Oblate Planet Tidally Warped: Prolate Planet T day ≈3000 K: MHD Effects Big R p, small a: Roche-Lobe Overflow Accretion on Star/ Bow Shock Peculiar Eclipse Depths: High C/O ratio (Hebb et al. 2009; Ragozzine & Wolf 2009; Li et al. 2010; Lai et al. 2011; Leconte et al. 2011; Fossati et al. 2010; Vidotto et al. 2010; Llama et al. 2011; Madhusudhan et al. 2011) Check Out These Posters: Crossfield Petigura Moses Li et al. (2010)

Sept 15, 2011Nick Cowan's Talk at ESS II3 Thermal + Ellipsoidal Variations HAT-P-7b as seen by Kepler (Welsh et al. 2010) Brightness Phases: Planet Light Geometrical Phases: Projected Area Optical Light Observations Reflected Light Dominates Phases Star’s Shape Dominates Geometry Infrared Observations Thermal Emission Dominates Phases Planet’s Shape Dominates Geometry

Sept 15, 2011Nick Cowan's Talk at ESS II4 Raw WASP-12b Photometry 3.6 micron 4.5 micron Transit Eclipse Phase Function Intra-pixel sensitivity variations are the dominant systematic 1.Gaussian Decorrelation (Ballard et al. 2010) 2.Polynomial in Centroid x and y

Sept 15, 2011Nick Cowan's Talk at ESS II5 WASP-12b at 3.6 micron  max = -53(7)° A therm / = 0.9(3)

Sept 15, 2011Nick Cowan's Talk at ESS II6 What Planets Are Supposed To Do Noon SOP Dawn SOP Midnight SOP Dusk SOP Increasing Heat Capacity 1) Decreases Thermal Phase Amplitude 2) Increases Hot Spot Offset Cowan & Agol (2011a)

Sept 15, 2011Nick Cowan's Talk at ESS II7 WASP-12b at 3.6 micron  max = -53(7)° A ellips = 2(2)x10 -4 A therm / = 0.9(3)

Sept 15, 2011Nick Cowan's Talk at ESS II8 WASP-12b at 4.5 micron  max = -16(4)° A ellips = 1.2(2)x10 -4 A therm / = 0.7(1) The Null Hypothesis Consistent with Cowan & Agol (2011a) Toy Model

Sept 15, 2011Nick Cowan's Talk at ESS II9 Interpreting Ellipsoidal Variations 4.5 micron phase variations Temperature profile is cos(  -  0 ) some of cos(2  ) due to temperature All of cos(2  ) due to temperature cos(2  ) all due to geometry Spherical planet most of cos(2  ) due to geometry But applying Cowan & Agol (2008) deconvolution leads to unphysical longitudinal brightness map Geometry Phases Brightness

Sept 15, 2011Nick Cowan's Talk at ESS II10 Day-Side Emergent Spectrum Day-Side 1D Model Spectra (Burrows et al. 2007, 2008) (Croll et al. 2011) (López- Morales et al. 2010) (Campo et al. 2010) This Study Null Hypothesis

Sept 15, 2011Nick Cowan's Talk at ESS II11 Transmission Spectrum (Chan et al. 2011) (Maciejewski et al. 2011) Transit Spectrum Assuming Day-Like T-P Profile (Burrows et al. 2007, 2008)

Sept 15, 2011Nick Cowan's Talk at ESS II12 Choose Your Own Adventure 1. Prediction-Buster Roche-Lobe Opaque at 4.5  m + Gravity Brightened Terminator Weird Composition (not just high C/O) 2. Null Hypothesis Ellipsoidal Variations As Predicted Solar Composition?

Sept 15, 2011Nick Cowan's Talk at ESS II13 WASP-12b Power Budget Eclipse Observations Phase Observations A B ≈ 0.25  ≈  rad /(  adv +  rad ) ≈ 0.1 Hot Planets are Poor Recirculators (Cowan & Agol 2011b) 1.Magnetic Drag (Perna et al. 2010, Menou 2011) 2.Short Radiative Timescale (  rad ≈ T -3 )

Sept 15, 2011Nick Cowan's Talk at ESS II14 EXOCLIMES 2012 Aspen, CO Jan 16-20, 2012 Registration Open