Black Hole Universe -BH in an expanding box- Yoo, Chulmoon ( YITP) Hiroyuki Abe (Osaka City Univ.) Ken-ichi Nakao (Osaka City Univ.) Yohsuke Takamori (Osaka.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Regularization of the the second-order gravitational perturbations produced by a compact object Eran Rosenthal University of Guelph - Canada Amos Ori Technion.
Advertisements

Plan 1. Introduction: Braneworld Dynamics General Solution of Braneworld Dynamics under the Schwarzschild Anzats K. Akama, T. Hattori, and H. Mukaida 2.
Does Birkhoffs law hold in MOND?. Birkhoffs Theorem Any spherically symmetric solution of the Einstein field equations in vacuum must be stationary and.
Backreaction as an explanation for Dark Energy ? with some remarks on cosmological perturbation theory James M. Bardeen University of Washington The Very.
Wald’s Entropy, Area & Entanglement Introduction: –Wald’s Entropy –Entanglement entropy in space-time Wald’s entropy is (sometimes) an area ( of some metric)
Chapter 11 – Gravity Lecture 2
May 28, 2010, Dezhou A Realistic Torsion Cosmological Model Li Xin-Zhou Shanghai United Center for Astrophysics, Shanghai Normal University.
ASYMPTOTIC STRUCTURE IN HIGHER DIMENSIONS AND ITS CLASSIFICATION KENTARO TANABE (UNIVERSITY OF BARCELONA) based on KT, Kinoshita and Shiromizu PRD
July 2005 Einstein Conference Paris Thermodynamics of a Schwarzschild black hole observed with finite precision C. Chevalier 1, F. Debbasch 1, M. Bustamante.
Physics 133: Extragalactic Astronomy ad Cosmology Lecture 5; January
Rotating BHs at future colliders: Greybody factors for brane fields Kin-ya Oda Kin-ya Oda, Tech. Univ. Munich Why Study BHs at Collider? BH at Collider.
Gerard ’t Hooft Spinoza Institute Utrecht University CMI, Chennai, 20 November 2009 arXiv:
General Relativity Physics Honours 2007 A/Prof. Geraint F. Lewis Rm 557, A29 Lecture Notes 4.
Coupled Dark Energy and Dark Matter from dilatation symmetry.
Lecture 22 Cosmological Models ASTR 340 Fall 2006 Dennis Papadopoulos Chapter 11.
The 2d gravity coupled to a dilaton field with the action This action ( CGHS ) arises in a low-energy asymptotic of string theory models and in certain.
The Theory/Observation connection lecture 3 the (non-linear) growth of structure Will Percival The University of Portsmouth.
Black Holes Matthew Trimble 10/29/12.
Why General Relativity is like a High Temperature Superconductor Gary Horowitz UC Santa Barbara G.H., J. Santos, D. Tong, , and to appear Gary.
Schwarzschild Perturbations in the Lorenz Gauge Leor Barack (Soton) Carlos Lousto (UTB)
Yoshiharu Tanaka (YITP) Gradient expansion approach to nonlinear superhorizon perturbations Finnish-Japanese Workshop on Particle Helsinki,
Black hole production in preheating Teruaki Suyama (Kyoto University) Takahiro Tanaka (Kyoto University) Bruce Bassett (ICG, University of Portsmouth)
Emergent Universe Scenario
Accelerating Expansion from Inhomogeneities ? Je-An Gu (National Taiwan University) Collaborators: Chia-Hsun Chuang (astro-ph/ ) IRGAC2006, 2006/07/14.
Probing the Reheating with Astrophysical Observations Jérôme Martin Institut d’Astrophysique de Paris (IAP) 1 [In collaboration with K. Jedamzik & M. Lemoine,
Osaka City University Yousuke Takamori Collaborators : Hideki.Ishihara(OCU), Ken-ichi.Nakao(OCU), Masashi.Kimura(OCU),and Chul-Moon Yoo (APCTP) 117/July/
The Problem of Initial Conditions for Primordial Black Hole Formation and Asymptotic Quasi-Homogeneous Solution. Alexander Polnarev Queen Mary, University.
A New Endpoint for Hawking Evaporation Gary Horowitz UCSB hep-th/ Gary Horowitz UCSB hep-th/
Some Cosmological Consequences of Negative Gravitational Field Energy W. J. Wilson Department of Engineering and Physics University of Central Oklahoma.
Æthereal Gravity: Observational Constraints on Einstein- Æther Theory Brendan Foster University of Maryland.
Cosmological Perturbations in the brane worlds Kazuya Koyama Tokyo University JSPS PD fellow.
Numerical simulations of general gravitational singularities.
Numerical simulations of general gravitational singularities.
Y.K.Lau Institute of Appl. Maths, CAS. Bondi Sachs Formulation of the Kerr Metric Gravitational Wave Physics of a Kerr Black Hole.
A Metric Theory of Gravity with Torsion in Extra-dimension Kameshwar C. Wali (Syracuse University) Miami 2013 [Co-authors: Shankar K. Karthik and Anand.
Black holes sourced by a massless scalar KSM2105, FRANKFURT July, 21th 2015 M. Cadoni, University of Cagliari We construct asymptotically flat black hole.
General Relativity Physics Honours 2008 A/Prof. Geraint F. Lewis Rm 560, A29 Lecture Notes 10.
Black Hole Universe Yoo, Chulmoon ( YITP) Hiroyuki Abe (Osaka City Univ.) Ken-ichi Nakao (Osaka City Univ.) Yohsuke Takamori (Osaka City Univ.) Note that.
Black Holes in General Relativity and Astrophysics Theoretical Physics Colloquium on Cosmology 2008/2009 Michiel Bouwhuis.
Hirophysics.com PATRICK ABLES. Hirophysics.com PART 1 TIME DILATION: GPS, Relativity, and other applications.
Gravitational collapse of massless scalar field Bin Wang Shanghai Jiao Tong University.
The Meaning of Einstein’s Equation*
Wilsonian approach to Non-linear sigma models Etsuko Itou (YITP, Japan) Progress of Theoretical Physics 109 (2003) 751 Progress of Theoretical Physics.
Dark Energy in the Early Universe Joel Weller arXiv:gr-qc/
3.3 Separation of Variables 3.4 Multipole Expansion
Optimization of Nonlinear Singularly Perturbed Systems with Hypersphere Control Restriction A.I. Kalinin and J.O. Grudo Belarusian State University, Minsk,
Yoshinori Matsuo (KEK) in collaboration with Hikaru Kawai (Kyoto U.) Yuki Yokokura (Kyoto U.)
Gravitational Self-force on a Particle in the Schwarzschild background Hiroyuki Nakano (Osaka City) Norichika Sago (Osaka) Wataru Hikida (Kyoto, YITP)
Three dimensional conformal sigma models Collaborated with Takeshi Higashi and Kiyoshi Higashijima (Osaka U.) Etsuko Itou (Kyoto U. YITP) hep-th/
Supersymmetric three dimensional conformal sigma models Collaborated with Takeshi Higashi and Kiyoshi Higashijima (Osaka U.) Etsuko Itou (Kyoto U. YITP)
Initial conditions for N-body simulations Hans A. Winther ITA, University of Oslo.
1 Yasushi Mino ( 蓑 泰 志 ) WUGRAV, Washington University at St. Louis Index 1: Introduction 2: Self-force in a Linear Perturbation.
BLACK HOLES. BH in GR and in QG BH formation Trapped surfaces WORMHOLES TIME MACHINES Cross-sections and signatures of BH/WH production at the LHC I-st.
Numerical Relativity in Cosmology - my personal perspective - Yoo, Chulmoon ( Nagoya U. ) with Hirotada Okawa ( Lisbon, IST ) New Perspectives on Cosmology.
The effect of Gravity on Equation of State Hyeong-Chan Kim (KNUT) FRP Workshop on String Theory and Cosmology 2015, Chungju, Korea, Nov ,
Gravity effects to the Vacuum Bubbles Based on PRD74, (2006), PRD75, (2007), PRD77, (2008), arXiv: [hep-th] & works in preparation.
Cosmology in Eddington- inspired Born-Infeld gravity Hyeong-Chan Kim Korea National University of Transportation 19 Feb 2013 The Ocean Suites Jeju, Asia.
Kaluza-Klein Braneworld Cosmology S Kanno, D Langlois, MS & J Soda, PTP118 (2007) 701 [arXiv: ] Misao Sasaki YITP, Kyoto University.
Based on Phys. Rev. D 92, (R) (2015) 中科大交叉学科理论研究中心
MOND Dark Matter effects in non-local models. IVAN ARRAUT.
Geometrically motivated, hyperbolic gauge conditions for Numerical Relativity Carlos Palenzuela Luque 15 December
Spherical Collapse and the Mass Function – Chameleon Dark Energy Stephen Appleby, APCTP-TUS dark energy workshop 5 th June, 2014 M. Kopp, S.A.A, I. Achitouv,
QUASI-SPHERICAL GRAVITATIONAL COLLAPSE Ujjal Debnath Department of Mathematics, Bengal Engineering and Science University, Shibpur, Howrah , India.
Charged black holes in string-inspired gravity models
Throat quantization of the Schwarzschild-Tangherlini(-AdS) black hole
2012 International Workshop on String Theory and Cosmology
A New Approach to Equation of Motion for a fast-moving particle
Global Defects near Black Holes
Local Conservation Law and Dark Radiation in Brane Models
Graviton Emission in The Bulk from a Higher Dimensional Black Hole
Presentation transcript:

Black Hole Universe -BH in an expanding box- Yoo, Chulmoon ( YITP) Hiroyuki Abe (Osaka City Univ.) Ken-ichi Nakao (Osaka City Univ.) Yohsuke Takamori (Osaka City Univ.)

Chulmoon Yoo 2 Cluster of Many BHs ~ Dust Fluids? Naively thinking, we can treat the cluster of a number of BHs as a dust fluid on average In this work, as a simplest case, we try to construct “the BH universe” which would be approximated by the EdS universe on average But, it is very difficult to show it from the first principle. Because we need to solve the N-body dynamics with the Einstein equations. dust fluid ~ ~

Chulmoon Yoo 3 Lattice Universe “Dynamics of a Lattice Universe by the Schwarzschild-Cell Method” [Lindquist and Wheeler(1957)] The maximum radius asymptotically agrees with the dust universe case Putting N equal mass Sch. BHs on a 3-sphere, requiring a matching condition, we get a dynamics of the lattice universe maximum radius of lattice universe number of BHs

Chulmoon Yoo 4 Swiss-cheese Universe Expand Homogeneous dust universe Cutting spherical regions, put Schwarzschild BHs with the same mass Swiss-cheese universe We want to make it without cheese (“Swiss universe” ?)

Chulmoon Yoo 5 Some Aspects of This Work If perturbations of metric components are small enough, we don’t need to treat full GR but perturbation theory is applicable. Perhaps, even if the density perturbation is nonlinear in small scales, we could handle the inhomogeneities without full numerical relativity. 1. “Cosmological Numerical Relativity (CNR)” In which situation, CNR may be significant? (In this sense, for late time cosmology, CNR might not be significant.) CNR may play a role in an extreme situation where the metric perturbation is full nonlinear on cosmological scales (e.g. primordial BH formation) 2. BH simulation without asymptotic flatness -In higher-dimensional theory, compactified directions often exist, and they are not asymptotically flat. -BH physics might be applied to other fields (e.g. AdS/CFT,QCD,CMP) without asymptotic flatness Their dynamical simulations might have common feature?

Chulmoon Yoo 6 Contents ◎ Part 1 : “A recipe for the BH universe” How to construct the initial data for the BH universe ◎ Part 2 “Structure of the BH universe” - Horizons - Effective Hubble equation with an averaging

Chulmoon Yoo 7 Part 1 A recipe for the BH universe

Chulmoon Yoo 8 … What We Want to Do ◎ Vacuum solution for the Einstein eqs. First, we construct the puncture initial data ◎ Expansion of the universe is crucial to avoid the potential divergence Periodic boundary Expanding BH … … …

Chulmoon Yoo 9 Puncture Boundary Infinity of the other world

Chulmoon Yoo 10 Constraint Eqs. We assume Setting trK by hand, we solve these eqs. How should we choose trK? We construct the initial data. where

Chulmoon Yoo 11 Expansion of the universe tr K must be a finite value around the boundary Expand finite Hubble parameter H H =-tr K / 3 →Swiss-cheese case

Chulmoon Yoo 12 CMC (constant mean curvature) Slice tr K = const. ⇔ ∇ a n a =const. induced metric isotropic coordinate CMC slice ?

Chulmoon Yoo 13 r=∞ R=R c For K≠0, we have a finite R at r=∞ We need to take care of the inner boundary To avoid this, we choose K=0 near the infinity (maximal slice) r=∞ R=0 Difficulty to use CMC slice

Chulmoon Yoo 14 trK CMC slice Maximal slice trK/K c R

Chulmoon Yoo 15 Constraint Eqs. Extraction of 1/R divergence Near the center R=0 (trK=0) ψ is regular at R=0 Periodic boundary condition for ψ and X i 1 * f=0 at the boundary r=∞ R=0

Chulmoon Yoo 16 Equations x y z L R :=( x 2 + y 2 + z 2 ) 1/2 Source terms must vanish by integrating in a box Poisson equation with periodic boundary condition

Chulmoon Yoo 17 Integration of source terms vanishes by integrating in the box because ∂ x Z and ∂ x K are odd function of x Vanishes by integrating in the box because K=const. at the boundary Integration of this part also must vanish

Chulmoon Yoo 18 Effective Hubble Equation Integrating in a box, we have Hubble parameter H effective mass density

Chulmoon Yoo 19 Parameters BH mass Box size (isotropic coord.) Hubble radius We set K c so that the following equation is satisfied This is just the integration of the constraint equation. We update the value of K c at each step of the numerical iteration. Free parameter is only other than and

Chulmoon Yoo 20 Part 2 Structure of the BH universe

Chulmoon Yoo 21 trK trK/K c R 0.1 L-0.1

Chulmoon Yoo 22 Numerical Solutions(1) x y z L ψ(x,y,L) for L=2M ψ(x,y,0) for L=2M

Chulmoon Yoo 23 Numerical Solutions(2) Z(x,y,L) for L=2M Z(x,y,0) for L=2M x y z L

Chulmoon Yoo 24 Numerical Solutions(3) X x (x,y,L) for L=2M X x (x,y,0) for L=2M x y z L

Chulmoon Yoo 25 Convergence Test ◎ Beautiful quadratic convergence! ◎ We cannot find the solution for L<1.4M

Chulmoon Yoo 26 Horizons ◎ To see Horizons, we calculate outgoing(+) and ingoing(-) null expansions of spheres ◎ We plot the value of χ for three independent directions (χ is not spherically symmetric in general) : unit normal vector to sphere ◎ Horizons (approximate position) : Black hole horizon : White hole horizon

Chulmoon Yoo 27 Expansion ◎ parameter : L = 1.4M χ+χ+ χ-χ- ◎ Horizons are almost spherically symmetric ◎ BH horizon exists outside WH horizon or they are almost identical R expansion WHBH

Chulmoon Yoo 28 Time slice BH horizon “WH horizon” Bifurcation point

Chulmoon Yoo 29 Inhomogeneity (x,y,L) for L=2M (x,y,0) for L=2M x y z L ◎ Square of the traceless part of 3-dim Ricci curvature homogeneous ⇒ homogeneous and empty ⇒ Milne universe (Ω K =1)

Chulmoon Yoo 30 Inhomogeneity (x,y,L) for L=2M (x,y,L) for L=4M (x,y,L) for L=5M Not homogeneous around the center of a boundary face

Chulmoon Yoo 31 An Averaging ◎ Effective density x y z L Area: Effective volume of a box ( ) Effective density ◎ Hubble parameter (defined by the boundary value of trK) ◎ We may expect (?) This relation is nontrivial! No dust, No matter, No symmetry, but additional gravitational energy other than “the point mass”

Chulmoon Yoo 32 Effective Hubble ◎ Effective Hubble parameter ◎ It asymptotically agrees with the expected value!

Chulmoon Yoo 33 Conclusion ◎ We constructed initial data for the BH universe ◎ BH horizon exists outside WH horizon or they are almost identical ◎ When the box size is sufficiently larger than the Schwarzschild radius of the mass M, an effective density and an effective Hubble parameter satisfy Hubble equation of the EdS universe, that is, the BH universe is the EdS universe on Average! ◎ Around vertices, it is well described by the Milne universe

Chulmoon Yoo 34 Including Λ<0 ◎ We may have momentarily static initial data integrate in a box ◎ Probably, It will collapse when we consider the time evolution because essentially it is dust + negative Λ universe ◎ Negative Λ can compensate the mass term ◎ It seems very difficult to get stable solution without exotic matter other than negative Λ

Chulmoon Yoo 35 Thank you very much!