Ethics and Plagiarism AAHEP8 -- Amsterdam 2015 Erick Weinberg -- APS.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Authorship APS Professional Skills Course:
Advertisements

Choosing a Journal APS Professional Skills Course: Writing and Reviewing for Scientific Journals.
Welcome to the IEEE IPR Office Plagiarism Tutorial Click to begin.
Submission Process. Overview Preparing for submission The submission process The review process.
Publication ethics Sadeghi Ramin, MD Nuclear Medicine Research Center, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences SUMBER:
Ethical principles at a University Patrice Koehl Computer Science, UC Davis Sources: Phil Rogaway, UC Davis Dave Touretsky, CMU.
Duplicate Submission: Journal Roles and Responsibilities Diane M. Sullenberger Executive Editor, PNAS.
Publication ethics Sadeghi Ramin, MD Nuclear Medicine Research Center, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences.
The Publishing Cycle Closing the Ethical Loop October 2011, University of Maryland Gert-Jan Geraeds, Executive Publisher
Writing an original research paper Part one: Important considerations
RESPONSIBLE AUTHORSHIP Office for Research Protections The Pennsylvania State University Adapted from Scientific Integrity: An Internet-based course in.
Improving Learning, Persistence, and Transparency by Writing for the NASPA Journal Dr. Cary Anderson, Editor, NASPA Journal Kiersten Feeney, Editorial.
Source: G. Stylianou - Writing for Computer Science, Justin Zobel Ethics.
APA Ethics Guidelines for publication. Goals To ensure the accuracy of scientific knowledge To protect intellectual property rights.
Plagiarism - Causes of Plagiarism - Shared Responsibilities - Best Practices for preventing Plagiarism Kye Gon Larissa Ayesha.
Research Integrity: Collaborative Research Michelle Stickler, DEd Office for Research Protections
Publishing Research Papers Charles E. Dunlap, Ph.D. U.S. Civilian Research & Development Foundation Arlington, Virginia
Manuscript Writing and the Peer-Review Process
P 3 =Plagiarism, Publications, and Professional Service Mark S. Daskin Dept. of IE/MS, Northwestern University Evanston, IL Spring, 2006.
Publishing your paper. Learning About You What journals do you have access to? Which do you read regularly? Which journals do you aspire to publish in.
Understanding APA Editorial Style For Students in Social Work Courses Part I Prepared by: BJ Bryson, PhD James Madison University.
Elsevier and the publisher role in supporting publishing ethics practices October 2011, University of Maryland Presented by: Mark Seeley, General Counsel.
Publishing Research Outcomes Bruce Gnade, Ph.D. University of Texas Touradj Solouki, Ph.D. Baylor University.
Writing Scientific Articles – General Structures Agus Suryanto Department of Mathematics FMIPA – Brawijaya University.
Week 1: Find resources, Summarize, paraphrase, thesis, and outline Week 2: Research and Write, incorporate evidence and transitions (1/2 done) Week 3:
Dr. Dinesh Kumar Assistant Professor Department of ENT, GMC Amritsar.
Procedures for reviewing and/or editing an article Role of the members of the editorial board in the reviewing process:. 1.Role of the editor in chief.
How to cite other authors Parenthetical citation.
How to Write Defne Apul and Jill Shalabi. Papers Summarized Johnson, T.M Tips on how to write a paper. J Am Acad Dermatol 59:6, Lee,
SLIDE 1 Introduction to Scientific Writing Aya Goto.
Ethical Principles of Scientific Publication PSYC 200.
Publication Ethics Hooman Momen, Editor Bulletin of the World Health Organization.
Ethical Issues in Journal Publication Barbara Gastel, MD, MPH Texas A&M University
Literature Search – How to Make Hard Work Easier? Prof. Haiying Huang Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering University.
Scholarly Publication: Responsibilities for Authors and Reviewers Jean H. Shin, Ph.D. Director, Minority Affairs Program American Sociological Association.
Publication ethics Professor Magne Nylenna, M.D., PhD
Publication Ethics R.Raveendran Chief Editor, Journal of Pharmacology & Pharmacotherapeutics.
Publication Ethics Hooman Momen, Editor Bulletin of the World Health Organization SUMBER: bvs4.icml9.org/.../Presentation%20to%20%20ethics%20workshop ‎
Publication and Research Misconduct Stephanie Harriman Deputy Medical Editor.
INANE Meeting –Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing Charon Pierson Geraldine Pearson August 5, 2015.
Authorship, peer review and conflicts of interest.
Ethics and Scientific Writing. Ethical Considerations Ethics more important than legal considerations Your name and integrity are all that you have!
Page 1 Plagiarism Concerns in IAS Manuscript Submissions March 2014
Plagiarism  Plagiarism is an attempt to pass off the work of others (in particular the writing of others) as one's own.  The most obvious type of plagiarism.
Approach to Research Papers Pardis Esmaeili, B.S. Valcour Lab Mentoring Toolbox Valcour Lab Mentoring Toolbox2015.
Scope of the Journal The International Journal of Sports Medicine (IJSM) provides a forum for the publication of papers dealing with basic or applied information.
Of 20 Responsible Authorship Responsible Conduct of Research Seminar George Mason University 2016 Jeff Offutt Professor of Software Engineering, VSE
SCI 论文发表流程 1. 上传或写信或发 投递 Dear Prof. xxx (Editor): Attached (Enclosed) please find the word or PDF version of my paper entitled "xxx" with the kind.
Jackie A. Rapp January 21,  Definition of Plagiarism? The copying of another's paper with the intention of representing it as one's own" (Lathrop.
ETHICS – FROM CODES TO PRACTICE KARIM MURJI, THE OPEN UNIVERSITY, UK.
Dr.V.Jaiganesh Professor
PUBLICATION PRINCIPLES for PUBLICATION PROFESSIONALS
How to get a paper published in IEEE
How to deal with suspected plagiarism
Reading Turnitin Reports
Plagiarism: What You Need to Know
Mojtaba Farjam, MD PhD, member of ethics committee for research
RCR Workshop on Authorship and Peer Review
Farmington Consensus Tom Babor  .
Role of peer review in journal evaluation
Types of Academic Misconduct
What Are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics?
Plagiarism.
What the Editors want to see!
Welcome to the IEEE IPR Office Plagiarism Tutorial
Academic Misconduct & Plagiarism
Welcome to the IEEE IPR Office Plagiarism Tutorial
Welcome to the IEEE IPR Office Plagiarism Tutorial
Chapter 18: Submitting a paper
TECHNICAL REPORTS WRITING
Presentation transcript:

Ethics and Plagiarism AAHEP8 -- Amsterdam 2015 Erick Weinberg -- APS

Authors may not present data and other results obtained by others as if they were their own. Nor may authors incorporate without attribution text from another work (by themselves or others), even when summarizing past results or background material. If a direct quotation is appropriate, the quotation should be clearly indicated as such and the original source should be properly cited. Papers that have been found to be in violation of this rule will be rejected. In such cases, resubmission of the manuscript, even with the plagiarized text removed, is not ordinarily allowed. However, the editors may allow exceptions to this policy if warranted by special circumstances. PRD Editorial Policies and Practices APS GUIDELINES FOR PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT Publication and Authorship Practices Authorship should be limited to those who have made a significant contribution to the concept, design, execution or interpretation of the research study. All those who have made significant contributions should be offered the opportunity to be listed as authors. Other individuals who have contributed to the study should be acknowledged, but not identified as authors. The sources of financial support for the project should be disclosed. Plagiarism constitutes unethical scientific behavior and is never acceptable. Proper acknowledgement of the work of others used in a research project must always be given. Further, it is the obligation of each author to provide prompt retractions or corrections of errors in published works.

The editors acknowledge receipt of this manuscript on ****** and are considering it as a Regular Article in Physical Review D. When sending correspondence regarding this manuscript please refer to the code number *****. We understand your submission of this manuscript to certify the following: - The paper represents original work of the listed authors. - The manuscript as presented accurately reflects the scientific results. - All of the authors made significant contributions to the concept, design, execution, or interpretation of the research study. - All those who made significant contributions were offered the opportunity to be listed as authors. - All of the listed authors are aware of and agree to the submission of this manuscript. - The manuscript has not been published, and is not now and will not be under consideration by another journal while it is considered here. - The authors have provided information to the editors about relevant unpublished manuscripts, including whether any version of this manuscript was previously considered by an APS journal. - The authors accept the established procedures for selecting m anuscripts for publication. PRD Acknowledgement of Receipt

Plagiarism of Text --- Copying text for “better English” --- Copying extensive background material I am very saddened and surprised by the I just received. The research I submitted for publication is entirely original, and I can easily demonstrate this. Quoting from other published material cannot be taken as plagiarism. Plagiarism is appropriating somebody else's results and claiming them as original, and this is clearly not what I did. --- Copying from self --- to save time --- to produce more publications

Paper 1, v Feb 2001, 20:46 GMT “the level... is not quantized” Paper 2, Feb :46 GMT “the level... is quantized” Paper 1, v2., Feb 2001, 08:53 GMT “the level... is quantized” Plagiarism of ideas Both papers were published: Paper 2 in PRL Paper 1 in PLB Harder to establish, but:

Authorship issues ---- Institute or lab director as author ---- (unknown author) + (leading relativist 1) + (leading relativist 2) : “There are no black holes” ---- (new Ph.D.) + (thesis advisor) “I”, “my thesis”, Institute or lab director as author “Authors” with no knowledge of being authors “Authors” with no knowledge

Duplicate submission Paper submitted to CQG May12, xxxx Revised version submitted to PRD May 25, xxxx Same version submitted to CQG May 26, xxxx There is no attempt here to publish the same paper in two different journals. My hope has been that this paper, which I know is correct, would find one journal willing to publish it.