Simon Wicks Columbia University Work done with William Horowitz, Magdalena Djordjevic and Miklos Gyulassy with input from Azfar Adil BNL Heavy Flavor Workshop,

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Why soft interaction approximations are not strong enough for jets in the QGP Simon Wicks Work done with Miklos Gyulassy With thanks to Azfar Adil, William.

Advertisements

W. A. Horowitz Quark Matter 2005 A Promising Solution to the Elliptic Quench Puzzle at RHIC William A. Horowitz Columbia University August 4-5, 2005.

1 PQCD Approach to Parton Propagation in Matter Ivan Vitev Hard Probes 2006, Pacific Grove, CA.

TJH: ISMD 2005, 8/9-15 Kromeriz, Czech Republic TJH: 1 Experimental Results at RHIC T. Hallman Brookhaven National Laboratory ISMD Kromeriz, Czech Republic.

Charm & bottom RHIC Shingo Sakai Univ. of California, Los Angeles 1.

1Erice 2012, Roy A. Lacey, Stony Brook University.

Heavy Quark Probes of QCD Matter at RHIC Huan Zhong Huang University of California at Los Angeles ICHEP-2004 Beijing, 2004.

Probing Properties of the QCD Medium via Heavy Quark Induced Hadron Correlations Huan Zhong Huang Department of Physics and Astronomy University of California.

21/05/07 William Horowitz CERN Heavy Ion Forum 1 Possible String Theoretic Deviations from pQCD in Heavy Quark Energy Loss at LHC William Horowitz Columbia.

Collisional energy loss in a finite size QCD medium revisited Alejandro Ayala Instituto de Ciencias Nucleares, UNAM.

M. Djordjevic 1 Open questions in heavy flavor physics at RHIC Magdalena Djordjevic The Ohio State University.

M. Djordjevic 1 Heavy quark energy loss puzzle at RHIC Magdalena Djordjevic The Ohio State University.

Winter Workshop on Nuclear Dynamics – San Diego, 16 Mar. 2006John Harris (Yale) Suppression of Non-photonic Electrons at High Pt John W. Harris Yale University.

1 Questions about sQGP Carlos Arguello Columbia University 24 th Winter Workshop on Nuclear Dynamics April 10 th 2008.

High-p T spectra and correlations from Cu+Cu and Au+Au collisions in STAR Marco van Leeuwen, LBNL for the STAR collaboration.

Andrej Ficnar Columbia University INT 10-2A June 25, 2010 High order DGLV Monte Carlo and q models of jet quenching ^

#: 1... and your jet energy loss calculation? What drives you? aka Perturbative jet energy loss mechanisms: Learning from RHIC, extrapolating to LHC Simon.

Luan Cheng (Institute of Particle Physics, Huazhong Normal University) I. Introduction II. Interaction Potential with Flow III. Flow Effects on Light Quark.

1 Heavy Quark Energy Loss Tatia Engelmore Journal Club 7/21.

6/1/07 William Horowitz CERN Heavy Ion Forum 1 Possible String Theoretic Deviations from pQCD in Heavy Quark Energy Loss at LHC William Horowitz Columbia.

Jet quenching at RHIC and LHC from finite endpoint momentum strings Andrej Ficnar Columbia University Hard Probes 2013 November 5, 2013 Andrej Ficnar,

M. Djordjevic 1 Effect of dynamical QCD medium on radiative heavy quark energy loss Magdalena Djordjevic The Ohio State University.

M. Djordjevic 1 Heavy quark energy loss in a dynamical QCD medium Magdalena Djordjevic The Ohio State University M. Djordjevic and U. Heinz, arXiv:

5/2/08 William Horowitz Yale-Columbia Fest Zero th Order Heavy Quark Photon/Gluon Bremsstrahlung William Horowitz Columbia University Frankfurt.

What’s Missing in our Current Picture from High p T Measurements at RHIC? Saskia Mioduszewski Texas A&M University 23 March, 2007.

Heavy-to-light ratios as a test of medium-induced energy loss at RHIC and the LHC N. Armesto Quark Matter 2005: 18th International Conference on Ultra-Relativistic.

Anomaly of over ratios in Au+Au collision with jet quenching Xiaofang Chen IOPP, CCNU Collaborator: Enke Wang Hanzhong Zhang Benwei Zhang Beijing Mar.

Precision Probes for Hot QCD Matter Rainer Fries Texas A&M University & RIKEN BNL QCD Workshop, Washington DC December 15, 2006.

7/7/09 William Horowitz WHDG Brick and Comparing WHDG to ASW-SH William Horowitz The Ohio State University July 7, 2009 With many thanks to Brian Cole,

6/26/07 William Horowitz SQM pQCD vs. AdS/CFT Tested by Heavy Quark Energy Loss William Horowitz Columbia University Frankfurt Institute for Advanced.

1/31/07William Horowitz Yale-Columbia Fest Spring ‘07 1 pQCD vs. String Theory: LHC Heavy Flavors to Decide William Horowitz Columbia University January.

11/15/06 William Horowitz 1 LHC Predictions 1 from an extended theory 2 with Elastic, Inelastic, and Path Length Fluctuating Jet Energy Loss William Horowitz.

6/6/06William Horowitz Hard Probes Overcoming Fragility William Horowitz Columbia University June 14, 2006 With many thanks to Simon Wicks, Azfar.

1 Search for the Effects of the QCD Color Factor in High-Energy Collisions at RHIC Bedanga Mohanty LBNL  Motivation  Color Factors  Search for Color.

10/26/07 William Horowitz AdS Strings Intersect with Nuclear Beams at Columbia 1 Probing AdS/CFT with Heavy Quarks William Horowitz Columbia University.

6/6/06William Horowitz RHIC & AGS Annual Users’ Meeting ‘06 1 Heavy Quark Energy Loss William Horowitz Columbia University June 6, 2006 With many thanks.

11/1/06William Horowitz 1 Jet Quenching at RHIC and the LHC William Horowitz Columbia University November 1, 2006 With many thanks to Simon Wicks, Azfar.

Luan Cheng (Institute of Particle Physics, Huazhong Normal University) I.Introduction II. Potential Model with Flow III.Flow Effects on Parton Energy Loss.

Jet energy loss at RHIC and LHC including collisional and radiative and geometric fluctuations Simon Wicks, QM2006 Work done with Miklos Gyulassy, William.

9/22/06William Horowitz 1 Surface or Volume Emission at RHIC: Is Jet Tomography Possible? William Horowitz Columbia University September 22, 2006 With.

M. Djordjevic 1 Theoretical predictions of jet suppression: a systematic comparison with RHIC and LHC data Magdalena Djordjevic Institute of Physics Belgrade,

11/02/07 William Horowitz Heavy Quark Workshop, LBNL 1 Falsifying AdS/CFT Drag or pQCD Heavy Quark Energy Loss with A+A at RHIC and LHC William Horowitz.

Testing radiative energy loss at RHIC and the LHC N. Armesto Fifth International Conference on PERSPECTIVES IN HADRONIC PHYSICS: Particle-Nucleus and Nucleus-Nucleus.

Probing the properties of dense partonic matter at RHIC Y. Akiba (RIKEN) for PHENIX collaboration.

Radiative heavy quark energy loss in QCD matter Magdalena Djordjevic and Miklos Gyulassy Columbia University.

Heavy Quark Energy Loss due to Three-body Scattering in a Quark- Gluon Plasma Wei Liu Texas A&M University  Introduction  Heavy quark scattering in QGP.

Nu XuDirector’s Review, LBNL, May 17, 20061/23 Future Program for Studying Bulk Properties in High-Energy Nuclear Collisions Nu Xu.

Yukinao Akamatsu Univ. of Tokyo 2008/11/26 Komaba Seminar Ref : Y. A., T. Hatsuda and T. Hirano, arXiv: [hep-ph] 1.

Elastic, Inelastic and Path Length Fluctuations in Jet Tomography Simon Wicks Hard Probes 2006 Work done with William Horowitz, Magdalena Djordjevic and.

Squaw Valley, Feb. 2013, Roy A. Lacey, Stony Brook University Take home message  The scaling (p T, ε, R, ∆L, etc) properties of azimuthal anisotropy.

Enke Wang (Institute of Particle Physics, Huazhong Normal University) I.Jet Quenching in QCD-based Model II.Jet Quenching in High-Twist pQCD III.Jet Tomography.

QM04 1/12/04M. Djordjevic 1 Heavy quark energy loss-Applications to RHIC Magdalena Djordjevic and Miklos Gyulassy Columbia University The Ter-Mikayelian.

12/16/08 William Horowitz TECHQM 2 nd Workshop, LBNL 1 DGLV : M. Djordjevic and M. Gyulassy, Nucl.Phys.A733, 265 (2004) [nucl-th/ ] WHDG : S. Wicks,

Collisional energy loss becomes probable André Peshier SUBATECH, Université de Nantes - Praha, 20 April

M. Djordjevic 1 Heavy Quark Energy Loss in Nucleus-Nucleus Collisions Magdalena Djordjevic The Ohio State University.

M. Djordjevic 1 Heavy flavor suppression in a dynamical medium with finite magnetic mass Magdalena Djordjevic Institute of Physics Belgrade, University.

M. Djordjevic 1 Heavy quark energy loss in a dynamical QCD medium Magdalena Djordjevic The Ohio State University M. Djordjevic and U. Heinz, arXiv:

M. Djordjevic 1 Hard probes at RHIC and LHC Magdalena Djordjevic Ohio State University.

M. Djordjevic 1 Light and heavy flavor phenomenology at RHIC and LHC Magdalena Djordjevic Institute of Physics Belgrade, University of Belgrade.

M. Djordjevic 1 Suppression and energy loss in Quark-Gluon Plasma Magdalena Djordjevic Institute of Physics Belgrade, University of Belgrade.

Heavy Flavor Measurements at RHIC&LHC W. Xie (Purdue University, West Lafayette) W. Xie (Purdue University, West Lafayette) Open Heavy Flavor Workshop.

1 RIKEN Workshop, April , Roy A. Lacey, Stony Brook University Primary focus: Scaling properties of flow & Jet quenching.

Production, energy loss and elliptic flow of heavy quarks at RHIC and LHC Jan Uphoff with O. Fochler, Z. Xu and C. Greiner Hard Probes 2010, Eilat October.

12/12/05William Horowitz Heavy Flavor Productions Workshop Role of Dynamic Geometry in Jet Tomography William Horowitz Columbia University December 12,

Probing QGP-medium interactions

F. Dominguez, CM, A. Mueller, B. Xiao and B. Wu, arXiv:

Qualitative Successes of AdS/CFT at RHIC

Modification of Fragmentation Function in Strong Interacting Medium

Heavy Quark Energy Loss

William Horowitz Columbia University June 14, 2006

Presentation transcript:

Simon Wicks Columbia University Work done with William Horowitz, Magdalena Djordjevic and Miklos Gyulassy with input from Azfar Adil BNL Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th December 2005 Influence of Elastic Energy Loss on Heavy Flavor Quenching

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)2 Radiative energy loss ● Radiative energy loss insufficient to explain electron data. DGLV predictions: Djordjevic, Gyulassy, Vogt, Wicks Phys Lett B (in press) Radiative energy loss

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)3 The Bottom Line: STAR Dong QM05Djordjevic et al PLB Even a factor 4 violation of Bulk entropy constraint fails to account for data Radiative energy loss

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)4 Radiative energy loss ● Radiative energy loss insufficient to explain electron data. ● Constraint on dN g /dy: bulk entropy density from total pion rapidity density. ➔ Cannot just 'dial in' dN g /dy = ~3500 ● Non-perturbative effects? ➔ Stay with pQCD, where falsifiable predictions are possible ➔ Include collisional energy loss in addition to radiative. (as suggested in M. Djordjevic thesis) DGLV predictions: Djordjevic, Gyulassy, Vogt, Wicks Phys Lett B (in press) Radiative energy loss

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)5 Radiative energy loss ● Radiative energy loss insufficient to explain electron data. ● Constraint on dN g /dy: bulk entropy density from total pion rapidity density. ➔ Cannot just 'dial in' dN g /dy = ~3500 ● Non-perturbative effects? ➔ Stay with pQCD, where falsifiable predictions are possible ➔ Include collisional energy loss in addition to radiative. (as suggested in M. Djordjevic thesis) DGLV predictions: Djordjevic, Gyulassy, Vogt, Wicks Phys Lett B (in press) AIM: To establish experimental limits on the kinematic range in (p T,y) where perturbative QCD can be accurately used to predict jet dynamics in dense QCD media. Radiative energy loss

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)6 Models of elastic energy loss ● Collisional energy loss is of the same magnitude as radiative in the kinematic region of interest (see M. G. Mustafa, Phys.Rev.C72:014905,2005) ● First estimate: Bjorken kinematic estimate of magnitude (FERMILAB-PUB THY, unpublished), then over time, improved treatment of IR and UV. ● Further possible improvement: input from evolving medium simulations by Molnar and Hirano. BT: E. Braaten and M. H. Thoma, Phys. Rev. D 44, 2625 (1991). TG: M. H. Thoma and M. Gyulassy, Nucl. Phys. B 351, 491 (1991).

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)7 Models of elastic energy loss ● Collisional energy loss is of the same magnitude as radiative in the kinematic region of interest (see M. G. Mustafa, Phys.Rev.C72:014905,2005) ● First estimate: Bjorken kinematic estimate of magnitude (FERMILAB-PUB THY, unpublished), then over time, improved treatment of IR and UV. ● Further possible improvement: input from evolving medium simulations by Molnar and Hirano. BT: E. Braaten and M. H. Thoma, Phys. Rev. D 44, 2625 (1991). TG: M. H. Thoma and M. Gyulassy, Nucl. Phys. B 351, 491 (1991). BT: unphysical energy gain for bottom due to a failure of the extrapolation from the weak-coupling limit (Romatschke, Strickland).

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)8 Models of elastic energy loss (II) P. Romatschke, M. Strickland (Phys. Rev. D 69, (2004) ● For a parton p=10GeV: ➔ Bottom elastic energy loss ~ TG >> BT ➔ Charm elastic energy loss ~ BT > TG

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)9 Open problem: Retardation effects? ● Naive expectation: Formation effects only non-negligible for time on order of the Debye length ➔ ie small effect Particle(s) created at finite time in the plasma, rather than at t=-∞

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)10 Open problem: Retardation effects? Peigné, Gossiaux, Gousset (hep-ph/ ) Peigné et al claim: strong suppression of elastic due to transient field and retardation effects (unexpected positive energy gain due to transverse response function) ➔ Challenge to all applications of elastic energy loss (Bjorken, TG, BT, RS and parton cascade)

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)11 Open problem: Retardation effects? Peigné, Gossiaux, Gousset (hep-ph/ ) Peigné et al claim: strong suppression of elastic due to transient field and retardation effects (unexpected positive energy gain due to transverse response function) ➔ Challenge to all applications of elastic energy loss (Bjorken, TG, BT, RS and parton cascade) BUT: formalism used mixes radiative (zerorth order) and elastic mechanisms Part of medium induced energy gain is due to Ter-Mekilian (see M. Djordjevic) that is cancelled by Transition Radiation (not included by Peigne).

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)12 Remaining theoretical uncertainties ● Interference between radiative and collisional energy loss? ● (X.N. Wang found small interference) ➔ Used here: incoherent addition of the two effects. ●  s (q) - running coupling constant. – Effect of full running with  q   max ~ 0.5? ➔ Used here: fixed  s=0.3 ● Length scale ➔ Used in this talk : fixed L=5fm as “typical” length ➔ See next talk (W. Horowitz) dynamical geometry

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)13 Results - Partonic Raa (fixed L=5fm) Charm Bottom ➔ Radiative + collisional ~2x suppression of radiative alone ➔ Large difference between BT and TG for bottom quark quenching Fixed L=5fm;  =0.3; dN g /dy=1000

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)14 Results - Electron Raa (fixed L=5fm) Fixed L=5fm;  =0.3; dN g /dy=1000

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)15 Results - Pion Raa (fixed L=5fm) Fixed L=5fm;  =0.3; dN g /dy=1000 Pions overquenched at low p T (for fixed L=5fm)

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)16 Conclusion ● Collisional energy loss must be included to account for all perturbative physical effects ● Important theoretical issues remain to be resolved – Retardation effects – Collisional - radiative interference – Running coupling ● Fixed L predictions get closer to single electron R AA data ● Fixed L predictions move away from the π 0 R AA data

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)17

Simon Wicks, Columbia University (Heavy Flavor Workshop, 12th Dec 2005)18 Key new physics insight: A: Elastic has greater quenching effect than Inelastic because  E el /E Fluctuates Less than  E rad /E!! BUT GLV,WW So what if elastic ~ inelastic? Q: Can’t this be just absorbed into the effective dN eff /dy or ? Elastic and inelastic: Fluctuations